Home » Why I Sold My Dream Car

Why I Sold My Dream Car

Dream Over Ts2

The 2021 Galvanic Gold BMW i3 Rex is the perfect version of what I considered the perfect car for me. As soon as I saw the vehicle for sale, I bought it for full price and shipped it cross-country, no questions asked. This was my Holy Grail of Holy Grails, a car I planned to keep for eternity. But recently, I sold it. Here’s why.

As a general rule, I like to learn from my mistakes, but when it comes to cars, I’ve made the same one four times now. That mistake is: When I find a car I really love, I buy the very best version of it, only to realize that, as strong as my love for the car is, it pales in comparison to my sentimentality and cheapness.

Vidframe Min Top
Vidframe Min Bottom

The first time this happened, the vehicle was a 1996 Jeep Cherokee XJ 5-speed. It was rust free, reasonably low-mileage, and it was the very first manual Jeep I had ever owned:

Screenshot 2026 10 07 At 9.02.01 am

I bought it because it was cheap at $2,400 and, since I’d so loved my first Jeep — a 1992 Jeep Cherokee Laredo — I figured buying a “better” version would be smart. The issue was that I wasn’t able to let go of my first Jeep. It was the vehicle that had started it all, and I decided being able to hold onto my first vehicle outweighed the benefit of the rust-free rocker panels and 5-speed. Plus, someone offered me good money, which at the time was $3,750. So the 1996 XJ left, and my 1992 OG remains in the fleet.

Screenshot 2026 10 07 At 9.01.28 am

Not much later, I managed to snag the true holy grail of XJs — a 1991 Jeep Cherokee Laredo 5-speed. Aside from a bad fender and a tweaked front axle, this Jeep was mint. It was basically a much cleaner, black version of my first Jeep, but with a 5-speed manual instead of a 4-speed automatic. It was the grail.

And yet, in the end, I once again couldn’t let go of my first car, and when the black XJ’s original owner offered me $7,000, I let the black beauty go.

Screenshot 2026 10 07 At 9.08.29 am

Not long after buying that manual XJ, I bought a hyper-rare 5-speed 1994 Jeep Grand Cherokee ZJ. I flew to Colorado with my buddy Brandon, we fixed the vehicle’s clutch, and then we drove all the way back to Detroit. I loved that Jeep so much that, when a reader emailed me about their low-mileage, minty-fresh manual Jeep ZJ for sale for a low $3000 figure, I couldn’t resist. I bought the ZJ, my colleague Brad drove it all thew way up from Reno, NV, and the Jeep was just fantastic.

 

Screenshot 2026 10 07 At 9.02.23 am

But then I received two junk ZJs for about $1000 for the pair. They were both on their way to the scrapper — one due to rust and the other due to the previous owner having yanked out the manual transmission. I decided that, instead of keeping the minty ZJ, I’d turn the two junkers into one running ZJ, thereby helping keep one of these rare Holy Grails from the scrapyard. A $9,500 offer for the minty ZJ made this a no-brainer. (As shown in the image above, this owner has taken great care of it).

You would think that, after three examples of me deciding I preferred soul+cash over a minty fresh, Holy Grail version of a car I love, I would learn my lesson. But I’m afraid I did not.

In 2023, I moved to California and decided I wanted to drive an electric car. The only vehicle I was remotely interested in was the BMW i3, after Autopian contributor Thomas showed me its engineering geekery. I found the cheapest dealership-sold i3 in the country — a 2014 with 135,000 miles on the clock — and snagged it for $10,500. I received a free new high-voltage battery and compressor under warranty, and for a few years, I was absolutely in love with that gray, first-model-year i3.

Screenshot 2026 10 07 At 8.43.31 pm

I loved that gray i3 so much that…yep, you guessed it — I decided to look for the mintiest, ultimate version of the car. And I found it:

Screenshot 2026 10 07 At 2.59.37 pm

But this time was going to be different, I convinced myself. I was now a business owner and a married man with a serious daily commute in LA. I needed something reliable and efficient, and the i3 was perfect for the job. I made my affinity for this car clear many, many times to the point where I’m sure some of you, dear readers, were tired of hearing about Goldilocks:

Screenshot 2026 10 07 At 2.53.16 pm

Why, then, would I sell it?

Not too long after taking delivery of that amazing Galvanic Gold i3, my wife Elise (not her real name) and I were blessed to learn we’d be welcoming a baby into this world. At that moment, something in my brain changed. Especially with my wife’s company being absorbed and laying off much of its workforce, I began to feel an overwhelming responsibility for the wellbeing of this growing family. “Am I doing everything to ensure a great future for this family?” is a question that began cycling through my mind nonstop.

I put the i3 up for sale.

I’d just bought the vehicle for $30 grand and shipped it for $2000 and paid taxes and fees; I was probably in it for $36 big-ones or so. But the market at the time yielded a top offer of $28,000, which I — anxious about my incoming new baby — planned to accept. Then, at the last moment, and at the urging of Elise, I decided to keep the car, but only because I was somehow able to find the exact same car — likely the only other one in the world — mere miles away from the prospective buyer in San Francisco. (He bought it and is very happy).Whew. Talk about luck!

I pulled the i3S off the market and drove it for two years, even taking my baby home from the hospital in it. I was in love. But as time trudged on, my love for the i3 changed. I found myself afraid to scratch the car while I daily drove it through LA’s treacherous streets, and I worried about Elise scratching the rims like she tends to with her Lexus RX. I also couldn’t help but ruminate on that question: “Am I doing everything to ensure a great future for this family?” Over and over again that question would pop up in my mind, scores of times a day. And though I was being responsible in many ways, I couldn’t shake the feeling that the gold i3 was serving me more than it was serving my family.

