“None.” Yes, OK, I respect the knee-jerk reaction. And I’m with you. No way, no how am I cool with paying a subscription fee to activate parts that are already installed in the car. If my new car is equipped with heated seats, I’m not paying a monthly fee to make them work. The automaker isn’t incurring any extra expense every time I want to toast my butt cheeks, so why the heck should I have to pay them?
I can see a case for subscribing to features that might become enhanced over time, or content that is updated. Maybe you can subscribe to fake engine noises for your electric car. A few come loaded for free, but if you want the latest engine sounds each month, you have to subscribe. I wouldn’t want that, but at least it makes sense.
I can also see subscribing to services that actually require ongoing investment from the automaker, such as OnStar (I just Googled it to see if that’s still a thing) or some kind of premium service package, but those aren’t car features.
How about over-the-air updates as a subscription? Anything safety-related or bug-fixing would be free, but otherwise, you’ll have to go to the dealer to get the latest updates or upgrades. Two things here: one, that would just make me mad, and two, I wouldn’t pay for the subscription or go get the updates. Nothing broken means I’m not taking a trip to the dealer to get it “fixed.”
Here’s a subscription idea: the automakers pay us. You want my data? Pay me a monthly fee.
What features or services would you be willing to pay a subscription fee for?
Top graphic image: Mercedes-Benz






Police radar cloaking. Part of the fee goes to the PBA, and no one’s the wiser. Capische?
Now WHY would you want something like that?
Yeah, you’re right. That shouldn’t be subscription-based. It should be a one-time purchase you can turn on and off. There’s no reason to charge a monthly or annual fee for something that shouldn’t need connectivity to function.
Or one could, oh I dunno, not speed and never need such a cloak.
Sure, but that doesn’t make as good a joke as intentionally misreading your issue with the idea.
I have paid for app access to climate control and locks. I didn’t particularly like doing it, but it is a feature that requires data access, so I can justify it when I really want my car to start defrosting or cooling off ahead of my arrival. Toyota wants too much for that functionality, though. That said, I would pay extra up front for the ability to set schedules in the vehicle and never need to use an app to remote start my car at the end of my workday.
My parents pay for satellite radio. Content and data service makes sense. The scammy pricing structure that always decreases when you want to cancel is what annoys me the most there. And I can always use my phone for music.
My parents should probably pay a subscription for navigation. They struggle with using their phones for things like Android Auto, so having updated in-vehicle navigation would be nice if they ever went anywhere unfamiliar. Since they’ve decided all cities are too scary and they don’t really travel, I guess they don’t need it.
I can see why people might pay a subscription to self-driving features (assuming they are being actively updated and therefore use , but I neither trust nor desire those. I wish everyone who doesn’t want to drive could rely on reliable public transit, but our country doesn’t really support that.
Nothing else makes much sense for a subscription model, in my opinion. You want an engine noise for your EV? Maybe pay for a one-time download, but certainly no subscription. OTA updates? No thanks. I don’t mind manual updates and I think anything they want to send as an OTA update should be done with no subscription.
Sigh. A phone. Several infotainment services. A few altruistic organizations. Utilities. Oh, in my car? If it pencils out a service agreement. Prepaid legal?
Seriously, Google grew by trading us for our attention, stop trying to charge me to give me you saleable assets.
As a scatterbrained person, I would pay a small monthly fee for remote access to my vehicle, specifically the ability to lock it. It would be worth $5/month to have that peace of mind.
Unfortunately, last time I checked that level of functionality isn’t $5/month, it’s like $35/month, which is what I pay for my entire cell phone plan. I understand there’s a cost to cellular network access, but that’s too much.
Mazda does their remote lock/unlock and remote start service for $10 per month after a 1 year trial. I too find myself leaving the car unlocked, or friends needing to drop something off when I’m not there, so it’s worth it. If it gets more expensive though, probably not.
