Would you like to learn about how shitposting works at The Autopian? Become a member and support independent media, lose the ads, and maybe even get a discounted account.
Would you like to learn about how shitposting works at The Autopian? Become a member and support independent media, lose the ads, and maybe even get a discounted account.
Follow us on:
Shitposts are great. They’re fun. They’re not serious. Ninety-nine percent of us get the joke, are indeed here to be entertained and enlightened, and get big grins out of a good shitpost. It’s great to just have a laugh sometimes. Reading about charcuterie-based data storage made me chuckle at the mere sight of soppressata days later. I’m not sure if yesterday’s “modded Dodge Nitro can go in 11 different design directions at the speed of a… stock Dodge Nitro” article was a shitpost, but it was lighthearted and I enjoyed it.
It’s the hot takes that wear me down. A lot.
I get it. You need to “drive engagement.” But inciting conflict down here in the peanut gallery is a terrible way to do it. This is an overextended analogy, but it’s almost like the difference between interacting with people on the street versus taping episodes of “Bumfights.”
There’s a huge difference between saying something like “Hey, I have a new perspective on electronic e-brakes and I’d like to share it” and “Electronic e-brakes are better. Here’s why.” Better for whom? Under what circumstances? Particulars aside, consider what you’re doing in instances like that: taking a firm editorial stance on a divisive topic. That’s entirely different from throwing out a new take on a controversial subject and doing what journalists do: showing, not telling. The Hot Take approach does more to tell your readers what to think than it does to help you find out what they think. As writers for this site, which of those two outcomes seems more valuable to you?
Hot takes elicit agreement. They drive groupthink. That’s fine for the hubristically unbothered, but absolutely no one who writes for the Autopian strikes me as that ego-driven.
Every time I read another article that stridently asserts “This is the only way to do things” or “Let’s all hate this company/public figure/product, (except carburetors… screw them)” I get a queasy feeling. Because beyond the devastation wrought by the VC goons and callous herbs, one of the things that sent people away from the old lighting site in droves was the proliferation of Hot Takes and the way that made the comment section a way less fun, way less inclusive and welcoming place to be. I dread that happening here.
I like the way you elaborated on the hot takes., personally I will even skip articles I’m interested in because I already know the comments will get too negative/political.
There’s enough negativity in the world. I don’t begrudge the Autopian writers their opinions, but I don’t come here to be told what not to like. The rest of the media landscape is full up of that.
Story time: Back before Hulkamania gave Gawker that crippling suplex, there was no greater wielder of the Hot Take than Drew Magary. I would gleefully read his takedowns on Deadspin despite my near-total sports illiteracy. For me, one of my favorite holiday traditions was reading his annual roast of the Williams-Sonoma Christmas catalog. And that’s the subject of this story.
One holiday season when I was writing for a local food mag, my editor invited me to dinner with her family. She lived hardly a block away, we saw each other all the time, and we remain friends.
It was a great meal but conversation was a bit halting, so I fished around for a lively topic.
“Hey, have you heard of the lampoon this one guy does of the Williams-Sonoma Christmas catalog?” I said.
There’s a brief silence and my host just said “No.”
“Well, he just goes off on all the ridiculous stuff they have in there.”
Again, she paused. The rest of the table was silent. Then she said “That was my favorite job I ever had.” Then I remembered her mentioning she had worked for W-S. Oh god.
Struggling for validation, I tried “They had a thing that just melts raclette! That’s all it does! It just melts one kind of cheese in a specific way.”
“That was my favorite wedding gift,” she replied.
The rest of the dinner was pretty quiet.
So that’s why I give hot takes a wide berth.
Oh man, I love those Williams-Sonoma articles too. I mostly read Defector because of how addicted I got to Deadspin.
They were fun, and not without merit. Who really needs a special bowl just for de-salting capers? But I should have read the room better. Turns out my editor played a big part in choosing those products. Oops.
