Home » The First Car To Have Rain-Sensing Wipers Did It In Such A Simple And Clever Way That I Want To Spit (On A Windshield)

The First Car To Have Rain-Sensing Wipers Did It In Such A Simple And Clever Way That I Want To Spit (On A Windshield)

Citroensm Wipers Top

I’m not ashamed to admit that rain-sensing wipers are one of those things that I think are clever, but have never felt the need for. I mean, I can see when there’s rain on my windshield, and it’s just not that hard to hit a little stalk on the steering wheel column to turn the wipers on. I don’t exactly see the point of them, except perhaps if you subscribe to the notion that true luxury means the car should do everything for you without you having to debase yourself by touching a control: shift, turn on lights, and, yes, turn on the windshield wipers.

Modern cars use a pretty sophisticated and clever system that uses LEDs that shine infrared light into the interior surface of the windshield, and then light-sensitive sensors detect how much light is reflected back. The amount of light reflected back is different on a dry windshield than on one with water on it, based on the principle of total internal reflection. Essentially, this phenomenon alters the reflection and refraction of light on a wet windshield, and the sensors can send this information to a computer within the car’s CAN bus to activate the wipers and adjust their speed depending on just how wet the windshield is.

Vidframe Min Top
Vidframe Min Bottom

Here, this video will give a more detailed explanation than I’m currently willing to:

Now, one thing to realize about this modern method is just how dependent on advanced electronics like computers and small integrated sensors and infrared LEDs it is, and just how much math is involved. It’s a non-trivial solution to the problem, and it’s only quite recently that we as a species have been able to make such components cheap and reliable enough for a system like this to make sense.

That’s why when I tell you that the first mass-produced dynamically-adjustable rain-sensing wiper system was introduced way back in 1970, you should realize that we’re about to talk about something nice and strange, because 1970s technology was not remotely capable of a rain-sensing system like a modern car, at least not without filling most of the car up with clunky humming boxes of computer hardware.

The first mass-produced car that came with any sort of rain-sensing wiper system was the Citroën SM, introduced in 1970.

Cs Citroensm 1
Image: Citroën

The SM was a sort of technological showcase for Citroën; it started out as a planned sportier version of Citroën’s DS, but soon developed into its own unique car, though it did adopt a lot of the SM’s advanced features, like the hydropneumatic self-leveling suspension and steerable headlights. The resulting car felt like an Earthbound spaceship, powered by a 2.7-liter Maserati V6 and so much ’70s sex appeal you’d think someone shoved Burt Reynolds into a Cuisinart and then brushed the resulting slurry over the leather seats.

In a car like the SM, an innovation like rain-sensing wipers made complete sense.

Cs Citroensm Eurofront
Image: Citroën

So, if there were no infrared LEDs or small computer modules or CCD cameras or any of the other components of modern car tech, how did they pull it off?

By being clever, that’s how. And, let’s be honest here, with this sort of engineering, being French probably didn’t hurt, either.

Citroensm Ownersman Wipers
Image: Citroën

Citroën was sort of oddly circumspect about their rain-sensing wiper system, never really mentioning it specifically. In the owner’s manual, the system is part of what they just refer to as “intermittence.” And that’s not wrong – the rain sensing was part of their intermittent wiper system – but I do think it’s a bit odd they didn’t call it out more specifically.

That could be because the problem they seemed to be trying to solve was less about the obvious detect-rain-turn-on-wipers problem, and more about the more subtle how-do-we-make-better-intermittent-wipers problem. You see, where most intermittent wiper systems just use variable timing to adjust how often the wipers wipe, Citroën wanted a system that adapted how often the wipers wiped to how much rain was falling, and that meant that their system had to know when it was raining, and roughly how much.

Here’s how it worked: when you put the wipers in intermittent mode, the wiper system began to monitor the electrical current drawn by the wiper motor. If the current draw was high, that meant the windshield was dry, because there’s a lot more friction when trying to drag a rubber wiper over a dry glass windshield. When this condition was detected, the wipers moved less frequently, because there was less rain.

