Home » Flagship Drop-tops: 1990 Mercedes-Benz 500SL vs 1970 Oldsmobile 98

Flagship Drop-tops: 1990 Mercedes-Benz 500SL vs 1970 Oldsmobile 98

Shitbox Showdown Flagship Ragtops

Hello everyone and welcome to another edition of Shitbox Showdown. For a brief period of time, I’ll be taking over duties from Mark in the wonderful task of separating the “or best offer” wheat from the “no lowballers, I know what I have” chaff. You’ll likely see some minor alterations, but please be assured that the hooptie parade will continue.

For starters, cars in good condition will likely be a little more rare. Bad examples of great cars are just too fun. Secondly, pricing will somewhat vary as shitboxes exist across the entire automotive pricing spectrum. That 1989 Volvo 740 sitting on a lawn with a dollar store for sale sign in the window? Possibly a shitbox. That high-mileage 2008 Toyota 4Runner from a rust belt state? Probably a shitbox. That rebuilt-title former-rental Ferrari 360 sitting at your local buy-here-pay-here dealer? Most definitely a shitbox.

While I’ll still try to stick to a reasonable budget cap, today we’re exploiting the joke that Canadian currency is basically worthless. Even though the weather’s cooling down, the deals are heating up as everyone’s looking to offload cars before paying for winter storage. But first, let’s take a look at the results from yesterday’s showdown.

Charade Poll

Huh, looks like only me and 99 other people wanted to play charades. This isn’t just a victory for the LTD, it’s a slaughter. Given the car’s condition, it’s easy to understand why. That Fox-body Ford is ridiculously clean for $2,500, plus parts availability is likely superior compared to the Daihatsu. Anyway, let’s get into the main event, where we’ll be looking at two flagship cabriolets from very different eras. Drop temperatures, drop tops, drop dead, etc.

1990 Mercedes-Benz 500SL – $5,000 Canadian

500sl 1

Engine/drivetrain: Five-liter 32-valve V8, four-speed automatic gearbox, rear-wheel-drive

Location: Brampton, Ontario

Odometer Reading: 260,000 kilometers

Runs/drives? You bet.

When you think of flagship cars, a bevy of Mercedes-Benz models likely come to mind. The S-Class is the definitive plutocrat express, Bobby Ewing had an R107 SL, and every lifestyle of the rich and famous tends to include a Geländewagen of some sort. Still, aside from a handful of much more expensive models, the gorgeous R129 SL might just be the pick of the bunch.

500sl 4

As this is a relatively early R129 500SL, it gets some tasty treats that later cars were deprived of, starting with the 32-valve M119 V8. This dual overhead cam wonder pumped out 322 horsepower, 20 more than the later M113 V8. Despite the four-speed automatic gearbox, this thing’s still quick by modern standards, dashing from zero-to-sixty in roughly six seconds. The other neat highlight is a motorized interior rear-view mirror, controlled in the same manner as the exterior mirrors. It’s completely excessive yet wholly indicative of an era when Mercedes-Benz built cars to a standard and sold them for whatever that standard cost.

500sl 2

This particular 500SL does appear impressively rust-free, although it’s certainly not without its warts. The front bumper and the plastics ahead of the left door seem to be flaking like a scab, an easy body shop fix but an unsightly issue as it stands. In addition, the complex hydraulic roof reportedly hasn’t been tested, which could prove expensive should it be non-operational, and the seller notes that the car may need a starter soon. Oh, and the gauge cluster appears to be on the rear package tray.

500sl 3

With a little bit of cosmetic work, this Sacco-era cruiser should be a marvelous three-season daily driver. Its interior still looks to be in stellar shape, while a set of somewhat undersized AMG wheels can easily be flogged to make a set of factory gullideckel alloys virtually free. Sure, some big German maintenance bills are likely on the way, but the periods between servicing sound like an absolute dream.

1970 Oldsmobile 98 – $4,800 Canadian

Oldsmobile 98 1

Engine/drivetrain: 455 cubic-inch V8, Turbo 400 automatic gearbox, rear-wheel-drive.

Location: Toronto, Ontario

Odometer reading: 98,927 miles

Runs/drives? Yes

Speaking of flagship drop-tops of bygone eras, how about your father’s Oldsmobile? Okay, your dad would’ve needed to make serious bank to drive a headless 98 back in the 1970s, but this large in-charge barge theoretically fits right in valet parked out front of a fancy restaurant. Forget the eight-ounce sirloin, you’re going for the porterhouse steak tonight.

