Peter Vieira
Wow, you're reading this? Thanks! If you're into RC cars and I seem vaguely familiar, it's because I spent over 25 years writing and editing RC car news, reviews, and tech articles in print and online. What else, what else ... I have a degree in Film Studies (useless), most of a degree in Graphic Design (useful), and I'm married to a wonderful woman with horrible taste in men. Thanks to her, we have a terrific daughter who just earned her Journalism degree and is way, waaay more together that I was at her age. Or right now.
Read All My Posts »
I bought a condo built in 2006 and all the smoke detectors were OEM. The one in the kitchen was poorly placed and any decently prepared meal would set it off. And then all the other four of them would join the chorus. Their wired that way for making sure every space knew something was up.
When I got tired of that shit, a year ago, I pulled them all and saw they were about 9 years past by their best by date and replaced them. Then the new one in the kitchen started bitching about its battery. I put a new one in and it still kept interrupting our sleep. So, the kitchen one is on my bench, and we’ve slept better and not burned up yet. My condo has sprinklers too, so I guess I’ll evacuate if water starts pouring on me.
Oh… and the model that replaced the originals, from the same parent conglomerate changed the wiring harness and the ceiling mounting bezel. Thanks. Assholes.
We had a CO detector fail; it somehow ended up on a shelf in the garage after I bought and installed its replacement.
I got a panicked call from my mom at work one day; the CO detector was going off!!! No, not the new one. The one in the garage. She had decided to back in that day, placing her Jeep’s tailpipe directly below the shelf where the old CO detector was perched. She couldn’t get the battery compartment open, so she ended up pitching it into the shrubbery.
Did it go off when she backed in, or when she started the car next? These days, I’d actually be surprised if a warmed-up car in closed-loop mode generated enough CO to set of a detector.
When she was backing in…she doesn’t exactly do that slowly, so the detector likely got a decent blast of ’03-era exhaust.
Ah, that probably makes sense. ’03 means not just older emission requirements but probably a catalytic converter that’s seen better days. And maybe an ECU that’s a bit less diligent about always staying in closed-loop.
I have bluetooth connected smoke detectors throughout the house, mostly because if a fire starts in my basement… well let’s just say I wouldn’t hear that one and we’d all likely perish thanks to my balloon framed house and the rather dry kindling that all this old growth pine has become.
*shudders*
Unfortunately, these also suck. We’ve had two bite the dust already, one which set off randomly at 3am (why is it always 3am???) and scared the absolute shit out of us, as every single detector yelled “FIRE” at us. But I really don’t have a better solution, as I’ve already spent every dollar I have on rewiring the house, and a true interconnected system just wasn’t in the cards (my house is a nightmare of plaster and lath and sadness).
Anyway, yeah, smoke detector options suck. If you have an old-ass house like me, the bluetooth ones have been relatively unreliable when it comes to malfunctioning.
Same story here. Came home from a trip and the whole house was going off, but was clearly not on fire. A week later we woke up twice overnight to them yelling “fire”.
I have had this exact scenario happen… I replaced all my detectors the next day.
I found out three months ago, at 2am, that my one year old Kidde smoke detectors require alkaline manganese dioxide AA batteries. The beeping had started during the previous day, which was nice, but the Duracell batteries I popped in at 6pm only kept it quiet for a few hours before it decided the battery was too low. I bought some of the Kidde-branded Golden Power batteries and replaced all the batteries in the house and all has been well. Well, aside from the hollow promise that those expensive Kidde batteries that died in 13 months would last at least 24 months.
I learned the hard way to respect manufacturers’ battery protocols. A couple years ago I put in a sensor-operated bathroom faucet which, together with a similar soap pump, was OCD paradise. “Touchless hand washing? Yes please.” The only problem was that the faucet’s under-sink actuator ran off a mess of AA batteries. No big deal, I thought. The ones it came with took a long time to die, and when they did, I put in rechargeable ones. I switched entirely to rechargeables years ago so I didn’t give it a second thought.