I wish I could have said my opinions as well as you have.
Thanks Kuruza, that kind of thoughtful commentary from this community is why I’m a member. Seems like we have “shitposts” and in-depth articles and either one can be a “hot take.”
Some things are also just going to cause some divisive discussion. On the one hand this site is somewhat self-selecting because it’s already not the place where you search for the best fart can or how to make your F-350 roll coal. I think the Morning Dump takes the most risks because at some point things like fuel prices and access to computer chips and trade wars are news, and effect car owners, and those things are the direct result of political decisions. At least I feel like we get a balanced journalistic “why” when those are reported then the commentariat does what it does. When I see more than 150 posts and the article only came out a few hours ago, often I just skip it, even though I often get as much or more out of the comments than the article itself.
Myself, sometimes I just have time for a SBS and a Cold Start sometimes I’m down for the full history or engineering lesson (still need to go back and finish that IPM motor story – will I?). One thing I do appreciate on the deep dives is if you have a legit question to follow up in the comments is the author interaction. Mercedes does that frequently, the number of replies that Adrian gave to the BMW 3 design comments yesterday being another case in point. Was his view a “hot take”? He had his opinion and presented as a defensible fact, but solid arguments and most importantly didn’t pooh-pooh anyone who preferred the e-version.
My remark to the staff would be that I like the balance of in depth and shitpost, maybe it’s getting a little too much – like you complained “these are the articles nobody read” but once you get into 10+ a day with comments, that’s a bit much to follow so we have to pick our battles. There’s not a lot of action on the weekends and holidays, maybe save some of those “evergreen” stories that aren’t time sensitive and give us more on the weekends and less mid-week.
My reading habits here are a lot like yours… weighing in on the SBS is probably the first thing I do, then a quick hit of humor or curiosity with the Cold Start, and on to the Morning Dump if I can give sufficient attention to industry news and analysis.
I feel similarly about articles with more than a hundred comments… if I have something to say, my first move is to scan those 3-4 pages to make sure I’m not doing a worse job of saying what’s already been said. I’d rather try to add something to a previous comment than say something similar all over again.
Adrian’s BMW design piece was an example of how I read the internet now: “Here’s a provocative headline that poses a question. What’s my initial take, does it align with the conclusions of the article, and if not, how do I feel about that?” In that case, I zigged while The Bishop zagged. I thought the EV looked better. The ICE car looked like it had a clumsily elongated snout and the tangle of cut lines, trim panels and window braces around its C pillar looked less coherent. But those diagrams with circles and sections thereof made a convincing case for the importance of maintaining proportions in car design. I wasn’t “right” but I learned something.
That’s why we don’t take “hot take” pitches from freelancers. I, too, find them to be low-quality content. I noticed them being used as filler at a previous employer, and I actually wrote into our style guide that we won’t take them.
My electric park brake story was not that at all. Maybe the headline could have been “why epbs have taken over” or something similar, but the actual story was quality.
I agree, which is why my story was thorough and really not a hot take. It had a bunch of diagrams, cited numerous primary sources, and fulfilled our Double-E rule by providing deep insight into the topic. What’s more, it specifically addressed the “For whom? Under what circumstance” question.
As an engineer, I rarely just write “Here’s my opinion, everyone else is wrong,” I write “here are my thoughts on a topic after much deep thought and research. Here’s the research. Here are opposing viewpoints and why I think xyz”
TLDR: Fear not, we are aligned on our stances re: hot takes.
I appreciate your feedback on shitpost versus deep dive balance, and I agree on weekend content.
Thank you, David. I should have reread the e-brake article before leaning on it as an example of a hot take. I think what I was reacting to most at the time was the sense I got – from both the article and the comments – that people were enthusiastically embracing the end of manual handbrakes. It was definitely an informative piece that I learned a lot from and it did a good job of showing where technology is going in that area.