Yes, I needed a commuter vehicle, and yes, ideally it’d be one I like, but did I need the BMW i3? What was the opportunity cost associated with the car? And not just the car, in all of the decisions I was making in life; this is how I began to think once Delmar entered this world. Every decision I made bore scrutiny like never before. Before I knew it, these thoughts led me to see the i3 through a different lens. This was a car I was constantly worried about damaging, one that I wasn’t comfortable with my own wife and child borrowing, and one whose value may be too high for a cheap bastard like me to continue driving.

Screenshot 2026 10 08 At 7.37.35 am

I feared that selling the Gold i3 would be a mistake — a decision I would regret for years to come, and so the process of letting it go took a while. I listed it for far too much money, then got some interest, was unwilling to negotiate to a reasonable price point, and ultimately denied offers for months. A couple of months ago, I finally changed my mind; I messaged the gentleman (Nathan) who had been interested in the car, accepted his reasonable offer, and boom: My dream car was gone.

Screenshot 2026 10 07 At 3.07.34 pm

It’s been a month since my i3 Holy Grail left me on its way to Colorado, and at no point have I ever felt even an ounce of regret. Why? Because, just prior to selling my beloved Gold i3S, I took the Amtrak Surfliner to San Diego…

Img 0151

…to purchase this:

Screenshot 2026 10 07 At 2.24.41 pm

I know, I know: It’s not Gold, it’s a 2014 and not a 2021 so its range is about half that of the gold car, and it’s got about 90,000 more miles on it. And yet, after purchasing the car I found myself driving up the 405 with a grin from ear to ear.

Img 0160

I adore this car, easily as much as I adored the gold car. I wasn’t expecting that.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by David Tracy (@davidntracy)

The 2014 BMW i3 is, on paper, a huge downgrade. It’s gray instead of the nice gold, it has less range, the exterior has some scratches and dings, it has much less time/mileage left on its extensive PZEV warranty, and overall it just doesn’t look as cool.

But from where I sat in the cabin, it felt exactly the same — possibly even nicer. The interior is in beautiful condition, and has brighter leather than the post-LCI i3(LCI means “mid-cycle refresh” in BMW-talk), whose brown is a bit dull. The gray i3 also has a compass in the mirror, netting at the back of the front seats, and a bunch of other nice features removed from the i3 as part of a clear cost-reduction exercise. What’s more, the 2014 feels better built, with better fitment of the panels and fewer squeaks:

Also, the ride is much less brutal than the i3S, the steering radius is tighter, and the car can go farther on a given amount of energy due to skinnier tires and efficiency-focused aerodynamics. Whereas the i3S tries to add sportiness to the i3 formula, this i3 Electronaut is as pure of a city car as it gets.

Img 0171

There’s still a lot more I need to do to get my new i3 up to snuff. It’s got some issues that need to be repaired (including lots of cracked rubber seals), and while I plan to address all those problems in a future story, the fact that I was able to snag this 2014 BMW i3 Electronaut Edition for $4,250 (after $1000 rebate from my power company), and still have $30,000 left over from my Goldilocks sale made this a total no-brainer.

Screenshot 2026 10 07 At 2.30.45 pm

I adore the gold i3 for its looks, range, the ability to precondition the cabin on a hot day via an app, and its minty shape, but there are so many attributes about the 2014 that I love, too. I love that each of the four wheels is unique (this means the wheels appear to be “pointing” in the same direction regardless of what side you’re looking at), I love that it’s the only model year with body-colored exterior mirrors, I love the brighter interior, I love the little niceties like the mirror-compass and behind-seat cargo netting, and I love the fact that this is the O.G. Electronaut Edition 2014 (Electronaut Edition i3s were the first i3s sold stateside, offered only to BMW owners who had driven the experimental ActiveE that BMW used to help develop the i3).

Img 0216

Today I got back home from work, and my wife — smile beaming across her beautiful face — told me all about how well our son had done in his ISR swimming class. These are classes that help babies as young as 6 months learn how to reach the edge of a pool or how to float on their backs in case they find themselves in water. Does my child absolutely need this? Probably not, and it is expensive. But it’s a skill, it helps Elise feel at ease, and Delmar is starting to like it more and more.

This is what I want to spend my money on: My child’s development. No, keeping the gold i3 wasn’t going to break us, but no matter what I did, I could never get around the realization that goldilocks was an unnecessary luxury that was more of a burden than it was a joy. I was overprotective of it, and I was always worried about it depreciating if I scratched it or drove it too much.

Img 0197

The delta in price between my i3s was $30,000. But if you factor in registration and insurance costs over the next 10 years, the Gold i3 was going to cost my family $45,000 more. (Investing some of the sales funds grows that 10-year delta even larger). To me, the benefits — extra range, a nice gold color, a longer warranty, nicer overall condition, a bit more reliability, a stiff suspension, and a preconditioning app — weren’t worth it, especially given that I plan to make some modifications to my Electronaut to make it feel less like a downgrade.

More on that soon.

Top graphic images: author

Follow us on:

Facebook
WhatsApp
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Subscribe
Notify of
191 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
"Redneck" Mark
"Redneck" Mark
1 month ago

The grail is “the cup of a carpenter.” – Indiana Jones.

Manwich Sandwich
Member
Manwich Sandwich
1 month ago
Reply to  "Redneck" Mark

Aaaand… IT BELONGS IN A MUSEUM!!!!

Canopysaurus
Member
Canopysaurus
1 month ago

Meanwhile, sometime in the future:

“Several years ago, for many reasons, I decided to move from the Midwest to California. It was so completely different from my previous homes I wondered if I could adjust to the ‘coastie’ lifestyle. Then I met Elise (NHRN).

