Let’s face it: some things that you wanted as a kid you were no longer interested in once adulthood took over. Sure, maybe you dreamed of being a firefighter or an astronaut, but as your twenties closed in, you realized that running into a burning building or riding a rocket to a place with no oxygen much less Uber service or a decent gyro joint was not what you first imagined it to be.
Cars are the same way. The dream machines of your grade-school or even high-school years might not have survived your more refined tastes of later years or simply the resignation that they wouldn’t fit with Real Life and Other Stuff. For me, it’s mainly the latter. In the early eighties, before I got my license, there were cars I flat-out loved and swore that I would purchase once I had the means. Once said means became available, the prospect of owning one seemed less appealing than just looking at a picture or watching a video.
If you subscribed to a car magazine back then, you couldn’t avoid the black-and-white ads in back by places such as Bayless Racing that sold kits to turn a dull Fiat 131 (or later Brava) into a replica of an Abarth rally car. These were the ones you saw in video snippets of the pre-all-wheel-drive days where they were never going in a straight line, tail hung out and spitting dust.
I thought this would be the coolest car ever to own, but as years went on, I realized I didn’t have the self-confidence to drive a loud fake race car and fully lacked the patience for seventies Italian cars (I know some people have had luck with theirs, but I can assure you that if I bought one it would catch fire within hours). What an awesome ride, though.

Some other car websites have declared that the Mercedes CLS was a highly influential and pioneering “four-door coupe”. Yeah, right. The 1976 Rover SD1 3500 would like a word with you.

Rover designer David Bache essentially took the shape of a Ferrari 365GTB/4 “Daytona” below and turned it into a hatchback sedan with a huge cargo area.

When British Leyland decided to finally import it to the US in 1980, I figured that one day I’d have to own one. Of course, fewer than around 1000 people agreed with me, and they stopped bringing it in after only a year.

Obviously, I can see why now. All of the issues you’d expect from a death-throes, labour-strike-plagued English auto industry were on display here. I wouldn’t touch one today with a thirty-foot pole. Also, as you can readily see, the American market headlights were terrible. If they’d added flip-up covers over the NHTSA-approved sealed beams like Ferrari did (and I just did below) I might feel different.
The Citroën SM is a masterpiece. I imagined one day buying one of the nonfunctional ones I saw sitting at a garage near my house, but over time the fear of breaking timing chains or hydraulic suspensions in a car that really wasn’t that fast put it further down my list. I could imagine that I’d spend tens of thousands on service and end up ultimately doing the same as Burt Reynolds did below:
How about you? If you really wanted a teal-colored Isuzu Amigo with a CHMSL wing years back but now don’t, that’s fine. I think you should change your mind, though.

