Good morning! We’re going to start out my favorite month with a couple of uncommon front-wheel-drive coupes. One is Italian, and the other just has an Italian-sounding name. But I think they’re both pretty cool. Hopefully you do too.
Yesterday we looked at two clearcoat-challenged cheap sedans, and I was a little surprised that the cheaper, manual Mazda Protege lost. I guess it came down to condition, and that green Taurus really was in better shape, especially inside. Sure, the transmissions in those have been known to fail, but I’ve also seen them with 300,000 miles on them. It all depends on how it was treated, and that car appears to have been treated well.
If I were looking for a fun car to tinker with, I’d prefer the Mazda, and figure out a way to un-automatic the seat belts. But the Taurus is the better buy here, if you just need a car. It’ll use a little more gas, but it’s safer and more comfortable. And at this point, reliability is probably a wash between the two.

All right; let’s take a look at a couple of less practical but more interesting cars. One of these is a two-seater, and the other might as well be. And they’re both better suited to weekend drives than daily commutes. Show up to a Cars & Coffee in either one, though, and you’re sure to make friends.
1980 Lancia Beta Zagato – $2,800

Engine/drivetrain: 2.0-liter DOHC inline-4, five-speed manual, FWD
Location: Grand Rapids, MI
Odometer reading: 67,000 miles
Operational status: “Runs, drives, stops”
“It’s better to burn out,” says Neil Young (or Joe Elliott, or the Kurgan, if you prefer), “than to fade away.” I’m not sure that’s true of everything, but it does seem to apply to automakers. As sad as it is to lose a cool company like Studebaker, or even DeLorean, it’s almost harder to watch a company like Lancia being reduced to selling only one little economy hatchback, and only in Italy. It won multiple rally championships. It gave us Herbie’s girlfriend. Sadly, it also left America in 1982 in a flurry of rust flakes, trailing broken timing belts behind it. This was one of the last Lancia models to be sold in the US, the sporty convertible version of the front-wheel-drive Beta.

Lancia was bought by Fiat in 1969, and some purists still insist that the Beta isn’t a “real Lancia” because it uses a Fiat engine. But what an engine! It’s the Fiat “Lampredi” twin-cam, punched out to 2.0 liters for the US market, and driving the front wheels through a five-speed gearbox. This is one of the last carbureted Betas sold in the US; for 1981, they all switched to fuel injection. The seller’s description is terse; all we know is that it’s drivable. Hey, that’s better than a lot of old Italian cars in this price range.

I get the impression that someone has struggled with electrical problems with this car in the past. The lower dash trim is missing, as is the horn button, and there’s a rat’s nest of wires hanging down. I’ve been through that nightmare before, and let me tell you, at some point it’s easier just to rewire the whole damn car. Hopefully they saved the dash trim, because I don’t know where you’d find a replacement. The horn button is less of a big deal, since this car should have a Momo or Nardi steering wheel in it anyway. The seats and carpet are in really good shape, which makes me wonder if they have been redone at some point.

The biggest problem the Beta ever had was rust, and this car does have some, but it’s not bad at all. There is an underside photo in the ad, and it looks fine. A nearly rust-free Lancia Beta? In Michigan? I guess anything really is possible. The convertible top is a little ragged around the edges, and could stand to be replaced. Or just leave it down, and only drive on sunny days.
1989 Buick Reatta – $2,500

Engine/drivetrain: 3.8-liter OHV V6, four-speed automatic, FWD
Location: Aspers, PA
Odometer reading: 254,000 miles
Operational status: Runs and drives well
For a long time, Chevrolet was the only GM division that was allowed to have a two-seat car. But then came the Pontiac Fiero, and after that, all the other divisions wanted one. And they all got one – well, all except poor Oldsmobile. Cadillac introduced the Allante in 1987, and in 1988, Buick brought out this car, the Reatta, based on a shortened version of the Riviera personal luxury coupe. Like the Allante, it was kind of a flop; Buick wanted to sell 20,000 Reattas a year, but it only managed a little more than that over all four years of production. That makes this kind of a rare car.