“it was magic. She was everything I’d ever desired, beautiful, intelligent, and tolerant of my automotive whims. We married and she even agreed to let me chaperone her in my freshly scrubbed Wrangler YJ on our wedding day. Now that’s love!

Soon, we were welcoming two new additions to our happiness, our son, Delmar (NHRN), and a handbuilt WW ll MB Jeep.

“I truly love Elise and my little family, but recently I’ve been thinking …”

Last edited 1 month ago by Canopysaurus
RataTejas
RataTejas
1 month ago
Reply to  Canopysaurus

I’ve read these letters before, and I never thought they were real until this happened to me…

Palmetto Ranger
Palmetto Ranger
1 month ago

Does your tire hack work on the 2014 or are you just okay with the higher replacement costs because you are saving so much overall?

I Farted So Hard it Hurts
I Farted So Hard it Hurts
1 month ago

A LOT has changed since you bought the i3. And IMHO… I think you should have spent more time looking at alternative options. We’re about to return a Equinox EV that we have leased for two years and as we are, there are a LOT of very inexpensive gently used EVs available versus less than two years ago. And as much as they get ridiculed, we have settled on a used Ford Mustang Mach E…. because its actually a fun car to drive. And the user interface is actually pretty good too. And after having an EV? Gas anything- especially in California- makes no sense.

The i3 is interesting. It came right before EVs had really taken off and were still a novelty. Now that there’s a lot of 300+ mile range used EVs out there you can have your pick from GM, Ford, Nissan, Tesla ( yeah I know- boooo!) Rivian, hell- one of my friends bought a used Fiat 500e… for $4000!

I Farted So Hard it Hurts
I Farted So Hard it Hurts
1 month ago
Reply to  David Tracy

Did you actually drive anything else? Because we drove a few EVs and the Mach E is dare I say- fun? Yeah. Its fun to drive. We too drove a weird nerdy car. A Chevy Volt. It was sort of like the i3. A early compromise where the battery tech wasn’t totally ready for rock and roll in any reasonably affordable package. Anyway- just sayin…

I Farted So Hard it Hurts
I Farted So Hard it Hurts
1 month ago
Reply to  David Tracy

Well… guess that must be the car for you. All we did was generically look up: ” What is the most reliable used EV” and the Mach E came up. I knew nothing about them. But yeah the car is fun as hell. And its got 320 miles of range.

Living with an EV is pretty different. The Volt was always sort of like the I3: A compromise while everyone else came out with more affordable EVs.

Last edited 1 month ago by I Farted So Hard it Hurts
Andrew Stewart
Andrew Stewart
1 month ago

Mach E has no range extender

Manwich Sandwich
Member
Manwich Sandwich
1 month ago
Reply to  Andrew Stewart

“Mach E has no range extender”

Sure it does! You go to a charging station and then your range gets extended!!

:-p

I Farted So Hard it Hurts
I Farted So Hard it Hurts
1 month ago
Reply to  Andrew Stewart

Becuz…. it doesn’t need one seeing as how it goes 300+ miles on a battery. From what I recall the engine in these i3s are barely big enough to move the car. So its more an emergency backup in case you run outta’ juice.

Lotsofchops
Member
Lotsofchops
1 month ago

Have you seen the shit he is willing to drive? That WWII MB Jeep he drove hundreds of miles to Moab? Every other rustbucket POS Jeep he’s loved? The i3 is a literal spaceship compared to his usual fare!

Nlpnt
Member
Nlpnt
1 month ago
Reply to  Lotsofchops

I remember when he first raved about the i3 “Giga World” interior, I had to comment that it was such an upgrade from his usual upside-down milk crate on the rusty metal floor.

Since then he’s posted a pic and video of himself driving that Jeep from a kitty-litter tub on the new-but-red-oxide-primered metal floor.

I Farted So Hard it Hurts
I Farted So Hard it Hurts
1 month ago
Reply to  Lotsofchops

I drive some pain in the ass cars too. The worst is my 1948 Plymouth that “might” go 55MPH has a 3 on the tree and more or less is like driving a tractor. And I get weird cars too like the i3. I just don’t really like the way they look and with a lot of 300+ mile used EVs out there for cheap I don’t see a reason to buy one as its got a pretty limited range.

Professor Chorls
Professor Chorls
1 month ago

David, this is why I stick with unholy grails. Stuff that nobody else would want, even if I tried to get rid of it.

CarEsq
Member
CarEsq
1 month ago

I love my wife. But her ability to scratch/ding/dent her car has me the closest to homicide that I will ever get. Her current vehicle, which wears a luxury badge, will be hers until the wheels fall off because I’ve grown tired of the buy a car and fix her dents/dings/curb rash. That doesn’t even get to the dents/dings that randoms do in parking lots.

It makes perfect sense to have something that you’re like “another ding. Oh well, F*$k it.”

4moremazdas
Member
4moremazdas
1 month ago
Reply to  CarEsq

My wife is an excellent driver. We just made a big upgrade to a Highlander Hybrid, but to avoid the Toyota tax I bought one with a handful of small dents and dings, one large dent, and badly scarred wheels (along with some easily repaired lower fascia damage) and saved $10-15k vs similar age/mileage.

She was on board with saving all the money, but wanted to get all the damage fixed right away so people didn’t think she was a bad driver and did it herself.

6 months on we’ve decided the money in the bank is worth it and haven’t fixed anything but the fascia lol.

CarEsq
Member
CarEsq
1 month ago
Reply to  David Tracy

There is a price point and age of vehicle where I will likely hit dgaf-itude and will refer to said items as “patina” or “character.” But it’s definitely not while the vehicle is under warranty and/or we’re making payments on it.

