Three-pedal fans, rejoice! This week on Shitbox Showdown, there won’t be a torque converter in sight. We’ll be sticking to the cheap end of the market and looking for good deals on manual-transmission-equipped cars. I’ll try to find a little something for everyone, and we’re starting out with two itty-bitty runabouts.
So, Friday was just about the easiest decision in a long time, wasn’t it? Presuming it’s rust-free, that Pontiac Vibe really can’t be beat if you just need a cheap beater. You could make a case for that little green Corolla too, but you all didn’t seem to like it nearly as well, even though it was three hundred bucks cheaper.
I’d have to inspect the Vibe carefully for rust, but if it checked out, I can’t imagine even bothering with any of the others. If there is rust hiding underneath that plastic body cladding, I could be talked into the Corolla pretty easily. The Honda Element is just too beat up, and the Chevy I have zero interest in.

The biggest problem with any of last week’s choices, though, is those damned automatic transmissions. I’m fine with automatics in some cars; my 300 would just be silly with a stick, for example. But all things being equal, I’m still more interested in cars with manual transmissions. Automatics all drive the same; you’ve driven one, you’ve driven them all. But every manual transmission has to be lived with for a while before you learn its ways. Sure, if you’re good with a clutch, you can hop in any stickshift car and drive off. But it’ll have its own personality, its own feel to the clutch, its own speeds where it feels right to shift up or down. Sometimes it’s a joy, sometimes it’s a chore, but it’s always more interesting than just moving a lever (or turning a dial or pushing a button) to D and stepping on the gas. The opportunities to celebrate those little differences, those opportunities to get to know a machine, are dwindling every year. So let’s take a look at some secondhand options, starting with these two.
1986 Honda Civic – $3,000

Engine/drivetrain: 1.5-liter OHC inline-4, five-speed manual, FWD
Location: San Francisco, CA
Odometer reading: 170,000 miles
Operational status: Runs and drives well
How the hell is this car still this nice? This thing is forty years old, and it was an inexpensive economy car to begin with. Someone has been taking care of it, and as it turns out, it’s been the same person almost all its life. It’s listed as a two-owner car, but the seller has owned it since 1986, meaning the original owner couldn’t have had it more than a few months. The mild California climate helped, of course, but really this looks like a testament to taking care of your stuff.

This third-generation Civic is powered by a 1.5-liter four-cylinder and a five-speed manual transmission. It’s still carbureted; the Civic wouldn’t get fuel injection across the board until the next generation. But I’ve never heard of many problems with Honda carbs. This one runs and drives well, and it just passed a smog test, which is always a good sign.

The driver’s seat has been replaced by a Recaro-looking unit with deep bolsters and probably a lot of adjustability. I’d be curious to know if the seat replacement was due to the original seat wearing out, or just an upgrade. It looks a little out of place in a stock Civic interior, but I bet it’s more comfortable than the stock seat. The rest of the interior looks really good, and the seller says the air conditioning works fine.

The outside looks good too, but I also suspect there’s some kind of filter at work on the photos. I don’t think this car is actually that shiny. It is damage-free and rust-free, however. I personally could do without the Pep Boys wheel covers and chrome exhaust tip, but those are easy enough to remove.
1999 Suzuki Swift – $2,650

Engine/drivetrain: 1.3-liter OHC inline-4, five-speed manual, FWD
Location: Lynnwood, WA
Odometer reading: 143,000 miles
Operational status: Presumably runs and drives fine
Captive imports – imported cars sold with domestic nameplates – have been so successful in the US that they nearly always outsell the maker’s own version of the same car. Dodge sold a lot more Colts than Mitsubishi did Mirages, for example. And this car, the Suzuki Swift, is far outnumbered by the Geo Metro. Metros still seem to be for sale everywhere, despite being out of production for a quarter of a century, but I haven’t seen a Swift on the market for a while. And it’s been far longer since I saw a purple one for sale.

The Swift and Metro are essentially the same car, with one crucial difference: the 1.3-liter four-cylinder engine, optional in the Metro, came standard in the Swift. That means this little car has a whopping seventy-nine horsepower at its disposal, not the measly fifty-five that a Metro has. In a car that weighs less than a ton, that’s a significant upgrade. All that might is channeled to the front wheels through a five-speed stick. I can’t tell you much about this one’s mechanical condition; all the seller says is that it’s a “gas saver.” I’m assuming it runs fine. I mean, if it doesn’t run at all, that would certainly be saving gas, but I can’t imagine that’s what they mean.

Like its Geo sibling, this is a simple little car, so don’t expect much in the way of creature comforts. I can’t even say with any confidence whether or not it has air conditioning. I also can’t tell you what the condition of those seats is under those cheap covers. I guess if you want to know more, you’ll have to go look at it in person.

Outside, it has some dings and dents, but nothing major. It’s missing its factory wheel covers, but personally I like plain steel wheels, so I don’t mind. The trailer hitch is a bit optimistic, I feel, even with the “big” engine. I guess you could pull one of those little Harbor Freight trailers with it.
I won’t pretend that either of these cars would be exactly exciting to drive simply because they have manual gearboxes, but I can say with some certainty that they’d both be insufferably dull with automatics. And they are both the sort of car that you can drive the wheels off of and barely break the speed limit, which is fun. Which one would you rather have?






This could be a Both day. I don’t hate either one, I guess the Swift wins as a hatch of sorts and could be a fun rallycross car. The Civic is super clean but just not interesting enough to keep for me.
But yeah, both?