Home » How Do You Choose Which Replacement Car Parts To Buy, And Where Do You Buy Them From? It’s Wrenching Thursday!

How Do You Choose Which Replacement Car Parts To Buy, And Where Do You Buy Them From? It’s Wrenching Thursday!

Wrenching Thursday
ADVERTISEMENT

If you can’t read this, it’s because it’s exclusive content for Members. Why not join today? You can become a Member right here! In addition to getting special Member content and perks, you’ll support our humble (but awesome, if we do say so ourselves) car website! Thank you!

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on whatsapp
WhatsApp
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on reddit
Reddit
Subscribe
Notify of
77 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Matt Stocke
Matt Stocke
14 days ago

Almost always Amazon (although sometimes it’s a long search in there to buy only good quality parts). Then Napa, then Autozone, and finally Rock Auto. I dislike Rock Auto no humans to talk to, and you have to pay full shipping price, even if they send you the wrong part or it’s broken in transit. Autozone is local, but prices usually double Amazon for exactly the same thing.

Horizontally Opposed
Horizontally Opposed
14 days ago

Selling Car Farts in a box can’t possibly help with the confusion you mentioned. The picture is proof.

Last edited 14 days ago by Horizontally Opposed
Manuel Verissimo
Manuel Verissimo
14 days ago

Anything that is cosmetic (either interior or exterior), I buy from the car manufacturer directly.

Wear items I buy at local professional parts shop. The service is great and I like keeping local business alive. Sometimes I go through online parts stores (mainly autodoc). The main thing is, I do not buy something from a brand I don’t trust to be somewhat reputable in the relevant field: SFK and NSK for bearings, Hutchinson for rubber parts, Brembo, TRW or Ferodo for brakes…

The price comes in second for these as I value my time and don’t want to do the job twice.

For non-wear items that break down (looking at you BMW cooling system), it can go either way. If the part breaking down was OEM and had a way shorter life span than it should have had, I try my luck with the after market.

Parsko
Parsko
14 days ago

FCPEuro, Autozone. Then, whoever has the parts.

The Pigeon
The Pigeon
14 days ago

really depends. For most long-term consumables (wipers, spark plugs, filters, etc.) I’ll do Rockauto if I can help it. I have an Autozone down the street from me, an O’Reilly’s not that much further, so if I need it today, I’ll check there. For more niche stuff on my newer cars, I’ll get OEM from one of the dealers that will sell it online. For my Saab, well, eBay is the best I have from lots that have plenty of other Saabs sitting and waiting to be recycled. There are a few places in Europe that will still make new OEM-style parts also.

Micah Cameron
Micah Cameron
14 days ago

FCP Euro for my personal vehicles; RockAuto for the family/friend’s cars. I like RockAuto but I really miss when I can’t order from FCP. They make it very easy to buy OE or original parts. Also their lifetime warranty is nice; I’ve been getting oil filters, air filters, and wiper blades for the cost of shipping for several years now.

Michael Rogers
Michael Rogers
14 days ago

It used to be (late 80’s, early 90’s) I could go to one of several independent/family run places. Where I grew up, I would go to Andy’s Auto. They showed me how to use the brake lathe, bearing press, etc. I remember they had a Studebaker carburetor up on the top of one shelf, ben sitting there for 20 years probably. Most of the places would let you pay for a part, then call the parts house and you could drop by and pick it up on the way home. Then in the late 90’s, they started dropping out, one by one. I visited my home town last summer and was helping my dad work on his truck, and there was still one (and only one) left. We went in there, and there was the guy running it, and his helper was Mike (Andy’s son) who had closed up shop and retired. I didn’t recognize him at first. We talked a bit, he said that this was the last independent shop in whole area.

Peter d
Peter d
13 days ago
Reply to  Michael Rogers

There used to be a lot more of these independent and small-chain auto parts stores that primarily served professional mechanics and shops. They were often the best places because if they sold crap parts, their customers (who often had daily purchases) would let them have it. There is a wide range of quality out there for parts, especially re-built parts, and a well-run store will only stock the better quality and will swap out vendors if the quality goes down. These places are likely to be branded Carquest, NAPA, bumper-to-bumper, etc. depending on who is their primary warehouse supplier. In my neck of the world there are a lot fewer of these than there was even ten years ago, and both Advanced and O’Reilly’s have small fleets of delivery vehicles, so I assume they are taking over the professional business as much as they can. In my region we also have Autopart International, and there stores are usually hidden in industrial parks, but they stock a huge range of parts and give off-the-street customers prices much closer to their big customers than most other autopart stores.

Michael Rogers
Michael Rogers
13 days ago
Reply to  Peter d

I think there’s an Autopart near me. I just figured they were a supplier. I’ll have to see if they have retail.

Laurence Rogers
Laurence Rogers
9 days ago
Reply to  Michael Rogers

There’s still an independent here in Dubbo, Regional Auto and that’s who I sent DT to for Project Cactus.