Last edited 1 month ago by CarEsq
Cars? I've owned a few
Member
Cars? I've owned a few
1 month ago
Reply to  CarEsq

My car is 9+ years old and I’ve reached that point with it. The first dent occurred while I was dollying it to Washington from Texas where it was originally purchased new. I don’t understand how it occurred. When I came out from lunch at a pretty good BBQ joint along I-10 west of Houston on the first day of the trip, there was an almost impossibly sharp and deep dent on a crease line below the driver’s side window. A couple of body shops said fixing it would require a replacement door and painting to match. Since then, it has acquired numerous other scrapes and dings to the point that the left rear fender is the only one that has some minor deformity. The left rear door was run into with sufficient force to deform the sheet metal around the side impact beam.

Mechanically, it’s perfect. I just wish it still had bodywork to match but I’m not willing to spend the money it would take to fix it.

Manwich Sandwich
Member
Manwich Sandwich
1 month ago
Reply to  David Tracy

So it’s the pre/post-driving that the issue… LOL

Nlpnt
Member
Nlpnt
1 month ago
Reply to  David Tracy

She’s a SoCal native? So to her a paint chip’s probably just a paint chip, not an open door to the Rust Monster that’ll eat the car alive.

Ottomottopean
Member
Ottomottopean
1 month ago

Great, now go put that $30K in a broad, low cost index fund to grow before you buy something else.

I joke (well, sort of) but I am currently struggling with the opposite side of this equation. I found a car that I do truly love. It is paid for and all I spend is on maintenance and insurance. Insurance is surprisingly cheap but damn that maintenance… But I can swing it, I do not want to sell this car. I love it. My wife loves it, we have so much fun in my Boxster.

We are almost 100% in on moving to Europe next year. Likely for a long time (ten years or so). Assuming our long stay visas get approved anyway. I’ve considered long term storage, leaving it with a trusted friend or selling it to someone who I could buy it back from. All the doom and gloom scenarios run through my brain where I come back and the car is broken and worthless and I should have just sold it while it was worth something.

I could ship the car over. At ridiculous expense. But it would not serve all our needs and we plan to drop down to only one car. My wife can’t drive stick and the dog and cat wouldn’t fit anyway. There’s not a solution for this one I’m afraid.

So, I am sure to sell it now. Maybe I can find another when I get back, maybe not. We may not come back though (which is another consideration). I really don’t want to, this car has been everything I wanted. I have been planning to upgrade the infotainment system to Porsche’s new PCM but I guess I won’t bother now. That would have made it as close to perfect as I could get it. Damn.

The only consolation is that I will have access to a world of vehicles I have been denied my whole life. Peugeots, Seats, Skodas and so many more. I’m sure I can find something that makes me happy but right now I am just bummed.

Data
Member
Data
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

Put the money into a 529 college savings plan.

Ottomottopean
Member
Ottomottopean
1 month ago
Reply to  Data

Hard disagree. There are many options for college payment (I say make the kids work for part of it) and too many parents are sacrificing their retirement savings window to save everything for the kids.

Take care of yourself first and then you can help the kid with school. You will never be able to get the compounded interest back from saving early for retirement.

MaximillianMeen
Member
MaximillianMeen
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

I disagree with your disagreeing.

Shortly after my kid was born, the company I worked for went private and all employee stock and options were paid out in cash. My mom had already started a 529 with a modest amount of money and we took a chunk of the stock payout and put it into the 529 and never put in another deposit.

My daughter will graduate from a UK university with my wife and I not having to have spent a dime on her education (other than plane tickets to/from the US). My daughter works summers and uses her savings during breaks in the school year to take weekend trips around Europe. The education she is getting between the university and her travels wouldn’t be possible without the 529 covering all edu costs.

As for my retirement, I’ll be quite comfortable as I have been able to focus excess earnings since then into my 401k and IRA.

So in Delmar’s case, having the chunk of change now, while he is young, is the perfect time to start a 529. David can then focus on retirement investing for Elise and himself.

Ottomottopean
Member
Ottomottopean
1 month ago

I’m certainly happy you’ve had a successful run. Sounds amazing for your daughter. I stand by my advice though. Generally you have many options for paying for college.

That’s ok, people disagree about a lot of things and it certainly doesn’t affect me. But I am happy for you.

MaximillianMeen
Member
MaximillianMeen
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

As the saying goes, there is more than one path to the top of the mountain. I think we at least both agree that investing while young, whether for retirement or college, is a wise decision when the opportunity is there.

I Farted So Hard it Hurts
I Farted So Hard it Hurts
1 month ago

I’m 50. And I know this will sound annoying but if someone had told me when I was 18 how I would feel at my age then I would have invested much more sooner. I started when I was in my late 20’s but even so, we had a scare at work and there were a lot of layoffs. I didn’t get cut but I took a look at my finances and realized I could possibly semi-retire. Because all of those investments and 401ks, mutual funds etc- all funds that were not super impressive for years- finally started compounding in a meaningful way. Had I started earlier or invested more? Probably could retire now. Nothing insane, just piddle crap like mutual funds and 401ks

JJ
Member
JJ
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

I think modestly funding a 529 when the kids are born is the smart option. I realize that’s giving up some compound interest goodness on retirement, but I’d still rather take a smaller hit earlier and let it grow on its own.

Tbird
Member
Tbird
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

Complete agree TBH. I put a little into a 529, but focused on my 401k and company stock options. The 529 has been stable with a slight tax benefit, the company stock option has flown and I’m considering liquidating a few tranches of shares. My daughter ultimately chose not to go to college straight out of school, and is happily working a good paying full time job.