Oldsmobile 98 2

Like the 500SL, you won’t have to explain what the 98 is, albeit for a very different reason. While the three-pointed star holds luxury appeal, John Q. Public will see a cabriolet with a hood large enough to park a Ram TRX on and assume that you have money to burn and a classic sense of style. Plus, because this is an old car, nobody will care about its fuel economy because it’s retro cool without falling into the fat Elvis Cadillac trap.

Oldsmobile 98 3

However, this big unit will need some work before it’s truly ready for the road. The seller advises that the brakes need bleeding, that a right ball joint needs replacing, and that the gas tank isn’t exactly installed because the car “needs some truck work before the tank can go back in.” Judging by the slightly crunchy door skins, it’s easy to imagine why. Oh, and the convertible top is very much split. Minor details, right?

Oldsmobile 98 4

Still, just look at it. More than 18 feet of primrose yellow land yacht with all the power amenities you’d expect from a classic flagship. So what if a 455 cubic-inch V8 isn’t the cheapest thing to run in an era of expensive gas? This thing is made to eat up the miles in style. Pop an eight-track into the player, set the cruise control, and lord over regular traffic in RAV4s and Civics. The dashboard packs more wood and chrome than Don Draper’s office, the seats look as comfy as anything from IKEA, and the multitude of lap belts suggest that this thing’s at least as practical as a well-equipped Ford Explorer.

So there we are, two posh soft-tops ripe for the picking. Choose wisely between expensive and time-consuming German car maintenance and expensive and time-consuming rust repair.

(Image credits: Kijiji sellers)

Share on facebook
Share on whatsapp
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit

51 Responses

  1. Finally a currency I can understand haha, the A plates on the Mercedes could indicate that the owner has had it for a long time which is a good sign, although I’m personally scared of both of these cars. If i had to choose I’d rather to cool factor of the Mercedes but I don’t want to pay for repairs… Oldsmobile it is

  2. Even in Canuck bucks both are overpriced for what they are. Having said that, seeing the rust on the Olds and the comment about trunk work needed leads me to suspect that there is far more sketchy underneath the car than on the Mercedes, so regardless of the 8-track, my vote goes to the Mercedes.

  3. Neither is worth repairing because better examples of each are available for just a little more.

    Therefore, the more drivable one wins. But it’s still an awful choice for this price.

    I’ll reluctantly take the Mercedes, and immediately set aside money for a new, non-biodegradable wiring harness. Decayed insulation is probably why the instrument cluster is not where it belongs.

  4. “That 1989 Volvo 740 sitting on a lawn with a dollar store for sale sign in the window? Possibly a shitbox.”

    You prefer the “for sale” info is written in the dust and grime covering the windows?

  5. While personal experience tells me even a malaise era 455 can handily offset it’s emissions equipment by vaporizing the rear tires it’s really not gonna be a fun car to drive once the novelty of driving a massive slow land yacht wears off and looks like its about to rust out any day now. The Merc will be a hideous money pit but will probably more or less stay running in between stomach churning mechanic bills. Though if it’s anything like old BMWs expect frequent uh electrical anomalies…

  6. Droptop 98 please. In ’78 while stationed at Ft Sam Houston, I needed a car. Took a cab to the blvd of used car lots and scanned the wares from the sidewalks. Saw a mint green 4 door across the street. A ’67 one owner DYNAMIC 88. Straight, clean and only $700. Ice cold air, 425 cubic inches of smooth. 5 mpg. Who cares? Gas was 50 pennies per gallon. Just need to stop by Harbor Fright and pick up one of their quality welders. I’ll be channeling David the whole time!

  7. Scratches head, pondering the Olds speedo, 120, gotta be mph ?
    So … Google/ wiki says “In 1972, the provinces agreed to make all road signs metric by 1977. During the Labour Day weekend in 1977, every speed limit sign in the country was changed from mph to km/h. From the same time every new car sold had to have a speedometer that showed speed in km/h and distance in km.” Well There’s that..
    Which means the 98k is actually 98000 Miles… Eek!
    Still going for it, but warily

  8. Guessing the Merc’s drop-top status is unknown because current owner knows those hydraulic lines like to rupture and spray stinky hydraulic oil all over the interior, essentially totalling the car, unless you can deal with stripping it all out, cleaning up the mess, replacing all the lines, etc. I’d be terrified to try it not knowing the condition.

    Forget that crumbling Olds. That wallowing barge is likely to break in half on hitting the first speed bump.

  9. Hard pass on both. If I was forced to choose, it would be the Merc because you could part it out for more. Both of these are well past being usable vehicles.

Leave a Reply