Being an automotive journalist/blogger doesn’t give you a remit to write about everything, which is why my Adventures of Brisco County, Jr. fan-fic keeps getting deleted by David. You are allowed to write about James Bond, though, and we have. A lot. There’s a new Bond coming, and I’m a little curious if he’ll be the right Bond for our time.
Being disappointed in James Bond choices is a famously common and almost historically dumb thing to do. People online were up in arms about a blonde actor playing the titular spy role, only to have to eat their words when Casino Royale delivered both a Bond and a Bond film that were immediately and unimpeachably fantastic.
The news that Robert Pattinson would be taking the lead role in the new Denis Villeneuve-helmed reboot of the series didn’t catch me off guard, necessarily, as the rumors have been flying for a few days. I’d have preferred Jack Lowden. I was also fine with Callum Turner, and Nicholas Hoult is the only actor on the list I’ve ever spent significant time with, so, for personal reasons, that would have been fun (he’s as charming and friendly as he seems, btw).
Here’s what Villeneuve had to say about the process:
“Before anything else, I want to express my deep gratitude to the remarkable actors who joined us on this journey. We were surrounded by extraordinary talent, but there can only be one 007. I am overjoyed to welcome Robert Pattinson as our new James Bond. He has the timeless soul of 007 and brings a spirit that is completely new. I cannot wait to begin.”
Being Bond is sort of like winning an Olympic gold medal in the Men’s 100 breaststroke, in that you only get one good chance in your career to do it. It’s possible that some of the younger actors get another shot (Jacob Elordi, maybe), but it’ll be tough for the older ones.
Pattinson is a safe choice, though, both because he’s more famous than any two other people on the list combined, and because he’s an incredible actor. While there are movies he has made that are not in my usual rotation (Twilight will probably come up when my kiddo is older), there’s no bad performance I can think of, and he’s excellent in action flicks. I loved him in Tenet and I’m looking forward to what he’ll bring to the role.
However, he’s definitely the darker choice here, and I don’t know if that’s the James Bond I want right now.
Bond Is A Reflection Of Both Our Best Desires And Our Worst Fears

I have taken a film class in college which, on top of the autojournalism thing, gives me a license to pontificate. This isn’t as potent as a license to kill, hopefully. It’s not groundbreaking to say that Bond movies can be viewed, critically, as a mirror that reveals how we want to see ourselves, and how we see the world around us.
The Bond of Ian Fleming’s novels is a bit like the person Fleming wished he was, a little tougher and more handsome, sure, and who got to take part in the action that he only planned from the safety of England. He was concerned with the post-WWII world order of two competing superpowers. Sean Connery, as chosen by producer Albert Broccoli, was a bit more playful and definitely sexier, which matched well with the 1960s. His fears, though, were still of a world with nuclear missiles and uneasy alliances.
I think both the portrayals by George Lazenby and Roger Moore were, in a way, a reaction to the Women’s liberation movement and larger social change (in the first Roger Moore film, he literally makes peace with the KGB long enough to sleep with one of its agents). Timothy Dalton was a great Bond in the Fleming-sense, which made him a little less fun as a movie Bond, and I think that’s why people don’t like him. He was the perfect Thatcherite Bond, strong and extremely British, reflecting a United Kingdom that felt less united or important, and a Cold War that had gotten tiresome (in The Living Daylights it’s possible to interpret Bond as letting Osama Bin Laden out of prison).
And what of Pierce Brosnan? A charming and funny Bond, whose films tried to reckon with winning the Cold War. What did it mean to be the only superpower? The challenge of those Bond films is that Brosnan had to make us care about a misogyny-laden archetype that felt very unwelcome in the ’90s. While there was a certain prescience in Tomorrow Never Dies (it turns out powerful media moguls with too much self-regard living in a bubble are bad), other than GoldenEye, the films feel light. Whatever you feel about the films, I think most people like Brosnan.
Craig was a strange choice and also a great one. The films exist perfectly in a post-911 world, where power is an illusion and the growing paranoia is not so much that people in charge might accidentally destroy the world, but that we have no idea who is actually in charge.
A point in his favor was that he looked deadlier than any weapon he carried, which isn’t enough to be a good Bond. As would become obvious later in films like Logan Lucky and the Knives Out films, Craig is also hilarious, and his humor is the only kind of humor that really works for a Bond. Craig is a master of bathos, of the little funny moment that comes after the serious one. It’s a c-c-c-ombo breaker that allows the audience to catch their breath. That beat in Skyfall, when he fixes his cuffs after the rest of the train falls off behind him, is maybe the best example of this:
The filmmakers set this up immediately in the opening vignette of Casino Royale, as Bond deadpans, “Yes, considerably.” It’s hard to be funny. It’s almost impossible to be funny while holding a smoking gun. It makes these films that much more enjoyable to watch, and credit goes to everyone involved for pulling it off across multiple films.
Can Robert Pattinson Be Funny? Do We Need A Funny Bond?
What is the existential dread of the future? Is it China? Is it AI? Is it a tech trillionaire with a media company and a space company? Do we want a Bond that is going to make us feel better about the world? Who is the bad guy in that world? I was a big fan of Jack Lowden as Bond because of his portrayal as a special agent in Slow Horses, which sees him more often as a punching bag than a superhero. Lowdon never has a sharp-witted line and doesn’t even seem capable of telling a joke as River Cartwright. All the good jokes land with Gary Oldman. Nevertheless, Lowdon’s Cartwright has a Buster Keaton-like ability to wring humor out of his own misfortune.
Has Pattinson been able to deliver that? Not exactly. Pattinson doesn’t get to be funny in most of his roles. There’s a lot of humor in Mickey 17, but it’s a little too cartoonish. If anything, the best joke that Pattinson ever delivers is in The Odyssey when he calls out the beggars:
That’s funny, both because the audience knows (or suspects) what’s about to happen, and because Pattinson puts a Wrigley Field’s worth of mustard on the word “beggars.” It’s a phenomenal delivery.
In general, I’m hopeful, given that I’ve enjoyed what Villeneuve has managed to accomplish with the Dune films. Those movies gave us incredible comic levity with the your-uncle-who-doesn’t-believe-in-vaccines fervor of Javier Bardem. Can he pull off the same trick in a Bond movie? Will Bond be the straight man to M’s smirk? Or Q’s? I don’t know, but I’m anxious to find out.
Top photo: MGM/Instagram






Thanks for the donut, Duncan.