Nlpnt
Member
Nlpnt
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

The saying when I was applying around for college loans and grants was “No thrift goes unpunished”.

Cars? I've owned a few
Member
Cars? I've owned a few
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

I’m kind of with Mr. M Meen. We bought five years of tuition for my son through a 529 program over several years starting when he was five. It was indexed to the rapidly rising costs of tuition over the years and thanks to scholarships and summer jobs, there was enough left over to cover his law school tuition. We made occasional gifts to allow him a social life. He graduated from law school debt-free as did his now wife who he met at a 1L mixer.

I’m not a financial planner and I don’t want to waste time trying to figure out if we all would have done better in stocks or whatever. Besides buying homes in the Puget Sound area, we think it is right up there as far as best investments we ever made.

Five years out of law school, he and his wife are each making more than I ever did. And now they have a cute baby girl.

James Andrew
James Andrew
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

Not sure if this helps, but maybe a switch in mindset to thinking more like selling this car is a sacrifice for the great good and happiness you will have living outside the country and starting anew. Plus, you are 100% right, there are so many cool cars abroad. You’re clearly a car person, so I would bet that something will strike your fancy while you are there pretty quickly! Good luck to you, I wish I could be doing the same.

Ottomottopean
Member
Ottomottopean
1 month ago
Reply to  James Andrew

I think the mindset switch will come after I’ve sold the Boxster. I’m not so much looking at it as a sacrifice as just sad I can’t keep the one car I’ve owned that I truly love and enjoy. I am already in the mindset that this is absolutely going to be a fun adventure for our family and the right move for us as we are also retiring for this move.

But you’re right, there will be others that are fun and enjoyable. I don’t know if I’ll get one that is truly one I’ll always want to keep forever but there are definitely going to be benefits.

I’ve already started shopping and the choices are dizzying!

James Andrew
James Andrew
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

I bet!! I understand though. I have a car that I just could not imagine selling under any circumstances. I wish you all the best though, sounds like a grand adventure!!

Tbird
Member
Tbird
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

Selling my ’94 SHO after my daughter was born pained me. Modern (then) rear facing car seats just did not fit right and I was neglecting it TBH. Cars have a place and time in our lives, but sometimes need set free.

Ottomottopean
Member
Ottomottopean
1 month ago
Reply to  Tbird

That is tough. I drove one of those for a couple of weeks after my dad (who was supposed to be reviewing it for the newspaper) hurt his shoulder and couldn’t shift it. It was a super nice Ford!

Of course you are right but that doesn’t make it easier. I’m sure I’ll feel better about it after the fact.

Tbird
Member
Tbird
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

I bought a used ’00 300M to replace it, so I kept the speed and sport focus. And gained 4″ or so in wheelbase.

Last edited 1 month ago by Tbird
I Farted So Hard it Hurts
I Farted So Hard it Hurts
1 month ago
Reply to  James Andrew

I have a large quantity of friends in the UK, Spain, Portugal, Germany and France. And they are having their own fare share of problems including a really bad economy. Their inflation is through the roof. They are way more dependent on Russian petroleum. And in the case of Germany, they’re now having to compete with China and we all know you can’t really compete against that. So I’m not sure its just an automatic “good” thing. In the meantime its looking like the GOP will get its ass handed to themselves in a few days and will lose both houses. The beginning of the end of the Bullshit is upon us. So its going to get better here. Not sure I would uproot my entire family only to find similarly bad situations overseas.

Tbird
Member
Tbird
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

Sell it. After 10 years abroad, will you be the same person with the same tastes? Will you still be able get in and out of said Porsche? Will the new family home have proper, safe storage?

Last edited 1 month ago by Tbird
Ottomottopean
Member
Ottomottopean
1 month ago
Reply to  Tbird

I am definitely selling it. There’s really no option.

I do wonder how much my knees would want me back in a manual transmission ten years from now. But I think I’ll still want to try. I never thought I’d be a convertible/roadster guy but it changed me. I believe my tastes in these areas will be consistent and ten years without one will have me quite hungry for one. But as I mentioned, there is also the possibility I won’t be back.

Storage is certainly an issue (long term storage doesn’t really even work for a ten year stretch) but I’m selling it regardless.

I’ll only be 63 in ten years so I should be ok for that, LOL. I hope… But yes, I don’t want to but I’m going to sell it as my only viable option.

Tbird
Member
Tbird
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

We are about the same age then. A big part of me envies your nerve to move. I’ve spent a month or so combined in the southern EU on 2 trips and think I could adapt and be happy there.

Last edited 1 month ago by Tbird
Ottomottopean
Member
Ottomottopean
1 month ago
Reply to  Tbird

It’s made easier by the fact we have some close friends who are going to follow us in another year or two. And we don’t have a lot of family we’re leaving behind.

I’m still not 100% sure we’ll get the visas approved and it’s a process that is a lot more difficult than I thought it would be. They don’t just let you in, who would have thought?

It is somewhat nerve-racking (wracking? not sure). But also exciting. We’ve started learning the language and pouring over so much paperwork and legal docs to build our application.

And don’t get me started on how hard (and so expensive!) it is going to be to get our dog and cat over there with us.

But we are sort of exhausted with the rat race in our current life and really want to slow the pace. None of us knows how many years we get and I really don’t want to spend mine staring at more spreadsheets.

Tbird
Member
Tbird
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

The pace of life just seems slower. Everything we ate was fantastic and REAL. Several trips to just a normal grocery store were eye opening – more akin to a Whole Foods than a Kroger. I’m up for a mid-day break and dinner served ar 9pm.

No Kids, Lots of Cars, Waning Bikes
Member
No Kids, Lots of Cars, Waning Bikes
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

I’m mid-forties and starting to think about something like this. Very happy for you (and wouldn’t mind following along if you’re sharing the experience somewhere).

