Home » The Next Mini Might Lose The One Feature Everyone Expects From A Mini

The Next Mini Might Lose The One Feature Everyone Expects From A Mini

Mini Cooper S Tmd

For some reason, I keep finding myself returning to Jean Baudrillard’s “Simulacra and Simulation.” Maybe it’s the way algorithmic social media no longer resembles actual sociality. Maybe it’s the strangeness of virtual avatars. Maybe we’re already living in hyperreality. Things to ponder over coffee. Either way, Mini is the car brand that best represents some of Baudrillard’s concepts.

The reborn Mini was a simulation of the original, the Countryman was a step further from reality than that, and now the next Mini might take things a step further again by potentially ditching the biggest thing the original BMC Mini is credited with popularizing.

Vidframe Min Top
Vidframe Min Bottom

Meanwhile, the new Jeep Cherokee might have an unusually short model cycle, Mercedes-Benz has done things to the regular C-Class, and decommissioned cop cars could become a source of cheap thrills again at some point in the next few years thanks to a certain twin-turbocharged Dodge. Welcome back to The Morning Dump. Let’s get cracking.

Put That Thing Down, Flip It And Reverse It?

P90550313 Highres Mini Cooper Se 05 20
Source: Mini

Roughly seventy years ago, British Motor Corporation boss Leonard Lord tasked Sir Alec Issigonis with designing a properly small car in response to a fuel price spike caused by the Suez Canal crisis. What Issigonis came up with changed the world. It wasn’t the first transverse-engined front-wheel-drive car, but it was the first one to sell in the West in serious volume and one of the first to be water-cooled. Gearbox-in-sump aside, the Mini laid the blueprint for the modern economy car. Even the latest modern Mini features front-wheel-drive, but that might change with the next generation. As Autocar reports:

BMW Group engineers told Autocar at the launch of the Gen6 that the firm had no plans to develop a viable front drive unit and that could force the Mini to make the landmark shift.

As previously reported by Autocar, the BMW 1 Series hatchback – which currently shares the petrol Mini’s UKL platform – is set to return to rear-wheel drive as it gains an electric option on the new platform, and BMW’s development boss Joachim Post has previously told Autocar the Mini could follow suit.

A rear-wheel-drive Mini would be strange, but also potentially a riot. Even though cells have grown more energy-dense over the past 15 years or so, a battery pack for an electric car is a relatively hefty thing. The current J01 Mini EV sold outside of America weighs around 400 pounds more than its combustion-powered counterpart, and if lightness won’t be a dominant driving trait, using rear-wheel-drive could really up the fun by taxing the front tires less. As long as it’s still dimensionally tiny, it could be a party if each horsepower’s pushing fewer than 15 pounds like it is on the current Cooper S.

That Was Quick

The Next Generation Jeep® Cherokee Is Coming Late 2025.
Photo credit: Jeep

The compact crossover segment is a ruthless battlefield. With strong competition and huge volume, it’s often where automakers give it their all. For instance, a new Jeep Cherokee on a purportedly new STLA One platform is on its way in three years’ time. As Automotive News reports:

Cherokee pilot production is scheduled to start in the first half of 2028, Stellantis said, with retail production targeted for the second half of 2029.

“Launching the next-generation Cherokee on STLA One allows us to deliver a more competitive product while leveraging the strength of our U.S. manufacturing operations,” Filosa said in a statement. “Selecting the right product architecture, timing and execution path supports our growth strategy and creates the best long-term outcome and stability for our employees, customers and stakeholders.”

This is an undeniably strange development because we just got a brand new Jeep Cherokee. Launched for 2026 and codenamed KM, the current model rides on the STLA Large Transverse platform, which isn’t really the same platform as the new Dodge Charger despite that car’s architecture also being called STLA Large. Anyway, it features a 1.6-liter turbocharged engine from the Peugeot parts bin, a transmission from Toyota Group-affiliated BlueE Nexus (seriously, that’s the official capitalization), and a 1.08 kWh lithium-ion battery.

In an age of extra-long model cycles, Jeep replacing the Cherokee with a new model after a mere four years on the market is an incredibly uncommon move. Unless, of course, STLA One isn’t quite what it seems. See, the STLA Medium Transverse platform under the current Cherokee is essentially an evolution of the Compact U.S. Wide platform found under the old Chrysler 200. Will STLA One be a further development of STLA Medium Transverse? Only time and a good look underneath will tell.

