Home » Exclusive Porsche ‘Re-Imaginer’ Singer Has A New Model And It’s A Design Disaster

Exclusive Porsche ‘Re-Imaginer’ Singer Has A New Model And It’s A Design Disaster

Singer Overcooked Ts2

Just over four years ago, I was deciding what interesting car I might buy with the small ill-gotten windfall that had just landed in bank account. I wanted something I could drive and enjoy that wouldn’t be a complete ball ache to run, lose any money and should financial ruin become a possibility, be easy to sell on. Despite my feigned ambivalence, once the prospect of owning one became a possibility, the siren call of the 911 was hard to tune out. As long as it was air-cooled, manual and preferably black. A Targa or cabriolet would be fine – I am an incorrigible show off after all.

Being the least desirable versions, my internal classic car value-o-meter told me roofless versions of the 911 should be under forty grand, right? Wrong. Flipping open the laptop revealed I could just about get a Tiptronic 964 with a spotty history, moon-shot mileage and questionable color choices for just under fifty. Recalibrating my search, I found a black on black, late 930 Targa for £33k ($44.5k). It sold before I could pick up the phone.

Vidframe Min Top
Vidframe Min Bottom

As I write this on Thursday afternoon out of the 34 964s listed on Pistonheads (the UK’s main specialist and classic car sales and auction site) 27 are near or over £100k ($135k) – some significantly so, including Targas. According to Wikipedia Porsche built 63,762 of the things so they’re not exactly unicorns. Aside from the tech/finance bro classic car bubble what the hell is driving the prices of these ass-engined coupes into the stratosphere? The Singer Tax.

Singer1

Happy Days

Singer was formed in 2009 by ex-Catherine Wheel singer Rob Dickenson, born of his obsession with the 911. After hand building and restoring a few cars by 2014 he was ready to pack the whole thing in. According to Car Magazine:

‘We’d done 13 or 14 cars, people were saying nice things and clients knew they were proper. But orders were trickling in, they were ferociously expensive cars to re- store and we were losing money on every single one of them,’ he reveals. ‘In 2014 or 2015 I said, “Right, why don’t we give up?”’

What Dickenson did instead was what so many small automotive startups and cottage builders with big dreams fail to do. Get in a professional CEO who knows what the fuck they are doing. Operations were grown and streamlined into a new a facility in Torrance Ca which employs over 600 people. Singer has now restored over 380 cars at least $900k a pop. Thus the prices of original 911s have been dragged ever upwards and encouraged other companies such as Theon to want a piece of the 911 restomod pie as well. So if you can’t buy the affordable 911 of your dreams, you know who to blame.

This morning’s press release instructs us to refer to this latest model as the Porsche 911 Reimagined by Singer – DLS Turbo, which infers busy fax machines in the offices of lawyers in both Stuttgart and Torrance. Mouthful nomenclature aside, what we have here is the first customer car – built entirely to the client’s requirements.

As with every Porsche 911 Reimagined by Singer, Sorcerer (the client’s name for the car – AC) has been personalized by its owner, according to their individual requirements.

Specification overview:
Type 964 chassis
Lightweight carbon fibre bodywork in Fantasia Blue with track-focused configuration
3.8L, four-valves per cylinder, twin-turbocharged flat-six with electrically powered fan
Six-speed manual transmission
Rear-wheel drive
Carbon-ceramic braking system
Lightweight 19” (front) and 20” (rear) forged magnesium, centre-lock wheels.
Interior in Pebble Grey leather and Pearl Grey Alcantara with Champagne trim
Nose lift, air-conditioning, navigation, and Car Play connectivity

So far, so “is your checkbook open sir?” I’ve not especially got a problem with this part of the equation. Even us regular people are not above wanting to personalize our own comparative shitboxes to our needs and desires. I’ve swapped half the interior of my fifteen year old Mini, for example. No, my problem with the Porsche 911 Reimagined by Singer – DLS Turbo is the way it looks. Because any subtlety in the classic 911 shape has been mutilated on the altar of heritage. Again, directly from the press release because as you I know I never want to upset anyone:

Sorcerer is restored around the original Type 964 monocoque, augmented with chassis strengthening, and wears lightweight carbon fibre bodywork, inspired by the rare 934.5 endurance racer from the late 1970s.

