Home » What Features Would You Be Willing To Pay A Subscription Fee For?

What Features Would You Be Willing To Pay A Subscription Fee For?

Screenshot

“None.” Yes, OK, I respect the knee-jerk reaction. And I’m with you. No way, no how am I cool with paying a subscription fee to activate parts that are already installed in the car. If my new car is equipped with heated seats, I’m not paying a monthly fee to make them work. The automaker isn’t incurring any extra expense every time I want to toast my butt cheeks, so why the heck should I have to pay them?

I can see a case for subscribing to features that might become enhanced over time, or content that is updated. Maybe you can subscribe to fake engine noises for your electric car. A few come loaded for free, but if you want the latest engine sounds each month, you have to subscribe. I wouldn’t want that, but at least it makes sense.

Vidframe Min Top
Vidframe Min Bottom

I can also see subscribing to services that actually require ongoing investment from the automaker, such as OnStar (I just Googled it to see if that’s still a thing) or some kind of premium service package, but those aren’t car features.

How about over-the-air updates as a subscription? Anything safety-related or bug-fixing would be free, but otherwise, you’ll have to go to the dealer to get the latest updates or upgrades. Two things here: one, that would just make me mad, and two, I wouldn’t pay for the subscription or go get the updates. Nothing broken means I’m not taking a trip to the dealer to get it “fixed.”

Here’s a subscription idea: the automakers pay us. You want my data? Pay me a monthly fee.

What features or services would you be willing to pay a subscription fee for?

Top graphic image: Mercedes-Benz

Follow us on:

Facebook
WhatsApp
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Subscribe
Notify of
189 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
MikeInTheWoods
Member
MikeInTheWoods
4 hours ago

In my mind, the monthly payments on the agreed upon purchase price would be the only payments required for the product to function. If it is delivered with the hardware to function, then the software should talk to the hardware from purchase day 1 until the product is at the end of it’s life cycle. Updates to software are allowed, for free.
Just like older equipment and appliances: You bought it and fully owned it. That’s the point of having a title to it after all.
I don’t want to “rent” anything. It neirher holds nor earns any equity. That is why corporations are rich and everyone else is working while poor.

RataTejas
RataTejas
5 hours ago

I’ll pay the subscription when the price of the car is low enough to rationalize the cost.

Currently – never.

But it’s sort of like a TV. It’s the gateway to the ecosystem. If you want it basic, it’s super cheap. You want all the features and all the shows, the base price reflects that, and you pay for the content.

Strangek
Member
Strangek
5 hours ago

I can’t think of anything I would want to pay for as a subscription, but I am willing to sell advertising space on my car like a NASCAR.

Dan1101
Dan1101
5 hours ago

Press a button to disable the vehicle of driver who is dangerous to themselves and others. I’d pay $10 for a 60 minute disablement.

Ricardo M
Ricardo M
5 hours ago

The only thing that makes sense as a subscription is connected services that require ongoing maintenance of a network and server, but now that everyone’s phone does navigation better than the car, there should be zero reason for the car to be independently connected to any kind of network.

If a manufacturer releases a car that they believe will need more over the air updates than oil changes under warranty, then they’re knowingly selling an unfinished product, and I refuse to buy an unfinished product for full price. If they believe their product is complete, then they can make whatever rare changes it might need over a wired connection when it goes to the dealership for regular service.

Last edited 5 hours ago by Ricardo M
TJ Heiser
Member
TJ Heiser
6 hours ago

How about a subscription fee for ALL maintenance and repair? For the life of the vehicle – fully transferable, of course!

Timbales
Timbales
9 hours ago

Subscription features I would pay for:

– a force field generator that wouldn’t allow another vehicle to follow me too closely or change into my lane too close to the front of my vehicle.