Botox’d Baby Benz

26c0225 008
Photo credit: Mercedes-Benz

Back in Spring, Mercedes-Benz unveiled an all-new electric C-Class that didn’t look like the gasoline-powered C-Class we’re all used to. The EV features an enormous faux grille just like the electric GLC, and that presented a bit of a brand identity problem. See, Mercedes-Benz seems to have this pathological obsession with visual consistency. An S-Class, E-Class, and C-Class all look similar, so this discrepancy between C-Classes couldn’t stand. That’s right, the regular C-Class just gained an enormous grille and it’s a little bit challenging.

Perhaps its’ the thick black bezel blending into the dark headlamp housings that makes the front end look a bit unfinished. The licence plate placement doesn’t help, and the three-pointed stars in the headlights are certainly something. This is definitely a vehicle for a customer, although I could see it being a bit garish for MB loyalists.

Outside of the grille, this is a rather light facelift for the C-Class. The interior’s still about the same other than an updated steering wheel with a couple of scroll wheels, the infotainment software’s been revised but the screens feature similar sizing and formatting, and the only change out back is to the taillights, which get three-pointed stars in them. Otherwise, there’s a new 48-volt mild hybrid system for the two-liter turbocharged inline-four, a Dolby Atmos-enabled Burmester sound system, and a stack of ChatGPT, Microsoft Bing, and Google Gemini in the infotainment system. Hmm.

Cop Shocks, Cop Tires

Remember when decommissioned cop cars were a source of cheap used car thrills? Slidey Crown Vics and Caprices, amusingly quick twin-turbo Tauruses, snow-munching all-wheel-drive V8 Chargers. Now, if you buy a recent decommissioned police car, it’s probably going to be a Ford Explorer (technically a Police Interceptor Utility), a Chevrolet Tahoe, or a V6 Dodge Charger. Decent transportation, but not exactly mayhem machines. That should change in the next few years because Dodge just stealthily showed off what a Charger Six Pack police car would look like. Team One Network, an industry association for law enforcement hardware, got a glimpse of a new Charger PPV prototype of sorts, and it looks rather interesting. As the Team One Public Safety Division wrote on Instagram:

The @dodgelaw Charger PPV is BACK! #dodge had what will be the 2027 Dodge Charger PPV on display during the Police Fleet Expo at the Daytona International Speedway today! Orderable in the summer of 2027. AWD is standard.

What we have here is a five-door liftback with a twin-turbocharged straight-six and all-wheel-drive that should eventually be unloaded at government auction prices once it goes into production, then through service. Assuming most will come equipped with the standard-output 420-horsepower engine, that could be a lot of power for not a lot of money. If production does indeed kick off in 2027, expect to see second-hand models start showing up in the used car market around 2030. Could be the move for cheap speed.

What I’m Listening To While Writing TMD

Is The Hellp unbearably pretentious or genuinely one of the few interesting bands to break through in the past few years? Maybe it doesn’t matter. The lyricism of “Live Forever” may be abstract and esoteric, but the track itself bottles a certain feeling beautifully. Not a bad way to end a studio album, this.

The Big Question

Over the past decade or so, Mini’s been in a weird spot. It’s not quite a traditional enthusiast brand anymore, but at the same time, everyone’s wondered where it’s going next. You can only rehash the same retro modus so many times, after all. However, would a rear-wheel-drive three-door Mini hatchback actually appeal to enthusiasts, even if it’s electric?

Top graphic image: Mini

 

Follow us on:

Facebook
WhatsApp
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Subscribe
Notify of
124 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Ben
Member
Ben
3 months ago

a stack of ChatGPT, Microsoft Bing, and Google Gemini

I am unreasonably amused that Bing was included here instead of Copilot.

Microsoft Copilot: So bad even Bing seems preferable.

Andy Individual
Andy Individual
3 months ago
Reply to  Ben

At least Bing has maps. Copilot has guesses.

