Home » Never Sold In America: 2006 Nissan X-Trail vs 2007 Mercedes B200

Never Sold In America: 2006 Nissan X-Trail vs 2007 Mercedes B200

Sbsd 2 21 23

Good morning, and welcome back! We were off yesterday celebrating America’s presidents, but today we’re back, and taking off to the Great White North to look at a pair of cars we never got here. But before we leave, let’s finish up with Friday’s LS swaps:

Screen Shot 2023 02 20 At 4.56.29 Pm

Vidframe Min Top
Vidframe Min Bottom

Well well well… Despite the howls of protest and cries of blasphemy, the RX7 emerges victorious. Sorry, purists, but a car on the road is worth two in the garage. I do love that Chevy van, though. Actually, come to think of it, this would make a decent two-car garage with a little work. And you’d only have to remember one oil filter number.

Today’s contestants come to us courtesy of Opposite Lock member “dogisbadob,” who found these two for sale up in Canada. I don’t know much about either of these vehicles, so bear with me. But who doesn’t like finding out stuff about cars from other places? (If you raised your hand, you might be on the wrong website.) Both are silver, both are manuals, and both, sadly, are still several years too new to bring into the US. But still, it’s fun to look. Let’s see which one you prefer.

2006 Nissan X-Trail – $2,000 Canadian

330438139 507246154678466 665803330836213876 N


Engine/drivetrain: 2.0 liter dual overhead cam inline 4, 5 speed manual, FWD/part-time 4WD

Location: Montcon, New Brunswick

Odometer reading: 180,000 kilometers

Runs/drives? Currently won’t start

Say the words “Nissan crossover” to Americans and they’ll picture some horrible Rogueish, Jukey blob with a CVT gearbox designed to last just until the warranty runs out. But Nissan makes some great trucks and SUVs, and in other parts of the world, they sold this little charmer: a car-based crossover with honest, boxy styling, selectable four-wheel-drive, and, crucially, a manual transmission. The first-generation X-Trail was only sold in Canada for two years, and nowadays it’s the same thing as a Rogue, so this happy little box is no more.


330816158 1125334894809191 4821386681137150290 N

We don’t get a lot of photos in this ad, but what we can see looks good: a straight body, a clean interior, and the sort of honest, no-bullshit design that Nissan is not known for in the slightest in most recent US models. This thing reminds me favorably of an old Pathfinder I once had. I’m not sold on the centrally-mounted gauges, but I can understand why they do it: to make the dashboard more easily adapted to right- or left-hand drive. That sort of universality of design rubs salt in the wound of the US never getting this vehicle; it was meant for everybody but us, apparently.

330197157 5973092989443693 8528225784064323966 N

This X-Trail is currently inoperative; the seller says the fuel pump was recently replaced, but it still won’t start. It apparently ran just fine before the pump went out, which means the new pump wasn’t installed correctly, or it wasn’t actually the problem. Time to put on your troubleshooting hat. And from the looks of it, for about $1500 US, it’s worth saving. Too bad it’s not welcome on this side of the border for another eight years.

2007 Mercedes-Benz B200 – $2,000 Canadian

329395970 3287252428182736 8693665632792012003 N


Engine/drivetrain: 2.0 liter overhead cam inline 4, 5 speed manual, FWD

Location: Montreal, Quebec

Odometer reading: 190,000 kilometers

Runs/drives? Yes, but check engine light is on

This isn’t what Americans picture when you say the name Mercedes-Benz, either. Sturdy, comfortable sedans, yes. Two-seat luxury convertibles, sure. SUVs, yep. Even work vans these days. But compact hatchbacks? Again, everywhere but here. The B Class is a front-wheel-drive hatchback designed for Europe, but sold in Canada as well.


328236919 482444120579263 2308457629845686564 N

This B Class is powered by a four-cylinder engine paired with a five-speed manual, also almost unheard-of in US-market Benzes. There’s not much luxury to be had here either, but from what I know of European-market compacts, this should be a very comfortable and well-mannered little car. It’s not in great shape; the seller says it has some rust, and the check engine light is on.

329224715 1171892786802498 8428042171224305787 N

It does look pretty rough. Dents and scrapes abound, the interior is a mess, and the rear wiper is apparently set to license-plate-cleaning mode. But it’s cheap enough, and if it does run all right, it could make a nice little winter beater for someone for a year or two. Unfortunately, that someone can’t be anyone here in the good old US of A.

Being a car nerd in the US has its share of frustrations, and chief among them is the “forbidden fruit” of other markets. Between the silly 25 year import rule and automakers only importing stuff they know will sell well, us enthusiasts are left longing for a chance to even see these cars in person. It’s especially frustrating when they’re right there in Canada, just on the other side of an arbitrary line on the map. But if you were able to bring either of these across, which one would it be?


(Image credits: Facebook Marketplace sellers)

Share on facebook
Share on whatsapp
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
1 year ago

Almost bought a second hand X-Trail once with a bulletproof diesel engine and clutch. But was a bit taken aback by the although still reasonable, it had a much higher fuel consumption compared to my Passat TDI. That little beast was my neighbour’s daily and he pulled a lot of trailers with it, often on slick surfaces or on snow, it never once got him stuck or quit on him. He traded it in for a X3 to have more cruising comfort but still missed his trusty workhorse, especially as the X3’s clutch went out after three years.

I still regret not buying it as a fun car, a no nonsense Nissan and a cheap 4wd …

B class Mercedes, meh. They drive fine but would prefer other Euro compacts like a Peugeot 206. Here the B class was oftentimes a car for more elderly people because A) Mercedes and B) higher seat position and easier entrance without having to buy a SUV.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x