Home » Which Nearly-New Old Car Might Actually Be Worth It? 1985 Chevy Cavalier vs 1990 Dodge Daytona

Which Nearly-New Old Car Might Actually Be Worth It? 1985 Chevy Cavalier vs 1990 Dodge Daytona

Sbsd 8 17 2026

Welcome to another week of questionable automotive decisions! Today, we’re looking at two American fastbacks with alliterative names and practically no miles on their odometers. Does their like-new condition justify their price tags? You’ll have to be the judge.

I make no apologies for Friday’s weirdness. I see cars like those, and I just have to share them with you all. I do it because I care. I expected that the be-finned Lincoln with a Pontiac face might win, given the sorry state of the Celica-maro, but I didn’t expect some of you to actually want the crazy thing.

Vidframe Min Top
Vidframe Min Bottom

Though looking at that Lincoln now, it’s sort of growing on me, too. Someone mentioned that it looks like something from Fallout, and I can totally see that. And I love the idea of taking it to car shows and making up a placard for it and everything – with a bullshit backstory, of course. I still don’t want it, but I have a grudging respect for it. Certainly more so than that ruin of a Toyota.

Screenshot From 2026 08 16 16 00 50

On Friday, Antti wrote about what might be the ultimate barn find, a nearly-new Mercedes-Benz 280TE station wagon buried under and protected by earthquake debris for decades. When I saw it, I couldn’t help thinking that for the right price, a car like that might actually make a lot of sense compared to a modern tech-heavy nightmare. But then it sold for more than a quarter million dollars, which is absurd.

But then a funny thing happened: I was perusing the Underappreciated Survivors group on Facebook, and came across not one, but two old cars for sale, both under ten thousand miles, and both under ten thousand dollars. Granted, they’re no olive-green 280TE, but they’re just as mechanically simple and free from technological crap. So I’m considering them the Shitbox Showdown equivalents of that Mercedes, and it will be up to you to determine which one might actually be worth its asking price.

1985 Chevrolet Cavalier Type 10 – $6,000

757937248 1325238333098322 7509784127296437631 N
Image: Facebook Marketplace seller

Engine/drivetrain: 2.0-liter OHV inline 4, three-speed automatic, FWD

Location: Amherst, NH

Odometer reading: 9,000 miles

Operational status: Runs and drives well

According to Wikipedia, Chevy sold 383,752 Cavaliers in 1985. I once owned two of them: a pale yellow sedan and a black Type 10 coupe. Both were scrapped with engine failures in 1996 (one spun rod bearing, one dropped valve, long story, not necessarily the cars’ faults). If I had to guess, a great many of them were already in junkyards by that time, and precious few of them were on the road by the time George W. Bush was sworn in. So how did this Type 10 hatchback survive forty-one years in almost perfect condition?

758751511 1729289928395546 5214620017240793545 N
Image: Facebook Marketplace seller

It is kind of an uncommon Cavalier; the hatchbacks never sold as well as the other body styles, and ’85 was the last year for the sporty Type 10 trim package. In 1986, it was replaced by the RS (four-cylinder) or Z24 (V6). You could get a V6 in an ’85 Type 10, but sadly this one doesn’t have it; it makes do with the old 2.0-liter four-cylinder. This engine is often mistaken for the 2.5-liter “Iron Duke” four-cylinder, but it’s a completely different design, and the two share no common parts. It delivers its eighty-ish horsepower to the front wheels through a TH125C three-speed automatic, which works fine and isn’t especially trouble-prone. With only nine thousand miles to its name, this one should be in fine shape – assuming it has had some exercise over the years and wasn’t just stuck in a garage and forgotten about. The seller says it “runs great,” so I guess we’ll take their word for it.

757419985 1390783959628014 1206401443471672731 N
Image: Facebook Marketplace seller

When was the last time you saw a first-generation Cavalier interior this clean? I’m guessing it was sometime in the late ’80s. These were cheap cars, made from cheap materials, and most of them ended up trashed inside. Seeing one like this is kind of a treat, even if you don’t like these old J-cars as much as I do. One word of warning, however: it does not appear to be equipped with air conditioning. Hey, it was like a seven hundred-dollar option! I might not have sprung for it either back then.

758266517 1727527788494664 8005755925419013174 N
Image: Facebook Marketplace seller

It was obviously kept in a garage, and kept clean; the paint looks great. I’d like to know how it ended up with the later model Cavalier Z24 wheels, though. They look good on there, but what happened to the originals? Are they still in a corner of the garage, with twenty-year-old out-of-date tires on them?

