Since 2022, I’ve been spending one week out of each summer in Wisconsin to enjoy the Experimental Aircraft Association AirVenture Oshkosh Fly-In. While planes are the central focus of each AirVenture, RV camping is nearly just as huge, and most of the tens of thousands of people who set up in the on-site campground have to figure out how to generate their own electricity. For years, I slid a chunky yellow jobsite generator next to my RV. But this year, I parked a little red Predator 5000 Watt Dual-Fuel Super Quiet Inverter Generator next to my RV and, simply put, it was the best upgrade I’ve ever made.
I’ll admit right from the jump that, until now, I’ve made a really stupid mistake in the past. I’ve been a lifelong enjoyer of RVs and come from a family of RVers; however, the concept of “boondocking” – camping off-grid – is more recent to me. In the past, my family would always camp somewhere with electrical hookups at minimum, and if we didn’t, we had a motorhome with a built-in generator.
When I started camping on my own, my initial solution to needing power was hooking up an inverter to a car battery. Later, I upgraded to a lithium power station that continues to be my rock whenever I go tent camping. With the station and my solar panels, I’ve been able to make a tent feel practically luxurious.

Taking the family travel trailer (above) out to Oshkosh gave me a new challenge. My family’s travel trailers are a bit too large and power-hungry to feed from my power station in any realistic manner. The additional twist was that whatever I used to get juice, it needed to last an entire week.
(Full Disclosure: The folks of Harbor Freight sent me a Predator 5000 Watt Dual-Fuel Super Quiet Inverter Generator to review and compare against my Champion Power Equipment generator.)
I thought the answer was simple. When my wife and I went to the 2022 edition of the show, generators were hanging off practically every RV out there. Camp Scholler even has designated generator areas where tents aren’t allowed, and the expectation is that you’ll hear generators all 24 hours each day.

So, I just did what everyone else did and bought a generator. I went to my local Blain’s Farm & Fleet, dropped about $370 on a Champion Power Equipment 3650-Watt RV Ready Portable Generator, and was so proud of myself. My little yellow “genny” even had a built-in 30-Amp RV plug!
Then, I ripped the cord, firing the Champion into life the first time.
At first, I was thoroughly impressed. There was nothing that my family’s 2007 Adirondack 31BH could throw at the Champion that could make it skip a beat. Run the air-conditioner, microwave, a vacuum, and the electric water heater at the same time? The Champion handled it without breaking a sweat. I was then able to run that generator for a whole week and throw it into my garage, just to retrieve it a year later and do the same thing all over again. Basically, that generator wasn’t running unless I was subjecting it to running for a week straight, and the unit did it without complaint.

Last year, I even forced the generator to handle my family’s larger 2022 Mallard M33, a power-hungry pile of unreliability with a 50-Amp connection. The generator still didn’t complain. Instead, it was me who wore thin.
Something I did not consider when I bought the generator was the noise of the thing. It sounded like I was at a construction site, and honestly, the sound was inescapable. It didn’t matter where I was in the RV; I always heard the generator. Worse, if the generator was close enough to the trailer, it actually transferred vibration to the trailer. Remember, most RVs have nearly nothing for insulation and have the structural rigidity of wet paper, so it was all noise all the time.

However, the Champion generator sort of worked out in 2023 and 2024 because my campground neighbors had equally loud units. I also built a little shack out of plastic tables, and then blocked the generator with a pickup truck. That at least seemed to help filter the noise. I also killed the generator every sunset. But by 2025, my hacks weren’t enough. I had to face the truth that, while my generator was reliable, its loudness was simply unacceptable. I was the jerk running a jobsite generator in a campground, even if the generator pinky-promised that it was totally an RV generator.
A Better Way
This year, I vowed not to be that person again. Thankfully, the generator industry already figured this out a long time ago. If you need to generate power but can’t have that power generation be loud enough to drive you insane, that’s what an inverter generator (below) is for.