Good to know. Unfortunately, I just rented a CX-5 and hated the new infotainment with a passion. 🙁
I really hope they don’t apply that to the rest of their lineup.
Oh, yeah, that new one is pretty shit. Our CX-90 has the old one which is much better.
At least for now, that’s still free on Fords, even to secondhand owners. The ford app will show you the vehicle location, fuel level, tire pressures, remote start, and lock the doors (as it makes you re-lock the doors before remote starting) for free.
I was somewhat shocked that Ford didn’t try to charge me for this feature on my Maverick. My wife’s ID.4 wants a subscription for voice commands. Considering that the voice commands don’t really work, that was easy to pass on. You can use all the remote app features without a subscription fee though.
I’ve had that for free on my current and previous car. Can’t say that i’d subscribe in the future. A paid option maybe. But monthly? Nah.
The cheapest Subaru plan comes out to $4.85 a month, does everything you want and can find your car in a parking lot
I’m in the “none” camp when it comes to subscriptions. This is not just for cars – I avoid subscriptions if at all possible. While it does not make logical sense, I am willing to pay more if it is a onetime fee than something recurring.
I think the majority of subscriptions are sold in bad faith. If something isn’t worth $500, it strikes me as disingenuous to sell the same thing for $20 a month in perpetuity.
This is the answer. If the album costs $20 and the streaming music costs $15 and the data to stream it, and the company only pays the artist .005 cents per stream, you and they are better off with the hard copy.
Who pays $20 for an album?
I do. Preferably short run vinyl. Support your local bands!
I do, but only for vinyl. I’d never pay to digitally “own” anything. Streaming is one thing, I know I’m just paying for access and have no illusions that I “own” any of it.
I prefer digital, ripped to my phone so I have my entire owned collection with me at all times.
Subscription are the first step to enshitifacation. Why make the next thing better when you have the money already coming in. I can’t think of a single time a subscription for a service improved the service.
Rent-seeking behavior is so toxic that even Adam Smith wasnt supportive
I learned something new today, and have new reading for this evening. Thank you.
For my car? Eh, not much, no. But for other drivers? Sure. I’d pay to increase the distance on a tailgater’s autobrake, or make an suv self-park inside the lines in a spot that’s not blocking the view of the intersection.
Is “something I wouldn’t use anyway” a valid answer? I don’t know if there’s any good answer here. As an Audi owner, I get real peeved knowing almost all cars in my model year have the ability to use built-in nav out of the box, it’s just a matter of whether you’re willing to pay the up front fee — if it’s offered — (like $2K) or an eighty dollar per month subscription fee. Somehow nav wasn’t listed as a lump sum option, but I can pay the subscription fee. I tried it for one month, worked like a charm. Dumped it immediately following. If I keep the car for five years, that $4,800 for nav. In a car with CarPlay and Google Maps capabilities. No thanks. If Audi rightsized the fee to like 1/4 or 1/3 what it’s charging now, I might consider it. Might. Then say no anyway.
If automakers would just stop playing games and start offering true optional stuff for the amount I pay for Amazon Prime, they’d get a far better response. Or better yet, just keep it as an option I can finance into my monthly payments. Oh wait, those are called options and we’ve had them since slightly after the dawn of the automobile.
This. Toyota wants $15 a month for Nav, which seems like a bargain compared to your Audi. I just plug my phone in and used Google maps with Android Auto. I think the $15 may get me some other doo-dahs like remote start or unlock from my phone but I don’t find it that compelling to pay for in perpetuity.
It’s the whole reason I still cling to physical media. I want to own it and you can’t take it away from me when the terms and conditions change. My daughter was looking to buy a large external hard drive to move her cloud storage onto because whatever site she was using was reducing the free tier and looking to soak people for a monthly subscription now that they had everybody’s digital data.
Nothing. What every I would want I would find another way.
What, are you going to raise and train your own trunk monkeys?
Don’t tempt me. I speak chimpanzee
Well then can I get a barrel of monkeys?