There’s nothing special about the Reatta mechanically; it uses the same 3800 V6 and four-speed automatic as every LeSabre and Bonneville and Delta 88 from the same era. As we all know, that’s not a bad thing. Cars with this drivetrain are known for racking up the miles, though this one is a little deceptive. The odometer shows a quarter-million, but the engine was replaced at 181,000, and the transmission at 219,000. It’s practically new under the hood. It has also had a bunch of other recent work, and the seller says it runs and drives well.

The Reatta was meant to be a halo car for Buick, so it makes sense that the interior would be a showpiece. It has nice leather seats, power everything, a cool futuristic (for 1989) digital dash, the works. This one appears to be in good condition, too. There’s some fading on the steering wheel rim, but everything else looks fine.

There’s only one exterior photo in the ad, but a few of the interior, so I guess I’ll show you another one. It gives me a chance to write about the Reatta’s big party trick: a touch-screen. This was wildly futuristic in 1989, and no one had any idea we’d all be sick of them by 2026. It still works, or maybe works again after someone refurbished it. That’s good, because it’s the only way to access the HVAC controls. There’s a little add-on gadget below it, probably satellite radio or a CD changer control unit. Of course, there’s still the factory tape player, if you kept your cassettes. (I didn’t, but my wife still has all of hers.)
If you’re looking for extra seats or cargo space, you’re out of luck today. But if you want a cool, rare two-door for weekend fun, here are two good choices. So which do you prefer: the Italian orphan or the Buick sales flop?






