Home » These Are The Times Automotive Engineers Did You Dirty (But Was It Really Their Fault?)

These Are The Times Automotive Engineers Did You Dirty (But Was It Really Their Fault?)

Frustrating Design Answers Ts

Sometimes you just know an Ask is going to really light up the comments, and I fully expected yesterday’s invitation to spout off about knuckle-skinning, profanity-producing wrenching tasks via “What Repair Or Maintenance Task Had You Cursing The Designers Of Your Car?” to be a surefire feedback generator.

I also knew that we shouldn’t pin all the blame – or even a lot of it, I bet – on the engineers who punched everything into the CAD machine. I’m sure that when the choice must be made between making a part easier to install on the assembly line or easier for the customer to get to once the car is assembled, the call will be made by accounting, not engineering. Not to mention the countless other necessary compromises that are part of any consumer product design, which increase by an order of magnitude for something as complex as a modern car.

Vidframe Min Top
Vidframe Min Bottom

But what do I know? Let’s consult an engineer. One who’s an Autopian author, even!

Dave Larkman
Former Automotive Design Engineer here, mostly Powertrain but also body and chassis parts.

Thing 1: if the nightmare job is a nightmare because the assembly was designed to save money either directly or as part of a manufacturing cost reduction, how about a little thank you to us for making your car affordable in the first place? We can make cars super easy to service, in fact I have on my desk right now a cylinder liner that could be changed in under 5 minutes, but the engine was wildly expensive.

Thing 1a: sometimes the tiny immeasurable change from an aero cover or a blob of HVH stuff is the difference between hitting an emissions target, or failing and having to add in a load of cost. Just because it doesn’t make a difference you notice doesn’t mean it shouldn’t be fitted to a million cars.

Thing 2: we fight for serviceability, not least because the pay is crap and we drive old shitboxes. But all of engineering is a compromise, and sometimes the starter motor just has to be under the intake manifold on the rear of the engine. Sorry. Genuinely sorry. I read the comments first to make sure none of the most shameful bastard jobs were mine.

Thing 3: some automotive design engineers are shit. I know a guy who designed a cover over a bearing that could only be disassembled from inside the cover. Great if you were a bearing planning to escape, but impossible to service without a gas axe.

Long Spacer

Mark Tucker
The rear plugs on my old Coupe DeVille (transverse V8) required me to jack the car up and access two of them from the bottom, with a long and convoluted asortment of extensions and swivels.

I’m pretty sure at least one of them was the original plug, too.

Oil filter locations on some cars were the bane of my existence when I worked at the garage. Looking at you, Nissan Maxima. And don’t think you can sneak out without me seeing you, 3800-equipped W-body cars.

Undoing an engine mount and jacking up the engine two inches to replace the timing belt on my old Neon had me sounding like a character in a Tarantino movie, too.

Finally, somebody talking about spark plug access of V8s. (And yes, that’s our very own Mark Tucker, not some Great Value Mark Tucker.)

Long Spacer

Rockchops
Rear main seals, heater cores and Evaps are the bane of every wrencher’s existence but that’s not a “curse the designer” thing as much as “this component logically makes sense where it is” or a factor of general packaging.

I think the most annoying design decision is in my Sky, the water pump (which fails between 75-100k on most engines) is driven off the timing chain and sits in the block behind the turbo. It’s possible to do without the chains but its better just to replace the tensioners and chains while you’re in there. Oh and it requires a special tool too, because why not.

Tone Capone
You mentioned heater core, and I had a bad flashback.
I’m not a mechanic, but I worked as a service writer.
I would still love to slap the Ford engineer that decided to bury the original Taurus/Sable heater core 8 hours under the dash.

A lot of mechanics found shortcuts to get the job done quicker, but it was still a 5-hour ordeal of ripping apart the dashboard.

Long Spacer

Rollin Hand
Headlight bulbs on my Mazda6 required going in through the wheel well.

The alternator on the V6 Ford Contours had a bolt that was impossible to get to unless you went in through the wheel well on the other side of the car with about four feet of socket extensions.

The Ford Thunderbird Super Coupe called for the engine to come out to replace the spark plugs. Most people were able to do it without.

Then there’s the Toyota Sienna. My understanding is that Toyota calls for the engine to come out to replace the front control arms. For obvious reasons, no one does it that way. Same for the head gasket, and you have no choice but to do it that way. A 23.5-hour book rate. The dealership quoted it at five figures CAD.

… And I think any company that installs a fuel tank with no access to the fuel sender and fuel pump from inside the car oughta have their head office TP-ed.

All headlight and taillight bulbs should be easy to change, ideally without tools. Because you might have to do it in a Walmart parking lot at night.

Long Spacer

Highland Green Miata
VW 2.0L turbo engine with a plastic oil plan and a plastic drain plug. Factory recommendation is to replace the drain plug EVERY. OIL. CHANGE. And if you don’t get it torqued just Goldilocks not-too-loose-or-too tight, it will leak.

