Home » I’m Having A Blast With This Virtual Engine Simulator And It’s Making Me Think A Lot About AI

I’m Having A Blast With This Virtual Engine Simulator And It’s Making Me Think A Lot About AI

Enginesynth Top

We live in interesting times. I’m not necessarily saying that as a value judgment, but in just a straightforward way: there’s a hell of a lot going on, not all of it great, but I suppose it isn’t boring. I think that’s why this seemingly simple post I’m writing right now is more complex than you’d expect. Fundamentally, it’s just about this very fun and engaging little online toy about engines that I’ve been having fun playing with. There was a time when that would be it. But that time is not now, because the particulars of how this online Diet Engine Simulator was made have implications that invoke ethical and even political issues. Nothing’s easy anymore!

But, and the reason why I’m writing about this anyway, is severalfold: most importantly, it’s fun. I found myself wasting a lot of time happily playing around with this, and if that’s not the definition of a successful toy, then I don’t know what is. Nextishly, I think the issues that it raises are issues worth talking about, because just ignoring them isn’t going to do anyone any good. Alsoly, this was done by Friend of the Site and occasional contributor Joel Johnson, who generally does interesting things. I mean, he once returned a press truck lent to us all smashed up.

Vidframe Min Top
Vidframe Min Bottom

I guess before we get into the complicated-thinking part, you should just try the thing out. There’s not that much to it, which is why I think it’s so good for just playing around with. You pick an engine from the big list – some are modeled on real engines, some just generic composites – and you get an animation of that engine in action, all wireframe and simplified so you can watch those pistons and crank move – and then you can listen to it, with sounds generated based on the actual collision of sound waves in the pipes and manifolds and cylinders of a combustion engine.

Enginesynthscreenshot1
joeljohnson.com

It does seem similar to something called Engine Simulator, which Joel was not aware of, and while Engine Simulator seems much more advanced, Engine Synth has at least two distinct advantages: it currently can be used, and it plays right in a browser. Engine Simulator has yet to be released, and is a Windows-only application.

Okay, back to the one you can actually play with now; Joel was nice enough to add the Citroën flat-twin engines at my request, as he already had a number of my other favorite engines in there (Volkswagen flat-four, Trabant two-stroke), but I can think of many other engines I’d like to see in here, like a Ford Tanus V4 or a DKW 2-stroke inline-three.

Enginesynth 2cv
joeljohnson.com

…there’s also rotary engines here, so if that’s your kink, you’re in luck:

Enginesynth Rotary
joeljohnson.com

…and I bet our co-founder David would appreciate this Buick straight-8, since he’s been on a bit of a straight-8 kick lately:

Enginesynth Buicki8
joeljohnson.com

It’s fun stuff, and if you have it running on your screen, it looks somewhat like you’re doing something important. Now, I wouldn’t expect these to sound all that much like the real-world engines you know and love because this is far too basic a simulator for that. Real engines are made of metal and have loose parts and bits that shake and are mounted in resonant bodies and so very many other factors that are simply not simulated here. These are kind of idealized engine sounds, from an all-math world that doesn’t really exist. Still, it’s fun.

I talked to Joel about what motivated him to make this, if there’s a goal to it, and the goal is mostly just that it’s fun. As he told me:

“…this is 100% just a fuckaround experiment/toy. Zero desire to commercialize and I’m about to upload the source to GitHub under MIT license (the freeballing commando license).”

As for the initial motivation to make it at all, well, that’s where we get into the part that may be a bit controversial here, because it involves the use of AI. In his words,

“Origin is just that I wanted a project to try fable 5.2, had been struck by this guy’s vocal chord physics generator and naturally thought of modeling the collision of sound waves in the pipes of a combustion engine.”

Now, when it comes to written or visual content on our site, we generally have a no-AI policy. I don’t think an AI-written article has any value to anyone, and even if we wanted to use AI to make visuals, it’s never accurate enough when it comes to specific cars to meet our standards, so we don’t use it, and I’m fine with that. I have plenty of problems with how AI is getting used in many ways, but fundamentally it’s just a tool, and a tool that at least has the potential to be used well and, if used really well, can be a significant amplifier of one’s own skills.

Of course, it can also be used to create absolute garbage. And yeah, while you could say the same thing of a pencil, pencils don’t generally plagiarize vast quantities of human endeavor to do what they do. That said, I think this is a pretty good use of AI. Uses like this – where someone has an idea and AI is used to do the behind-the-scenes labor to make it real, and if they lacked those skills, they’d just not have done anything. I don’t think this is taking away anyone’s job?

Joel’s opinion on all of this is (and I’m paraphrasing here) that AI is a remarkably powerful tool that is out in the world now, and while we may have issues with how it’s being used, nothing is going to make it go away, and if you choose to just ignore it, you’re ceding control over it to people that you may not want to have exclusive control over such a tool. I asked for opinions about this in the Autopian Members’ Discord, and it generated a bit of discussion, with some expressing zero interest in anything with the taint of AI on it, and others just having fun with the Engine Synth. One member, Tam, sort of echoed Joel’s point:

“Pandora’s Box has been opened and you can’t unshit that turd so make the best of it.”

It’s a beautiful analogy, regardless.

There are also practical, car-owning reasons to consider the use of AI tools. According to Joel:

“And when it comes to cars I think it’s going to be an incredible resource for independent mechanics and hobbyists… The OEMs are so clearly planning on taking us down a road where only they and their dealerships can repair cars. If some open source and AI tooling can help independent mechanics and owners actually fix their own cars that is a path worth exploring.”

So, the truth is I’m conflicted about all of this. I can think of many projects where employing AI to write code I don’t know how to write or don’t have time to try to write would be extremely helpful. There are other times when I want to do the mental work of coding, like just the other day when, on the airplane, I started to write a new system to generate the Apple II randomized birthday cars we send to members. I wanted to try a more photoreal approach, so I needed to figure out how to get photographic images converted to the Apple II’s weird video formats, then cut them up into ninths to be randomized, then figure out how to cram all these car picture chunks into the upper 64K of a 128K machine.

Apple2bdaycars Test
Author

I’m not sure if Claude or any of these models code for archaic machines like these, but in this case I wanted to think it through and try to make it work. But that’s not the case for everything!

I asked Joel about the prompt process for making this, and the answer was interesting:

“There were dozens (hundreds?) of interactions after the initial one, mostly tuning or matters of taste, but in broad strokes I just wrote up a fairly thorough requirements description and then let it rip. 90% of what is there now was generated by Fable 5.2 on its own on the first pass. That’s somewhat because I know how to write a good prompt/PRD, but in this particular instance I’d give almost all of the credit to Claude, the Chimera vocal library, and the billions of man-years of human effort that Anthropic stole to create a corpus.”

So, in the end, I’m just as confused as ever. None of this changes our no-AI-editorial-content policy, but it does get me thinking about contexts where AI as a tool – not a replacement for human thought, creativity, joy, or experience – makes sense. This doesn’t negate any of the environmental impact of data centers or the rampant content-stealing of these models, but as our Autopian Member so elegantly noted, that turd cannot be unshit.

I’m not done thinking about all this. But I may play with Engine Synth while I ponder these sticky issues.

Top graphic image: joeljohnson.com

Follow us on:

Facebook
WhatsApp
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x