I went with the Lancia today. It’s as close to owning a Stratos as I’d ever get.
I like the Lancia better, but not worth the apparent issues and rust will always be a fight. I was going to go with it anyway when I saw the Buick’s mileage, but the shape of the Reatta is great and I always liked them, if it’s not really the kind of thing I’d seek out.
Probably the only time I saw a vehicle before its release that wasn’t camouflaged. They were shooting photos of a Reatta up by the Art Center in Pasadena. I thought that it looked great for GM, still do.
For the price, the Buick is the better deal. The Lancia is more interesting long-term, but this is just getting started on a project.
The tears stream down my face as I pass on the beautiful Italian car for the dull Buick. I’ve never really liked the Reata, the touch screen seems like it would have to end up being a problem, and it’s an automatic. Ugh. But a Lancia with a Fiat engine and wires vomiting out of the dash like shower spaghetti gone past its prime is a something that will almost never be more than a driveway ornament. Waaahhhhhh.
The Lampredi engine is superb. It’s the only good thing on that specific Lancia. And the wheels. The rest is rust.
As an Alpha male, I could never drive a Beta.
Molon labe
FYI: The alpha male concept is false. The author of that publication regrets the mistake. The alpha male and female of that wolf pack were the parents of the wolves they were pestering and not pestering the pack overall. It ends up that wolves have a lot of respect for each other, but will let their young’uns know when they are misbehaving.
I was totally joking, besides being false it’s also moronic and dumb to call oneself an alpha male
Can I have both? I feel like I’ll need the Reatta while fixing the Lancia. In fact I feel like it’s too hard to choose between the two.
Gun to the head, probably the Buick, which would be easier to live with, but I’d still be kicking myself over the Lancia. But if I got the Lancia, it’d be kicking me, even if I did the YouTuber thing and hired a guy to make a harness for it.
Some cars are rare for a reason, and the Reatta is an excellent example of one of those. I’d rather have my heart broken by the Italian mistress than live with a perfect Reatta. The good days would be so good, all the more so due to their infrequence.
The Buick is the objectively better car, but fixed up, it’s still a hell of a boring car. You put some time and effort into the Lancia, and it’ll be a far, far more interesting car. That the Buick is ahead by nearly a factor of two is a crime. Lancia all the way today. Character is the great redeeming feature in a car, and only the Lancia has it today.
I feel like it’s an average vs. peak experience thing. The average vs. peak experience of the Buick will both be “kinda boring convertible” while the average vs. peak of the Lancia will be “not running” vs. “pretty fun for a FWD.”
Beta!
The Buick would be boring to drive, but the cool CRT says it’s still 1988 inside, which I would be all for.
I like the styling on the Lancia better…I love that angular little chuckabout vibe (I’m similarly a fan of the Fiat X1/9 and the Porsche 914).
But I don’t dislike the Reatta’s styling either…I think this is somehow an over-hated car. More importantly, it’s in much better condition and, at least for mechanicals, should be a lot easier to service.
The Buick is an easy choice here.
This is a day that should have a had a “Both” option. Sure, you’re rolling the dice on each of them, but the prices are worth the risk.
Or a “neither” option, which is what I would choose. I’m not spending two grand on crap.
Neither. The Lancia is a piece of shit, and nicer Reattas with lower mileage are cheap enough that I would not consider this one. Also, I do NOT want that CRT screen; yeah, it’s rad, but we all know it WILL fail soon enough.
I will own a Lampredi at some point, this would not be my first choice, but I like it better than the Reatta. Also, the electrical system in that Lancia has to be fairly simple. I am sure it would still humble me, but some patience, a voltmeter, and something to label the wires should see it sorted out.
Buick please oh god I hate electrical gremlins.
Lancia, please!
Just because I think it would be fun and interesting, and the touchscreen in the Reatta is on borrowed time.
I have a theory about Reattas. When they were new, people thought they were investment-quality vehicles so they basically kept them in the mylar, hoping to cash in at some undetermined point in the future. Now, however, they are realizing that point is quite unlikely to arrive, which is why there have been more of them on the market in the past several years.
Kissing cousins on styling, and of course the 3.8 Buick anything is always the answer. But, I do see the draw to a really odd never seen Italian car. at least the obvious wire mess would stop me from overthinking it and accidentally going with the Lancia. Though if I had the money for both and the 3.8 would fit in that Lancia, maybe that is the ticket? Rebody the Reatta with the Lancia?
The Reatta is, and was, an ugly church organ player car and no better than the other lame 80s grandparent Buicks. Always voting against that turd.
except in this case they look almost the same, just one is a slightly older and lumpier turd.
Yeah I don’t like the FWD coupe idea at all really.
I had to vote Lancia. I know it’s be work but in the end, I’ll have something I love. 5spd and nice sounds. Interesting thing about the Vermont loophole. I know they closed it a few years back but I hadn’t run across a car that had actually used it.
The Reatta seems like one of the nicer condition ones but Buicks have never been my jam.
Voted Lancia in VT. Then read the article. Go ahead, tell me I am wrong.
I voted Lancia. I don’t know if that is a fair price, but I know I have $2800. I also know it can’t be more than $2799 overpriced. As long as it generally works at the moment, I think it would be worth the risk to own something this rare and interesting.
Like a few other commenters below, I would like to know what is going on with the license plates. I presume the Vermont plate was a workaround to missing paperwork. I would like to know exactly whose name is on the title, which state it is titled in, and if there are any other potential claims to ownership of this vehicle. My state makes it tough to deal with paperwork issues, so dodgy titles can be a problem. At least this is something that should be easy to figure out before money changes hands.
“Works for a moment” is how I read your comment… I’m being unfair as many friends owned perfectly reliable Fiat Group cars.
I’d go with the Lancia. It’s at least a little offbeat and unusual. I’d be really wary of the rust though. Underside might “seem fine” but I’d want to go through it with a fine toothed comb. The windshield seal looks goofy like it’s been RTV’d or something.
FWIW that Reatta is really nice too, I’d have it in a heartbeat. $2500 is a great price for a well-sorted one.
flat head screw driver….lots of checking for going through. Comb might work, but not as effective in the end.
I never knew that a Lancia Beta existed before this article.
Although it’s cool with the 5-speed and mini-convertible, I’ll take the dependable Buick today.
Reatta, cause it rhymes with Miata.
Funnily enough, there’s a drivweay not too far from my house with both a Reatta and a Miata in it. I keep meaning to stop and get a picture.