Car insurance: ya gotta have it, but no one wants it. Most of the time, it’s doing absolutely nothing for you other than tapping you for cash once a month. “Sure, nothing happened last month, but who knows what could happen this month!” I can imagine the insurance company saying, better safe than sorry, and all that.
But what if you were in control of the need for an insurance bailout? What if you could engineer a way to make that insurance work for you? Maybe even rescue you from a car you were metaphorically underwater on, perhaps by allowing it to be literally underwater?
As reported by NJ.com and other outlets, such may have been the thinking – allegedly – of some New Jersey car owners who saw a parking lot flooded by a nor’easter as an opportunity to retroactively, illegally, suffer flood damage to their vehicles and send the bill to Jake from State Farm or the Limu Emu or Flo from Progressive, etc.
As the caption explains,
A split-screen video shows the changing scene at a flooded parking lot along River Road in Edgewater, New Jersey, following the weekend nor’easter. The top footage, recorded on September 26, shows fewer vehicles submerged in floodwater, while the bottom footage, recorded on September 27, shows a significant increase in the number of vehicles underwater.
Significant indeed! On September 26, it appears there was but one lone car in the drink, a 9th-gen Honda Accord with water over the tops of its wheels. I’d say that’s a pretty solid warning to other drivers that this parking lot is full (of water), best to park elsewhere.

What a difference a day makes. Overnight, a C7 Corvette has appeared, looking like a lion that has sauntered up to the watering hole to sip a cool drink through its enormous mouth. “Golly, this parking lot is flooded!” I can imagine the poor driver exclaiming convincingly. “And my sneakers are ruined!” You know what brand they are, I don’t need to tell you. Is the monthly payment that seemed doable in the heat of the moment in the showroom now a severe drain? And maybe the poor fellow paid too much to begin with? It’s possible.

Here, we see the hapless Accord has submerged a bit further, and is joined by what appear to be an Audi Q7 and a BMW 7-series. And a Caravan back there? Hard to tell.

Nothing to see here, just some randomly-parked, meteoric-depreciation, not-particularly-reliable German cars. Perhaps financed for a big chunk? I’m just asking questions.
Liberty Biberty!
Top graphic images: Vuralelibol/Instagram; Liberty Mutual






This is the most Jersey shit I’ve seen in a while.
What about the Mazda next to the hotel building? Doesn’t seem like it was accounted for in the article, but it looks like it was already there along with the Accord so I guess we can give it a pass. Everything else in there definitely screams “underwater on their loans”, with the Caravan likely being the result of typical Stellantis high interest/predatory lending.
I work in a lab that does testing on vehicle controllers and ecus, to do this we simulate the entire can bus of data feeding these controllers to make them think they are actually in a car, this gets fed into a simulation and the data gets translated back into can messages and input into the controller and so on.
I have had the thought about getting one of those OBD2 loggers that gives you an insurance discount for driving carefully, coding up a really tame driving profile and plugging it in, but then realized I would just be committing insurance fraud and the juice was definitely not worth the squeeze, not to mention involving company resources would result in loss of employment.
Still though had the opportunity to commit what could be the world’s most high tech insurance fraud.
Fire insurance, but still: https://xkcd.com/1494/
I know a guy who drove into the back of a car because he thought braking hard to avoid it would cause a negative score on his insurance tracker.
I know anecdotal evidence isn’t evidence, but those insurance trackers don’t encourage good driving, just discourage any remotely enjoyable driving.
I did it with Flo for giggles, and I very much agree – what they consider “hard braking” is about what you HAVE to do here in SW FL where there are plenty of traffic lights on 55mph roads. Not even remotely what I would consider hard braking. Never had it squawk for anything else though. But I had it in my Mercedes wagon, not a car that encourages driving fun anyway. Thankfully my BMW convertible was on a different insurance policy. 🙂
We had one of those when my son was learning to drive, belatedly, at 18 and it would beep, which would freak him out–the last thing you want when you are actively trying to avoid a crash. OTOH, when my now-licensed son told me (years later) about he took our CR-V up to 100 mph with three of his best friends with him.
I’ve had one on my car with Jake, and all they’ve done is take away my low-mileage discount when I have had to make 1400+-mile drives to sort out stuff for my Alzheimer’s mom in N California. It doesn’t beep. But as I probably have more of those trips in my future, I may just get rid of it. It was kind of fun to look up trips on the app where I had to nail the brakes or swerve evasively to avoid a moron and see what it thought of my driving. No context. No thank you for not T-boning that guy.