There are multiple online Chrysler Valiant specialists, but I find even if they are less expensive on some of the mechanical parts the time taken to get them here is outweighed by parts getting here overnight or within a few days via the independent. Building Project Cactus with such a tight window, you bet this was an advantage!

The fact I can check the parts at the counter at Regional’s and return faulty stuff right away is a great benefit in the rare cases where things didn’t go right, such as many listings for Suzuki Mighty Boy tie rods being incorrect length. Brought in the original part, checked the new one that came in, if it was wrong they put a note on their system to not order that one again.

Along with Martin, Dutch Gunderson, Lana and Sally Decker
Along with Martin, Dutch Gunderson, Lana and Sally Decker
14 days ago

I buy from pretty much everywhere, sometimes from multiple places for the same job, often on a whim. Certain things are better from the parts store than from Rock Auto, but OEM parts from RA are fine, as they are from Amazon.

4SpeedToploader
4SpeedToploader
14 days ago

RockAuto for almost everything. You should see my magnet collection.

The Pigeon
The Pigeon
14 days ago

I just bought all new wipers for my fleet and they forgot the magnet! I was kind of annoyed.

Jesus Chrysler drives a Dodge
Jesus Chrysler drives a Dodge
14 days ago

For my old Mercedes, Pelican Parts and FCP Euro are great. Both have free shipping with a min purchase and a lifetime warranty on their parts. I have yet to use it but it translates into “windshield wipers for life.”

For the Subaru and Toyota I actually often get dealer parts. They need so little service that it’s not worth cheaping out on stuff.

Consumables and small items from the usual suspects: O’Reilly, Napa, etc. I always research first. The counter jockeys in those places are not reliable advisors.

Last edited 14 days ago by Jesus Chrysler drives a Dodge
Chris D
Chris D
14 days ago

Agreed. I worked for Kragen back in college. We counter guys learned about cars and parts as quickly as we could, and the customers taught us a lot, as well.

When I went in to an Auto Zone and asked for a part for my Mazda, the parts girl asked me,
“What’s a Miata?”.

Memphomike
Memphomike
14 days ago
Reply to  Chris D

I get the same reaction to BRZ. And forget asking for my son’s Ford 500. Nobody lists anything besides Taurus.

Jesus Chrysler drives a Dodge
Jesus Chrysler drives a Dodge
12 days ago
Reply to  Chris D

The Kyle at my local Oreilly (they’re all Chads or Kyles) tried to tell me that any aftermarket head unit would pull an extra 100 amps so I needed a much bigger battery.

Jatkat
Jatkat
14 days ago

Never parts stores if I can help it. Worked at a parts store for 5 years. It’s all garbage. Rockauto is pretty good, it at least gives you the widest array of options, even if the shipping stuff is a total PITA. OEM if I can, high quality aftermarket if I can’t.
If I must go to a parts store, I’ll go to a locally owned place, or NAPA (If its locally owned).

Matt Sexton
Matt Sexton
14 days ago
Reply to  Jatkat

Rock Auto sells the same “garbage” the stores do, where do you think they get it from?

Jatkat
Jatkat
14 days ago
Reply to  Matt Sexton

Sure, but they don’t JUST offer garbage. I can get OEM parts or other reputable name brands vs just trusting that whatever is in the O’reilly box is going to be okay.

Matt Sexton
Matt Sexton
14 days ago
Reply to  Jatkat

Pays to do your research I guess. As a NAPA store I sell NAPA-branded stuff, most of it brakes, electrical and undercar, but I can tell you exactly where it comes from. Seems like the trend lately is to have the vendor brand front and center on a lot of things.

Dogpatch
Dogpatch
14 days ago
Reply to  Matt Sexton

Having owned a auto repair business,Napa parts used to come to us with a sticker over the original label noting the Napa part number.Peel off the Napa sticker and voila there was a label with a parts plus number , a auto value number, a oreilly number etc.allon the same box.
They have switched now as you know to a branded box but I’m sure the same place in China or wherever labor is cheapest is making the part.
I still do some business with our flaps ( friendly local auto parts store )(Napa)
and the guys and gals there are great.

Matt Sexton
Matt Sexton
14 days ago
Reply to  Dogpatch

NAPA Batteries = Deka
NAPA Chassis = Mevotech or Federal-Mogul (Proformer brand)
NAPA Filters = Wix, soon to be Premium Guard, Baldwin & Donaldson
NAPA Ignition & Engine Management = Standard Motor Products
NAPA Rotating Electrical & Calipers = BBB Industries
NAPA Brake Rotors & Hardware = Brake Parts International
NAPA Exhaust = Walker
NAPA Fuel Pumps = Carter
NAPA Shocks = Monroe
NAPA Belts & Hose & Water Pumps = Gates

In addition, NAPA sells many vendor branded parts: CR/SKF, Delphi, Denso, NGK, Bosch, Dorman, KYB among others.

NAPA’s branded brake pads come from their own brake pad company, Rayloc, which has plants in Kentucky, Maryland and Utah. However we also sell Akebono and Brembo pads too.