In a traditional generator, the engine turns an output shaft, which drives an alternator, producing alternating current (AC). That juice leads to a control panel and outlets. While this design is simple and very inexpensive to make, it requires the engine to run at a constant 3,600 RPM to reach and maintain the required 60 Hz frequency. That, as you can imagine, is loud.
Wen Products, a producer of power tools, explains what makes an inverter generator different:
The alternating current (AC) power produced by the alternator is sent to a rectifier, which is a device that converts the AC power to direct current (DC). This DC power is then inverted back to AC power by the computer inside the generator before it is sent to the control panel. This is where the name “inverter” comes from. Because the power to the control panel is controlled by the computer, inverter generators offer much lower total harmonic distortion (THD) than standard generators. THD is an important consideration when powering sensitive devices, like smartphones, tablets, computers, and televisions. These devices expect “clean” power (power that has low THD, like the wall power in your home), and can be damaged if they receive high-THD power.
[…]
Inverter generators are generally more compact than traditional generators, and are much quieter, but have lower maximum power outputs and are more expensive. There are two main sub-types of inverter generators: closed-frame and open-frame. Closed-frames are the most compact type of inverter generator, as well as the quietest. Their protective shell contains noise-absorbing insulation, significantly reducing their acoustic impact. They are usually portable and suitable for powering small loads. Open-frame inverter generators have no such insulation, and therefore are louder than closed-frames, but are still quieter than standard generators – usually about 50% quieter. Open-frame inverter generators produce power that is just as clean as closed-frame inverters, and may be capable of handling larger loads.
If you do not need the full capacity of your inverter generator, it can throttle down dramatically while still producing 60 Hz AC. That’s better for your ears, better for fuel economy, and really, just better for everyone.

When I started this new quest, I first looked at getting a Honda, which is generally considered the benchmark of this industry. The absolute cheapest Honda generator that should be compatible with the family’s older RV is the Honda EU3200i, which is good for 3200 watts of peak power for $2,799. That’s more than seven times the price I paid for the Champion, and it puts out less power. The next step up was the Honda EU7000iS, which costs a whopping $4,899. Like Honda motorcycles, these generators hold onto their value pretty well, too. I regularly see used EU3200i generators for sale for $2,000 with lots of hours on them.
Now, to be clear, you definitely get what you pay for with a Honda. They’re so quiet that sometimes I can’t even tell when one of the smaller Honda inverter generators is even running. Honda engines are also known for their legendary reliability.
As I thought about this more, I remembered all of the food trucks I’ve seen around home. Almost all of them have a big red Predator inverter generator strapped to their back. Over in Camp Scholler, it seemed like most RVs that didn’t sound like construction sites had a Predator nearby. Others had Hondas. Only a few had something like a WEN, a Champion, a Westinghouse, a Yamaha, or some brand I’ve never heard of.

So, I moseyed on over to Harbor Freight’s website. For $999.99, you can get an inverter generator with 5000 watts of peak power. Harbor Freight says this unit is comparable to the Honda EU3000IS, which costs $2,399, but the Predator’s spec sheet is better. On paper, this generator puts out 5000 starting watts and 3,900 running watts. In theory, that’s better than my old Champion.
What powers this generator is a Predator 224cc 6.6 HP single-cylinder air-cooled engine. Apparently, this engine isn’t exactly the same as the ones people plop down into go-karts, as its accoutrement is generator-specific. However, it does use the same proven platform.

Anyway, the generator sips either 87 octane fuel or propane, weighs 110 pounds, and can be started from a remote, a push-button, or via pull start. In terms of fuel economy, Harbor Freight says that the generator will drink up 3.7 gallons of fuel in 18 hours at a 25 percent load, or a 20-pound tank of propane in 14 hours.
In comparison, my Champion generator weighs 103 pounds, has 4,550 starting watts, 3,650 running watts, a 224cc single-cylinder engine, and a 4.7-gallon fuel tank. At half load, the generator is said to be able to run for 14 hours.
Of course, the whole reason I switched to the Predator? Noise. The Predator is rated for 61.7 dB at 23 feet with a 25 percent load, while the Champion chomps away at 68 dB from 23 feet away. As for the Honda EU3000IS that Harbor Freight says the Predator is comparable to? Honda says that runs between 50 dB and 57 dB depending on load. A Honda EU7000iS puts out between 52 dB and 58 dB.