Smwiper Sensingmodule
Image: Citroënvie

But when the current draw from the wiper motor dropped, that meant that there was less friction between the wiper blade and windshield, a condition that would be caused by the windshield becoming wet, likely from rain, (though to be fair, I suppose if a squirrel climbed on your roof and peed down your windshield or someone dumped a full bottle of Yoo-Hoo on your window, that would work, too) and the wiper speed would get faster until the current draw increased again, indicating a drier windshield.

So, look at what we have here! A simple, completely electromechanical system that is not just detecting when there’s rain on the windshield, but adjusting the wiper speed dynamically based on that feedback. Instead of detecting rain via total internal refraction or whatever I was going on about before, it was detecting rain via its lubricating qualities on the surface of the windshield. And you know what? They both work! Both methods are capable of detecting the presence of rain, but one requires zero computers or sensors.

Here’s the system in action; it’s maybe not especially dramatic to see, because the wipers just, you know, work, but I think it’s still worth showing:

I love this solution so much. It’s so clever and simple, and you can almost picture a room full of Citroën engineers sitting around a table thinking about ways to detect rain, when someone just remembered the visceral sensation of running a squeegee over a dry windshield, and how much different that was than sliding one across a wet one. It’s an engineering solution that seems like something based on feel, on the experiences of our senses in the real world, not on the understanding of complex math or physics, but gut-level engineering.

This approach may largely be gone, but I think it’s still worth appreciating.

Top graphic images: Bring A Trailer; Citroënvie

 

Follow us on:

Facebook
WhatsApp
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Subscribe
Notify of
121 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Ferdinand
Member
Ferdinand
1 month ago

How did they actually make it work though. At some point high current has to equal less wipes and low current more wipes.

Scoutdude
Scoutdude
1 month ago
Reply to  Ferdinand

It is essentially a thermal breaker, the more current the more heat put into the breaker and the longer it takes to reset. See below for a more detailed description based on what I can see in the photo.

Dan Hull
Dan Hull
1 month ago

because 1970s technology was not remotely capable of a rain-sensing system like a modern car,

The US patent for the modern sensor design that works via the change in total internal reflection was filed in the 1970s. It’s not complex, and does not require “filling most of the car up with clunky humming boxes of computer hardware”. It doesn’t even need an IR LED, but because IR was easier than shorter wavelengths (it took us a long time to work down to red, then green, then eventually blue), IR LEDs were available much earlier. In fact, the first LEDs were infrared. Texas Instruments had IR LEDs available commercially in the early 1960s, which is why the 1970s patent filing for the rain sensor design (4355271) used LEDs.

But in a nutshell, it’s a light source and a photocell and a small circuit to detect brightness… and that’s about it. If the windshield is wet, you get less IR reflected internally, so your photocell detects less and turns the wipers on. The patent was 1970s, the light source was 1960s.

Ferdinand
Member
Ferdinand
1 month ago
Reply to  Dan Hull

Just because there’s a patent for it doesn’t mean it was a viable product. The fact that there was like 15-20 years between that patent and light refractive based rain sensing wipers becoming available on even the fanciest cars suggests that it was anything but reasonably viable for the passenger car market in at the time the patent was created.

Dan Hull
Dan Hull
1 month ago
Reply to  Ferdinand

Sure… my quibble is with the statements that 1970s technology wasn’t capable of doing it, that it required “clunky boxes of humming computer hardware,” and even more specifically that IR LEDs didn’t exist when they’d been available commercially for a decade.

The timing being what it is, though… this seems more like an example of “nobody wants to pay the inventor, so let’s just wait for the patent to expire” than anything. Nothing about it would have been terribly hard in the 1970s except coming up with the clever idea in the first place. The parts were all there.

10001010
Member
10001010
1 month ago

The automatic wipers on my Polestar work pretty good when it’s raining. Well enough that as the rain lightens up they wipe less and less until they quit completely and I forget they’re on. The the next day I hop in the car, pull out of the driveway, and about a mile down the street they start wiping for absolutely no reason on a perfectly sunny day.

