Roughly put, there are two kinds of small cars. One is the basic penalty box, designed to get you where you need to go for the least amount of money, in some cases with an inbuilt sense of “If you’d just pay a little more, we could put you in a bigger car…” There aren’t that many creature comforts, the most common color is appliance white, and profit margins for the manufacturer are seemingly slim. That’s why in recent years, the choice in this class of car has increasingly shrunk in Europe, as Euro norms constantly make it harder to turn a profit in the bargain-basement segment.
The other kind is the Fancy Small Car. Small in footprint, big in equipment and style. In this case, the manufacturer has directed its offerings to buyers who don’t mind the small size, or actively want it, but are also willing to pay bigger-car money if that means the thing is cool. Some Fancy Small Cars have been created out of more basic models, body shell and running gear unchanged, but made more profitable with special trimmings. In time, these might even end up cherished and pampered, unlike their econobox brethren.
A Basket Of Goodness

In the Special Edition article, I briefly touched upon the Peugeot 106 and 205 Roland Garros. These metallic green hatchbacks are good examples of the “upgrade the basic model” fancy-small-car path, as they have half-leather seats with the bolsters in white.
The Roland Garros trim level was also available for the Pininfarina- designed 205 convertible, and it used the 85 horsepower 1.4 TU engine from the 205 XS with a wonderful throttle response and lust for life as well as head gaskets.

They are a world removed from the most bare-bones 106 and 205 models, as Peugeot made a couple of tactical choices with the most basic versions: for example, in the one-liter 205 Junior above, you didn’t even get all the fresh air vents that a driver of a better-equipped version did. There was just a big blank on top of the dashboard, even if it would probably take all of five seconds to replace that with a secondhand vent from another car.
It’s also a good sign when the carmaker replaces a gauge or a clock with a blank with the brand name on it.

The Roland Garros cars also often got a big glass sunroof that would bring the summer in, oftentimes also dampening the carpets or drying up the leather. Even the 205 GTI was available as the Gentry, which added full leather seats and a tan dashboard, a deviation from the GTI’s usual red-trimmed hotness; the engine was a 1.9 with the same 105 horsepower as the 1.6 GTI, and the suspension parts were GTI. Consider it a trade-off in power with an extra helping of style instead.
A comparable 106 to the Gentry was the Griffe (above), which again added leather and foglights but didn’t match the XSi or Rallye in power.

Bigger Peugeots, such as the 306 hatchback and cabrio and the 405 station wagon also got Roland Garros editions, and the 206 got a really nice-looking RG version: full glass roof in addition to the metallic green exterior paint, and seats trimmed in cognac and green leather.

The 206 Roland Garros looked really special, and if the 206 itself doesn’t set your heart on fire, the RG cars are worth saving. They don’t cost much for something so neat, as you can get one in Europe for a couple grand. The bigger 307 didn’t get a GTI version, but instead a 307 Feline with leather and a 177-hp two-liter engine shared with the 206 GTI RC.
These days, Roland Garros is aligned with Peugeot’s competitor, Renault, and you can get a new R5 E-tech EV with the usual RG trimmings, though with white paint. It feels weird, as traditionally Roland Garros cars have been Peugeots.
Yes Sir, I Can Boogie

Renault is also no stranger to fanciness with small hatchbacks. The original 5, also known as the Le Car, (the “The” Car, suitable for fans of The The), might have been noteworthy for its Turbo versions, with or without midship engine mounting, but the second generation introduced the Baccara. Take a hatchback, add all of the leather. Step back and admire.

Bigger ‘80s Renaults such as the R25 would get the Baccara trim level too, but you could get the R5 with similar metallic paint and full leather interior. In the UK, these cars were called the Renault 5 Monaco. It certainly adds a bit of Monte Carlo flair to a small Renault hatchback. They had the 1.7-liter engine from the 5 GTX, with 90hp.

The R5’s successor, the Clio, also got a Baccara trim level, again with metallic grey paint, full leather, wood décor, alloy wheels and a 1.8-liter engine, making it a suitable pairing to the bigger Renault Safrane Baccara. It was no Clio Williams, but it was special in its own way. The cross-spoke wheels were a nice addition.
Renault Twingos weren’t always cheap and cheerful either, as the Twingo Initiale/Initiale Paris came with tan leather and a big glass roof instead of the folding canvas sunroof. [Ed note: “Yes Sir, I Can Boogie” never charted in America, so if the reference to the Baccara’s 1977 hit is lost on you, here ya go – Pete]
The Citroën of Plenty

For a fancy small Citroen, you could look at the 2CV Charleston, which was also the trim level of the last 2CV built on July 27th, 1990. Talk about leaving in style.
The small Visa, AX and Saxo most often went for motorsport style rather than plushness (except for a bunch of special edition Visas with “Boxline” imitation leather seats, such as the Carte Noir), but the later Citroën C3 Pluriel nails the look: the ovoid bodywork was painted in the same curved two-tone as the original 2CV Charleston and featured leather seats.