Porsche 934
Porsche 934. Image Porsche
Porsche 935
Porsche 935. Image Porsche

The 934.5 was created by smashing together two similar, but separate racing 911s – the road based Group 4 934 and the flat nosed, box arched Le Mans winning Group 5 935. The result was a horrid Frankstein that appeared to be constructed from the back and front halves of two completely different cars. Because that’s exactly what it was. Now that’s fine for motor racing where engineering and regulatory expedience trump aesthetics. The Brawn BGP 001 isn’t winning any beauty prizes but it doesn’t matter because that’s not the point of it. You can’t just take A, combine it with B and proclaim the result as heritage inspired design. It’s about taking and refining what is appropriate, not applying historical elements with a blunderbuss. When you lean into your racing past and transpose those engineering necessities onto a road car they look more out of place than that weird utensil in your kitchen drawer whose purpose you’ve forgotten.

Is A 911 By Any Other Name As Sweet?

The Porsche 911 Reimagined by Singer – DLS Turbo looks like a standard car has backed full speed into an outsize cereal box and driven off again with it still attached. Where the hell did that rear wing come from? Boeing? You’d need clearance from ATC before driving this anywhere near an airport. I can only assume the purpose of it, and the outsized jutting splitter at the front, are to keep drooling smartphone wielders a safe distance from the rest of the expensive carbon fiber bodywork.

Singer3

Singer2

Also residing firmly in the ‘overdone elements’ part of the design are the wheels, which are 19” at the front and 20” at the back. You can’t take modern wheel sizes and slap them on what is essentially a car from 1964, because the basic shell was never designed around that sized wheel in the first place. Muscle car restomods are guilty of this crime all the fucking time and it looks stupid. It’s like a leprechaun wearing seventies sized roller skates. Bigger is not automatically better. The craftsmanship and finish on display here is no doubt exquisite. It’s the cartoon execution that bothers me, especially since Dickinson (as well as being related to Brexit blowhard and Iron Maiden frontman Bruce Dickinson) is a trained car designer having been hired by Peter Stevens to work at Lotus.Singer4

This thing probably cost the owner more than $3 million – and despite having handling developed by Marino Franchitti you cannot tell me it is six times the driving experience of the Sportklasse 911 I drove a couple of years back. I get why cars like exist – they allow high net worth individuals to play car designer, picking out color and trim, deciding on finishes and materials and deciding on their chosen mechanical specification. And rich people commissioning one offs goes back to the dawn of the automobile at the turn of the last century.

Singer5

But my feeling is there’s a Bridezilla element to all this – getting swept in the process and then a feeling of crushing anti-climax after the event when it’s all over. You’re rattling about in a loveless McMansion drinking wine from a box, or in the case of a Singer, with an un-drivable three million dollar bauble.

Which may be why six of the 34 964s currently listed for sale on Pistonheads are Singers.

(Unless otherwise stated all images Singer.)

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on whatsapp
WhatsApp
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on reddit
Reddit
Subscribe
Notify of
115 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Rod Millington
Rod Millington
1 month ago

I will continue sticking to my opinion that if I’m spending bonkers money on an air cooled 911 it’s going to be a Tuthill 911K.

LMCorvairFan
LMCorvairFan
1 month ago

Yup I agree, it’s a carbuncle. Ballers and bros might like em but I don’t.

Jonathan Green
Member
Jonathan Green
1 month ago
Reply to  LMCorvairFan

Carbuncle is a great word. And there’s quite literally a gathering of pustules at the back of this car, under the bumper…

Howie
Member
Howie
1 month ago

“When you lean into your racing past and transpose those engineering necessities onto a road car they look more out of place than that weird utensil in your kitchen drawer whose purpose you’ve forgotten.”

oh yeah. I have stuff from the MIL I have never touched.

“Muscle car restomods are guilty of this crime all the fucking time and it looks stupid.”

Ringbrothers hold a special hateful place in my heart.

my s10 has better design ffs.

LMCorvairFan
LMCorvairFan
1 month ago
Reply to  Adrian Clarke

I like most of their output.