Something to keep in mind is that an increase in decibels is on a logarithmic scale, not a linear one. A single-digit increase makes a larger actual difference than it appears. 60 dB is about the sound of a normal conversation, while 50 dB is about the sound of rainfall or an office. 70 dB is roughly the sound of a constantly running vacuum cleaner.

Mind you, when it comes to these generators, the standard is from 23 feet away, so they’re louder when you’re closer. In other words, my old Champion was about as loud as the average vacuum cleaner when you’re two dozen feet away from it.
So, how is the Predator like in real life?
It’s So Much Better To Use

Before I ran the unit, I first had to take it out of its box and prepare it for its first run. I was pleasantly surprised to see that the battery was already installed and setup was minimal. All I had to do was push the battery connectors together and then fill the machine with oil using the provided funnel. Then, I just hit the on switch, pressed the start button twice, and the generator started right up.
The whole generator is full of thoughtful design like this. There’s an oil drain plug, and the chassis of the generator has a built-in spillway for the exiting oil. The generator also sits on four rubber wheels with a built-in lock, has a few sturdy grab handles, and there’s even a sort of spillway for fuel when your stupid gas can splashes all over the place. I also like how, like other decent generators, the Predator will not run when the oil level is too low. I tested the function, and it works as advertised.

Some of these features made transportation far easier than the old Champion. Just the different carry handles alone were a big help. Then there were the wheels. In the past, I had to worry about my Champion generator sliding around the bed of whatever pickup truck I was reviewing.
But here? The generator stayed put thanks to the wheel lock and the rubber tires. I used suitcases as a sort of cushion, and they weren’t even needed.

Performance seemed to be great, too. The Predator had no issues chewing away at whatever we threw at it. Much like the Champion, the Predator had no issue working with the air conditioner, microwave, water pump, and electric heater all going at once. Fuel economy was roughly similar to the Champion, with us getting in the ballpark of 14 hours of runtime per tank. However, a notable difference is that the Predator used less fuel over the same 14 hours, so I didn’t feel like I was always needing to go to the gas station. That was refreshing.
The big question was sound. I goofed up and did not have a decibel meter with me, so I had to rely on my worn, subjective ears. However, I think that is probably good enough, because it’s not like you’d be walking around a campground with a decibel meter. You’d be hearing the generator with your ears, too.

The sound difference was night and day. In my experience, the Predator was indeed louder than the Hondas. It would seem that Honda is still the king of quiet. However, the construction site-style open-frame generators weren’t even in the same league as the Predator.
This time around, quite a few of our campsite neighbors had the super loud generators, and honestly, I couldn’t even hear the Predator over the roars of their generators. I was once this person; don’t be this person:

Thankfully, as Oshkosh cleared out toward the end of the event, Sheryl and I became a little island by ourselves. I was impressed that, from inside our camper, the Predator was little more than a hum in the background. When we turned on the RV’s air conditioner, the noise just blended in, and I couldn’t tell the generator was running. Only changes in load, like Sheryl running the microwave or turning on the electric water heater, changed the RPM enough for me to notice.
Walking around the unit itself, the loudest point was directly in the line of fire of the exhaust, which isn’t that surprising. Again, the Predator was noticeably louder than a Honda, but so much quieter than one of those open-frame mills.

Overall, I was impressed, and so was my sleep cycle. The old Champion was so loud that I turned it off at sunset, even in a 24-hour generator campsite. I just couldn’t sleep with the darn thing keeping a racket, even though the source was over 20 feet away. Once I closed the door to the camper’s main bedroom, the Predator faded away.
This Should Be The Baseline For RV Generators
I think I’ll go a step further. This Predator is such a huge improvement over the Champion that I now think the Champion shouldn’t even be on the market with an RV plug. The Champion is marketed as an RV generator, but using it for an RV will make you a giant jerk by filling the campsite or wilderness with the sounds of construction. Honestly, I’d find the Champion unacceptable even if I were entirely by myself.
To be clear, my old Champion was and remains a fantastic generator in terms of power delivery. Just use it for weather emergencies or on the jobsite, not for RVing near other people.