The Pluriel in itself is a good example. It’s nearly concept-car-like in its uselessness; the folding roof has a lot of parts that are difficult to find now, and if you remove the roof pillars to be able to open the top completely, you can’t store them in the car but have to leave them home. Good luck if you get caught up in rain. But it’s all very fancy.
A Highly Individual iQ

Looking at Japanese options, one of the best-known alternatives is partially British, in name and appearance. It’s the 2011-2013 Aston Martin Cygnet, famously based on the short and wide Toyota/Scion iQ.
Cygnets were extensively retrimmed in leather and offered to Aston Martin clients who would like to drive a small, easy-to-park hatchback in town. No engine tuning was done to extract more power out of the Toyota engine.

Cygnets have remained valuable, which goes to show how little a car’s humble beginnings really mean when you affix a storied brand on it. Part of that comes from the Cygnet’s rarity, as only 150 were sold in the UK and some 600 in the rest of Europe, during the two years that they were built. Now, you would pay £40-50k for one in the UK, while an iQ can be had for a grand or a fully-loaded low-mile one for £8.5k.
Mini In Size, But Not In Price

It wouldn’t be right to mention British small cars and forget perhaps the quintessential Fancy Small Car, the original Mini, for one, and its Radford and Wood & Pickett conversions. Rockstars used to pay serious money to get customized, vinyl-topped Minis that had the ambience of Rolls-Royces, and while they didn’t come fully loaded from the factory that famously was struggling to turn a profit with the way Minis were originally priced, they definitely need to be included here.
As well as wide wheels, the converted cars often had headlights and front grilles swapped from other, bigger cars such as Vauxhalls or Mercedes-Benzes, to stand out. In that sense, they’re probably comparable to British Mod-era scooters that had a lot of extra mirrors and lights.

And speaking of profit or lack thereof, the last Mini Wood & Pickett ever made ruined the company. It took so long to build that the client ended up not paying for the car at first, and eventually only getting the finished car after Wood & Pickett had ceased trading.
The Mini in question had a specially tuned engine, custom wood and leather interior with Recaros, Ferrari 308 mirrors, and it was painted in a Rolls-Royce shade of blue. Sparingly driven, it was auctioned by RM Sotheby’s in 2024.

Later and final Rover Minis also have the same attitude, especially when fitted with wide fenders and wheels and shipped to Japan. Rover built the Mini until 2000, by which time it was one of the oldest new cars you could buy. The final edition Mini Coopers were fully leather trimmed. The Metro airbag wheel does stand out in the otherwise 1960s cabin.

As for factory-built Minis, it’s worth mentioning the Riley Elf and Wolseley Hornet, which were odd-looking Minis that grew a trunk. They don’t really count as shatchbacks, as the original Mini wasn’t a true hatchback, but they are them in spirit. The Wolseley Hornet had a front badge that lit up, which should appeal to modern fans.

BMW Group Classic describes the Hornet, using words that really get to the heart of the matter:
The Wolseley Hornet was designed by BMC stylist Dick Burzi, using the Mini platform. The car with its extended boot and upright radiator grille with its illuminated badge (a feature of Wolseley cars since 1932) plus extensive use of chrome gives an air of refinement. A unique range of colours with contrast roof were available. Central speedometer and auxiliary gauges were surrounded with wood veneer. Leather-cloth seating, thick carpets and chrome gear lever add to the luxury feel. With all the extra features the performance suffered as it used the 848 cc engine. This would be addressed on the Mark II version.
Get Smart – In The Maxwell Coffee Color Palette

Smart cars also dabble in the fancy sector. While the MCC City-Coupé was available cheaply when it was first launched, over time special versions were introduced, including the Crossblade which looks like a sandal and offers about as much weather protection.

The Mercedes-Benz tuner Brabus also collaborated with Smart, with Brabus-trimmed Smart hatchbacks and cabrios offered for those who wanted that particular style. On top of that, you could get the Tailor Made versions that are as cool, if not cooler than the Cygnet. In the UK, a fully loaded Tailor Made would cost double compared to a base spec car.
La Dolce Vita

Fiat, one of the big companies best known for making small cars, gave its original 500 a lot of extra style by cutting stuff off. The classic Fiat 500 Jolly had no roof and no doors, and its seats were replaced with wickerwork chairs.