I like the balance. It’s working, keep on keeping on!
I enjoy the variety because what mental investment I have to read varies by the day.
Yep. Sometimes I’m cool with reading 20 thousand words on the history of a camper manufacturer that made 30 RVs in the 1960s. Other times I want to laugh at a hideous modified Dodge Nitro. Both are very mood dependant.
Uhhh the topshot promised me seven information films?
They’re in product development stage…
Instead of all this random people you can give us more SWG,I hear he’s sadly between jobs at the moment. Let him write all the Jaguar articles he desires. I’ll go to sleep now,nevermind.
I second your motion and stand ready to sign it into law.
Thirded. Free SWG!
We’re taking as much as he is giving.
This makes me think of entirely different things..
I did notice a increase in sort of random “bloggy” stuff lately that to me made it seem like you let your otherwise healthy editorial standards go for the sake of being able to post more stuff,or shitposts as you call it. I for one am not a huge fan,and I advise you to focus on keeping the usually supreme standards of this establishment. Sorry for whining,but you asked.
Seems like you’ve balanced the silly shit with the thoughtful shit pretty well. Carry on.
I propose updating the double-E rule to the ET rule. It must be Entertaining and Taillight related.
I don’t consider a shorter post a shitpost, but I’m happy with a mix of lengths.
A quickly readable fun story is good. I don’t always have time to read a Mercedes length epic.
I second what most people are saying, I think it’s a good mix of longer or technical content with shorter blogs mixed in.
Shitposting, when done well, is considered a modern form of art. Much like the rest of the art world, there’s a very fine line between what is considered to be something that socially and culturally moves the needle positively… and the rest. Which are basically well, poop.
Keep it up y’all, I’m here for the high-art shitposts that always provide countless hours of enjoyment.
Absolutely keep it up.
I figured the command to shitpost was literal.
Considering the number of poop-related stories, I thought it may be ordered / required.
I’ll echo others in that I think there’s a good balance. I’m not a writer or anything, but I do understand how it’s a tight rope to walk. If everything is a deep dive, there might be 2-3 posts a day just due to the time they take. If everything is a shitpost, it detracts from the quality.
You don’t have to worry quite as much about members I feel, since we’re clearly dedicated. But when you’re trying to also attract new readers through MSN or whatever other aggregator you use, you have to tailor it towards that audience. Basically I’m saying I don’t envy you, but I think y’all are doing pretty damn good in this regard.
I read this whole post and I have to ask, what the shit
Here and I always thought shitposts were about bidets. Least that what happens in the memes channel on discord 🙂
Did someone mention bidets? We should talk about how great they are. But not in the memes channel. Nick doesn’t like that.
Name/topic do not correspond!
Memes channel has the best discussions.
Truly life-changing stuff
You could say, it’s the shit.
Bidets are the difference between animals and humans.
like, why does it take my Subaru 20 minutes for the heater to blow hot but my Alpha bidet can burn the hair off my butt before I’ve finished my second bite of toilet ravioli?
I think there is a good balance now. A proportionally higher number of simple posts to keep things fresh and give sufficient breathing room for the fewer in-depth articles.
I think you have a great balance as is. I really like the long educational articles and they’re the main reason it’s worth being a member, but most of my visits hare are for “Is there something funny or interesting I can distract myself with for 5 minutes”, and I save the long form ones for things like Lunch, commute, etc. I wouldn’t mind more shitposts, but I think it’ll be a bad look for any new visitors to your site if significantly less than half of your articles are relevant / serious.
The Salami data storage shirt is probably my most prized possession.
Keep it up!
I need to remember to wear my salami shirt to the skatepark after I drop my kids off at travel ball practice tomorrow. Skater dads of the world unite!
Autopian Creative Director:
“We have what appears to be a dynamite site. but I think we could use a little more shitpost.
“Really explore the white space this time.