I believe in this so much that, when I decide to sell the Champion, it’s going to come with a detailed warning. It’ll say that, despite the RV marketing and the RV plug, it is not an RV generator unless you don’t care about the people around you.
I will acknowledge that, at current prices, the Champion is half the price of the Predator. But honestly, spend the money. You, your family, your sleep, and your campsite neighbors will thank you. Maybe if you don’t buy the Predator, buy some other inverter generator that’s not an open-frame design. If you can swing the cash, get a Honda and have the quietest RV around. Just don’t be the person with the jobsite generator ripping in a campground.
My biggest regret is not discovering these generators sooner. I mean what I say in the headline. Of all of the RV upgrades I’ve done, this was the best, and it’s not even close.
Top graphic images: Mercedes Streeter; NBC






Good info, need to talk to my neighbor about his power needs, i’ve got a honda clone and my neighbor has a jobsite unit, after a week of no power due to hurricane, that is an upgrade worth some money to me. :-)
Those cage generators are a pox. You can probably go a long way toward replacing generators with solar—or maybe replace them entirely. It would be interesting to run the numbers on that.
You absolutely can, though it’s a bit easier in a van than anything overly long. Trying to run dual or triple AC off of solar requires a lot of panel real estate and pretty significant battery capacity.
It’s doable-ish, but it’s definitely an investment. On the order of $5K-$20K depending on the specifics, even with how much lithium battery prices have dropped the last few years.
The noise is not even half of the reason to switch to an inverter type generator. It’s the gas usage.
I had an open frame generator and ran it a week. It used 5 gallons of gas every 4 hours or so. A neighbor had a Honda with the invertor and 5 gallons of gas would last them 2+ days depending on how much they loaded it.
In the world of electricity, there is an in-rush and a steady state current. A fridge might take 20A to kick on the compressor for a second or less and 4A to keep it running. For an old school generator, it makes 60 Hz for that fridge by holding the RPM at a constant 3600 rpm and drinking gasoline like crazy doing so. While the Invertor type uses the inverter to put out 60 Hz and the engine will drop down to idle when the fridge is drawing only 4A instead of 20A.
So, while an old generator goes WAHHHHHH 24/7, the inverter types go putt, put, put, PRFARRHT, put, put, put, put, put, put. This allows them to be significantly more fuel efficient than the old school generators, in addition to being quieter.
So, if you are using a generator for any length of time, the savings in fuel will offset the additional cost. If you start thinking about the hassle savings of not having to get 5-5 gallon jugs of gasoline a day to keep the power going (for 2 weeks in my case), then it doesn’t make sense to even consider the “cheaper” generator.
There are 2 reasons to sleep in a camping trailer. One of them involves going to the great outdoors and experiencing all it has to offer. To me, that’s camping. The other reason to sleep in a camping trailer is when it’s a cheaper and/or more convenient way to stay near the location or event you want to be near. That’s not camping, that’s a mobile hotel room. There’s nothing wrong with doing that, but my expectations of quietude from my neighbors is rather different when I’m in a campground vs. when I’m parked in a field of mobile hotel rooms.
Tip for ya: Since that’s a dual-fuel genny, you should put a Y splitter on your propane tank and run it off of that instead of gas. Never have to worry about gumming up the carb when you run it on propane.
The Predator generator instructions state that fuel stabilizer must be used or the warranty will be void.
That’s why you run it on propane. You don’t need fuel stabilizer.
Always use ethanol free gas, always put stabilizer in it. Always follow the instructions for winterizing it.
I won’t say always runs, but mine does.
20 lb bottle of propane how often? Good grief.
According to the spec sheet? Every 14 hours, probably every 11 hours in my use case. It’s easier to keep five gas cans around than five propane tanks, so I think gas works better in my use case.
I thought about that, but then I realized that, at the fuel economy of a 20-lb propane tank every 14 hours or less, I’d be practically living at the propane refill station. Or, I suppose I could buy lots of propane tank spares that I won’t use for 51 weeks out of a year. At least with gas, I can stock up on cans of the stuff and go multiple days without needing to go back to a station. Any gas I don’t use just goes into my cars or motorcycles.