In the 2000s, the new generation Fiat 500 became available in various expensive-looking editions, such as the convertible 500C Riva that harks back to classic wooden Riva motorboats.
The wood dashboard is a direct homage to the boats, which you might remember from the third Indiana Jones movie.

The 1980s Fiat Panda had no such option, but in the mid-’80s the Panda outsourced some style to a platform cousin, as the Autobianchi/Lancia Y10 was a differently trimmed boutique hatchback based on the same mechanicals and floorpan.
The Panda is itself very boxy, yet the Y10 manages to be even more so thanks to its vertical rear with the hatch painted satin black. Inside, you’d find special cloth or alcantara depending on the version, including on the dashboard. Unlike the Panda, the Y10 was available with a turbocharged version of the Brazilian 1050cc FIASA engine.

Like the Panda, you could get the first-gen Y10 with four-wheel drive, and Fiat did sell special editions of the Panda 4×4 such as the Sisley and Country Club with comparable amounts of style.
Later Y10s, also sold as Lancia Ypsilons (above), dropped the 4×4 option but kept the Alcantara and wide color palette. In fact, you could pick the color for your Ypsilon from 100 different colors, using Lancia’s Kaleidos color scheme.

And while Lancia has increasingly crumbled from those days, the Ypsilon has survived, sometimes as the only car Lancia has offered. Italians used to buy the final generations of Ypsilon in droves, when they weren’t even sold outside Italy.
Currently, Lancia again makes an Ypsilon, which is based on the Peugeot 208 but with more stylish interior and exterior. On one hand, it’s a disappointment as Lancia could do so much more, but at least they’re making something.

As it competes with the Renault R5 E-Tech, the Lancia Ypsilon is also available as an EV, and small EVs might be the ticket for well-appointed small cars of the future, as they can cost more than city cars have traditionally cost. Hyundai’s tiny Inster EV is quite cool to begin with, and Hyundai has now introduced a better-appointed Inster Lounge (above) that has part leather seats and comes in a special shade of green. Sounds like a Roland Garros to me!
Most of these examples have been European or Europe-specific, as small cars have traditionally suited roads and city streets here better than across the Atlantic. What do you think would represent the Small Fancy American Car – if it ever existed in a similar shape, form or purpose?
Top graphic image: Fiat