John Beef
Back before time itself, a.k.a. before kids… 2000 Tacoma 4cyl. The oil filter drained right onto a lower control arm, making the oil stream in two different directions. My wife’s 98 Civic HF – removing the oil filter meant removing the front wheel and going at it from the wheel well. It was on the back of the engine under the exhaust manifold.

My ’91 Toyota pickup with the 22RE was a breeze to work on. Plenty of room on all sides and high enough to crawl underneath without a jack. I loved that truck. It had no air conditioning, and after moving to Phoenix and spending 4 summers with it, it sadly had to go.

Jack Trade
My ’02 Mustang has the same setup – oil filter right above the control arm. Apparently, this was caused by Ford’s last-minute decision to use a V8 developed for FWD for RWD, necessitating a 90 degree turn of the engine.

I’ve figured out a multiple plastic bag process for removing it that mostly contains the oil/prevents it from covering the arm, but it’s still never perfect.

I do the thing where you let the oil run down your arm and pool in your armpit. Not intentionally, but I do it.

Long Spacer
Have you hit today’s Autopian Asks yet? Here:

What Brands Should Making Pickup Trucks Right Now That Aren’t?

Follow us on:

Facebook
WhatsApp
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Subscribe
Notify of
45 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Cars? I've owned a few
Member
Cars? I've owned a few
1 month ago

Reading the original article and this follow-up, I guess I had it easy with my ’01 Jetta TDI. The hardest thing I had to do was pull the battery to change the lefthand halogen bulb, which for whatever reason needed to be replaced twice while the righthand one never failed. Same bulb. Go figure. Maybe airflow around it on the back side?

My ’17 Accord V6 has a transversely mounted engine and I don’t know what it’s like to get to its rear bank sparkplugs. But the iridium plugs go 100K miles and now I pay people to do the stuff I don’t want to lose flesh and blood over.

Pupdog
Member
Pupdog
1 month ago

I miss my ’71 Cutlass Supreme for oil changes. You could put a pan under the filter, reach down from above and punch a screwdriver through it and unscrew it, then reach under and do the drainplug without even getting under the car.

Sofonda Wagons
Member
Sofonda Wagons
1 month ago

At least Chrysler products (what’s left of them) quit putting the 12 volt battery in the front fender well, AKA Status, Sebring, etc.

Nicklab
Member
Nicklab
1 month ago
Reply to  Sofonda Wagons

Finding out this was where the battery was while stranded in a snowy parking lot almost resulted in my roommate and I never talking again.

Salaryman
Member
Salaryman
1 month ago

I’m a civil engineer, so I don’t design parts, but more than once, I’ve chimed in on design decisions asking “How many times do I want my name taken in vain” as we are laying things out.

GirchyGirchy
Member
GirchyGirchy
1 month ago

Having to cobble together some extensions to reach a fastener isn’t that big of a deal. What makes me throw wrenches are the captive bolts which cannot be removed unless they’re cut in half, or something else important has to be removed first. I’ve seen this a few times:

1) Transmission pan bolts on my ’85 Caprice for its 700R4 – some were directly above the crossmember holding the transmission in place. That was the spark for me deciding I no longer wanted to own that car.

2) Motor mount bolt on ’01 Galant – luckily this was easily fixed by cutting off the exposed threaded end of the bolt; they were far longer than necessary.

3) Rear lower motor mount nut/bolt on ’06 Altima – it must have been easier at the factory to install the bolt from one side, nut on the other. But during attempted removal, the bolt would hit the engine block, so it had to be hacked in half to be removed. After replacement, you could easily insert the new bolt from the other side and re-use the original nut.

Other annoyances have been oil changes on my ’95 F150 4×4 (you have to invert it while passing it up and over something, dumping oil fucking everywhere), trying to get the battery tray out of my Mazda3 (gave up, way too hard), rear shocks on the Mazda3 (the lower mounts go over a threaded stud, but both of mine were completely welded to the stud by rust and had to be cut off. I let a shop handle that BS). I believe I’ll soon have spark plug replacement on our Outback to add to this list.

Angry Bob
Member
Angry Bob
1 month ago

If I end up in hell, it’s going to be an infinitely long Pep Boys service center, where in every bay is a Mercury Sable that needs a heater core.

Rob Stercraw
Rob Stercraw
1 month ago

Those Toyotas where they had you pulling the engine to replace the control arms – yeah, that was a thing on multiple models for several years. Toyota has since updated their service information and the labor guides have adjusted accordingly. If someone is still getting quoted engine removal money then yeah – they’re being scammed for sure.

Stones4
Member
Stones4
1 month ago

On nightmares of my own doing, I was design engineer then the build/test engineer on a system that was installed onto an existing customer vehicle. We had the engine and transmission CAD and a rough box of the engine bay, but insufficient detail.

