Remember The Jeep That Overheated 20 Minutes After I Sold It To A Nice Lady? Well, Its Engine Suffered Severe Damage

Image (97)

This sucks. It really, really sucks. I’m selling what I consider the perfect example of my favorite Jeep — a 1991 Jeep Cherokee XJ Laredo five-speed 4×4 — for one main reason: I’m tired of working on it. So it’s pretty absurd that that, after I sold it, I’m now covered in grease, tearing into the vehicle’s broken engine, whose cylinder head I just took to a machine shop to be diagnosed. What the machinist found was not good; let’s have a look.

I have so much regret. I should have taken the XJ on a long-ish test drive before selling it, because I know I would have noticed a thermal issue far before the engine overheated. The buyer — like most people who expect their cars to, you know, work — did not, and continued driving until the Jeep literally spewed steam out of its exhaust pipe and would no longer start. The result of my inaction is that, instead of just replacing a water pump in two hours, I’m rebuilding the top end of an engine. Actually, to be more precise, I’m replacing it.

This last part is news I just received from my machine shop, whose kind, towering, heavy-set foreman called me earlier today to say only two words: “It’s cracked.”

To be honest, I already knew this was the case. I have owned four Jeep Cherokees in my lifetime, and have cracked cylinder heads on all four of them. I even once wrote about how, while traveling through Colorado, I stayed an extra week to fix my best friend’s family’s XJ, whose engine, I’d been told, was drinking coolant. That ended up being a cylinder head crack as well. (Its crack is shown at the bottom of this article).

As great as the AMC 4.0-liter engine is, that long cast-iron head is unforgiving when subjected to high temperatures, and given that the Jeep Cherokee XJ was designed initially to cool only a 2.5-liter, 100 horsepower inline-four and a 2.8-liter, 110 horsepower V6, its engine bay isn’t exactly ideal for the 190 horsepower fuel injected straight six. The short, wide radiator, along with its two tiny fans (one mechanical, one electric) are just not enough to reliably keep the Jeep cool in a variety of conditions, especially if the cooling system parts aren’t in tip-top order.

Obviously, in this case, the problem had less to do with the XJ’s marginal cooling system and more to do with a water pump that leaked out all the coolant, but my point is that I’m tired of replacing 4.0-liter heads. I’d rather do just about anything else at this point.

Usually I snag a new head from O’Reilly Auto Parts for about $400, but because my donor vehicle for my $350 red overlanding Jeep was a rusted-out Green ZJ with a good motor, I’ve had a spare sitting in my garage for a number of months. I zipped its cylinder head off and took it to the shop today to be checked and shaved perfectly flat; I have no doubt it will be crack-free based on the condition of the 205,000 mile engine (it’s remarkably good).

Now let’s get back to that cracked head.

Here’s a look at the crack that the shop identified:

That’s pretty substantial; I mean, the fact that it’s clearly visible to the naked eye, and that it’s over an inch long tells me that this engine got very, very hot.  What I find interesting is that the crack propagated between two cylinders; my previous experience with a cracked 4.0-liter head in my friend Bobby’s Jeep involved a crack forming between two valves of the same cylinder:

What a nightmare scenario for all involved, really. You sell a car after spending years replacing its entire front suspension, front fender, fender flare, fender liner, rear bumper, front bumper, driver’s seat, ECU, power steering pump, front axle vacuum disconnect motor, radio, and on and on — you’re certain that finally, after all of those fixes, the car is worth enough to be sold for at least a small profit. You didn’t buy it to sell it, of course; you wanted to keep it forever, but it’s been too much of a hassle, and now just want it out of your hair. Then finally, you find a buyer, who drives away and then 20 minutes later — boom: You’re stuck fixing the Jeep yet again.

I truly believe that, if a car has been unreliable enough, it will feel like it’s betrayed you, and you’ll fall out of love with it. That happened long ago between me and what I once thought was the most perfect Jeep on earth. I want it out of my life.

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on whatsapp
WhatsApp
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on reddit
Reddit

88 Responses

  1. I think you just have bad luck man. I am on my 4th XJ as well and none of them have cracked the head, even the 2000 I had. And the 2000 was the one that the lower radiator hose broke and it did overheat!

  2. Real mechanic would have drilled and pinned that crack, heated the head up in the oven in the rental house, Welded it with the battery DC stick welder and then smoothed out the weld with a flat file

  3. Hey David!

    Been watching this, and I have one fear that I will share…….and possibly (likely) piss you off to consider.

    If the engine got THAT hot, by those cracks and Rootwyrm’s explanation, this baby got hooooooooooottttt with a capital F, hahahaahahah. What’re the odds of the piston rings losing their temper?

    I ask, because I have had this happen a handful of times over the 30 odd years I have been working on cars. It’s not often that it occurs, but it does seem to happen when you give one a real through nuking.

  4. Just for the record: I have been a friend of The Nice Lady for over 30 years and she is perhaps not actually divine, but a goddess of the more human sort, and thus deserving of the benevolence and karmic right-making David is heaping on here.
    All kudos to David for being a stand up guy (from the initial meeting with TNL) and all subsequent transactions, and the universal scales of justice and whatnot do level off.

  5. Hot take coming.

    This is not your fault. This is/was the new owners fault. I would have told her to pound sand, but I understand you are a bit of a public figure at this point, as anyone looking to get into having hobby vehicles NEEDS to know how to keep them in good condition; there were no idiot lights back then. She found that out the hard way. I think you should charge her something for the repairs. It was under her watch and she destroyed it. I’m all for being nice. But part of being nice is not rewarding stupidity. We must reward being smart. She was not smart. She was dumb and couldn’t watch the gauges she needed to while driving a vintage vehicle. But she’s going to be rewarded with a rebuilt head. The circle of stupid continues.

  6. Idk if I’d call a cracked head “severe engine damage” if everything else is fine. Cool you had a spare. Weird about the location of the crack; I don’t get how that can happen either.

Leave a Reply