1990 Dodge Daytona – $9,500

774184607 122219953748305460 8598851872172377812 N
Image: Facebook Marketplace seller

Engine/drivetrain: 2.5-liter OHC inline 4, five-speed manual, FWD

Location: Santa Barbara, CA

Odometer reading: 7,000 miles

Operational status: Runs and drives well

Base models of sporty cars are funny things. They probably outsell the fancy high-performance versions by quite a lot when they’re new, but twenty or thirty years after the fact you’d never know it, because they’re all gone. Dodge Daytona Turbo Zs and Shelbys turn up for sale with some regularity, but this is the first base model I’ve seen in I don’t know how long. It isn’t even the luxurious Pacifica model, or the stripe-and-spoiler ES package. It’s just a Daytona. And that makes me like it even more than the fancy ones.

775260300 122219951498305460 948974780328129165 N
Image: Facebook Marketplace seller

So what did you get under the hood of a Daytona if you didn’t check any boxes on the option sheet? A basic 2.5-liter four, sitting alongside a five-speed manual transmission. It’s only a hundred horsepower, but it’s also probably the most reliable K-car drivetrain ever made. Chrysler’s perpetual shoestring budgets mean that engines stay in production for ages, and eventually all the bugs get worked out. And without the potential pitfalls of an automatic to worry about, this car should be just about bulletproof. The seller has already replaced all the soft parts that you’d want to refresh on such a low-mileage car, and they say it gets driven regularly to keep the juices flowing.

774575418 122219951648305460 3034487614382378434 N
Image: Facebook Marketplace seller

1990 was the first year for the new dashboard in the Daytona and LeBaron, and personally, I don’t like it as much as the old one. The switchgear feels flimsy, and I find the gauges harder to read. But just look at those seats! Do they look inviting, or what? And this one does have air conditioning, by the way, and the seller says it works fine. It’s just about the only option, though. It has crank windows and little blanking plates on the steering wheel where you’d find cruise control buttons on a fancier Daytona.

774726911 122219951846305460 5182311626969203996 N
Image: Facebook Marketplace seller

It’s nearly perfect outside as well, and in a great color. This car shows another thing I like about base models: like the second- and third-generation Chevy Camaro, the Daytona looks best without the ground effects and big rear spoiler that the faster versions come with. Sometimes it’s best to just let the sheet metal speak for itself rather than tacking on a bunch of extra stuff.

Now, I know you’re all going to scoff at the prices of these, and maybe you’re right to. But maybe not; does it really make any less sense to spend six or nine grand on one of these than it does thirty or forty grand on something built this year? You can maintain either of these with a good socket set and a Chilton’s manual. They won’t get quite the gas mileage of a brand-new car, but I bet they’re both up in the thirties on the highway. And no, they don’t have all the safety doodads or crash survivability of a new car, but they’re both still way safer than motorcycles. Still not convinced? Fine. Pick one anyway.

 

 

Follow us on:

Facebook
WhatsApp
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Subscribe
Notify of
143 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Acrimonious Mofo
Member
Acrimonious Mofo
3 months ago

The Cav is cheaper, and for some reason I find the red on red more appealing than the Daytona blue and gray (which is weird because I generally don’t like red cars, and generally find blue to be a good car color), but 80hp and an old school autotragic slush box and no A/C is a hard nope.

Ariel E Jones
Ariel E Jones
3 months ago

My first car was one of these Daytons. Except mine had T-tops (Yess!!). For a 17 year old, with the tops off and a system banging, and smoky burnouts with the 5 speed, it was initially fun. However it proved to be possibly the most miserable piece of shit crafted by the hands of man. EVERYTHING broke. Seeing it in these pics, all clean and shiny is like stumbling over your first girlfriend who has really held up over tue years. Sure, she made your toes curl, but you know tipping your toes back into that pond is a very bad idea.
I voted for the Cavalier. Much less fun, but the price seems like you could buy it, cruise it around for the summer. Enjoy it being ironically cool and then sell it for what you have into it. The Dayton is priced way too high.

Butterfingerz
Butterfingerz
3 months ago

Too much money but the Daytona is nicer.

Timothy Swanson
Timothy Swanson
3 months ago

I wanted to like the red Cavalier. But stick beats slush box.

Baja_Engineer
Baja_Engineer
3 months ago

so you skipped A/C and Fuel Injection back in ’85? Alright, then grab your inflation calculator and pay triple what they costed back then if you want them now. I’ll give you a 36yr old airbag as a bonus.

I know the used market almost never works this way but it was fun thinking about that.

PS. Yes I’ll pay extra for those so I’ll go with the Daytona

Comet_65cali
Comet_65cali
3 months ago

Here is my take on this:
I would take the Cavalier if it was backed by a manual.
Or I’d take the auto with a V6.

So its the Daytona.

Matthew C
Matthew C
3 months ago

Daytona all the way. A 5speed makes the NA 2.5L enjoyable. ( the standard auto made it a weezy experience)

I almost bought a Cavalier in the spec as my first car and glad I didnt

Aridbiome
Aridbiome
3 months ago

I really wanted to go with the Craptastic Cav. But 80 hp + auto + no air would make for a miserable driving experience.