“Who designed this piece of shit?? oh yeah…that was me”

On headlights through the wheel well, my wife called me once so excited that she changed her own headlights! “It was so tricky, I had to weave my hand into the fender area around the wheel and that space was tiny!” I asked if she turned the wheels to give herself more clearance, she went silent and hung up on me

Cheap Bastard
Member
Cheap Bastard
1 month ago

how about a little thank you to us for making your car affordable in the first place?

Pretty sure those savings went into golden parachutes.

Joe The Drummer
Joe The Drummer
1 month ago

Re: Rockchips and his timing chains: eight of the most expensive words in wrenching are the dreaded “while you’re in there, you might as well…” Ow, my wallet.

Pappa P
Pappa P
1 month ago

Thing 1: When replacing a commonly failed part is a nightmare due to manufacturing cost saving measures, you didn’t make my car cheaper, you made it more expensive. Maybe it was easier for the dealer to sell but the depreciation is steep due to repair cost, so the cost of ownership is high.
No modern car should ever need new cylinder liners, unless big mistakes were made during design.
Thing 2: You’ll have to make some things inaccessible by necessity. Take a page from Toyota in 80s (Previa), and make sure those inaccessible components are designed in a way that they are unlikely to fail or need maintenance.
Thing 3: AI is coming for people like this.

Anoos
Member
Anoos
1 month ago

I didn’t have the chance to read through the large quantity of comments on that thread, so I thought it had been mentioned, but SUBARU VALVE COVERS need a mention.

Subaru insists on the stupid more expensive, less powerful and less efficient H4 vs an I4 setup.

Subarus (essentially) only sell in areas that have snow. That means they have road salt. Snow / salt slurry gets flung everywhere by the tires. That splash zone includes the valve cover (see my mention of the stupid H4 configuration).

So if you go to change the valve covers on a Subaru (which fail all the time – especially the plug donuts), you will find at least one bolt that will not cooperate.

So a job that takes an hour even on a car with all the silly plastic covers becomes a motor-out job for a home mechanic who doesn’t trust himself to use torches in the garage.

Anonymous Person
Anonymous Person
1 month ago

“What Brands Should Making Pickup Trucks Right Now That Aren’t?”
I see you still haven’t fixed that headline yet. 🙂

Autonerdery
Member
Autonerdery
1 month ago

Seeing all these oil filter horror stories makes me want to send cookies to Munich to thank BMW for always putting the oil filter right at the top/front of the engine and making it as easy to replace as it is to get to, as long as you’ve got the right oversized socket to open the housing.

Anoos
Member
Anoos
1 month ago
Reply to  Autonerdery

I’ve never owned a BMW but I may try now. Subaru (in spite of their infinite other shortfalls) has been really good with the oil filters on their newer engines.

I have to pull a wheel off my Miata to get to the oil filter.

Pappa P
Pappa P
1 month ago
Reply to  Anoos

I had leased WRX.
The car had to be on a hoist so you could lower the underbody shield to access the oil filter.

Anoos
Member
Anoos
1 month ago
Reply to  Pappa P

I wonder if they had to put it somewhere else on the turbo motors, but the filter in my FR-S and ’18 Forester were right up top at the front of the engine bay. I think those were both FA series engines (I could be wrong, I don;t really know subaru engine codes).

Pappa P
Pappa P
1 month ago
Reply to  Anoos

My Subarus were all EJ so that probably explains it. Most owners would cut a hole, but of course I was reluctant to do that on a leased car.

Nicklab
Member
Nicklab
1 month ago
Reply to  Pappa P

That’s strange, my 05 Legacy GT (similar if not same motor as the WRX) had 2 trap doors in the shield, 1 for the filter and 1 for the plug. I did a couple changes in the college parking lot with 2 chunks of 4×4 as “ramps”

Pappa P
Pappa P
1 month ago
Reply to  Nicklab

Mine was ’12 so I guess no trap doors was a later innovation, lol.

Rod Millington
Member
Rod Millington
1 month ago
Reply to  Autonerdery

As an added BMW benefit, you never need to worry about an oil change or subframe rust due to the oil leaks!

Mike F.
Member
Mike F.
1 month ago
Reply to  Autonerdery

Now if they could only make an oil filter housing gasket that doesn’t prematurely leak.

Dave Larkman
Dave Larkman
1 month ago
Reply to  Autonerdery

I sold my penultimate BMW because the next big job required undoing a bunch of single-use aluminium bolts threaded into the magnesium cylinder block to hold on the steel oil pan. That job had multiple bolt failures written all over it.

Pappa P
Pappa P
1 month ago
Reply to  Autonerdery

When that oil filter housing leaks, it wets the serpentine belt, then the crank pulley tries to eat the belt, then you won’t need an oil change because you’re doing an engine change.

