It’s time we admit two things: Fetty Wap is actually an incredibly talented vocalist, and “piano black” trim is one of the worst things to happen to cars since the EPA implemented the footprint rule. Thankfully, after more than 15 years of shiny plastics previously seen on slide phones, some automakers have decided enough is enough. Leading the charge, weirdly, is Kia.
Shiny black plastic has been slagged on for years, but this horse isn’t dead yet, so let’s keep beating it. This material is cheap, it invites unwanted reflections, and it’s prone to swirl marks that make it look like a scratched CD when it adorns any horizontal surface. Fingerprints, dust, and crumbs cling to it like it’s a lint roller, which means that five seconds after you clean it, it’s filthy again. Perhaps the worst part, besides this sort of plastic aging like milk, is that we used to simply know better.
Flash back nearly two decades, and you largely had two diverging schools of thought. Some brands thought the future was silver, with cars like the Saturn Astra and Ford Focus featuring huge slabs of metal-hued plastic. Even the BMW 3 Series wasn’t immune in most markets, with many trims receiving what was officially called Titan Shadow trim. On the other hand, some manufacturers like Volkswagen were leaning more heavily on rich, satin plastics. Sure, the coating could chip if sufficiently abused, but this rubbery paint made ordinary hard plastics look and feel expensive while maintaining a low price point.

Right, that’s the exposition, time for the exhibition. This is the new Kia Niro, which is roughly the same as the old Kia Niro, pictured below for reference. It’s a compact front-wheel-drive crossover offering a choice of hybrid, plug-in hybrid, and electric power, now with effectively a heavy facelift: same doors, same fenders, different face. Admittedly, it seems a little less interesting than the model it replaces for a handful of reasons. The new face with blocky vertical headlamps connected via a bar of trim is more homogenous with Kia’s current lineup. The reverse lamps no longer mirror the design of the headlamps, and the tail lights look a bit more basic than before. However, that’s where the bad news ends.

For one, Kia’s latest infotainment system is onboard, consisting of two 12.3-inch screens. Not automatic improvements by themselves, but more legible gauges and wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto are welcome additions. Granted, the Niro still has that fiddly dual-duty bank of radio-slash-climate control buttons, but with automatic climate control and physical heated seat switches on the doors, how often are you flipping that panel over to HVAC?

The real joy here is that Kia has rediscovered other plastics, replacing the large shiny black console trim of the old model with a more demure, more mindful matte finish. The sort that won’t reflect whatever’s seen through the sunroof, collect more fingerprints than the FBI, or scratch upon its first exposure to the real world. It looks to be the right finish for this sort of surface, and it isn’t the first time Kia’s done this.

Roughly a year and a half ago, Kia facelifted the EV6 electric crossover and pulled the same sort of trick out of its colors, materials, and finishes bag. Big slabs of LG Rumor 2 faceplate-grade plastic? Gone, replaced with matte stuff that makes far more sense and should stay looking reasonably clean for longer. Job well done.

So, hats off to Kia for quietly declaring the era of cheap shiny black interior plastics as dead. We didn’t want them in the first place, and we’ll be better off once they thoroughly disappear from the roads. Who knows? Maybe they’ll all eventually be melted back down and turned into budget phones. One can only hope.
Top image: Kia