Ferdinand
Member
Ferdinand
1 month ago
Reply to  10001010

My Ioniq 5 is almost as bad. On foggy/dewy mornings, it loves to keep wiping the dew away even though it got it after the first wipe.

Mike F.
Member
Mike F.
1 month ago

Yet another reason to lust after an SM. (Can’t imagine trying to keep one running, though.)

Droid
Member
Droid
1 month ago

analog, not digital

3WiperB
Member
3WiperB
1 month ago

Neat. Rain sensing wipers are great if they work well, but some aren’t great.

Useless fact, the 2008 Saturn Astra had rain sensing wipers standard, but not air conditioning. I suspect there probably isn’t another car out there that can end up from the factory with rain sensing wipers but no air conditioning.

Our 3 series lets you adjust the delay up or down when in rain sensing mode, so you can really get it finely tuned the way you like it.

Kevin Rhodes
Member
Kevin Rhodes
1 month ago
Reply to  3WiperB

BMW’s rain sensing, at least on my 2011 e91 and e88 works fine in the rain. But they’re absolute shite in light snow. The better systems work as standard fixed interval intermittent wipers when the rain sensing is turned off – Audi, as much as I gripe about their ergonomics as a rule, does this perfectly. I’d be curious if your car is a newer generation than mine and if they have made it better in light snow.

I solved the problem by spending my winters in a place where the last time it measurably snowed was in 1939. 🙂

pizzaman09
pizzaman09
1 month ago
Reply to  Kevin Rhodes

I wonder if it’s just a model thing. The rain sensing wipers in my parents 2001 e38 work great in the rain or snow.

Kevin Rhodes
Member
Kevin Rhodes
1 month ago
Reply to  pizzaman09

They worked fine if it was really snowing. But light snow just completely flumoxed them. You either get way to frequent or not frequent enough, no matter how you adjust the sensitivity adjustment. Seems to be a common complaint. Best to be able to just put them on a fixed interval in that particular circumstance, but BMW doesn’t give you a way to do it on my cars. No idea about 5-series.

Overall though, I LOVE rain sensing wipers, this is a minor complaint. Especially on the highway when the conditions can be highly variable due to getting behind or passing other cars and especially semis.

G. K.
Member
G. K.
1 month ago

One of the things I love about these older cars is the hand-drawn illustration in the owner’s handbook. My 1996 Jaguar XJ12 has its original handbook with these sorts of drawings.

Twobox Designgineer
Twobox Designgineer
1 month ago

The resulting car felt like an Earthbound spaceship, powered by a 2.7-liter Maserati V6 and so much ’70s sex appeal you’d think someone shoved Burt Reynolds into a Cuisinart and then brushed the resulting slurry over the leather seats.

Sounds like a bit too much work for a Cuisinart. Better go with a wood chipper followed by a Cuininart.

Slow Joe Crow
Slow Joe Crow
1 month ago

I like the thinking of indirectly sensing the amount of rain to produce adaptive intermittent wipers.
This triggered a memory of an aftermarket intermittent wiper system for A1 VWs that used replacement relay and a Nintendo style cheat code with the wiper stalk.

Dave Larkman
Dave Larkman
1 month ago

My Z4 had automatic wipers that worked so well it was about six months into owning it when I realised it had automatic wipers, and I wasn’t just switching them on via muscle memory and subconscious thought like I do in all my other cars.

It was very impressive, but also functionally the same as not having them.

The auto-dimming mirrors on the other hand I still miss. And the engine.

Spikersaurusrex
Member
Spikersaurusrex
1 month ago
Reply to  Dave Larkman

I never knew I couldn’t live without auto-dimming mirrors until I bought a car that had them. The heated steering wheel is also great when your fingers are achy in the winter.

pizzaman09
pizzaman09
1 month ago

I’ve had a few cars with auto dimming center rear mirror, but the real luxury was the auto dimming side mirrors in the doors of my parent’s 97 ZJ Grand Cherokee Limited. It was so nice not also getting blinded by the side view mirrors.

Spikersaurusrex
Member
Spikersaurusrex
1 month ago
Reply to  pizzaman09

Oh yeah, auto-dimming side mirrors are really great.