The obvious American small fancy car clearly is the Cadillac Cimmaron, which probably explains why this is a mostly unexplored segment here.
Funny I was just on marketplace looking at 500C’s and lo and behold the cover shot. Though I want mine in yellow or that delicious Campagnolo green.
American small car with luxury trim?
Chevy Spark EV. This was GM’s practice run before the Chevy Bolt. It took the absolute penalty box of the normal Spark, added way more power, far better driving dynamics (due to lower center of gravity and retuned suspension for the weight) plus it added a lot of sound deadening (which I assume the base car had zero to begin with), heated seats, nicer seat upholstery and a few other random electronic gadgets that I am forgetting. It was built on the same chassis as the base Spark so I think it qualifies here. It’s not like a new Blazer/Blazer EV which share nothing.
I had the pleasure (?) of driving a base Spark quite a bit and then was able to put some miles on the Spark EV and it was the most dramatic difference I have felt between two of the “same” car, outside of stepping from a normal car and into a stripped, caged race version of a car.
The Spark EV was a solid first shot at an EV but the range was only about 100 miles which doomed it from the start. I believe Gm only sold them in California. You can see a lot of what the first Bolt would be from this car.
I own one! They were also sold in a few East Coast states including Maryland, which was the origin for mine. When my grandmother’s Subaru died and she needed a car to go to the grocery store, I got her a Spark EV because it was easy for her to get in and out of, easy to park, and she wouldn’t have to pump gas. She loved the thing, and now it’s mine until it goes to a niece as a first car. They are absolutely a hoot and for the right use case, remain an excellent option.
Very nice! Glad you are enjoying it! I am surprised they sold them in colder States since the relatively low range would be very low in the winter (I worked for a supplier and drove one of these in MI winter and it was a series struggle with range). Otherwise I agree they are nice cars for in town.
Great article, really enjoyed the deep dive into French luxury hatchbacks.
I wanted so badly for Honda to sell the E in the US for this reason, shitty range or not.
One of my favourite genres of cars! What is great about them is all the mechanicals / replaceable parts etc are easily available from a cheaper model. but you get the extra lux bits which bring them up to date. 80’s-90’s seem to be the sweet spot of tech and serviceability.
My mate Mick took a base model AE95 Corolla and slowly turned it into a bit of a show stopper by adding a whole lot of JDM parts including velour interior, JDM front, cruise control(from a Camry), climate control, electric windows, locks and mirrors easily as the parts (except the climate control) basically plugged straight in.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OKIDgG5Y2yU
I had a 60’s mini in my collection in the late 70’s great little car. It was a slightly tight fit, but some creative mods made it livable. Also had a gen 1 fiesta which was slightly larger and just as much fun. My cvcc civic was a gas too as was my tr7 which was easily the largest of the lot. My fave was my gen 1 CRX HF.
Small cars are great to have and I’d much rather have one over a gigantic truck any day of the week.
I’ve always liked the “Small Luxury Car” genre.
Seems the closest we got to that in the US in recent years has been the 2021-2023 Mini Sidewalk Edition.
Closest thing I’ve had to that was my 1989 Mercury Tracer – with 68 standard features!
(You’d think they could have added just one more….)
Would have been nice.
The BYD Dolphin Mini we had as an Uber the other day had a pretty nice interior. It’s that minimalistic EV aesthetic that feels futuristic and not as cheap as it could.
um, thanks?
Oh come on! That song is an absolute banger.
What did I just see and hear??! That was so 1977….
No mention of the A and B-Class? 😛
At least MB sold the B-Class in Canada, though not down here. We only got the second gen W246 electric, the EV motor coming from Tesla, and the sunroof wasn’t available in the US, either. But Canada got gas and electric W246, as well as the (gas-only) W245. The first gen was even available with a manual transmission on both the turbo and non-turbo.
The B-Class had an awesome sunroof. The W245 had a 5-panel sunroof like the G6 from the sane era, while the W246 had a modern 2-panel sunroof where only the front opens.
I’d love to bring down a 5-speed non-turbo W245 from Canada with the big sunroof and heated seats.
The Cygnet is the best Aston-Martin ever made. There could also be a Toyota Tax on the used models, as a real Aston would depreciate like a rock LOL. They should’ve sold the Cygnet over here. They could’ve at least offered that shit in the Scion Accessories Catalog 😀
The last Fit that Honda sold here was available with leather, sunroof, and heated seats 🙂
Don’t some JDM kei cars now have nice interiors and lots of features?
Came here to talk about the fancy minis. You beat me to it.
Just sold my 500c, Fun to drive, easy to park, good on gas and the top came down. Tiny, but a safety cage filled with airbags and a back seat for the dog. Great little car and cute as hell.
I like un-fancy small cars with deluxe engines, forget the interiors. We need more very basic subcompact two-seaters weighing under 2,500 lbs(preferably under 1,500 lbs), with big ass V8s in them and rear-wheel drive again, dammit!
I just saw this weekend that the Picanto is available with ventillated seats (and adaptive cruise control – it’s very likely that I would pass on the Picanto for this one,that it has no ACC in Europe, while for example a Swift, or an Aygo X has it in its base trim) at the korean market:
https://www.kia.com/kr/vehicles/morning/features
The new Mini had the “Inspired by Goodwood” edition that apparently has some Rolls Royce influences. It has wool floor mats and leather upholstery and I guess that makes a 2012 economy car worth $50,000. I’m not convinced.
If I recall correctly the Goodwood Mini was introduced in the BMW Mk2 generation. Now the original Cooper S needed the bonnet scoop, but it was retained for subsequent generations as a design feature despite not being needed any more.