– same generator capable of gently lifting a vehicle going too slow in front of me so I can pass under it then gently lower it back to down a safe distance behind me

– special paint that can change color and type on a whim. “I’m in the mood for Soul Red Metallic today”

Oafer Fox-ache
Oafer Fox-ache
10 hours ago

I’d happily pay for a subscription that once a month gives me alive feed of an orangutan slapping Elon Musk in the face with a blancmange… a gibbon would be fine if the orangutan isn’t available

Sp1nz
Member
Sp1nz
10 hours ago

Personally, for newer vehicles, I would pay a subscription for full statistical and health monitoring, aggregated into a beautiful dashboard that’s infinitely drillable. Yes, I’m in IT.

That Belgian Guy
That Belgian Guy
15 hours ago

Two categories that are accepteable for me personally:

  • Something where the manufacturer or seller is actually having a time or money cost. For example a wireless data connection that keeps my navigation up-to-date and keeps my remote services going. Obviously I need to be able to opt out without much trouble.
  • Something where the manufacturer or seller is ofsetting risk of higher cost by averaging out costs. For example a service subscription, where, as long as you keep paying for your subscription, all mechanical trouble (not stemming from accident) is taken care of by your mechanic. Including maintenance, wear parts, corrosion, repairs, replacement vehicle, …
Balloondoggle
Member
Balloondoggle
10 hours ago

On your second point, a service subscription: I’d like to talk to you about your car warranty!

James M
Member
James M
6 hours ago

Tesla charge a $10 per month “premium connectivity” fee which is required to use a number of connected services that require cellular data. This never seemed unreasonable to me, much like data plans needed to use internet connectivity on watches or iPads.

Mercedes charges for features that require connectivity, which boils down to the same thing in my mind, though they want $15 per month which seems a little steep.

What I don’t find acceptable is essentially creating a paywall for features installed in the car that incur no incremental cost to the manufacturer, like seat warmers or a heated steering wheel. That’s a straight up money grab that stinks of greed.

Logan
Member
Logan
16 hours ago

Nothing. I have my cell phone service as a subscription already, and there’s basically nothing that a car infotainment system can do better than it that I’d want to pay extra to offload onto it. Any attempt by a manufacturer to force the issue for that (ie. GM, Tesla) not only will not get me to buy a subscription but will get me to not buy their car at all.

Last edited 16 hours ago by Logan
That Belgian Guy
That Belgian Guy
15 hours ago
Reply to  Logan

I would defenetely be OK with a subscription infotainment as long as I can opt out and use my phone without much trouble.
Seems manufacturers are not heading in that direction.

Luxobarge
Member
Luxobarge
17 hours ago

Will pay for: things that require someone else’s ongoing investment. OnStar, satellite radio or communications, constantly updated maps. Without the other party maintaining infrastructure, these things don’t work, so it’s fair to ask me to pay for them if I want to use them.

Won’t pay for: things that my car is equipped with and require no external party’s input to function correctly. Super Cruise, heated seats, battery capacity, car door puddle lights. Asking me to pay for something already in my car, something that can still function 50 years after Kessler syndrome has destroyed all the Starlink satellites, is just holding me hostage.

Will never buy a car that has: onboard ads. Get bent.

That Belgian Guy
That Belgian Guy
15 hours ago
Reply to  Luxobarge

Oh absolutely. I had a BMW that did just that.
Turn the brights up at night => Navigation screen gets covered by a message about their subscription to automatic brights that were already installed on the car.

Get bent BMW!

Last edited 15 hours ago by That Belgian Guy
Totally not a robot
Member
Totally not a robot
17 hours ago

I’ll gladly pay to stop my stupid maps from changing my stupid route in the middle of my stupid drive, after I already checked a stupid route and clicked “Go” on that specific stupid route. Just let me go where I want to go! Stop trying to “optimize” and take me down a million side streets to save two minutes! The time it takes to make that left turn is going to erase any potential time savings anyways!

Last edited 17 hours ago by Totally not a robot
Church
Member
Church
9 hours ago

Yes! And as someone who lived on one of those side streets, we don’t want the traffic. Our tiny road was not designed for the congestion and really makes it hard to get out of the driveway.