LMCorvairFan
Member
LMCorvairFan
1 month ago

Positively steampunk cleverness!

Tj1977
Member
Tj1977
1 month ago

Mister Saturday Night special…

I’ll take the SM car chase at the start of The Longest Yard over most of the car chases that followed in Burt’s career, including those in Smokey and the Bandit. There’s one moment towards the end where he gives a look towards the camera, but not at the camera that is the right amount of self-reference, better than his Cheshire cat grin directly at the camera in Smokey…it’s just such a great car chase and the best use/abuse of an SM that that springs to mind.

G. K.
Member
G. K.
1 month ago
Reply to  Tj1977

There was also a Citroën SM in the 1998 music video for Janet Jackson’s song I Get Lonely, as well as the subsequent remixed version’s video featuring Blackstreet (of No Diggity fame). What’s more, it was from Janet’s personal car collection, and in the music video, she was chauffeured in it.

Tj1977
Member
Tj1977
1 month ago
Reply to  G. K.

That’s pretty cool.

Too bad it wasn’t one of those four-door Chapron four-door sedan SM’s…those are such amazing looking cars.

Paul E
Member
Paul E
1 month ago
Reply to  Tj1977

I watched that car chase clip again today and realized that 24 hours previously, I was walking around that fountain in Savannah where the SM zoomed through Forsyth Park. Small world, and no car chase for me yesterday.

Tj1977
Member
Tj1977
1 month ago
Reply to  Paul E

I love how small things like that happen.

Question for you: SM, Torino or Fury if you were driving in that chase?

Paul E
Member
Paul E
1 month ago
Reply to  Tj1977

SM back then would have been like driving an alien rocket ship, so of course… that! Otherwise, the Fury. Big Mopar battleships like those, especially in police spec, handled surprisingly well for what they were.

Tj1977
Member
Tj1977
1 month ago
Reply to  Paul E

I was going to say the Fury would be my pick…I’d be too afraid of breaking the SM…Burt seemed like he had a lock on that aspect of the chase.

RustHoles
Member
RustHoles
1 month ago

The auto wipers on my wife’s Mazda are super annoying… always wait too long to turn on. Wish it had regular intermittent ones.

Y2Keith
Member
Y2Keith
1 month ago
Reply to  RustHoles

What year Mazda? I have a 2022. I turned off the rain-sensing feature through the infotainment system because the seemingly random intervals bothered me. With that setting turned off, they just work like regular intermittent wipers.

RustHoles
Member
RustHoles
1 month ago
Reply to  Y2Keith

It’s a 2024, I’ll see if I can do that! Thank you!

FormerTXJeepGuy
Member
FormerTXJeepGuy
1 month ago
Reply to  RustHoles

I had a 2013 BMW 3 series with auto wipers and they never seemed to work properly. I went back to just using the regular functions.

Mike F.
Member
Mike F.
1 month ago

I had a 2006 330i that had poorly functioning auto wipers, such that I didn’t use them, either. On the other hand, our ’20 M240i’s auto wipers work really well. Something must have changed somewhere along the line.

Spikersaurusrex
Member
Spikersaurusrex
1 month ago

I generally like the rain sensor on my Mercedes, but it does sometimes act weird. Sometimes it waits too long to wipe, and other times it wipes like I’m driving through a biblical deluge when there’s been like two drops. Most of the time it’s just about right, though. Maybe the light refraction doesn’t always compensate for shadows or something.

Tbird
Member
Tbird
1 month ago

That was my issue with the Acura system – wipe speed was never what I actually wanted, always too fast or too slow.

D-dub
Member
D-dub
1 month ago

Maybe someday, perhaps with the help of AI, engineers can figure out a way to automatically turn a car’s headlights on whenever the wipers are on. Because most drivers sure aren’t capable of doing it themselves.

TK-421
TK-421
1 month ago
Reply to  D-dub

Came here to say I’d settle for wiper-sensing headlights.

Keith Tanner
Keith Tanner
1 month ago
Reply to  D-dub

I’m pretty sure my 15 year old Dodge truck does that.