The Goodwood Mini had the Cooper S drivetrain with a bonnet without the scoop. Just for thay it is worth it.
VW’s Mk5 Golf redefined “premium”
It took, quite literally, a generation for everyone else to catch up.
The Mk4 did. There is even a rumour the interior of the Mk4 was so good, even better than the contemporary A3, that VW decontented the Mk5 interior to separate the Golf and A3 in the marketplace.
By the time the Mk4’s ~10-year run ended, most brands had surpassed it in that time.
My 1991 Geo Metro was more in the ‘Penalty Box’ category. Our 2024 Trax is the closest we’ve had to a ‘fancy’ small car.
https://d2ivfcfbdvj3sm.cloudfront.net/7fc965ab77efe6e0fa62e4ca1ea7673bb65942580a1e3d8e88cb10/stills_0640_png/MY2024/53391/53391_st0640_051.png
https://images-stag.jazelc.com/uploads/theautopian-m2en/IMG_3928.jpg
The current Chevrolet Trax is not an small car.
It’s considered a subcompact wagon by 2024’s EPA. It’s about as small a car as you can get from GM nowadays.
The 1.2L 3-cyl is pretty small.
It’s still as big as a Tiguan…
I’ve never seen one of those. But, other than the New Beetle and an occasional Atlas, nobody in my area drives Volkswagens.
The Tiguan has been downsized in the U.S. (previous gen was LWB here) but it still fair bit larger than a Trax–wider by an inch, longer by 6 inches, 25 cubic feet more cargo.
A better candidate is the much shorter Buick Encore GX Avenir.
And the question was, “What do you think would represent the Small Fancy American Car – if it ever existed in a similar shape, form or purpose?“
I just realised GM offers the Trailblazer and Encore GX which are smaller but more expensive.
Those could probably be good candidates.
It is within two inches in height, width and length as my 2014 Sportwagen, which is generally considered to be a compact wagon.
Compact is not the same as small in this context.
Exactly. In this context it should be B-segment or smaller.
But the other Metro, the Rover one, could be had with leather seats and walnut trim on the dash and door cards, in GS and GSi forms
But it was still a Metro, and just riding in one was enough to make you re-think your life choices.
No, no, it was different when it was called the Rover Metro
I suppose they when they changed the name to Rover, they did stop selling the majority of Metros in baby-shite-brown, so there was a minor upgrade, but they never got any prettier, and I doubt they got any more fun to drive.
I’m afraid I have an entirely rational hatred of the Metro and can’t be swayed on this point. I’d rather drive a Fiesta.
There was a rather nice limited edition of the first-gen Metro Vanden-Plas called the VP500 which had black paint (not a regular option back then), biscuit leather and MG pepperpot alloys. To go with the walnut and pop-up sunroof – yes it was 1984 – that were already there.
American brands aren’t great at “small” and have only recently been good at “fancy” I can’t think of anything from the American brands that have nice small interiors that aren’t sports cars.
But actually in the 60s, the opposite was true, American interiors were a lot fancier and far better equipped than anything Europe could throw them at.
Agreed. There was definitely a time when American interiors were the standard that everyone else was measured against.
Ford had a great small car (OK, maybe not because of the perceived quality of the interior). Than they decided they don’t want to build it anymore.
Ford could have really done something with the Focus and instead they just killed it. They had that Vignale trim in Europe and if they would have put it with the 2.0T from the ST and Fusion, they could have made a really nice small GT hatch.
They would have sold 2 of them but still…
The Vignale was the second attempt, after Ghia Fords of the 80s and 90s. Ford burnt through two renowned Italian design houses as if they were nothing.
The Focus was a mid-sized car, the Fiesta and Ka were Ford’s small cars at the time. (and the original Puma).
By the American definition of “small car”, the Mazda3 and CX-30 are available with some seriously premium equipment and trim levels. I’d happily own either.
That Riva 500 interior is a steering wheel and cluster trim recolor away from being way better looking than a 500 interior has any right to be!
That “wood” trimmed dash and shifter is a classy look by themselves, honestly.
Some of you may feel differently but this brings up one of my many gripes with modern cars.
EVERY CONVERTIBLE SHOULD HAVE A WATERPROOF INTERIOR!
Small premium car from the US, huh? Terrifyingly, all I can think of is the Cadillac Cimmaron…
The Buick Verano was canceled just under a decade ago
Ah, the Buick Skyhawk of it’s era
Or Buick Special, if you prefer
Maybe not
Ford Mustang II Ghia.
Having the latest Roland Garros edition as the Cinq is indeed weird. RG cars should be Peugeots.
I remember when you could option the VW Polo Mk4 with a full leather interior and a 130bhp 1.9 TDI. Almost a mini GT car.
Later on my mum had an original BMW Mini Cooper S with full leather interior, wood dashboard, BRG over white roof and white Minilite-style alloys. That was a great car.
We the Euros love those things. Smaller-size doesn’t mean we want to skimp on refinement or luxury.
Until recently I had a 2006 Polo Sport, which I partly bought because I didn’t know what it even was.
It was a Mk 4 Polo, with pretty much every possible option, electric everything, pointlessly stiff springs, and most importantly: the 1.6l engine out of a Skoda, making a jaw dropping 105PS.
My two favourite things (apart from the engine) was that there was absolutely no badging, except a subtle “1.6” badge on the back (most Polos topped out at 1.4, so it was a very subtle badge). Also, it had cloth seats instead of leather, which personally I have always thought is a much better seat material.
Alas, I ruined the engine in the Polo, and have had to side-grade into an MX-5.
Honorable mention to the slightly premature “final edition” Reliant Robin 65, which got minilite wheels, metallic paint, two tone leather seats with contrast piping, burl walnut dash, chrome trimmed white face gauges, thick pile red carpeting, plus power windows and a decent stereo system
The actually final BN-1 and BN-2 versions kept a few of the 65’s features, at least as options