Just turned in a Niro after a week long rental. Nice car, 50 mpg in mixed driving even 5 to 10 mph over the speed limit. A hybrid without annoying eCVT thrashing of Toyota’s 2 motor hybrids
That said, it is a car. Just an everyday hatchback without any pretense that it will go offroad. Crazy to call it a crossover.
Edit: I keep the switchgear in HVAC mode basically the whole time. Everything radio / infotainment is controlled from the touchscreen or wheel.
Very unpopular opinion – piano black is good, actually, especially if it replaces what would have been matte black hard plastic instead.
Look at the exterior trim of the Niro. Piano black everywhere – and it’s way more premium looking for it. That would be cheap ugly molded black plastic if it wasn’t piano.
Swirls aren’t relevant if you know how to use polish, which you should.
Most of the complaint against piano black plastic is its use on interiors. Not sure how well it holds up on exteriors but should be easier to clean than inside.
I don’t even mind it inside, because we don’t have kids or dogs and are not animals ourselves.
Hold on, what? Is this like the stupid VW window switches where the behavior depends on a different switch? That’s horrible. I’m honestly not sure if that’s better than all-touch controls.
And yes, I regularly use both the audio and climate controls in all of my vehicles. This would drive me bananas.
It is not as bad as people say. Don’t get the problem. And yes I drove many HKMC vehicles.
Audio controls are in the touchscreen or wheel
Who the fuck is Fetty Wap?
Let me google that for you
New Kia Niro exterior looks a LOT better than the current/old model!
I leave mine on HVAC on my EV6 for access to defrosting (gets a lot of use now that it’s winter), temp, recirculation, etc. The steering wheel has buttons for volume and track. I use Android Auto exclusively for music (gave up on radio years ago), so it’s the touch screen for selecting the music source when I want to swap between YouTube Music and Apple Music. I can’t remember the last time I switch the cluster over to audio.
And yes, I’m glad my EV6 doesn’t have the piano black trim.
I will argue that “satin plastic” is far far worse than gloss black plastic. Once coated plastic starts to peel, and it will, you’re in for a nightmare of sticky residue as it slowly deteriorates.
I call coated plastic – “tactile” plastic, because it does feel nice when new, and yes, it will start to wear away, leaving a mess. That or if you leave it long enough, it degrades on it’s own, especially in heat.
There’s a distinction to be made between satin plastic which is a hard plastic with very finely textured surface, and what I think you’re talking about, which is a hard plastic overmolded with a soft, elastomeric plastic. The former is nice, and I think is what this article is talking about (though I haven’t seen this Kia). The latter is, as you said, the hellish material that is nice while it lasts and disgusting after. It is what makes small things like kitchen utensil handles and electric razors initially sell, and eventually have to be thrown away before the functional part has actually gone bad.
Yes exactly. These soft touch plastics felt toxic to me so I avoided them but have one or two rarely used examples and they all are sticky now. Ive simply and quickly covered them with tape. I suspect some solvent would clean if off but looking or function no better than tape
I’ll take that over Cerberus grade stuff anyday.
I think it’s not an exaggeration to say that Igloo coolers have better quality plastics than those of Cerberus/Great Recession era Chrysler products.
Roughly the same quality of the 10$ pool skimmer my wife bought on Amazon. Which similar to Cerberus era Chrysler products, broke immediately.
I like the old version better. But, I am biased as I own one. The new is not bad at all though.
I think the new front end is an is an improvement.
I’m not a fan of the monoslab tablet combining the instrument cluster and infortainment system.
I am happy that Kia continued to support this vehicle since it could be considered the replacement for the Soul that just got cancelled. I always liked the different propulsions variants into one vehicle, similar to what Stellantis is doing with the Charger but in a more realistic way.
I agree this thing kind of embodies their “pick whatever propulsion suits you” ethos which has been wildly successful in the US.
Sorry, which is the old one and which is the new one? White one is new?
I don’t get it. Two different consoles are pictured. I don’t see piano black on either one.
It looks like both of the interior shots are of the new ones. The only shot of the old one is the exterior shot (black car, by the water).
US News has this shot of the previous interior
https://cars.usnews.com/static/images/Auto/custom/15688/2024_Kia_Niro_EV_Dashboard_2.jpg
And they don’t even look similar to me. Very confused.
They’re showing a picture of the EV6 console, for some reason.
The new design is much cleaner, inside and out. The “junkyard replacement” C pillar on the previous version was certainly an attempt, but not everything can be a hit. I would actually consider this now, I’m curious about the specs of the EV version.
Oddly, that junkyard replacement C pillar was an extra cost option. I agree with you it was hideous.
99% of the niros don’t have the “junkyard replacement” C pillar
I like the update, it makes the exterior look less generic and forgetable than the previous versions. Now if they would only offer it with AWD for those of us in the snow belt.
It looks like a Storm Trooper, I like the update.
The old design just always looked cheap to me.
Quite surprised to see this, as the EV3 was mentioned as the official successor.
Good. Any move away from this stuff is welcome. One of the worst I’ve seen is the current Grand Cherokee; the piano black is all over the console and it gets destroyed in short order. Try looking at a few pre-owned listings of 2-3 year old ones.
I wouldn’t get too excited just yet. It seems a lot of carmakers are putting piano black plastic on the exterior. I looked at this car and there is a lot to like about it but I opted for a Civic Hybrid Hatchback instead with all the options.
This car finally has a design that would make me consider buying it. All previous versions were just a disjointed mess IMO