UX Designer
Member
UX Designer
1 month ago
Reply to  D-dub

Subarus have done this for a while and I think my Prius did too.

Can Subaru assemble a rattle-free car? No. Are they monitoring dozens of different inputs at all times with millisecond accuracy to accomplish small safety improvements and conveniences? Absolutely- a bit like old Citroën. Maybe that’s why I ended up with one when I was very seriously in the market for a DS.

TheDrunkenWrench
Member
TheDrunkenWrench
1 month ago
Reply to  D-dub

We programmed all the body control modules in our lease truck fleet to do this, back when I worked at International.

Scoutdude
Scoutdude
1 month ago
Reply to  D-dub

Ford has been doing it, at least on some vehicles going back at least 25 years, my son’s 2001 Grand Marquis has lights with wipers as do my 03 Marauders, my Daughter’s 13 C-Max, my 15 MKZ, wife’s 22 Escape and Son’s 23 Lightning.

James E
James E
1 month ago

My 1984 Nissan Skyline had a piezoelectric/vibration-type rain sensor. Raindrop → tiny impact → vibration → electrical signal → wiper controller

TriangleRAD
Member
TriangleRAD
1 month ago
Reply to  James E

Some high-trim S12 200SX’s came with them, too. I found an 87 200SX coupe in a junkyard years ago while hunting for parts for my 88, it had the big black sensor box at the bottom of the windshield to detect the raindrop vibrations.

TheDrunkenWrench
Member
TheDrunkenWrench
1 month ago
Reply to  James E

The PERFECT car for a couple of 12″ subwoofers in the trunk.

Dingleberry Butch
Dingleberry Butch
1 month ago

The current system detects how much rain IS on the windshield and thus when to wipe. Citroen’s system detects how much rain WAS on the windshield when it last wiped and then extrapolates when to wipe next. It is a subtle difference, and probably doesn’t matter that much in application, but I am guessing that the Citroen system is slower to react to an increase in rainfall.

Scoutdude
Scoutdude
1 month ago

Great point!

Hoonicus
Hoonicus
1 month ago

Simplify, then add swipeness.

Angrycat Meowmeow
Member
Angrycat Meowmeow
1 month ago

Blame it on the rain? A French car with a Italian engine seems like a good way to set fire to the rain.

Y2Keith
Member
Y2Keith
1 month ago

I’ve seen fire and I’ve seen rain.

I drive a boring SUV
I drive a boring SUV
1 month ago
Reply to  Y2Keith

But have you ever seen the rain coming down on a sunny day?

David Smith
Member
David Smith
1 month ago

Two points:

That song was playing at the grocery store about an hour ago (what a treat)

I was in Brazil about 15 years ago walking around a city central park with not a cloud in the sky and it started raining, not hard, enough to dampen the ground. My wife said yeah that happens. I asked her not to tell Fogerty.

JayJay
JayJay
1 month ago

My first car with rain sensor was a late 90s Citroën Xantia.
I have no idea how it worked, but it was nice 🙂

Tbird
Member
Tbird
1 month ago

I loathed the rain sensing wipers in my Acura, they were never at the speed I wanted.

Same reason I always run my climate control in manual.

Last edited 1 month ago by Tbird
Church
Member
Church
1 month ago

In retrospect, duh, I could have predicted the answer. But I didn’t.

Casey Blake
Casey Blake
1 month ago

I’ve only had 1 car with rain-sensing wipers- my old Saab 9-5 wagon. I don’t miss them much at all, with the rare exception of a day where the rain is constant but variable, and switching from intermittent to regular wiping and back repeatedly gets to be fussy.

Last edited 1 month ago by Casey Blake
Andy Individual
Andy Individual
1 month ago

Just imagine the number of Gitanes that went into figuring this out.

I think I’ll stick to my peril sensitive sunglasses.

4moremazdas
Member
4moremazdas
1 month ago

Very cool bit of old technology, but did it really sense rain? As in, decide when to turn on the wipers for you?

It sounds like it relied on you to turn the wipers on, then adjusted the speed based on feedback from the previous wipe.