Ottomottopean
Member
Ottomottopean
1 month ago

I’ll be quite happy I expect once we get through it all successfully. Like I mentioned there is a non-zero chance we don’t get approved for the move but of course we are documenting everything and will likely spend a not insignificant sum on using relocation services to help along with advice from a CPA that is well versed in EU tax policy so we don’t make a costly mistake.

This site is pretty much my only form of social media. I’d be happy to update anyone interested but posting on the internet for me is pretty much limited to these hallowed halls.

CarEsq
Member
CarEsq
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

Got any EU blood? I was able to get citizenship by descent for myself and my child from my grandfather who emigrated when he was really young. Varies from country to country and while it was not cheap, it wasn’t “golden passport” expensive, either.

Ottomottopean
Member
Ottomottopean
1 month ago
Reply to  CarEsq

Our friends who are following us over have done that. But her mom was from Germany and her dad was from Ireland so it made it much easier.

I do have a great-grandmother who immigrated from France and a great-grandfather who immigrated from Italy. But the records for these are likely not easy to get as all of my grandparents have since passed.

It would make it easier certainly and I am jealous of our friends’ relative ease compared to mine but we’ll get there.

I’m honestly more concerned about having to renew so often and we might be forced to come home at some point if a visa renewal gets delayed or rejected. But that’s a problem for future-me. I can only worry about present-me and future-me is always pissed at how little I planned for him.

I Farted So Hard it Hurts
I Farted So Hard it Hurts
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

Good luck. The EU’s economy is pretty much in freefall. You could very well be leaving one shitshow and entering another. I have a pretty decent number of friends in various EU countries and Spain for example? The job market is HORRRIBLE. Same goes for Germany, the UK and Italy.

Ottomottopean
Member
Ottomottopean
1 month ago

It’s more of a cultural thing. I’m not leaving to run from a bad situation here but to retire in a more calm environment and immerse myself in a new culture.

The job market isn’t going to affect me and maybe bringing a small amount of my savings will help just a tiny bit.

Sometimes it’s not all about the politics.

I Farted So Hard it Hurts
I Farted So Hard it Hurts
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

I would be rather curious about the “calm” aspects you think are guaranteed where you go. I say this because I have lived all over the US and there is a massive difference from the east to west coast. I grew up in the south, lived in the northeast for a few years then moved to California. And California might as well be its own country. totally different vibe, weather, culture ( Its VERY diverse) , food, and attitude. Its pretty laid back and people generally have a “Whatever” attitude. Had I not moved here I would probably still think most people acted like those in Boston or New Jersey.

Anyway- good luck. I hope you find your own little piece of paradise just like I have here.

Jay Mcleod
Jay Mcleod
1 month ago

All this running off to Europe to find calm reminds me of the very old tale about the man looking for a better place to live who pulls into the gas station to fill up, and asks the attendant if he should move there and what the people are like.

(see, it’s old)

The attendant sizes up the man and asks, “What were the people like where you came from?”

“Horrible. Just selfish, shallow and greedy.”

“Well”, says the attendant, “Then they are pretty much just like that here too.”

Pete M Wilson
Pete M Wilson
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

As someone who knows, the PDK is a wonderful option. Besides in ten years it will be an EV Boxster anyway.

Last edited 1 month ago by Pete M Wilson
Ottomottopean
Member
Ottomottopean
1 month ago
Reply to  Pete M Wilson

Hopefully there will continue to be many many Porsche owners who baby their cars and keep the miles low so I can buy used and in near-new condition!

Manwich Sandwich
Member
Manwich Sandwich
1 month ago
Reply to  Tbird

“After 10 years a broad”

Yeah.. spending 10 years with a broad can definitely change someone…

:-p

Ottomottopean
Member
Ottomottopean
1 month ago

Ha! That’s a hell of a slip.

Ottomottopean
Member
Ottomottopean
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

I just thought I’d make one addition to my comment above:

If any of the EU readers out there have advice on what I should look at, I’m all ears.

I probably want a wagon, maybe hatchback since we plan to move around a little across EU countries and cities every 2-4 years. But a good sedan with good trunk space would work too. I don’t need all the HP in the world but 200-250 in a hybrid or plug-in would be good.

For reference I have started looking at the Peugeot 308 GT trim as well as the SW variant. On paper it looks great. Anyone with experience with it? Other suggestions? I’m open to new or used.

CarEsq
Member
CarEsq
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

If you’ve driven a VW passat, you’ve driven a Skoda. I watched them roll off the same line in Bratislava, one after another. Pull one hood from this pile, pull another from that pile. Was a really neat tour.

Ottomottopean
Member
Ottomottopean
1 month ago
Reply to  CarEsq

That is one thing I find disappointing in how global all the cars have gotten, it could make the individual character of them all too similar.

It’s why I might look used, or I might just stick with the brands that are fully unavailable to me now, like the Peugeot group for one.

*Jason*
*Jason*
1 month ago

Sounds like it is time to know oneself and stop buying “Holy Grail” cars

You don't drive a Miata, you wear it!
Member
You don't drive a Miata, you wear it!
1 month ago

Smart move. When you have a beloved car that’s too nice to drive, and you can find a much lower cost example, it makes sense to sell/buy. That said, watching your baby drive off (or get trailer’d off) still hurts… sort of like watching a child move away.

Did something similar with a 2004 Mazdaspeed Miata I had. Bought it new, pampered it, did many tasteful track, performance and appearance mods (including swapping out the rear end gears) making it a near prefect example of the breed. Tracked it many times, but it got to the point where I put so much into it I was sort of afraid to drive it to it’s limits. It was pristine after 3 years of driving, and thought it would be a damn shame to put this car into the tires or concrete.. it was just soooooo good. Way better than new!