As you probably know, China is the source point on many components on a good amount of everything all of us buy, but saying it’s all crap and comes from wherever they can get it cheapest rubs me quite a bit the wrong way.

Dogpatch
Dogpatch
13 days ago
Reply to  Matt Sexton

Sorry I offended you but if you look at what I wrote … “Im sure the same place in China or wherever LABOR is the cheapest is making the part.”
Did I say it’s all crap? No
Or “comes from wherever they can get it cheapest?No
I said where LABOR is cheapest .
That is probably not in the USA ,Canada ,Europe, New Zealand ,
Australia anymore.
Foe example …
Mevotech,Standard,both have manufacturing plants that are huge in China.
Brake Parts International has zero manufacturing in the USA it’s all in Mexico,China and India although distribution and headquarters are in the USA
Walker ,(owned by Tenneco Industries)has a large manufacturing presence overseas in Asia.
I like my local Napa store operated by local people I know and trust .
I will continue to support my local economy and hope everyone here does the same because if we all bought online there would be no local businesses left.
Have a great weekend and again I’m sorry you took my comment as being offensive to your place of employment.

Jeremy Aber
Jeremy Aber
14 days ago

Advance Auto Parts for small stuff because they’re close to my house. If I’m ordering, I’ll check Rock Auto first. Recently I had to replace a window regulator in my truck and Rock Auto didn’t have any, so I went to 1A Auto and ordered from them. I figured they have a ton of installation videos on youtube, they seem to know what’s up. What I got was a broken used part that someone had returned sold to me as new. They made it right, but that was not a fun first ordering experience with the company.

Jeremy Aber
Jeremy Aber
14 days ago
Reply to  Jeremy Aber

Oh, and if it’s for the Volvo or Saab, I’m going to either IPD or FCP Euro, I know they’ll have the right parts.

JDE
JDE
14 days ago

Rock auto is really the best thing out there, though if I need something quick, Napa seems to be the best option these days. Protip, Napa Brand filters are also WIX Made. and they will break a bulk pack that they might otherwise sell to a dealer and sell them to you for a pittance of what others sell now. Add in the lack of Wix at most other places now and it is a no brainer. Also I end up using Rock Auto to identify parts more than anything. because they seem to be the most correct, I tend to want to buy from them even if amazon is sometimes a bit simpler and cheaper if shipping is free.

Matt Sexton
Matt Sexton
14 days ago
Reply to  JDE

NAPA is severing ties with Wix in mid-October. Ever since Mann-Hummel bought Wix, and because of the pandemic, Wix has had massive issues with supply chain and order fulfillment. NAPA has been with Wix for what, 80 years? So it wasn’t a knee-jerk thing, backorders and short fill were so bad that NAPA split half the country to Premium Guard to try to help out, and it only got marginally better. Anecdotally, there’s some evidence that the Wix product is not as good as it used to be. I’ve been a Wix guy all my life, so I’m torn. I don’t know how losing a customer as large as NAPA won’t be very difficult for Wix in the long run.

NAPA Gold (light-duty) filters will be Premium Guard product nationwide, heavy duty will be split between Donaldson and Baldwin.

Der Foo
Der Foo
14 days ago

Rock Auto or maybe online dealership that has a good price, if I can wait a few days to get it shipped.
NAPA if I need it like today or tomorrow.
If it cannot wait and NAPA needs a couple days, then Advanced or the dealership.

As to which parts, I do a little research to find out who makes that particular part best. Usually I stay with the name brands and those linked to the manufacturer. If I go with a house brand, it is NAPA. Special parts or those that involve a lot of labor, I try to stick with manufacture branded.

In my experience Duralast didn’t last. O’Reilly’s is not terrible if I’m not keeping it long. Advanced is kinda my minimal. Amazon is a big “nope”.

Jatkat
Jatkat
14 days ago
Reply to  Der Foo

Here’s a tip for ya. If you have a part number, pretty much any of the big part stores can get you what you need. I worked at a Napa for 5 years. The days of NAPA having better parts than the competitor are long gone. It’s all Dorman and Standard Automotive garbage wrapped up in an Echlin or Balkamp box. Where NAPA’s tend to do better than the competition is that in smaller towns they are locally owned, and have employees who actually know what the hell you are talking about.

Der Foo
Der Foo
14 days ago
Reply to  Jatkat

Thanks for the advice. I realize NAPA has fallen some from their quality heights. That’s why I research who makes the NAPA branded parts. At least for the parts that I’ve needed, the NAPA branded are still made by reputable manufacturers. Heck, I even research who makes the parts for the brand behind the NAPA brand.

If I had to pick one parts store to supply ‘whatever’, I’d go with NAPA. I’m lucky though that I live in an area with several different part store chains and OE parts sources, so I can pick and choose where I want to get the best part for the job.

Last edited 14 days ago by Der Foo
67 Oldsmobile
67 Oldsmobile
14 days ago

For my Jeep,Chevy and Olds I go to one of the two local parts stores that specializes in American cars,(still 40 minutes away). For the other stuff i go to the closest one if they have what i need. I usually don’t buy online.

77
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x