They’re on back order. Can I interest you in an orangutan that talks?
Absolutely! And what great timing! I just ran out of blinker fluid.
Right turn Clyde!
I would be OK paying a subscription for something like SuperCruise where GM has to constantly keep the base maps updated so the feature works. (I see GM mapping vehicles in a daily basis)
I would not pay a $300 subscription for something like Tesla’s Cybercab as they say their autonomous tech doesn’t need a base map
It also doesn’t need LIDAR, Radar, or accountability when it slams you into a barrier, vehicle, or other immovable object.
I think I might pay for a subscription to full active development and more open control of ECUs. If an auto maker was willing to devote development resources to gather data, actively modify and improve performance and/or efficiency, and give me some level of user-controllable settings it would be worth some continued support in terms of payment from me.
The fundamental problem is that subscriptions are primarily rent-seeking extractions for finding new revenue streams from already existing practices rather than avenues to create marginal benefit for both parties.
I don’t want to own any car with even a single feature which is capable of being paid for by a subscription. Not now, not any time in the future.
I pay $12 ‘subscription’ to Tesla for the glass warranty. Not sure if it’s worth it. But I know the minute I cancel it; I’m getting hit with a rock or a deer.
Is that monthly? Do you have comprehensive coverage on the car already? For me, adding glass coverage with no deductible is a couple bucks every 6 months.
None.
Not one.
I don’t even want a car with a cellular antenna.
Why, Autopian Membership, of course!
Oh, wait, you mean in a car. Right, no, don’t need anything other than, I guess, all dealer services are free so long as you pay us a reasonable amount per month. And they’re going to drop you after 100,000 miles with that. Or send the price up to thousands a month. Which is not very nice.
Honestly, a subscription for all issues with the car (including consumables) to be covered for the life of the car. Oil changes, tires, any breakdowns. Since that literally would never exist, my answer is nothing.
This is why BMW, Audi, Mercedes are leased and not bought.
Oh contrare; Riversimple (mostly) exists right now! Car, fuel, insurance, tires, brakes, fluids, everything in one payment.
That is kind of what I was talking about, but for the US…and for a pick up truck.
$1 per zap to the CEO’s chair!
I’d pay real money for that ability. What fun!
probably an unpopular opinion here: full self-driving.
I appreciate that maintaining up to date maps, software bug fixes, etc. are expensive for a company, so I’d be down for a reasonably priced subscription to keep it up to date and safe.
Tesla charges $99 month. I’m sure they did their research where to price it – but for me – get lost.
No doubt they did their research to maximize profit, and I wouldn’t pay that either. That said, if I had a big roadtrip and could pay for just one month, that could be worth it
I do wonder what price I would pay for it, but it’s definitely lower than $100/month. I think they’d also get a lot of people hooked if they had an intro price of like $100 for your first 3 months.
I think they used to call that having a chauffeur.
It will get lost in the usual reflexive Tesla hate here (if you’re going to hate, be specific. For example, I hate Tesla’s whole UX, their steering feel, and their interiors), but the new FSD is actually really good, and probably worth paying for.
I avoid subscriptions as much as possible. This place is my only one and, oddly enough, it’s optional.
Same
I wouldn’t pay for any subscription. Not one.
I would, however, pay a premium for a car that came without “connectivity,” screens and all the other electronic bilge that gets in the way of driving a car with some degree of privacy and human control.
Isn’t Super Cruise a subscription? I’d probably pay for that. Stuff like in-car wifi, weather, traffic etc. no, but it all probably comes bundled in some huge package with Super Cruise anyway.
We chose not to. It was close. I think if the price was a little lower it would be worth it to us, but the combination of not noticing substantial improvement over the 3 year intro period, the utility, and the price didn’t work in practice. But I agree, in theory I find it acceptable.
What was the going rate for the subscription? I’m curious if Super Cruise falls back to radar cruise when you don’t have a sub, or it goes all the way back to the dark ages of regular cruise. Super Cruise is neat and probably a joy when it’s working, but I’m not paying $75 a month for it, especially if I only get “dumb” cruise anywhere that’s not a highway.