Finally life happened and the car wound up sitting idle for nearly a year as I delt with stuff. Too nice a car to just sit around so I wound up selling it (too cheap, it sold in minutes when I posted it), but I only sold it since I knew I could get a car almost as nice, and almost as much fun easy enough when things got back to normal.

… so like you, after selling my near-perfect example of a Miata, I found a ‘track dog’ Miata. A used but nice low cost beater with 150,000 miles on it + a Jackson Racing super charger already installed for 1/4 the cost of what I had sold my Mazdaspeed for. Drove the wheels of that car with many track days, road trips, and hooning. Finally wore it out after 250,000 really hard miles. Great car, but honestly, I wish I still had the Mazdaspeed in the stable too. First-world problems 🙂

Elhigh
Elhigh
1 month ago

Oh, I am SO on board for upgrades. If I wasn’t already a member I’d sign up just for that.

Mrbrown89
Member
Mrbrown89
1 month ago

You can wrap it on Gold and make it look the “same” as the +30K if you really miss the color.

Mr E
Member
Mr E
1 month ago
Reply to  Mrbrown89

I bet Galpin Motors has a body shop. 😉

Space
Space
1 month ago

$4250 for a working EV with 90k miles, you scored a smoking hot deal there!
Congratulations.

JJ
Member
JJ
1 month ago
Reply to  David Tracy

hm…did you just replace your damage anxiety with warranty anxiety?

Jay Mcleod
Jay Mcleod
1 month ago
Reply to  JJ

Ha

Rockchops
Member
Rockchops
1 month ago

May be a silly question, but why are the values of these so far apart? I get that the gold one is LCI, but is it just the color? 30k seems totally bonkers to me but I’m certainly not an i3 collector.

Ottomottopean
Member
Ottomottopean
1 month ago
Reply to  Rockchops

The later models nearly doubled the electric range. The earlier ones had batteries that could degrade fairly quickly I think so this one could have dropped to ~50 miles or so but at least the range extender should keep it from being stranded.

But I agree there must be other details about the condition of this car that perhaps David is keeping to himself for future updates. The cost seems quite low.

JJ
Member
JJ
1 month ago
Reply to  Rockchops

There were a lot of other upgrades: bigger display/updated iDrive, wireless carplay, radar cruise control, that sort of stuff. Whether any of that justifies the price, I dunno. Plus the i3s has a price premium (and was only available in the final years).

Icouldntfindaclevername
Member
Icouldntfindaclevername
1 month ago

“More on that soon.”

Make it a Safari version!!

D-dub
Member
D-dub
1 month ago

A super efficient commuter car you love to drive for $4K? That my friend is a win.

Rollin Hand
Member
Rollin Hand
1 month ago

I am, in a small way, living through a similar dilemma. I am on the hunt for a newer car, and because I am retiring soon, I want something more fun. I wanted a GTI, but there is not enough room behind me for my daughter, who I’ll driving to and from school a lot of days. I then said GLI….and same problem, but to lesser degree. Civic SI? Nope. And 2.0T Accords are insanely overpriced around here.

I am now down to a couple of Hyundais: the Elantra N-Line, and the Sonata N-Line. I like the Elantra a lot. It is tight for room for me, but lots in back for my daughter. I also like the Sonata, which has acres of space for me, but if I put the seat all the way back, it’s tighter for my daughter than the Elantra.

I’ll be checking out both for fit with my wife this weekend (I’ll also take winter gear with me to see how I fit in both cars with a parka and boots). I really dig that Elantra (my daughter likes it too), but if it’s better for the family, I’ll go with the Sonata.

I have a funny feeling that it’s better for the family.

JayJay
JayJay
1 month ago

Makes sense, you can buy a lot of rust for 30K

Sid Bridge
Sid Bridge
1 month ago

When I got married I had my 1968 Olds and a teal 1991 Corvette. My wife had to drive the Vette a few times while she was pregnant and getting in and out was a real chore. Owning a Corvette had been a dream of mine since I was a kid and I fulfilled it when I had the money right before I got married. Selling it was the right thing to do and I don’t miss that car either. It was fun to drive, but I was also constantly worrying about damaging it and it cost a lot more to maintain than a more conventional car. Of course, most of the cars that followed weren’t that much more practical, but a lot of them had back seats.

No Kids, Lots of Cars, Waning Bikes
Member
No Kids, Lots of Cars, Waning Bikes
1 month ago
Reply to  Sid Bridge

I have a Teal ’91 Corvette in my shop right now! Have to put the door card back on after plunger replacement, but it will be ready for fall leaf-peeping drives this weekend!

Then I can pull the R107 into the shop to address the fuel pump. Curses.

Sid Bridge
Sid Bridge
1 month ago

Hmm… does it have a 6-speed and cloth seats? Not that I want the car back. I will say that I LOVED the L98 engine. It was particularly fun with the 6-speed. I’ll take it over an LT-1 any day.

No Kids, Lots of Cars, Waning Bikes
Member
No Kids, Lots of Cars, Waning Bikes
1 month ago
Reply to  Sid Bridge

Sadly it is automatic with leather in poor shape. My primary criteria was color in the C4 search, but the lack of optispark was a nice bonus.

Frby98
Frby98
1 month ago

Hats off to you for making a win-win decision, especially prioritizing your family & your responsibilities as a father & husband. We need more of this in our consumer-driven world, where car payments are closer to house payments!