The younger geek in me would like to compare capabilities of their sensors and algorithms for tut-tut reports. I don’t know whether their based on GPS data from the smart phone along for the ride or if they actually do have two-axis accelerometers built in. But now I’m too old for that sh!t.
Never in a million years would I do the smartphone app. That can’t tell if you are the one driving or if you are even driving your own car. And potentially has access to WAY more data than I have any interest in sharing. I drive rentals as much as I drive my own cars, 100% covered by my employer, not my own insurance. And as P. J. O’Rourke once said, the fastest, best handling, toughest car in the world is a *rented* car. 🙂
Flo’s OBD plugin unit is nothing but a 2-axis accelerometer. You only have to use it for a few months, then you send it back. Supposedly it reads mileage off the car but not speed. Certainly they never dinged me for my usual 85-90mph pace here on the Floridabahn. I ultimately got an A- which was a paltry discount off my already absolutely rock-bottom insurance rates – something like $50/yr. Not worth the bother or the angst in my case – but I could see it being a much bigger deal for a kid.
Good advice. Thanks. FWIW, the State Farm gizmo is a very small object stuck to the windshield and communicates via Bluetooth. But it’s banished tomorrow. The one on the car my son drove plugged into the OBD2 port. Probably time to find a new insurance company anyway.
I used to drive rentals more than my own cars. A corporate umbrella policy, blah, blah, blah. Great rates though. I was able to take advantage of those on personal vacations. Retired now. Trying to use up all the airline and hotel points before I die.
LOL – that is my plan on retirement as well. Currently at ~4M hotel points and ~2M airline miles. I had 100K Hertz points but then they changed the rules so they all expired. Hertz is very dead to me.
I am a big fan of the “staycation” at this point. But I do use miles for upgrades regularly.
I refused to KNOWINGLY be judged by an algorithm.
I live in the Chicago area and I am sure what their algorithm judges to be “hard braking” is what we call “driving on the Ike”.
I don’t think you can safely drive within the limits of grip without knowing what those limits are. You have to occasionally practice emergency stops, full throttle acceleration and corner hard enough to get a bit of understeer to have any understanding of how much safety margin you have the rest of the time. In a RWD car you should also provoke a bit of oversteer when safe to do so because you absolutely don’t want that to happen for the first time during an emergency manoeuvre.
That’s the sensible sounding reason I always use whenever one of my passengers feels sick.
They can always walk!
Seriously… the first thing I do when there is snow on the ground is to get the car to slide a little so I can recalibrate.
Yep, I do the same when the road I live on turns to sheet ice for a few weeks every winter.
Everyone else just drives normally with a little orange light frantically flashing on their dash.
Judging from how many “risky events” the Life 360 app still says I do, even when pulling a camper at 5-10mph below the speed limit on the interstate and doing all acceleration and braking pretty slowly, I don’t think I’d ever get one of those insurance dongles.
Just as an FYI, Life 360 is selling your geolocation (and transit) data to insurance carriers and other 3rd party data brokers. You may not have a dongle in your OBD2 port but that app on your phone is arguably way worse.
What is the juice on those, anyway? I’ve never looked at them, because I didn’t buy a twin turbo V6 to just to gingerly accelerate and coast everywhere.
How much do you actually save by driving like an elderly person?
Don’t know, I never seriously considered one because I know I would get deemed “unsafe”
Not much. Five percent if that
The savings in fuel would probably be more impactful on your wallet.
Even worse, the new ones are an app that lives on your phone, so you get audited even when you’re not driving. Hells to the no.
Fuggedabodit…
I’m impressed they managed to get the Corvette that far in before it hydrolocked. The air intake on those things is extremely low and even driving through a puddle too fast can cause problem.
Problem exists between keyboard and chair.
Good old PEBKAC error. Much nicer than the ID-10T error.
Code 18 is our go-to. Problem’s about 18 inches back from the screen.
PICNIC Problem In Chair Not Computer.