Ranwhenparked
Member
Ranwhenparked
3 months ago

This is sort of bringing things full circle. Rover Group originally wanted to do a rear engine/RWD replacement for the Mini in the 1990s, which BMW vetoed as not being upmarket (profitable) enough and not having enough retro style, so it was dropped in favor of BMW’s own design

Cloud Shouter
Cloud Shouter
3 months ago

A three door, ev Mini could become a cult classic if, and only if, they take it rally racing.

M SV
M SV
3 months ago

If you make it a rdu ev give the mini a fronk I would imagine current new mini buyers would find them interesting. If the price is right probably buy. When others get ahold of them would probably be decent to drive and hoon. Sort of a historic irony you get the rear hatch and a fronk were the original made a big deal their main competitor the beatle only had a fronk with not much cargo volume.

Will be interesting to see how the charger does with the cage. It looks like it should be ok. That was one of the biggest issues for many depends with the Taurus. Not enough room for a cage and a foot. So they had to lay people on their sides. Once they have some reliability with the ev version could also be something alot of police fleets would go for.

Carbon Fiber Sasquatch
Member
Carbon Fiber Sasquatch
3 months ago

TBQ: As long as it’s one of the smallest cars on the road, rwd sounds like it would be even more fun to own as a daily. I’m on board.

I was going to get the new Cooper E as my new daily but they didn’t bring it over to the states

Ricardo M
Ricardo M
3 months ago

The next Mini might just be the EV I’ve been asking for, even if it’s not the Mini I would expect. Whether it’s a proper Mini is questionable, but I like it. At least as much as I can like a Mini without a manual transmission.

The simple truth is there’s very little reason for an EV to be front-drive.

The Austin/Morris Mini was front wheel drive to get rid of the transmission tunnel and rear diff and maximize interior space, with the engine sideways for packaging and efficiency. The great handling came from simply being small and well-tuned. As a truncated sedan, the trunk floor was as low as possible to maximize vertical space, and the rear seats didn’t fold down.

Before we even get into the EV thing, modern hatchbacks have a raised trunk floor to match the height of the seats so the cargo floor is flat when they’re folded forward. There’s usually some space underneath for a spare tire, tool-kit or rear-mounted battery, but it’s seldom used for luggage, so there’s little downside to having a rear differential. And finally, traction/stability control is so effective that if you retrofitted a fully-developed version of these systems to a Lamborghini Countach, you’d end up with a perfectly controllable, mostly idiot-proof all-season car.

Once we start talking about EV’s, we can eliminate transmission tunnels, spider gears and lengthwise engine blocks. An electric drive unit takes up the same negligible space whether it’s at the front or back and has the same efficiency in either location.

Scott
Member
Scott
3 months ago

“…and a stack of ChatGPT, Microsoft Bing, and Google Gemini in the infotainment system.”

Wow, it’s hard to imagine a more off-putting, dystopian sentence to describe a new car.

4moremazdas
Member
4moremazdas
3 months ago

the current model rides on the STLA Large Transverse platform, which isn’t really the same platform as the new Dodge Charger despite that car’s architecture also being called STLA Large

See, the STLA Medium Transverse platform under the current Cherokee is essentially an evolution of the Compact U.S. Wide platform found under the old Chrysler 200.

This is a confusing couple of sentences. I’m sure I could look it up and clarify, but is the current platform STLA Large or STLA Medium?

Daniel Franco
Member
Daniel Franco
3 months ago
Reply to  4moremazdas

Look, all I know is this: That short palm-reader lady claimed to be a psychic and ripped me off for 3 big ones. Today I read in the paper that she knocked over a bank and went on the lam. That makes her a small medium, at large…

EXL500
Member
EXL500
3 months ago
Reply to  Daniel Franco

Even easier. It’s from Stellantis, so I wouldn’t consider buying it. Too much agita in my past.

Sackofcheese
Sackofcheese
3 months ago

While an Explorer Police Utility may appear boring on the surface, they can be optioned with the hot 3.0T EcoBoost that is in the Explorer ST. At least locally, that’s all we have here. Plus the Police one gets an upgraded 10R80 vs the ST’s 10R60 transmission. Those things can run 12s with bolt ons and a toon.

Nsane In The MembraNe
Member
Nsane In The MembraNe
3 months ago

Holy shit. Already killing a brand new car is madness…especially considering the new Cherokee is:

1). Fairly attractive

2). Competitive on paper

Of course it’s been plagued by the usual Stellantis QC problems…but Jeep owners happily put up with that shit for the most part. I had no idea it’s been selling so poorly. I get that that’s a competitive class but there’s no reason why a hybrid soft roader with classic Jeep looks should be such a slow seller.