JerryLH3
Member
JerryLH3
1 month ago

This seems like a solid financial move. While going back through the history of selling the upgrade in favor of the original, I couldn’t help but think of the HBO show Barry. It follows a hitman who is trying to self-reform and can’t seem to stop being a hitman. Every time he performs a hit, he repeats “starting now” to get back on course and stop killing people. I picture David saying “starting now” after buying/selling cars over and over.

Autojunkie
Autojunkie
1 month ago

I traded my Alfa Giulia for a Grand Cherokee 4Xe for a similar reason. The car was perfect, but I constantly worried about it. I figured I would car far less about a GC and that definitely remains true since December of last year.
I still take care of it and trust that it works for a good family road trip car, which it has done so absolutely flawlessly. However, I don’t constantly worry about curbing a set of ridiculously expensive wheels, worry about parts and service that can be difficult to get (even in Detroit), and run it happily down Michigan’s dirt roads. The bonus was being able to take it on some light-duty trails on trip west to the PNW over the summer.
It’s a luxury to have a car you don’t have to care about or worry about more so than it is to have an actual luxury car.

V10omous
Member
V10omous
1 month ago

Only you can decide your tolerance for life’s mishaps, and I do understand the financial upside of “downgrading”. Ultimately, I am glad you are happy, and your family is happy.

I have to say though, this reads like a Corvette guy trying to preserve value on his C5 by keeping it pristine in the garage. A stereotype we (correctly) mock as being silly. It would have been refreshing to read an article entitled “I’m Never Selling my Holy Grail i3, So Why Would I Care About A Couple Door Dings Or Scratched Rims?”

Clark B
Member
Clark B
1 month ago
Reply to  V10omous

Yeah, like don’t get me wrong, I love my Sportwagen. I plan on keeping it for the long term, and I try to take really good care of it. I’ve put a decent amount of money into upgrades as well. But hey, scratches and dings happen no matter what. I’d rather accept that and get to drive and enjoy my car. Scratches, dings, dents and scuffs can always be repaired. Wheels can be refinished or replaced. Messes can be cleaned up. I try not to let those things happen in the first place, but it’s a car and shit happens.

V10omous
Member
V10omous
1 month ago
Reply to  Clark B

Exactly. My kids ride in my nice cars, my wife drives them, and I’ve already scuffed the wheel on the Cadillac. I’m not careless on purpose, but who precisely am I saving these cars for?

Kudos to DT for at least recognizing that the situation was causing him stress and that stepping down made sense. Better to do what he did than to lock the car away in a a garage. But I still think it’s a bit sad.

Ottomottopean
Member
Ottomottopean
1 month ago
Reply to  V10omous

This sounds like a great example of the difference between mid-western and west-coast philosophies. You guys already have an expiration date on your cars from rust so why bother keeping up with cosmetic repairs?

I kid, but it’s sort of true. I’m in the southeast and a lot of us like to keep the car looking nice although I don’t have kids so maybe that part of life just wears you down to the point you have to focus on other things.

V10omous
Member
V10omous
1 month ago
Reply to  Ottomottopean

That’s certainly true of daily drivers, and I guess I’m a bit hypocritical because I put my nice cars away for winter and never let them see salt. But that’s so that I can enjoy them longer, not for any sense of resale value.

The kids thing is certainly true. I want my kids to enjoy this passion with me; how does it make sense to shut them away from enjoying it when they’re young? Riding in the Viper makes their day, if they get foot prints on the dashboard, how big a deal is that really?

4moremazdas
Member
4moremazdas
1 month ago
Reply to  V10omous

I think this shows that point just as well, though. If you had to stretch the budget to get the “grail” version, then are constantly worried about resale value since you might one day need that 20k-30k back, it gets in the way of enjoying the car. If you swap it for something that was 1/8 the cost but essentially the same car, it’s a much better enthusiast choice.

The extreme example would be something like someone stretching the budget to buy an original Cobra vs selling it and getting a replica to drive more without the worry.

David didn’t buy the i3 as an investment that he never drove, but he did stretch the budget and the resale value weighed on his mind as it did face wear and tear.

V10omous
Member
V10omous
1 month ago
Reply to  4moremazdas

I think if you’ve bought a car for its resale value, you’ve lost the plot already.

Stretching the budget, I understand. If the financial stress was too much, that makes sense as a reason to sell.

But religiously worrying about the minutiae of resale values, tracking comparable sales, stressing over the smallest scratches – some of the saddest people I know do this.

V10omous
Member
V10omous
1 month ago
Reply to  V10omous

Maybe I should pitch the site on my own version of this article.

No Kids, Lots of Cars, Waning Bikes
Member
No Kids, Lots of Cars, Waning Bikes
1 month ago
Reply to  V10omous

Hey bud, this is a true 1 of 1. The only one painted yellow before lunch on a July Wednesday. Nevermind the custom (automatic) shift knob.

RidesBicyclesButLovesCars
Member
RidesBicyclesButLovesCars
1 month ago

I understand the strange feeling of not regretting a cherished vehicle go. Out of the 16 vehicles I’ve owned and sold (or left at the junkyard), I only regret letting one go. A manual transmission Mazda 5 minivan. All the other cars were loved (or tolerated) but I was ready to move onto the next set of wheels.

Jim Zavist
Member
Jim Zavist
1 month ago

Smart financial move. Cars are meant to be driven and driving means the inevitable nicks and dings. An icon, a museum piece only makes sense if you own (or are starting) a museum. Use, enjoy, rinse, repeat!

MazdaLove
MazdaLove
1 month ago

Today I gave up cocaine. I started meth instead. The king is dead; long live the king.

Manwich Sandwich
Member
Manwich Sandwich
1 month ago
Reply to  MazdaLove

Have you considered Bath Salts?

1 2 3
191
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x