Are we.. certain that either photo is even real? The 9/26 photo in particular looks fake as hell, the entire way across the water’s surface and especially surrounding the Accord. It looks like a very hasty photoshop
Also, not that it’s particularly convincing in either direction but the POV of this camera angle would have to certainly be from someone standing in a flooded parking lot themselves. On satellite and street views there is no refuge or platform in this vicinity that these photos could be taken from if not by boat
That 13-14 Accord is definitely real…it was all over the news here.
In the linked articles you can see a pic of the guys in an inflatable craft.
“In Jersey everything’s legal. Until you get caught.”
Bob Dylan
Gold bars in the door pockets: “Gee officer, I’m just a saver”
Pfft. Not even a single pelican in sight.
Pretty sure that’s an Accord
https://abcnews.com/blogs/headlines/2012/10/texas-driver-accused-of-crashing-1m-bugatti-for-insurance
Umm.. Yeah, I was riffing off the “Pretty sure that’s a Lambo, dude” comment on the Veyron video.
But I’m sure you knew that.
Yeah. Yeah, that’s the ticket.
https://www.reddit.com/r/80s/comments/17ciscr/the_most_famous_and_uhhh_beloved_character_in/
I live in northern NJ and pass by this lot often. It’s a large parking lot next to a Trader Joe’s and a hotel (Comfort Inn or similar). This lot will puddle during a regular rain event, and it’s rightnextto the Hudson River. It doesn’t take much to make this area flood. These cars here seem suspect, especially since I would expect the hotel management would likely alert customers to move their cars.
It’s a large parking lot next to a Trader Joe’s
I’m going to stop you right there. There are no large parking lots near Trader Joe’s
I know of one! A TJ’s just opened in south Sarasota that is in a brand new strip mall with a HUGE parking lot, because it’s the site of a mostly now torn down mall (only the JC Penney remains, as a stand-alone store). But I am sure they will eventually build more strip mall in what is now the parking lot and turn it into the usual TJ’s parking nightmare. I swear the one in Portland, ME, which when built was the largest TJ’s in the world, has a parking lot smaller than the store! And it’s not the only business using that parking lot.
My Dad and his girlfriend winter in Sarasota. She is ridiculously happy about that Trader Joe’s opening
Me too to be honest – I live South of Sarasota, so it’s WAY more convenient to my place than the other two. And right around the corner from my favorite model railroad shop.
Now if they would just open one in Port Charlotte or North Port, life would be grand.
There is one in Phoenix that dates back to the 90s IIRC, that is part of an outdoor mall so technically has a fine parking lot.. but not on purpose. The one I shopped at most was the one in St. Paul and it had a comically tiny parking garage. You literally had to three point turn in and out of spaces. “Minnesota nice” evaporated quickly there.
The new one here in Mesa/Gilbert is OK in number of spaces, the spaces are just 2/3 scale.
It’s the same psychology as the shelving, if they can only shelve 1/2 the stock they need, they are constantly stocking shelves giving the illusion of items being “really popular”.
https://youtu.be/SGHDeTwbmoo
Genuine LOL!!
On a serious note, I was talking to a suspiciously friendly cashier once in St. Paul, and he had to have ACL surgery right after getting hired. The insurance was really good and he got paid time off to recover. I was pleasantly surprised.
People can be stupid. Half of them have below-average intelligence!
Smart person can guesstimate how deep the water is based on other cars. Smarts won’t help the first car. (I did this once: in a street in Toluca Lake during a standard-issue torrential rain that blocks up drainage. Got a truck to push me to unflooded area, right next to where I live. Needed a few days to dry out before it would turn over. Note: ALL cars should have the air intake as high as possible! I kept this car for another 9 years.)
One might say that a “smart person” wouldn’t drive into a flooded area that they couldn’t guesstimate the height of.
Um, yes they could!!!
OK, I guesstimated very poorly with a lot of confidence.
If I were smarter I would have used “depth” instead of “height”. Oh well.
If Luck is when skill meets opportunity then maybe bad luck is when over-confidence meets opportunity?
In my brother’s defence, he was 17 when he drove our car through a ford*. Actually, fuck defending him, I had to walk home in the rain!
(It dried out enough to drive by the next day)
*as in, this, not a Ford
I really fail to see how this would solve anything. You take the insurance payout and pay-off the car maybe; if you’re not underwater *chuckle*. Then you still need to replace it and you have a recordable incident on your insurance that could affect your rate.