LastStandard
LastStandard
1 month ago
Reply to  Autonerdery

Same thing on my Colorado diesel. Cartridge filter right on top of the engine, 27mm socket to remove – and they were smart and made the fuel filters use the same 27mm socket.

I don’t have to lift the truck to get under it, so it usually takes about 10 minutes for an oil change.

Spikersaurusrex
Member
Spikersaurusrex
1 month ago

“…the call will be made by accounting, not engineering.”

Darn it, Peter and the rest of you! Accountants don’t make the call, management does. Accounting provides cost data and management decides on their priorities. If management doesn’t give a fig about the repairability, that’s not on accounting.

Signed, An Accountant

Jack Trade
Member
Jack Trade
1 month ago

A great point. I always try to keep in mind that one of the things that’s great about my cars is…I can afford them.

Dave Larkman
Dave Larkman
1 month ago

Yep, the engineers do the engineering, the accountants do the numbers but all of the decisions are made by management.

If the engineers and accountants are good the management get to choose from a better range of options, but they also get to choose the engineers and accountants in the first place.

Littlebag
Member
Littlebag
1 month ago
Reply to  Dave Larkman

As a manager, I can tell you I absolutely do not get to choose my engineers, I got what I got and do the best I can with it. Some manager sometime got to pick them, but in big corporations it’s impossible to get rid of someone that’s just barely adequate.

Dave Larkman
Dave Larkman
1 month ago
Reply to  Littlebag

It took them 25 years to get rid of me…

Anoos
Member
Anoos
1 month ago

Although not accountants, can we lump management choosing to save $0.30 while adding hours to a service job ‘bean counters?’

I like that term. We should go back to it.

Besides, accountants may not even be involved in coming up with the production cost of a vehicle. The complete costs come from purchasing and production.

Can we stop blaming accountants and get back to blaming lawyers?

Spikersaurusrex
Member
Spikersaurusrex
1 month ago
Reply to  Anoos

Yes, we should definitely go back to blaming lawyers. It is all their fault.

Anoos
Member
Anoos
1 month ago

We should make this official. We need to amend the Autopian bylaws.

Someone call the Autopian lawyers so we can get this done.

Shit.

ClutchAbuse
Member
ClutchAbuse
1 month ago

Buddy of mine was an engineer at BMW. He worked on the i3. I asked him about this and he said that they tried their best to make things easy to repair but keeping cost down was always going to trump any repair convenience.

Dogpatch
Member
Dogpatch
1 month ago

I’d just be happy to have a physical dipstick to check oil .

Gene
Gene
1 month ago
Reply to  Dogpatch

Mike drop!

Rod Millington
Member
Rod Millington
1 month ago
Reply to  Dogpatch

I am a meat popsicle physical dipstick.

Dave Larkman
Dave Larkman
1 month ago
Reply to  Dogpatch

You owners have it easy. Imagine being a development engineer trying to set the oil level limits in a new engine and having to rely on prototype-level sensor calibration. It’s a nightmare.

A nightmare that is entirely caused by owners not bothering to check their oil level and needing an electronic safety net to avoid engine failures.

Jdoubledub
Member
Jdoubledub
1 month ago

I forgot to complain in the last thread.

My biggest pet peeve is all automative fasteners seem to be a fine pitch. So while I’m bent over like a pretzel trying to remove this impossible to reach bolt I just turn, and turn, and turn, and turn, and JESUS CHRIST WHY IS THIS FASTENER 5″ LONG TO HOLD A 2 oz. BRACKET AND HAS 100 THREADS PER INCH!!!!

Jack Trade
Member
Jack Trade
1 month ago
Reply to  Jdoubledub

Or even just seemingly randomly-sized for the purpose fasteners. My cars seem to have unnecessarily long bolts for the various battery holddowns. And what kills me is they’re Fords, well known for originally having spark plug threads that weren’t long enough. Really Ford, the battery box needs this but not a completely misson critical piece of hardware?!

Lotsofchops
Member
Lotsofchops
1 month ago
Reply to  Jack Trade

Stuff like that I assume they have a list of fasteners by cost, and they had a large quantity of those on-hand or supplied for another part. So hey, it works even if it’s overkill, and it’s $0.005 cheaper!

Dave Larkman
Dave Larkman
1 month ago
Reply to  Jack Trade

Some cars have optional larger batteries, so all cars get the long bolts just in case.

You never want to risk someone fitting too short a bolt and getting a failure.

Dave Larkman
Dave Larkman
1 month ago
Reply to  Jdoubledub

Fine threads give more clamp load for a given torque, so sometimes they are the only solution. And once you have one of them you definitely don’t want some moose on the production line cross threading a bunch of corse thread fasteners in there. So they tend to spread to all fasteners nearby to avoid quality issues.

45
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x