It’s basically everything the market wants on paper. Is it THAT bad to drive or that poorly put together that people are sitting in them and immediately leaving the dealerships? This is genuinely perplexing to me, especially considering Toyota keeping the RAV4 artificially scarce and hybrid Foresters being a relative hit. You’d think that “Toyota will get you a $50,000 RAV4 in 6-12 months but we can sell you a similarly efficient Cherokee for $40,000” would move some cars.

What the hell is wrong with it? Even with the QC issues and whatever is pissing potential customers off you’d think they could turn it into a good car by the mid cycle refresh. People still buy the current Grand Cherokee and that car isn’t really competitive in its class anymore.

Is it just a situation where Stellantis customers are furious about the fact that it’s a hybrid and don’t feel like a car is adequate unless it’s as damaging to the environment as possible? Are they re-engineering it to shove a V8 into it? Is the new one gonna roll coal? I’m very confused, and Stellantis’ recent return to their FUCK YOU YOU STUPID FUCKING IDIOT IT HAS A HEMI approach might make the line go up for another year or two but eventually there will be a new administration that doesn’t have committing violence against the environment on its list of priorities…

Last edited 3 months ago by Nsane In The MembraNe
Taargus Taargus
Member
Taargus Taargus
3 months ago

I think it’s become as simple as people who buy regular-ass cars (things that compete with a RAV4) don’t go to CJDR dealers anymore. There’s a good chance that the last time they did, CJDR didn’t even have a compact CUV on the lot. Because Stellantis was the king of cancelling products without a replacement.

That and yes, I think Stellantis have put out so many horribly unreliable vehicles over the past 5+ years that nearly everyone knows someone that has had a catastrophic experience with one. The Cherokee may be a decent product (maybe?) as a RAV4 with enough seasoning that you can actually taste it, but I just don’t think that’s enough for most people.

EXL500
Member
EXL500
3 months ago

5+ years? Try 15.

Taargus Taargus
Member
Taargus Taargus
3 months ago
Reply to  EXL500

I was mostly focused on the Stellantis years (since 2021?). But yeah I mean, this isn’t a company known for reliability and quality, no matter how far back you go (in my lifetime anyway).

And I think even the past 5 years put the previous 10 to shame.

Phil
Phil
3 months ago

No way I’d risk a Stellantis hybrid given how good the RAV4 is, unless the price differential was huge. Vs the CRV with its head gaskets? More likely.

Needles Balloon
Needles Balloon
3 months ago

I think it’s not selling well because it’s a bit overpriced; it starts at $37k but the version with ehated seats is $40k, while the (more reliable) competition gives you that feature for $35-37k. The Cherokee also got bad press for being pretty awful at off-roading (several medium-size youtube channels covered it), much worse than a RAV4 or even a CR-V or Escape. I wouldn’t be surprised if the obligatory Stellantis incentives have not arrived yet, which is probably the real answer.

Noahwayout
Member
Noahwayout
3 months ago

I think this plays a huge part. If you want soft-roading chops, the Bronco Sport looks better, is cheaper but still plenty capable, and has the better overland trim package.

Last edited 3 months ago by Noahwayout
Needles Balloon
Needles Balloon
3 months ago
Reply to  Noahwayout

And that’s before they even bring a hybrid version of the Bronco Sport, which tehy could easily do considering it shares its platform with the Maverick and Escape.

DNF
DNF
3 months ago

How bad can a jeep be off-road?
What did they do to it?
I chose my 4wd by covering my eyes and stabbing at a list.
Just a 4wd pickup

Needles Balloon
Needles Balloon
3 months ago
Reply to  DNF

From what I could tell, the main issue is that the AWD system couldn’t send enough torque to the correct wheels, and there’s two potential issues causing it. First is software tuning, for some reason the Sport mode worked better for getting out of a rut than the slippery surface modes, which had some weird behavior. I’m not at all surprised by a Stellantis product rushing out underdeveloped software, but at least that can be improved with an update. Second issue is more speculative, and might be true if complete software optimization doesn’t fix things: the Cherokee is using a Toyota/Ford style planetary gearset eCVT, which I believe has a fundamental torque output limitation based on the strength of the secondary motor used. Every planetary eCVT I’ve seen has a fairly low ~1,500lb tow rating as a result. While the eCVT RAV4 aced the off-road tests, it did so with a dedicated rear drive motor, while the Cherokee uses a traditional transfer case/driveshaft. Additionally, it would not surprise me if Stellantis cheaped out on that secondary motor and it resulted in this low wheel torque problem.