It’s like when your car is being repossessed and you struggle like a hooked fish to escape from the tow truck, creating all sorts of damage. You either get current and have a f’ed up car or it finally gets repossessed and the auction doesn’t cover enough to pay it off. You’re still on the hook for the remaining balance.
“Oh what’s up man!”
If there was mechanical or other damage it gets rid of the car
I’m reminded of that scene in Kalifornia: “I hear a lot of place offer first month’s rent free, so I figure we’ll move around a lot at first”.
These people are not long range thinkers.
If you’re in the car, I thought they legally couldn’t tow it…
It would be a comprehensive claim not a collision claim. Still foolish to commit insurance fraud.
“It depends”. If you can convince the insurance company that the car was parked when it got flooded out, that’s a comprehensive claim and doesn’t count against you individually, just against EVERYONE in the area as they set comp rates more-or-less by zipcode. If you drive into a flood, yeah, that’s probably going to be a collision claim and you will likely pay for being a dumbass. And GAP insurance is a thing. A very smart thing if you know you are likely to be underwater financially for a while on a long term loan.
Four years ago Hurricane Ian flooded my mother’s Camry while it was parked in the guest lot of her friend’s place she evacuated to. On the OTHER side of Florida. Said guest parking being right below a retention pond that overflowed from the two feet of rain that fell. On the bright side, The Lizard gave us 50% more than I paid for the car several years before. Downside, it was a minty, 55K mile, ’01 Camry V6 that she could have driven for the rest of her life. Sigh. Boring as Hell, but a nice Grannycar. Amusingly, even after sitting in water up to the tops of the window sills for a day, it started right up!
I guess it depends on the insurance company. Every car I saw in the shop after it drove into water was covered under a comprehensive claim.
Oooh, I also have a ‘Drowned a Toyota product and it started up the next day story!’ I was driving a beater ’98 Sienna with 330k miles on it I picked up for $400 in Iowa to move my stuff from Iowa back to Colorado, and I was out storm chasing with it in rural southern Kansas and drove down a road I shouldn’t have (the ‘Road Closed’ barrier was laid over in the ditch) and I drove into a 4′ deep pond in the middle of this road, which I would later find out was a popular mudding spot for the 38″ tires jacked up truck crowd in the neighborhood. As soon as I realized my fuckup, I killed the motor, then rolled the window down, and the water flooded in to about… ankle depth in the van. I somehow high centered it on the high spot between the ruts and when I stepped out of the rolled down window, promptly sank up to my chest.
It took two tow trucks and two hours to extract it (Thanks AAA, back when they were still useful!) and it got towed to Wichita. Spent the night with a friend, and called the shop the next morning and they said ‘You’re not gonna believe this, but it started right up this morning!’
The ABS light stayed on for a few weeks and the ABS system occasionally acted up afterwards, but I drove it back to Denver and put another 20k miles on it before the transmission blew up the fall of ’17 at just shy of 360,000 miles and I sent it to the scrapyard.
I somehow suspect modern Toyota’s, especially with the hybrid battery packs and delicate electronic systems in the floor pan, would not take as kindly to such waterboarding.
Now that is impressive!!!
These aren’t the cars you’re looking for, move along, move along.
Never assume malice when incompetence can just as easily explain it.
Hanlon’s razor
Hanlon forgot about the “dumb criminal” case: malicious *and* incompetent.
It’s so easy to legally sell a car, with outfits like Carmax and Carvana all over the place.
I mean, they may not give you what you want, but is insurance fraud worth the additional payout that may or may not be?
You can make that comment about a lot of crimes. Some people seem unable (or unwilling) to even think one step ahead.
If you are underwater (financially) on the car, with GAP insurance a little insurance fraud will get you out of it completely. MANY policies include this now – mine does (not that I need it). If you are underwater on a car to sell it you need to cough up the difference in cash (or roll the negative equity into a new loan like a moron).
I was thinking about that. Being stuck in a deep underwater loan (heh heh) is the only reason why this may make some kind of sense.
I was in the dealership waiting for some work done on my car and I overheard a customer desperately trying to return a lease a year early. I suppose going for a drink can also apply here.
Oh yes, needing to ditch a lease early SUUUUCKS. BTDT when I lost my job with my first new car. That lease payment had to GO. Bailed out by the First Bank of the Old Man (his interest rates sucked, and it really sucks making payments on a car you don’t have anymore). Learned several valuable lessons from that experience, the big one being that I refuse to ever be in a situation with a car where I can’t drive to CarMax or call Carvana and walk away with at least a small check and no more car loan if the poop hits the rotator for whatever reason.