Dan1101
Dan1101
2 hours ago
Reply to  Church

I watched a video that made a pretty good argument that so many people are using rerouting that it has reached a tipping point where it often does more harm than good. If a bunch of cars reroute it’s just adding traffic jams (and likely more accidents) to other roads.

Last edited 2 hours ago by Dan1101
Ed Kummel
Ed Kummel
19 hours ago

I guess it all depends on how you buy cars. If you buy new cars every 2 years or so, why pay for an option outright just so a future buyer can benefit from your extra cost of buying or leasing? Better to get the car’s final price as cheap as possible to keep payments down, and pay a subscription than to pay more upfront so future owners can enjoy what you paid! These options don’t add much on the used market scene…

T. Ferguson
T. Ferguson
19 hours ago

I would like a family plan at the car wash. Nope, those dorks want me to pay a separate monthly subscription fee for each vehicle. We have 4 vehicles so eff off with that noise. And I think the price of the car washes (individual washes or subscriptions) have doubled in the last 4-5 years. Imagine Netflix charging you for each tv in your house instead of 1 monthly fee. No thanks.

Mr. Asa
Member
Mr. Asa
9 hours ago
Reply to  T. Ferguson

This is a good one. I don’t wash my cars as near as often as I should, but if I could get in on my wife’s subscription I would be there a lot more often

Calvin Banman
Calvin Banman
20 hours ago

None. Nada. Zilch. Sum Zero. Full Stop.

StillNotATony
Member
StillNotATony
20 hours ago

I would pay a subscription for a low-orbit particle accelerator cannon that obliterates cars that are annoying me.

But I’d want some sort of warning shot so the person controlling the car I’m about to have vaporized has a chance to mend their ways.

I’m not TOTALLY heartless…

That Belgian Guy
That Belgian Guy
15 hours ago
Reply to  StillNotATony

Honestly,
Even that would be better in a pay-per-use.

Sometimes, during the summer period, I go weeks without actively wanting to obliterate other road users. Imagine having to pay for a low-orbit particle accelerator cannon that you don’t use.
I would probably consider a slightly higher-orbit particle accelerator cannon to obliterate the first one. As long as the second one isn’t a subscription as well.

Ricardo M
Ricardo M
5 hours ago
Reply to  StillNotATony

I’d pay a subscription for the ability to suspend other people’s drivers’ licenses at will, with the option to play any message I wish to through their infotainment system.

You know what, I’d also pay for the ability to turn other people’s headlights on/off.

CR-V Oswald
Member
CR-V Oswald
20 hours ago

I’d consider paying for something that’s pure software and costs the provider money to run. E.g. hypothetically if a really useful AI feature was invented, I’d consider it.

What I will not pay for is the privilege to unlock capabilities already available in the hardware I paid for. Like heated seats or drive modes. Somehow those are even more insulting than blank panels covering existing wiring in a dashboard.

That Belgian Guy
That Belgian Guy
14 hours ago
Reply to  CR-V Oswald

… hypothetically if a really useful AI feature was invented…

Seems like you have never heard of deepfake phonograpy.
It turns out you can have your favorite phonograpy, and then have an AI tool to convert it so it’s another performer.

Not sure I would wan’t to pay to have it in a car though.

Bodnar
Member
Bodnar
20 hours ago

Remote start that doesn’t require an internet connection and is distance bound should be free. But if it needs an internet connection, then I get why there is a cost given the cost of maintaining the service, but the cost should be way lower than what companies are charging for it.

Everything off the top of my head otherwise I don’t have a problem with manufacturers offering a paid service, but since most of those can be replace with my phone, I don’t really care if they offer a subscription.

Eslader
Member
Eslader
20 hours ago
Reply to  Bodnar

The dumbest part is that some of them (Hi, Lexus) set it up so that it’s triggered by the keyfob and is distance bound, but when the car receives the start signal it phones home to see if you’re paying for a subscription, and if you’re not it won’t start the car.