Vetatur Fumare
Member
Vetatur Fumare
3 months ago
Reply to  Aridbiome

Sometimes, the suffering is the point. I voted Cavalier.

-67Mustang
-67Mustang
3 months ago

BOTH!

M SV
M SV
3 months ago

I always find it strange when cars like these are preserved. I like the Daytona better but it’s likey a basket case being a k car. I also couldn’t deal with red on red. The blue is nice looking. Plus better looking car. 5spd makes its enjoyable. If only it had the Mitsubishi engine.

Mr. Canoehead
Member
Mr. Canoehead
3 months ago
Reply to  M SV

The Mitsu engines of that period were pretty crappy. The turbo 2.2 would be the best option here.

M SV
M SV
3 months ago
Reply to  Mr. Canoehead

I’ve had good luck with the Mitsubishi engines of that era. Less so with the k car engines. But also the k car electronics and transmissions. Not that Mitsubishi electric system doesn’t throw you for some loops but I’ve always found fixes.

I knew a few guys that would get about 180k out of the v6 Mitsubishi in the mini vans and could swap them out in about an hour.

ColoradoFX4
Member
ColoradoFX4
3 months ago

Pop-up headlights and a stick? Yes, pop-up headlights and a stick.

Lotsofchops
Member
Lotsofchops
3 months ago

They’re both overpriced, no matter the condition. Internet money says Daytona, as it’s probably a little more fun to drive. Real money goes to a few hundred Uber rides.

Taargus Taargus
Member
Taargus Taargus
3 months ago

There’s basically no chance I’m ever choosing a Cavalier, but even less chance I’m going to pay freaking 6000$ for one. Jesus.

Yeah the Daytona is overpriced but at least a sort of like it.

SAABstory
Member
SAABstory
3 months ago

Easy for me. K-car = NO. Cavalier.

RustyJunkyardClassicFanatic
Member
RustyJunkyardClassicFanatic
3 months ago

Daytona! WOW, this was actually extremely difficult…but I just couldn’t pick a mid 80’s Cavalier (trash) over an awesome beautiful blue Daytona which is at least somewhat better in quality/reliability, is in amazing condition, + is MANUAL! $9500?! I will do everything possible, find every miniscule flaw, and see if they want any of the household items I’m currently trying to get rid of to get the price down as much as possible! It’s a total ripoff and should be half that; especially for a base model even if it’s the most reliable K-car drivetrain (that’s an oxymoron, plus anyone who pays “what it’s [supposedly] worth” doesn’t mean they are still not a…moron, ha ha). At least they replaced all the rubber bits and it’s somewhat bulletproof…yes, those seats look comfy and it has A/C! (none of my shitboxes have had A/C that worked; and in extremely hot places too…only my current daily which the AC used to work; but hasn’t in years- maybe “just needs a charge” ha ha) I really wanted to go Cavalier (Type 10? More like Type O Negative, ha ha) ONLY because I used to have an 86 Sunbird hatchback that looked almost exactly like this; but this is not that… (the Cavalier will still run VERY badly for longer than other cars will run at all, ha ha) The Pontiac was so much better, even though Sunbirds weren’t the greatest cars. Mine was awesome since it was black w/ blue interior and even had the fog lights in the front, so it almost looked like a Trans Am front end. I even thought about putting a screaming chicken on the hood so it would be my poor man’s Trans Am, but never did it. I still miss mine though, and really miss Pontiac!

Dodsworth
Member
Dodsworth
3 months ago

Because I never learn, I’ll take the Daytona. I bought a new 1984 Daytona Turbo which was a mechanical nightmare and easily the worst car I’ve ever owned. It was, however, good looking and the simplicity of this one appeals to me. No turbo and a manual? I’ll take it.

JDE
JDE
3 months ago

Popup headlights and a stick, even on a lowly NA 2.5 is superior. Out side of the low miles on a cavalier that you never see anymore anyway, there is nothing compelling about that option.

TriangleRAD
Member
TriangleRAD
3 months ago

13-year-old me lusted after Dodge Daytonas. I’d still like to own one someday, even a stripper like this one.

The Type 10 fastback is by far my favorite style of Cavalier and the condition of this one is truly incredible. I’d be thrilled to see it in person. But my teenage self won’t allow me to choose it above the manual Daytona.

Shop-Teacher
Member
Shop-Teacher
3 months ago

I have similarly warm feelings as you do for J-bodies, but I’ve always loved the way the Daytonas look. Plus, as you said, it has pop-up headlights and a manual. Also, AC! That’s a winning combination.

Y2Keith
Member
Y2Keith
3 months ago

Red interior almost swayed me, but even without A/C, that Cadavalier must be a real dog with the automatic.

Daytona is worth the extra scratch for me today. It looks way cooler, is a cooler color, has a cooler transmission, and will be a lot cooler to cruise around in with A/C.

143
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x