DNF
DNF
3 months ago

Wow!
Seems to me the one thing a jeep has to do is work off-road.
Sounds like a fundamental flaw too.

DNF
DNF
3 months ago

Will the next administration still be burning 12 tonnes of fuel per hour while they fly about saving the universe from my 500 hp, 25 mpg car?

Nsane In The MembraNe
Member
Nsane In The MembraNe
3 months ago
Reply to  DNF

Absolutely, but they won’t be actively trying to destroy it out of spite like the current one is. Baby steps…

DNF
DNF
3 months ago

The same voters that chose this administration will be making the decisions for us again.
I’ve seen no change of strategy so far, unless you count Sanders.

Nsane In The MembraNe
Member
Nsane In The MembraNe
3 months ago
Reply to  DNF

The whole Sanders wing of the party has expanded and is winning elections. Whether or not that will be allowed to continue to come 2028 remains to be seen…I want to believe but I wouldn’t put money on corporate Dems doing anything but protecting their bottom line and the bottom line of their billionaire donors.

But who knows, despite all of that I do think they kind of, sort of want to win elections and the desire to do so just might be enough for them to hold their noses and get behind actual progressives. Possibly? Perhaps?

DNF
DNF
3 months ago

Sanders keeps pointing out they can’t even be motivated to get votes.
The persistent attempts by the Democratic party to pass delusional and absolutely non-negotiable laws trumps any goofiness by the GOP.
And there’s too much of that too.

How did Sanders suddenly become the most effective politician on that side, even if no one is listening?

Ranwhenparked
Member
Ranwhenparked
3 months ago

The current Cherokee is built in Mexico, Stellantis was supposed to be moving production to Illinois at the end of 2027 for model year 2028, I wonder if they’ve maybe decided to delay that, rather than spend the money to move existing tooling, time the production launch there with an all-new model?

Footballplaya3k
Member
Footballplaya3k
3 months ago

I think it’s a simple as you’re overlooking how almost all of this market’s customers decide their vehicle. Is it cheap? No, they’ll buy a Kia/Hyundai instead. Is it sought after? Also no, they’ll buy a Toyota/Honda instead. That leaves a small percentage of the market who are 1) Jeep die-hards 2) those unwilling to go to any other dealer. Makes a lot of sense to me why it isn’t selling.

VictoriousSandwich
Member
VictoriousSandwich
3 months ago

Have you seen one in person, I agree they look good in photos but was dismayed by how cheap and crappy it came across on the one base model I’ve seen in person. Big panel gaps, wavy uneven plastics, somehow just looked unfinished.

May also be that Stellantis build quality for the past so many years is finally catching up with them, and the only Cherokee anyone remembers fondly is pretty far in the rear view anyways. And as near as I can tell they never really figured out a credible revival of it. I think the Wrangler is a specific niche that only recently has competition whereas almost everything else they make has better competitors.

Urban Runabout
Member
Urban Runabout
3 months ago

I believe the next gen Mini MUST be an EV – whether it’s FWD or RWD is unimportant.

Mini intenders are not wedded to ICE engines – they’re wedded to cute, individualistic and efficient small cars.

EXL500
Member
EXL500
3 months ago
Reply to  Urban Runabout

And that will make them unavailable to me as a choice with no chargers and long trips. That’s okay though, because I doubt I’d spend the high price they charge.

Urban Runabout
Member
Urban Runabout
3 months ago
Reply to  EXL500

I’m sure you, as well as many others, are not the target market.
Can’t be everything for everybody.

EXL500
Member
EXL500
3 months ago
Reply to  Urban Runabout

True. Makes my decision making easier too.

DNF
DNF
3 months ago
Reply to  Urban Runabout

“Mini intenders”
That’s a phrase to conjure with!