I think it was $50 a month? I’m not 100% sure since it was more than a year ago now. It does revert properly to solid adaptive cruise control without the SC subscription. What I don’t know is if it maintains the collision detection that can sense cars in front of the car directly ahead. I know SC does, but I am unsure if that’s maintained.
Automatic emergency braking is pretty much mandated today so I can’t see them taking it away.
Yes, it’s still there, but how sophisticated? The vehicle (Bolt EUV) has more advanced sensors than the standard, since not every EUV sold that year was SC compatible. Once the SC subscription ends, does it still utilize the full sensor suite for safety functions? Or does it revert to the equipment that’s common across all trims?
I would subscribe to an extended warranty that would enable me to drive some wildly complicated and depreciating German machine.
I’m sure you’ve gotten phone calls offering you an Extended Warranty. Maybe you should answer.
I can’t think of anything in a car I’d pay a subscription for. And I say this as someone who used to pay for a Sirius XM subscription.
Free trial subscriptions and an unlimited number of emails goes a long way with Sirius.
I got tired of doing the dance with them 2x a year. Not worth the effort now that Jimmy Buffett isn’t around to do live shows anymore anyway.
Remember pre-smartphone nav? They charged for yearly map updates, which meant the maps never got updated, My 2013 Civic Si has maps from 2012 in it.
There’s real value there, but still no one is paying for that, and I don’t plan to ever subscribe to any vehicle services, not even Sirius XM.
The opposite is also a NO, those insurance dongles to lower your rates? Nope. If the data is collected it can get stolen and used against me, this last week has proven just how paranoid we SHOULD be about mass data collection IMO.
Even before that, did you not have a a portable GPS unit? You could pay for updated maps for them. I don’t know anyone that ever did. If you had an old one, or were driving somewhere that was growing fast, you often just used a paper map to get through those points, and then you’d watch yourself cut across a field or something on the GPS.
I bought the Europe maps for my Garmin when I went there in 2011.
But these days, I don’t see the point of built in NAV in the first place (though the setup in my M235i was actually pretty good). My phone is so much better, and it gets updates constantly for free, with real-time traffic info. And as I have said here before, I can very much take or leave (mostly leave) any sort of screen mirroring.
I use the built in NAV on my Ioniq 5 sometimes because it’ll automatically handle battery pre-conditioning for charging, because if you use Google Maps via android auto or apple carplay, Hyundai doesn’t share battery state-of-charge info with them so they can’t suggest charge stops and thus won’t handle battery pre-conditioning.
It’s a pretty unique/niche scenario though.
That being said, Hyundai’s system ain’t bad at all. It’s basically Google maps in a different wrapper. What I don’t like about it is that you are then in the standard car infotainment screens instead of Android Auto, so voice texting then sucks ass.
No, I never had a portable GPS.
I wouldn’t even trust how they interpret the data they’re telling you they’re collecting. Brake hard to avoid any of the endless idiots and they raise your rates for increased risk for “not paying attention” or however they choose to make the numbers work in their favor, which they only ever do.
Yep, data without context is trash; OBDII Based data collection only knows what the car is doing not what the human is reacting to.
I have a 2008 Caddy that you had to buy new DVD’s for to update the maps. Again, no-one bought updates.
My 2013 Lincoln had SD card maps. I’d buy one year old ones from Ebay cheap. Kept it almost updated.
Facebook and your phone already is selling your info to the insurance companies. Why do you think Facebook is worth so much? It’s not for all the pictures of your dogs and what you ate for dinner…
Who said anything about me giving Facebook useable data?
I don’t wrap my phone up in foil. But I don’t have Facebook or any social media installed.
I use a Garmin. The map updates are free.
If its a SERVICE, that has recurring costs to maintain, then you can charge a recurring fee, else GTFAC