Not long after that it quit working so I hunted down the manual to troubleshoot it. “DO NOT USE RECHARGEABLE BATTERIES” Kohler insisted. I did a little research and discovered that some electronics can be damaged by undervoltage conditions, but all I really know is that I can’t replace that faucet for less than like $250 unless I find another one on closeout.
NiMH? Those are only 1.2V instead of 1.5, so that would make sense, especially if they are run in series. You probably would have been fine with li-ion AAs, but they have to be direct replacements so they put out 1.5V via an integrated buck converter as standard cell voltage is 3.7.
Yep, basic Panasonic Eneloop NiMHs, so after they come off the charger and sit in the battery organizer for a while, probably close to 1.2V. And there were about five or six cells in series, which probably amplified the problem.
They (NiMH) don’t drop voltage on a heavy draw like alkalines do, but smoke detectors don’t draw a lot of current, especially when they only rely on batteries during a power outage. The difference in recycle time on an external camera strobe flash between alkalines and MiMH is incredible. And stays that way until the MiHH ones are nearly depleted.
That industry is as messed up as any other.
But they start off at a lower voltage. Being run in series, the difference is even greater. If the device required a higher voltage to avoid damage, then that would make sense as to why the manufacturer explicitly instructed to avoid them. That typed, I imagine typical alkalines drop below that 1.2V of the NiMH prior to cutoff (if they didn’t, I would think the NiMHs wouldn’t work at all), so maybe it’s a matter of pulling too much current from the NiMHs that the alkalines couldn’t supply? Like, the internal resistance of alkalines could be designed into the device’s operation as a regulator, but the NiMH has significant enough lower resistance that they allow too much current to damage the components. As you state, they don’t draw a lot of current, so it would make sense that they wouldn’t be designed to handle much in the first place.
Yeah, the house has hardwired detectors, but still needs battery replacements and I suspect they chirp by time passed, not battery voltage drop as, being hard wired, they shouldn’t need to drain the battery and batteries today have really long shelf lives, a lot longer than it seems the detectors go between sessions of annoyance.
A roommate once caused an entire apartment building to be evacuated in winter in Detroit by spraying an air freshener too close to a smoke detector.
Anyway, it’s worth looking at Wirecutter for actual good smoke alarm recommendations. Also, you can stick them up there with Velcro, so you can pull them down with a (slightly) lower risk of damaging your ceiling.
I had the smoke detector issue late at night once and found that you can make it stop if you stab the speaker with a cavalry sabre. Just an FYI, if you happen to have a sword around.
I feel your pain. I swear there’s a time chip in them that makes it so they only go off in the middle of the night, never at say, 7:30 pm. I think they monitor your sleep and when you get into that awesome sleep from which there is no waking without swearing, “CHIRP”. We have seven smoke detectors in our house and they are all linked. One goes off, they all reciprocate. Finding the culprit is just about impossible. Mostly I mitigate the problem by replacing the batteries every New Years Day so they don’t get weak. Humidity is usually taken care of with the A/C or heat running, but bugs get in there and set them off sometimes, too.
Edit: Helpful hint: You can stop a dead detector from beeping by disconnecting the power and batteries and holding down the test button until it discharges.
Huh, I think you may live on my street. A while ago, I kept hearing an odd beep from somewhere outside my house. It turned out to be a smoke detector in the middle of my alley beeping about a dead battery, but it didn’t sound like any smoke detector I’ve heard before, hence the delayed recognition. I left it in the alley where I found it just in case someone actually lost it, but a couple days later I found it moved on to my grass, so I gave up and threw it out. I could still faintly hear it beep from the trash can until it got picked up a few days later though. I wondered what journey lead it to the middle of the alley.
Hey my login actually works on my work computer again! Good thing I discovered this late in the day as I needed to be productive. Tomorrow’s productivity is about to drop massively though!