Or if you are “underwater” on repair/maintenance bill.
The Q7 and 7 series definitely fall into the very high cost of ownership category.
Sorry to be pedantic. In New Jersey, you don’t commit insurance fraud. You commit to insurance fraud.
I really expected “In New Jersey, you don’t commit insurance fraud, insurance fraud commits you”.
It seems be a state pastime in NJ. Parking lot floods car goes in. Then they get shipped down the east coast with electrical and rust issues.
Meanwhile, there’s three shady used car lot owners waiting at the back door of the office for the insurance company, holding a pile of cash and a handful of pine tree air fresheners, getting the lot ready for the latest hot new deals on premium vehicles.
Why you gotta call me out so publicly like that man?!
And, they come pre-washed!
Exterior and Interior!
“No accidents on the Carfax!” (Please don’t ask about other damage…)
Most NJ drivers I’ve seen in my neck of the woods would never notice they are parking in a flooded lot – a parking space is a parking space.
Much less – anticipate that the water can go higher – or anticipate anything for that matter.
It’s called Jersey Slide for a reason. Futureproofing is not part of its code.
Serious question, how does insurance differentiate driving into a flooded lot intentionally for fraud from driving into a flooded lot because you’re bad at driving?
Exhibit A–all those driving-across-the-ford Youtube channels in the UK.
Indeed, a good question.
Plenty of people drive into floodwaters hoping to get out. I’m not sure it’s such a clear case of fraud, or how you’d determine it was.
“Your honor, I was going to buy milk in my Corvette, and I thought it would be ok”
In both cases you’re at fault so it’s on you, but if you parked it there before it flooded it could have been an unforeseen accident that insurance would have to cover if you have comprehensive coverage.
At fault so you would still receive a payout— I presume comprehensive coverage is required here too since there is no collision— but would face increased premiums for the at fault claim?
from progressive’s website, https://www.progressive.com/answers/comprehensive-car-insurance/
I think they would argue and likely succeed in saying that the damage was not caused by a flood but by a collision with another object outside of live animals especially as it was being operated at the time.
Why didn’t they show the ppl actually driving into the flooded lot and walking out?
“I thought if I went fast enough, I’d stay mostly on top of the water I swear!”
A bucket list item for me is to try this with a snow mobile (and a life preserver obviously)
Seriously. Anybody want to help make a wish?
I had a coworker who has done this many times.
His most recent stunts included taking a snowmobile up a frozen dam and also taking a canoe full-speed down a snow-covered hill into the unfrozen open river water.
He loved living on the edge.
The canoe is a fun time. Not sure I’d want to try it into a river. I can tell you a kayak is near uncontrollable.
“Loved living on the edge.”
Loved being past tense.
Hope this is not correct.
I noticed that too!
A’Aron:
“Loved living on the edge.”
Loved being past tense.
Hope this is not correct.
Fordlover1983:
Reply to A’Aron
I noticed that too!
Past tense only since I no longer work with the guy.
He did break his neck once falling off a snowmobile. Then he drove himself to work the next Monday. After complaining that both his hands and fingers were completely numb, he was finally convinced to drive himself to the hospital to get some type of cable installed in his neck and stitchwork that looked like a zipper.
His doctor told him he was not allowed to do any strenuous activity for a couple of months to which he replied, “I can still drive my snowmobile, though, right?”
There’s a toboggan chute in my town that is equivalent to the canoe stunt. Every winter we have the Toboggan Championship and a small village of alcohol enthusiasts arrives to camp on the frozen pond. It’s pretty fun.
[redundant]
Can we have an article about how absolutely unhinged the Liberty Mutual commercials have become? If you haven’t seen the original commercials years ago, these current ones are like fever dreams
And the messaging seems to be “hey, look at how stupid we can be!” I guess it’s just to get their name stuck in people’s heads?
That’s literally all it is, as more and more customers become aware that switching insurance every couple years is advantageous, it’s all about just being one of the handful of companies whose names they remember well enough to bother requesting a quote from for their next rotation.
Yeah, I just hate that name recognition, even from just annoying people, is enough of a business strategy to be worth the deluge of stupid ads.