I have rain sensing wipers in that when I’m driving with my partner and it starts to rain she has lower tolerance for rain on the windshield than I do and will reach over and turn the wipers on. Alternately, she gets annoyed if the wipers are going too fast for the conditions and will adjust the speed.

06 Z33
06 Z33
1 month ago
Reply to  4moremazdas

Sounds like me. She hates when I don’t use wipers, even though I can see just fine.

To me, there is significantly more annoyance and distraction from wipers going when they aren’t needed than from the windshield being a bit wet.

Tbird
Member
Tbird
1 month ago
Reply to  06 Z33

Oh good, I’m not the only one.

I’ve had to slap my partner’s hand away from the wiper stalk while I’m the one driving. It’s a pet peeve of mine.

Last edited 1 month ago by Tbird
Jeff Diamond
Member
Jeff Diamond
1 month ago
Reply to  Tbird

SPOT ON!!! The driver is the pilot in-command, the passenger is NOT the copilot, at best the passenger is the navigator. No passenger should ever attempt to control any aspect of vehicle operation unless directed by or authorized by the driver. This especially includes the radio, AC & widows. A light slap on the wrist is the appropriate response to a first time offender followed by increasingly strong verbal rebukes for repeated offenses. Of course, when the passenger is your significant other you may want to defer action until you reach your destination or forever ????

Spikersaurusrex
Member
Spikersaurusrex
1 month ago
Reply to  Jeff Diamond

In one of my cars we have dual zone AC. It’s OK if the passenger adjusts their side. But otherwise I agree with you, and I’m pretty sure that most religions recognize spousal interference with car controls when not driving to be grounds for divorce.

Bags
Member
Bags
1 month ago

The dual zone automatic climate control opens up the possibility of “overcompensation”.
I’ve had to explain (while trying not to sound like I’m talking to a child) that we just got into a hot car and it’s gonna take a second to cool off. The AC is running. Give it a minute. Please don’t turn your side down to “MAX” because it will actively start blowing heat at me to try to keep me at the 70 degrees set over here.

Lockleaf
Lockleaf
1 month ago
Reply to  Jeff Diamond

So…. Driver picks the music, shotgun shuts his cakehole.

Tbird
Member
Tbird
1 month ago
Reply to  Lockleaf

You’ve not met my partner… TBH her desire for total control of all vehicular function when I’m driving has me near my breaking point at times. I can’t pick music, temp, etc…Many times I’ve been tempted to pull over and just say “Then you drive.”

Long drives alone are bliss

Last edited 1 month ago by Tbird
Lockleaf
Lockleaf
1 month ago
Reply to  Tbird

I was just quoting Supernatural, the tv show. Honestly, when I drive with wife, I let her control all of that from the get go. wiper speed is mine though. Music, temp, etc, those are always in her hands. I don’t care. I’m fine regardless. If I really hate the music, I will put an earbud in my window side ear and listen to that.

Tbird
Member
Tbird
1 month ago
Reply to  Lockleaf

Wipers are a Red-Line.

We argue when I put the windshield of defog so I can see.

Last edited 1 month ago by Tbird
Tbird
Member
Tbird
1 month ago
Reply to  Jeff Diamond

We are well past repeat offense. She has a habit of pulling the ‘washer’ function at the absolute most inopportune moments while I’m driving. Waiting to pull out at a complex intersection – pull the washer! I think people have been sentanced to death for less.

Adult daughter claims her mom has no concept of boundaries.

Last edited 1 month ago by Tbird
06 Z33
06 Z33
1 month ago
Reply to  Tbird
GENERIC_NAME
GENERIC_NAME
1 month ago

I guess the key issue is that it has to wipe the screen to know if it’s raining, so the driver has to set the wiper to wipe unlike newer systems. But given the time period it’s an impressive achievement.

I wish I had something similar on my car. I have four intermittent settings, and the rain is always seems to be at 2.6.

JumboG
JumboG
1 month ago
Reply to  GENERIC_NAME

On my BMW you have to switch to intermittent to get the wipers going, then you can set the sensitivity of the systems with the intermittent wiper control.

121
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x