Dogisbadob
Dogisbadob
3 months ago

Will the RWD Mini be rear-engine/motor like the Twingo?

Urban Runabout
Member
Urban Runabout
3 months ago
Reply to  Dogisbadob

I imagine so, as it would be silly to have a front engine/RWD EV Mini.

05LGT
Member
05LGT
3 months ago
Reply to  Dogisbadob

More important issue is where the batteries go? For an electric I assume no transmission and motor on or beside driven axle(s).

Last edited 3 months ago by 05LGT
Urban Runabout
Member
Urban Runabout
3 months ago
Reply to  05LGT

Usually under the floor, but for this form factor they could go up front here the ICE motor would have been.

Joshua Christian
Joshua Christian
3 months ago
Reply to  Dogisbadob

Funnily enough, despite being rear-engine RWD in its final ICE guise, the the Twingo EV is actually Front Motor FWD (like the Gen 1 it is based on, and also the somewhat forgotten Gen 2).

Last edited 3 months ago by Joshua Christian
Ian McClure
Ian McClure
3 months ago

They already long ago lost the one thing that makes a Mini a Mini, which is that it’s very small.

FndrStrat06
FndrStrat06
3 months ago
Reply to  Ian McClure

They’re fairly small still, especially in the US market. Be mad because cars in general are too big, not because MINIs are too big.

JayJay
JayJay
3 months ago

I don’t think people who would buy a mini in the 2020s give a hoot.

Scott
Member
Scott
3 months ago
Reply to  JayJay

Agreed. That is a lovely shade of metallic mint green regardless. 🙂

Phil
Phil
3 months ago

“would a rear-wheel-drive three-door Mini hatchback actually appeal to enthusiasts…”

Why wouldn’t it? Traditional enthusiasts tolerate FWD, they generally don’t go looking for it.

“…even if it’s electric?”

Well, that’s a complication. EV is a bit of a divider where some will love the Mini for it and others will write it off.

Personally, having just driven a FWD BMW 123 hatch, if moving to RWD restores some kind of steering feel they should go for it and not look back. The Camry we used to own permitted more information through the steering wheel than that BMW did.

MyMustangBestMustang
Member
MyMustangBestMustang
3 months ago
Reply to  Phil

It’s like people want the car to fail. If BMW wants to make something weird, I’m all for it. Who knows what’ll be like.

Noahwayout
Member
Noahwayout
3 months ago
Reply to  Phil

There’s a lot of enthusiasts out there who don’t mind or actually like FWD. Civic SIs and VW GTIs have been the quinessential everyday enthusiast driver for 40 years.

If I want an efficient car that’s managable in all weather I want FWD.

Last edited 3 months ago by Noahwayout
Phil
Phil
3 months ago
Reply to  Noahwayout

They’d lose some sales to those who specifically wanted FWD but would pick others up who specifically wanted RWD. Don’t know what the balance is there. I’m sure sticker price factors in as well, FWD is cheaper.

I have a FWD hot hatch and don’t really like the FWD aspect of it.

Noahwayout
Member
Noahwayout
3 months ago
Reply to  Phil

If it’s not AWD/4WD, I don’t think most consumers care which wheels do the driving. Case-in-point, the BMW 2 Gran Coupe is FWD in spite of the brands great tradition of RWD sedans.

For years I drove e30s and as much as I loved them, they were terribly mediocre in slick weather. My Prelude was much more foregiving.

Phil
Phil
3 months ago
Reply to  Noahwayout

I think your e30 experience shows that many normal customers do care. FWD is popular in my area and any transverse Bimmer or Merc is Xdrive and 4matic.

Enthusiasts skew differently, they’re more willing to put up with the RWD weather traction problems. Besides, if Mini goes RWD it’s likely they’d put AWD optional and retain the normies.

Last edited 3 months ago by Phil
Noahwayout
Member
Noahwayout
3 months ago
Reply to  Phil

I was young and dumb and willing to tolerate the tradeoffs because I really wanted an e30 and could only have one car. I moved on to a Jetta and a Civic.

Phil
Phil
3 months ago
Reply to  Noahwayout

Yeah, I had a similar phase with a compact rwd pickup. That thing was absolutely useless in any kind of snow/ice. Almost died because I had the nerve to try to drive it down a straight road with some camber and the back end decided to become a ballet dancer in The Nutcracker and pirouette the whole truck into the oncoming lanes. Luckily missed everyone.