Top graphic image: Bring A Trailer







A Jeep Wrangler. It was the first off-road car I liked, but I probably will never buy one. Also, to a lesser extent a Defender, but I still would like one of those, even though their problems.
I wanted the Scout 2, I actually have one, though the reality of big lumps of tractor motors without fuel feed back carbs resulting in heat removal issues and vapor lock, make me want to get rid of it on a hot day. But alas, modern Fuel injection or if a decent deal on a 6.0 is found, I can make it better.
Oh boy, I’m currently in a bit of an International craze (I mean I’ve lowkey been wanting a Scout 2 for years now, but there’s literally like 5 of them max in the country) so this is interesting. If I’ll ever import a car it’ll be an International.
What’s it like owning one? How difficult is it to find parts? “Luckily” we had around 10 days this summer where the temperature went above 20°, so maybe vapor lock isn’t something I’d have to worry about.
mine is an early Scout2, they actually called it an 810A I think, But by midyear it was a Scout 2. Parts are not terrible to find. But they can be pricy depending on what you need. Because they rust there are basically all body panels, one or two places still list bolt on exhaust even. Some things like the fuel tanks and thermostats have caveats. The poly tanks tend to leak as delivered, though they can be sealed and they don’t rust anymore after. the Thermostat is Robert Shaw style. others tend to be questionable, and trust me cooling the engines is probably the biggest issue. Champion Radiator if going aluminum, chinesium knock offs are not usually as good. Fan Shroud is required. those are actually hard to find in decent condition. water pumps are easy enough, but flushing the block is important. Mine is a 304 V8 and I think it is only 140 ish HP. weighs a couple hundred lbs over a similar sized all iron Chevy small block, but it will lug around all day as long as you keep it cool. I had some trouble with the stock carb vapor locking since they run the hard fuel line up over the intake and then between the carb and the upper water neck. I had a lot of trouble with the Holley Electronic ignition that came in my vehicle. it was a retrofit into the point distributor, so I could not swap it with Pertronix without replacing the distributer or finding the mounting plates from a point distributor to add back. ended up with DUI, it works really well though. so yeah. more of a labor of love thing than reliable daily transpo, but take the top off and head on down to wherever and it kind of makes up for it.
It sounds so cool! I’ve been wanting an American car for a while now, I’ve also entertained the idea of a 1990 F250, but surprisingly I’ve heard from owners that the parts for them are getting scarce. Others say otherwise though, so it can ho both ways.
So body panels are avaliable? That’s a big plus. I’ll keep this in mind if I ever get my hands on one!
A NEW Mustang. Over the years, the Mustang has moved away from what I want (but so has everything else). I still love them, and book one as a rental whenever I travel. But, I wouldn’t go down to the dealer and buy one now. I’ll keep my no-screens, analog old school one around as long as I can.
With you 100%. Doesn’t bother me in the least that mine’s slow by contemporary standards, she’s much more visceral than the current ones. Good and bad, sure, but driving her feels like driving a car not playing a video game.
When I was a kid, I was obsessed with VW Beetles. They were just so different looking than almost everything else available, and I showed no interest in any other car really until much later. There weren’t too many left up in Michigan, so when the family would go on trips out west where they still roamed freely, I would ask my parents to take pictures (using precious film of course). I still love they way they look, but doubt I could handle a Beetle today (sorry Torch).
Ferrari 328 GTS quattrovalve – I knew I’d never own one but it was a dream car for a while. Now that I potentially could own one, there’s no way that I’d be willing to put up with it!
Renault Fuego – Through a family connection, I got to tour a Renault factory in France as a teenager, and it made a big impression. I love that Torch recently wrote about the Fuego’s horizontal ribs which I too thought were a defining feature.
I also briefly thought the Peugeot 405 Mi16 was cool.
No way I’d pursue either one now – owning a French car in the US is asking for trouble.
Mu stepdad had a 308QV. It was pretty reliable but you should have seen the bills to keep it that way.
When I was a kid, kit cars were hot! My Dad had dreams of building one, so there were always catalogs showing all kinds of wild bodies on VW mechanicals.
The one I wanted was the Fiberfab Aztec 7. To then me, it looked incredible!
To now me, it looks a little oddly proportioned but not terrible. But my brain knows it’s absolutely going to be a miserable to drive death trap.
Same for me but my era had different donor cars. Ferraris build on Fieros, Mercedes built on Chrysler convertibles….. Then Factory Five got into the game with their mustang based kits and to a lesser degree the Stalker Lotus clone built from S-10 parts and other “locost” lotus clones.
I remember there was a Lotus Europa and a Porsche 914 that would sometimes be parked on my block, and they both captured my imagination when I was ~6. I probably wouldn’t own either one now. Probably.
914 was one of mine too. I’d see a white one with black interior on a back street, and it seemed like this awesome, right amount of compact sporty car. I had no real concept then of how exactly Porsche made that smallness possible. I do now…
Rover would like a word twice with Mercedes about four door coupés. The SD1’s predecessor – the Rover P5B – was available as a coupé, and that also had back doors and a 3.5 litre V8.
The P5B coupe always made me think they wanted to build Britain’s first (only?) 4-door hardtop but couldn’t get the structural stiffness right so they had to settle for a lower roofline with full B-pillars.
The always excellent AROnline agrees!
https://www.aronline.co.uk/cars/rover/p5/
The secret sauce to Detroit 4-door hardtops was to let the stub B pillar feast on as much rear legroom as needed, and not care about squeaks and rattles as long as they don’t show up during the warranty period (in that era as little as 90 days but no more than a year).