Borton
Member
Borton
1 month ago

“…looks like a standard car has backed full speed into an outsize cereal box and driven off again with it still attached.” – YES! That’s it! I was struggling to figure out what it reminded me of.

Jimmy7
Member
Jimmy7
1 month ago

I appreciate it, because, like large cigars and too-young girlfriends, I know to automatically avoid any person that has one.

Methodjason
Member
Methodjason
1 month ago

I always said that if I won the lottery, I would want a Singer. But that’s when they had the relatively svelte, subtle, naturally-aspirated cars that they no longer sell. While I appreciate the attention to detail that’s gone into this new one, the over-the-top flares, wing, and wheels just make it less desirable. Like the Gunther Werks or RWB Porsches, it just looks swollen and cartoonish.

Ricardo M
Member
Ricardo M
1 month ago
Reply to  Methodjason

Did they stop selling the base Singer? I figured they’d just keep churning them out after all that up-front R&D cost.

Methodjason
Member
Methodjason
1 month ago
Reply to  Ricardo M

Yeah, they stopped taking orders for the “classic” Singer a couple years ago, to focus on the Turbo cars. You still see new ones on Instagram because they take so long to build, but my hypothetical lottery-winning ass would be out of luck.

Angel "the Cobra" Martin
Member
Angel "the Cobra" Martin
1 month ago

The color is nice?!?!?!

SirRaoulDuke
SirRaoulDuke
1 month ago

I like it, simply because I like the actual racer it is based on. But I’d rather have a “normal” Singer because it’s cleaner, and I would prefer a NA model over a turbo one. I also rather liked the mint restomod 911 you reviewed.

Grayvee280
Member
Grayvee280
1 month ago

“Your scientists were so preoccupied with whether they could, they didn’t stop to think if they should”

Cerberus
Member
Cerberus
1 month ago

I’m so glad I don’t like Porsches as it means that, when I see what they go for, I get to shake my head in confusion rather than anger at them being so far out of reach.

The big wheels on old cars thing is a horrid trend and I make bad assumptions of the people who own cars they’ve so encumbered.

Weird customer requests aside, I like the idea of what Singer does (though maybe applied to something with a lower budget construction in the first place)—make a car as good as it could be, price no object, for a real fanatic of the model or for a specific car that holds sentimental value (of course, it seems they’ve become more about wallet-swinging than the former two, but shallow people will always be a larger pool to draw customers from). However, when I thought about it in regards to the car I would have loved to have been able to do this to, I came to a similar conclusion: I would have taken a car I loved largely for its usability and versatility and turned it into a fragile, rolling liability I wouldn’t want to drive. I would have made it too precious at the cost of the reasons I loved it in the first place.

Argentine Utop
Member
Argentine Utop
1 month ago
Reply to  Cerberus

Yes. This is Pimp my Ride all along.

Spikedlemon
Spikedlemon
1 month ago

It successfully made a statement.

That seems to be the point of having f-you money lately.

Lithiumbomb
Member
Lithiumbomb
1 month ago

I’m with you on the wheels. I’ve been steadfast in sticking with the 14×7 Alpinas on my ’73 BMW bavaria, because that would have been a period correct accessory. It allows me to fit the widest tire I can on a 50 year old car (225-60/14s), and it still looks like it means business without looking out of place. People put 16 or 17 inch wheels on these cars and they were just never designed for it. Their logic is they have actual performance tire options, which is fair, but I’m fitting a BF Goodrich T/A muscle car tire which is already leaps ahead of the 175-70/14 bias ply tires, with tubes (!) , that it had from the factory. The ride quality surely suffers as well with a low sidewall.

Stephen (aka Belyle)
Member
Stephen (aka Belyle)
1 month ago

This reminds me of some of the monstrosities I used to make in Need for Speed: Underground. 50% cool, 50% cringe.

Lizardman in a human suit
Lizardman in a human suit
1 month ago

Only 50% cringe? I used to go for full cringe. Just like on F&F

Manwich Sandwich
Member
Manwich Sandwich
1 month ago

” You can’t take modern wheel sizes and slap them on what is essentially a car from 1964, because the basic shell was never designed around that sized wheel in the first place. ”

+1

Couldn’t agree more.