Never again, not in my region anyway.

Last edited 3 months ago by Phil
TK-421
TK-421
3 months ago

I was expecting “being MINI in size”. I don’t think they’re very MINI.

Angel "the Cobra" Martin
Member
Angel "the Cobra" Martin
3 months ago

“The Next Mini Might Lose The One Feature Everyone Expects From A Mini”Consuming an ungodly amount of oil?

JDE
JDE
3 months ago

Timing Chain Stretch and Overheating. Or possibly Rough running motors from Carbon build up or fouled plugs.

James McHenry
Member
James McHenry
3 months ago

I’d argue Mini has been retro since…probably the Metro superceded it as the contemporary British Leyland economy car. Because they just kept making Minis, and even reverted to the old Austin/Morris face instead of the later one. But part of the Mini Legend is a little car hitting well above its weight. A point that becomes increasingly moot the bigger and heavier the cars get. FWD is a part of the legend – the old trope of “boot it and straighten out” – and an indelible part of the brand’s identity. Will adopting the rival Beetle’s layout – because like Hell are they going to stick the EV motor in the front with a driveshaft to the rear wheels, that’s stupid – make the Mini instantly ruined? Maybe not, but it’s hard to argue that it won’t just feel like a smallish electric BMW instead of a sprightly city car.

Eggsalad
Member
Eggsalad
3 months ago

The revival of MINI was largely created on what was effectively another retro-mobile. Yes, there were performance models for enthusiasts, but the bread-and-butter cars were sold on the basis of being “cute”. Sales in the US haven’t exceeded 35k since 2019. Hardly anyone in the US wants a cute retro-mobile any more. I’m calling it dead brand walking, at least in the US.

Trust Doesn't Rust
Member
Trust Doesn't Rust
3 months ago

Correction: A manual transmission was the one feature everyone expected from a Mini.

Alexk98
Member
Alexk98
3 months ago

Unfortunately that’s already dead and gone, the last stick Mini’s were built in early 2024.

Ricardo M
Ricardo M
3 months ago
Reply to  Alexk98

If they won’t be manual anymore, there’s no reason to have an engine under the hood, and in that case, there’s no reason to be FWD. RWD EV’s are the second best option right behind a manual.

Alexk98
Member
Alexk98
3 months ago
Reply to  Ricardo M

Fully agree that they won’t be sticks anymore, more just my general argument that Mini has largely abandoned the enthusiast crowd overall and is pushing to a brand of upmarket highly customizable accessories than they are sporty practical small cars.

Ricardo M
Ricardo M
3 months ago
Reply to  Alexk98

You’re right, BMW in general has also in a lot of ways abandoned the enthusiasts, they focus on stat sheet keyboard racers while their cars keep getting heavier and uglier. I was just building on your mention of the discontinued manual to add a point towards TBQ.

Alexk98
Member
Alexk98
3 months ago

TBQ: Mini has abandoned the true enthusiast market, and a switch to RWD will not change that, certainly if it goes EV heavy. Mini was reasonable in realizing it’s appeal was not broadly enthusiasts, but as a foil for Jeeps in the lifestyle/customizable space. Mini appeals broadly to the base of people who want something that’s a bit quirky, much more customizable than a normal car, and has some flair to it that stands out. The current Mini lineup has zero manuals, their current lineup has horrific reviews for it’s DCT calibrations (ie not enthusiast friendly) and BMW as a whole is leaving manuals behind.

The switch to a RWD base will be purely from a convenience and corporate decision standpoint, but I see no reason to believe that they will suddenly change course on tuning and setup. Heck, they’re cramming a crappy AI assisted dog avatar into screens as a “virtual assistant” that their marketing centers around. If that doesn’t scream “enthusiasts mean nothing to us” then nothing will.

TheDrunkenWrench
Member
TheDrunkenWrench
3 months ago

I was shopping the Mini Clubman back around 2010, and remember wishing it was RWD. So maybe there is a market for it.

Interestingly enough, the Rover Mini I picked up a few months ago is my first FWD vehicle. Now maybe I can get another Mini that’s RWD to tow it around?