“There’re not a whole lot of car sites that feature shitposts and we’d be doing ourselves a disservice and every member of the Autopian if we didn’t write the hell out of this!”
“Always leave them wanting more” is an old Vaudeville rule, and there’s something of that in a ‘shitpost’ (a-la-Autopian). if the E/E ratio is weighted too far to one side it gives the commentariat a chance to provide some of our shtick (‘shtickpost’) to round it out.
Staying with Vaudeville, it’s like the interstitial acts that filled in during costume and scenery changes, the Fozzys between the Gonzos, where material was trotted out to see if it played at all.
“We have standards. Super high standards.
…we require posts meet “the double-E rule.” Entertaining or Edifying (ideally both).”
Perhaps the triple-E rule would be good?
Because nowhere in there do I see edited.
Yet almost every day – outside of Mercedes’ writing (women always do a better job somehow) – I find factual or grammatical mistakes which would have been cured by a simple Google search and editing.
Which distracts from the message, subtracts from the authoritative voice, and takes the fun away.
Two Nights in Bangkok?
Really?!?
It’s not a big deal to the rest of us!
That was a joke! The very next line is “Wait that was just one night, and I’m being silly.”
It’s nice to see a hard man like you be humble
He’s using his Murray Head.
That character’s name is Freddie Trumper. No Sh*t!
Yeah this sent me down a Wikipedia hole.
I like to think of their grammatical and editorial errors as anti-Ai both in seeing them lets us know that humans are making these articles and poison-pilling the Ai readings
And there are certainly more important things to worry about in the world!
There is so much AI slop these days that I get a small ping of relief each time I see a spelling or grammatical error here, because I know it was made by the human writers I enjoy and not some AI bot like the ones that have replaced the writers of so many other sites I frequent.
Same! I also have begun to specifically enjoy “QWERTY” style typos because then I know it was actually typed!
That’s good to remember, I hate those comma splice headlines a tiny bit less now.
Yeah, as someone who is pretty pedantic and has enjoyed calling out errors many times, I’m starting to change my tune for the reasons you stated. What a time to be alive.
Even if that were a real mistake, I wouldn’t have caught the reference!
And for the record, I gave the whole team grammar books (my go-to: Strunk & White), and while I always want us to improve, I think we’re decent there and in the area of fact checking, though in the area of typos…
Let’s just say: Lots of us have the universal blood type!
Oh man, I’ve got feelings about Strunk & White. A lot of grammatical “rules” are contrivances entirely of their provenance – and before we get all philosophical and argue “yeah well everything is made up at some point,” old S&W were fanning the grammar hammer fast and loose and actually broke several conventions for things that they believed on a personal level “sounded good.”
(This is not me coming at DT or saying there should be no rules at all or any such thing, just that in an arbitrary world full of arbitrary rules, some are much more arbitrary than others, and it grated when some are elevated as authoritative.)
The engineer is giving writing advice??!! Admittedly UVA does a better job than most with respect to making sure their engineers have a well rounded education… but engineering school barely teaches writing more than a lab report! UVA engineering does require a senior thesis and the feedback generally is very good with respect to the actual writing.
One town’s very like another
When your head’s down over your pieces, brother
It’s a drag, it’s a bore, it’s really such a pity
To be looking at the board, not looking at the city
Whaddya mean? Ya seen one crowded, polluted, stinking town
So your definition of “shitpost” includes opinion pieces and news of the weird.
Plus most of Torch’s taillight takes. Which is what brought me here in the first place.
MORE SHITPOST. I’m usually avoiding work, and by golly, I see Mercedes and know that’s going to be an hour long read, following links, and sometimes I want the empty calories of a chuckle post of something silly.
This made me giggle thinking of the old Christopher Walken Saturday night live cowbell bit. IT NEEDS MORE SHITPOST!
Admittedly, I have said several times that I’m doing a “shitpost,” but then, 2,000 words later…
Was this story a shitpost?
… yes.