And with the level of ‘reimagining’ going on here, it’s not like the the buyer is truly getting the ‘classic 911 experience’

They should have just bought a new Porsche.

Grayvee280
Member
Grayvee280
1 month ago

100%, Those wheels give it a bit of a Lightning McQueen vibe

LMCorvairFan
LMCorvairFan
1 month ago
Reply to  Grayvee280

Yeah, there is a barris et-al over the top customized look.

MP81
Member
MP81
1 month ago

Counterpoint: no, it isn’t.

The spoiler could stand to be smaller, but I also understand why it isn’t.

Gubbin
Member
Gubbin
1 month ago

Well, that’s one way to give your customer a car that looks unique. Also, I appreciate the wealth redistribution.

MATTinMKE
Member
MATTinMKE
1 month ago

I like it. I like the cartoonish nature of it. I like that it exists and that there is someone out there to build such a thing.

No Kids, Lots of Cars, Waning Bikes
Member
No Kids, Lots of Cars, Waning Bikes
1 month ago

I think I would find a cheaper but better looking kit car.

Gubbin
Member
Gubbin
1 month ago

I know a guy who built an AC Cobra kit car for fun, and ended up selling it to someone in England. I could go for something like that.

Ottomottopean
Member
Ottomottopean
1 month ago

When Adrian says you’ve made the wheels too big is when you should know you’ve gone too far.

Unlike most I have a fairly deep appreciation for Singer’s efforts. But this is… oof, tough to look at. So much wasted potential.

At least I can say they made some really enjoyable color choices across the board.

D0nut
Member
D0nut
1 month ago

Spot on! The Singer 930s are UGLY.

Nunca el Jefe
Member
Nunca el Jefe
1 month ago

Is “Press Release” one of the paid options on a Singer?

Waremon0
Member
Waremon0
1 month ago
Reply to  Nunca el Jefe

COTD nomination.

BB 2 wheels > 4
Member
BB 2 wheels > 4
1 month ago

I don’t even know what Pistonheads is, but I know I can’t afford it.

TK-421
TK-421
1 month ago

I… don’t hate it.

Lotsofchops
Member
Lotsofchops
1 month ago
Reply to  TK-421

Reading Adrian’s articles always makes me glad I’m not a designer, because man I don’t care about most of his complaints (I will say the wing is too much). But I’m not knowledgeable enough in 911s specifically, or car design in general, to care like he does.
I do always appreciate his passion for it, though. And he does make me look at things with a different mindset than I normally would.

Lizardman in a human suit
Lizardman in a human suit
1 month ago
Reply to  Lotsofchops

I see what Adrian is saying. It’s like putting breast and butt implants on Sasha Grey. Just cause she is a pornstar doesn’t mean she needs them. It’s not an improvement on fantastic lines

Lotsofchops
Member
Lotsofchops
1 month ago

Agreed, I definitely get his position logically, and I don’t really love the car. It just doesn’t affect me in the same way it does for him.

Lizardman in a human suit
Lizardman in a human suit
1 month ago
Reply to  Lotsofchops

It’s Uncle Goth. His soul burns with a black fury.

Lotsofchops
Member
Lotsofchops
1 month ago

And we love him for it.

Argentine Utop
Member
Argentine Utop
1 month ago

Went to check who Sasha Grey is. You are right.

Jonathan Green
Member
Jonathan Green
1 month ago

I’m reminded of an article I read the other day that said that Mar-a-Lago face isn’t about looking good, it’s about showing you a. spent a ton of money, and b. spent it on exaggerating the parts of the body associated with youth and sexuality…

Gubbin
Member
Gubbin
1 month ago
Reply to  Jonathan Green

Also c. submission display.

Howie
Member
Howie
1 month ago
Reply to  Gubbin

Ha. It’s always about fitting in.

Bite Me
Bite Me
1 month ago

Nah it looks like a rad real life Hot Wheels car

David Weis
David Weis
1 month ago
Reply to  Bite Me

Needs a cartoon character on the wing supports. Dick Dastardly from Wacky Races. The Superbird had the Roadrunner, eh? ;p

115
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x