V10omous
Member
V10omous
3 months ago

It’s not a segment I shop in, so feel free to tell me I’m way off base here, but if the Mini and the 1 series are sharing a platform and RWD, why would BMW not just sell the 1 series here instead?

Why make a Mini at all, if it’s presumably going to sacrifice space for the RWD layout? Is the brand that strong? Mini Cooper sales in 2024 and 2025 (and so far this year) were the lowest of all time and less than a third of their peak two decades ago. The experiment might have run its course.

MyMustangBestMustang
Member
MyMustangBestMustang
3 months ago
Reply to  V10omous

I’m the weirdo who wants a small platform BMW rwd shooting brake in the US. They have it in Europe. But to your point, I think the BMW bodied car would be easier to sell than a quirky mini.

Spikedlemon
Spikedlemon
3 months ago

The old BMW 1-series 5-door hatchbacks were a beautiful profile. But the rear seats were absolutely pathetic; they should have abandoned the pretense and lost the rear doors altogether.

Alexk98
Member
Alexk98
3 months ago
Reply to  V10omous

I think Mini is a bit lost, they started to lose the enthusiast crown as they made their cars bigger, and have pivoted to be heavy on image, technology and customization. Seriously, I just looked at the Cooper configurator and it is incredibly vast. Ultimately these seem to be lifestyle cars akin to Wranglers more than pragmatic transportation, so I suspect a RWD platform push won’t make much of a difference other than helping push a “premium/luxury” brand image.

V10omous
Member
V10omous
3 months ago
Reply to  Alexk98

That’s sort of my point though, no matter how premium the Mini brand becomes, I doubt it will eclipse a BMW badge. And if the customization isn’t selling cars, maybe a 1-series makes more sense (and would be cheaper to develop) anyways.

Noahwayout
Member
Noahwayout
3 months ago
Reply to  V10omous

My sense is that low-end BMW buyers would step up to the 3 since the marginal difference on an 84 month loan is pretty negligible. Mini drivers want fun and quirky and that just isn’t a BMW 1.

Last edited 3 months ago by Noahwayout
Ottomottopean
Member
Ottomottopean
3 months ago
Reply to  V10omous

Don’t forget that is about the same time they made all Minis automatic-only. The loss of manual transmission to that brand is basically the same thing happening to the VW GTi.

Tekamul
Member
Tekamul
3 months ago
Reply to  V10omous

BMW back home may see the 1-series as too down market for BMW USA. Putting a mini badge on it keeps the riff raff across the street.

First Last
Member
First Last
3 months ago
Reply to  V10omous

I agree the experiment has run its course. I bet the only reason for a new model is….dealer agreements.

Phil
Phil
3 months ago

“The Next Mini Might Lose The One Feature Everyone Expects From A Mini”
Nighmarish reliability?

Sorry, I’ll go read the article now.

LMCorvairFan
Member
LMCorvairFan
3 months ago
Reply to  Phil

Keeping the legend alive, or why break with tradition.

Last edited 3 months ago by LMCorvairFan
Phil
Phil
3 months ago

Good to see. My wife has a crush on the redesigned Countryman, but she won’t indulge it on a problematic model. Not sure she’d like the lag of a turbo paired to a dct though.

MaximillianMeen
Member
MaximillianMeen
3 months ago
Reply to  Phil

Y’all should test drive one. BMW’s B48 engine that’s used in Minis is both reliable and pretty torquey for an I-4 turbo, as long as it’s not in eco-mode. However, I have a Cooper S hatch, not a Countryman, with a manual, so it’s lighter and I get to control the revs vs clutch. But I believe the Countryman gets at least the S engine from the hatch (or it may be the JCW engine with even more power).

Phil
Phil
3 months ago

Looking now, I think the F70 BMW 123 I rented recently has the same B48 and 7-speed DCT as the Countryman. I actually liked the combination quite a lot, it generally stepped off quickly (unusual for a 2.0t + dual clutch) and had more than enough power. So yeah, maybe it would pass muster.

Last edited 3 months ago by Phil
Spikedlemon
Spikedlemon
3 months ago

I look forward to police vehicles in North America being cars, again.

Tbird
Member
Tbird
3 months ago
Reply to  Spikedlemon

Fix the cigarette lighter.

124
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x