I will give them credit on one thing–the recent ad with the tandem skydive with the emu actually used an accurate tandem skydiving rig. I’m so used to seeing movies, TV, and ads get it wrong that it was a pleasant surprise from a very stupid ad campaign.
Yeah, I think advertisement in its current form is one of the lowliest human pursuits, the fact that they have directors, actors, screenwriters and editor carefully making these short films, and they’re aware that they’re creating this piece of media to be seen exclusively by people who don’t want to see it.
Not for long! Soon we’ll still have the stupid ads but they’ll be AI generated.
Audien is already running them for hearing aids.
I’m still trying to fathom the brain trust that though it would be a good idea to turn “Schwab!” into a swear word. Those commercials leave me feeling that Schwab is the company I need to run away from.
Yeah, that is a weird one. The premise of “banker stymied by Schwab” almost works, but the part that is memorable isn’t that he is defeated again, but that he curses them.
And, of course, the “benefits” they tout include managing your own portfolio, which is just investing without a portfolio manager. It’s not a benefit, but a drawback. If I have someone manage my funds, they can advise me and move money around, but I can still tell them what I want them to do. If it’s self-managed, I just have to do that all myself.
Agree, also why are there 2 different fever dream storylines? The dumb actor and Limu and Doug, to me that says they’re making too much money so need to go with somebody else. Of course I say that having Progressive who have an entire staff of actors in commercials with boats and such so maybe I’m the fool.
there’s three of them now, the liberty biberty has become an actual creature.
The only nice feature is he gets attacked by a bird. I was hoping to see the bird eat his eyeballs before going for the rest, but alas he just gets dropped somewhere else.
Even birds want nothing to do with that weird blob of rejected Muppet material.
It’s my money and I want it now! Call 1-800-JG Wentworth.
So obnoxious and over the top I will never forget it. Mission accomplished.
Whoever created, performed in and approved those should be fired.
Cameras and DNA testing are making things really tough for the new generation, and we all thought RICO was as bad as it was going to get. Not to mention all the big corporations controlling the casinos and the weakening of labor unions
I hear you loud and clear [insert two winky face emojis here].
If I need money, I should make sure my truck has an “excess combustion event” in a rural area away from cameras.
Blink once if you recommend torching my vehicle in the woods.
Blink twice if you recommend torching my vehicle in the desert.
Blink thrice if you think an unfortunate boat ramp incident is the more plausible option.
(I quietly await your reply)
Thanks for the practical consumer advice, Peter!
I just want that Liberty Biberty thing to stop blinking at me at all
For $100 I can set our friend Biberty up on a blind date with a mermaid, if you know what I mean…
(picks up phone)
“Hey Siri, how you fit concrete shoes on a guy wit no feet?”
( o_o ) ( -_- )
( o_o ) ( -_- )
( o_o ) ( -_- )
;;)
Easier to see if there is anyone around
Nothing like an engine converting to external combustion via a surprisingly loose fuel fitting to close the GAP in your negative on-paper equity. Shame the factory forgot to torque that fuel line fitting right over the exhaust to spec.
Hmmm…
My truck is a diesel. The exhaust system gets very hot during a regeneration cycle. Long, dry grass + hot exhaust = payday! No sabotage needed!!
Foolproof plan, even with cameras!!! Take that, Jake from State Farm!
My insurance might wonder why the truck was suspiciously low on fuel before the unfortunate event, but I’m not torching a tank full of $6/gallon diesel…
(incidentally, it would suck if my truck were to actually catch fire after writing these dumb comments)
The flash point for diesel is 52 degrees Celsius, regardless of how much fuel is in the tank, it’ll all burn in a fire.
Somebody tried this in their new Corvette beside my 73 Plymouth. The insurance company gave me 1500 for the Plymouth, I kept it and drove it for another 4 years. It was a little crusty on the drivers side, droopy dash and door card. Great deal for me as I paid $50 for the car. The thing was a cockroach.
I recommend Torching your vehicle by letting the battery go bad and swell and leaving it in an undisclosed North Carolina neighborhood with a chainsaw in the bed and a fresh 6 pack of clam juice.
That’s always an option.
Two or three. Don’t burn down the woods.
Lol. Well the joke wrote itself, but these people were definitely underwater on their loans. Obviously they couldn’t find a good bridge to park under.