They did this on my 2016, and the best part is that the cheap fucks installed a 3g modem in the damn thing, even though 4g had been out for 7 years by the time the car was made and, of course, when 3g shut down 6 years after the car rolled out of the factory, the remote starter no longer worked at all.

Not that I particularly cared because I’d already had my own installed (better range, no sub fees) but it was a particularly boneheaded move on their part.

Bodnar
Member
Bodnar
19 hours ago
Reply to  Eslader

Ugh, that’s so dumb.

My suspicion is that the 3g modem was done cause it was cheaper and that for what they are doing with it, there’s no benefit to use 3g for what they were using it for.

Now, you might think surely they wouldn’t choose a tech that was being replaced by 4g. The problem is that in 2016, none of the carriers had announced 3g retirement yet. So my guess is they largely chose it cause of costs and not knowing the future.

Glad you worked around it.

Eslader
Member
Eslader
3 hours ago
Reply to  Bodnar

Once 4g came out, we knew 3g was going to go away, especially since 3g sits right in the middle of the frequency band used by 4g, so if you want better 4g you need to get rid of the 3g transmissions hogging the bandwidth.

That 3g modem handled everything they charge money to subscribe to including their version of Onstar, and if you subscribed to everything it was something around $100/month. Multiply that by all the 3g Lexuses that were made after 4g came out, and the beancounters left a lot of potential money on the table. A good example of penny-wise, pound-foolish – particularly when you realize they kept installing 3g modems through 2017 and in one case, 2018, 2 years after the 3g sunset was announced.

Ed Kummel
Ed Kummel
19 hours ago
Reply to  Bodnar

I agree. I work and live where I park underground. Internet/cell signal isn’t just spotty, it’s non existent! So why would I pay $300+/year for something I can’t use most of the time?

Syaieya
Syaieya
21 hours ago

I would pay money if it guaranteed that I didnt have to worry about a part being discontinued/out of stock for my cars. I cant get a keyfob for one. Another just got its rear glass restocked after years and is still a 6 week wait if i need it. And my newest car has a servo on back order for 3 months out.

Like im okay if its aftermarket. Just dont leave me dead in the water

Last edited 21 hours ago by Syaieya
Aaron
Aaron
21 hours ago

I pay $4 a month for satellite radio, love listening to Liquid Metal, gets me into new bands or when somebody puts out a new album.

If I lived where there were a lot of toll roads, a flat monthy fee would be great instead of billing me for each trip. Would never happen though

Dolsh
Member
Dolsh
21 hours ago

If it’s something that’s part of the car – navigation, remote starting, etc – I want that built into the cost of the car. I know there might be data charges – build that into the margins on the car. I won’t pay monthly for something that’s part of the car.

Entertainment and music options are fine to be subscription as long as I have bluetooth and can ignore them.

Me? I might pay a subscription to someone to keep my car clean ALL THE TIME. It was one of those summers where I didn’t wash the car even once. Kinda looks it now.

Curtis Loew
Curtis Loew
21 hours ago

I will go even further than none. I would not even buy a car that requires a subscription to any feature.

Top Dead Center
Member
Top Dead Center
22 hours ago

Assuming it reaches reasonable not fearing death all the time, a fully self driving feature where I can sleep on the way to and from work when traffic sucks – I would gladly pay a Benjamin a month for… Maybe 2 Benjamins if it would go pick up an order from the grocery store or Target for me. Otherwise, no… Where I live traffic sucks and driving around me sucks too…

That Belgian Guy
That Belgian Guy
14 hours ago

Not fearing death while full self driving equals my FSD use case of it driving me home when I am drunk.
Seems I never fear death while drunk so there’s a full overlap.

However, 200 dollars a month is a lot of taxi money.

Sofonda Wagons
Member
Sofonda Wagons
22 hours ago

None! especially if my ride already has it built in with out a sub. Where does this corporate greed bullshit madness end. Hey you just spent 50k on this unreliable
POS with its CAFE ass kissing overstressed turbo motor. You want the headlights and air bags to work? 20 bucks a month for each. This shit needs to end now.

189
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x