I wonder which of those compromises was unacceptable to Rover?
The first one listed was wind noise, and then chassis flex – and I guess since it’s a monocoque rather than body-on-frame that chopping out the B-pillar was a lot more of an issue.
Renault Fuego. B/c fire! Or so I thought in the 80s, occassionally seeing this amazing oddball turbocharged sport hatch on our roads. B/c back then, “Euro” seemed to me to be shorthand for awesome, but I had still to learn there were different types of Euro.
I assume that money is not part of the assumptions
I liked the Alfa Romeo Milano, hard no on that one.
I still think I would enjoy a Jag XKE
Gen II Ford Bronco
I have owned enough jeeps to get them out of my system.
Would love a Shelby Cobra (kit/new/modern old shape)
Ford RS200 but blindingly out of my price range.
Triumph TR7; always loved the look of these (and still do).
Morgan Plus8. Caterham, Lotus… any of the low-slung sports cars would have been so much fun to drive, but now at my age would just take WAAAAY to long to get in and out of
Fiat X-19, loved the little car when I was Like 12. Current ones that I am still on the fence on: Caterham 7, totally not realistic transportation, and would probably die it in it. Porsche 365 Kit car might be fun to drive. I also love the Lancia Stratos, which they make replicas of, but I think it would be a tight as a Condom to sit in.
As embarrassing it is to say, any Hummer from H1-H3.
I was obsessed with the Hummers, I had multiple models from 1/64 up to 1/18, posters, books, pamphlets, backpacks, a t-shirt of the wooden soapbox H2 from the commercial (got to see the real one from the ad in Disney World at what was then the GM Test Track, I wonder which GM warehouse it’s currently residing in now), all because when I was little we went to an Outback Steakhouse and their Outback H1 was parked out front and just being aghast at how huge it was. Then my dad took my brother and I to the Cadillac/Hummer dealership in Montgomery where the salesmen were more than happy to let us play and climb around the two they had in the showroom. But yeah Hummers were the coolest thing in the 90’s/early 2000’s
When I was 7, my brother’s best friend (they were both 20) just bought a red Chevy Monte Carlo. I thought it was the coolest thing (I was a dumb kid, all red two doors are sports cars duh!) but knowing what I know now, I don’t know if I would take a free one lol
Basically all of them. I grew up in the 80’s and 90’s and pretty much any sports car sold in that era was on my list. Anything from a Countach or 911 Turbo to a lowly Mustang or Firebird. Today I have zero interest in anything from the era.
I remember thinking the last generation of Trans Am WS6 was fantastic and now it looks clownish and tacky. I also remember thinking 305 HP was almost impossible from a modern factory car that didn’t sell for supercar prices. Not so impressive today.
Yep, this is the exact answer I have too.
I loved so many of those late 80s/early 90s cars and I just don’t have the nostalgia for them like so many others do.
I remember thinking the Vectra was the very definition of cool as a kid… I still think it’s pretty handsome, but don’t particularly want one.
When I was in elementary school, there was this big garage/house combo looking thing across from the school. The building was huge, with multiple garage bays. Surrounding it were a ton of cars from the 40s, most of them Hudsons, all rusty and inoperable. They were these cool shades of turquoise and sky blue, and they always fascinated me. Even in 1999, how many cars from the 40s did you see? Anyway, there was a sky blue one I, for some reason, wanted very badly. They tore down the building and hauled off the cars when I was 9 or ten, and built a CVS in its place. So, no Hudsons for me.
But the car I really wanted, wanted since I was about four years old, was an air-cooled Beetle. I watched the Herbie movies so many times I can still quote them. When I was 11 my Boy Scout troop auctioned off a project ’72 Super Beetle to help raise funds for our summer trip. I’d been incessantly bugging my folks, I wanted to learn how to work on cars and for that I needed one of my own. Anyway I’m 33 and I still have that Beetle.
Middle-class suburban kid wanted a big block, 4-speed El Camino SS. I have no idea what I’d do with such a thing today.
Pretty much anything British; my MGB GT cured me of that affliction. I have a terrible feeling that all the old Italian cars I loved back then are out as well, for similar reasons. If I want one, I’ll just build a model of it.
I still want a Dodge Shelby Charger, though. Ten-year-old-me and current me are still in agreement on that.
When I was a kid, the Ford EXP came out, and for some reason I was charmed by it. In my imagination, I was going to put an air suspension in the back to boost it up at stoplights to surprise drag-race people. (No, I did not understand the concept of front wheel drive or the myriad of physics laws that made this idea ludicrous.)
I was obsessed with the MGB… specifically the ones with the plastic bumpers. They just looked so cool to me as a kid. When I finally had the disposable income to grab one, I opted for a 1980 Triumph Spitfire instead. The Spitfire was (IMO) better looking with more sculpted lines, easier to work on, and a better driving experience. When I finally drove an MGB I was a little surprised at how big it felt and how closed-in you felt when sitting in one.
Both cars fell flat compared to my Miata, though.
Fiat X/19. Supplanted by the original MR2. Today: no to the Fiat, yes to the MR2.
I had a Matchbox “Le Car.” It had the name along the side of it. It was SO cool, but my 7-year-old self didn’t know better.
I am 16, and I still want to buy my parent’s 2017 4 cylinder 5 speed Tacoma. We will see if I regret it.
Jeep Wrangler. I really wanted one for my first car. Now? Hard pass.
I think a lot of people would agree; sadly, some already spent $50,000 on one and now realize the same thing.
I dailied a ’99 Sport for 13 years and loved every minute of it. Because of that love, I bought a ’20 and got rid of it less than a year later. Still might buy another ’99 though, nostalgia is a hell of a drug.