If you’re living at the propane refill station, there’s probably an awning to park under when the camper leaks. 😉
Sorry, sorry, I’ll show myself out.
LOL!
Had you considered running a pair of inverter types?
Heard
Yeah, Propane is less energy dense and the generator will use more.
Propane as a source really only works if:
– someone has a large household tank (500+ gal) for their heat, and they want to plumb off of that
– As an emergency backup being able to use a grill tank when you run out of gas.
I’ve had an open frame generator for several years, and it is louder than I would like.
Recently I picked up several Predator power stations (600s, 1200s) and placed them around the house for lights, fans, internet, etc. They charge from AC in under two hours and will hold at 100% for a few months.
For bigger issues, I bought a Predator 3500 inverter generator and a nice-sized window AC unit. Harbor Freight also sells a flat(-ish) extension cord – supposed to go under doors – to turn the 30A socket on the generator into three household outlets. In theory I can put the generator under the deck table and run the cord into the house, and then distribute power from there. The window AC should keep the first floor tolerable (knock on wood, fingers crossed, etc) if necessary.
A couple things.
There are interlock kits for generators. You flip a switch and it turns off the mains and turns the house circuits are powered by the generator. This allows you to use the circuits in the house to power the outlets. Well, some of the outlets.
My dad had a generator in the garage (with an exhaust pipe out of the garage) that was on an interlock. When the power failed, he would go to the garage, flip a big switch, go to the electrical box and turn off everything. Then he would start the generator and turn on the circuits that were marked with little red dot stickers one at a time, waiting for the generator to calm down after each switch was turned on.
If you want to get fancy, do a power inventory of your house. Look up what draw you have on each circuit and make decisions on what to turn on or not and when to have those circuits on.
A big thing is that with an interlock you can run your house easily with the electrical panel.
(Oh, there are ways to back feed your panel, but they are illegal and dangerous. The issue is that if you are back feeding the panel and the switch to the mains is on, then you are back feeding the pole. I’ve talked to linesman, and after a storm it is very common for them to find power on a pole that is not connected to the main line from someone doing an illegal back feeding of the generator to the pole. It’s dangerous as hell to a tired crew. Which is why you are always supposed to use an interlock where if the generator is on, the main switch cannot be on.)
I was already aware of all that (except what your dad did) but thank you. 🙂 (Brother is an electrician)
It’s easier this way ^^^ to provide temporary power where it’s needed if necessary. The house central AC (discrete units for upstairs and downstairs) would require a significantly larger generator and accoutrement, which I’m not really interested in doing.
Dad’s panel had red stickers for the regular 120V circuits and not the big draws. When I ran a house on a generator, I would go to the panel a couple times a day to switch what circuits were on. I had a big enough generator that I could turn on the hot water heater (4500W), after I turned off the microwave (3000W) and the circuit with the kid’s computer on it (500W). It allowed me to actively pick what circuits were powered at all times. The HVAC was NEVER powered, but all the lights and fans in each room were.
I seem to remember it’s either illegal or ppl are trying to make it illegal to sell a cord with male plugs on each end. The only reason you’d need one is to do what you described, which kills people.
Or pairing two generators.
I don’t see how that would work. AC power isn’t a stable 120/240V, but a sine wave from +120 to -120 and back again. The peaks and valleys have to happen at the exact same time with more than one generator, or one generator will force the other to that their timing. Which is a quick way to grenade a generator.
Cue someone showing me a picture of a set of big diesel generators all running on the same circuit. Yep, I had Aggreko hook up 4 generators for a project once. It took them an hour to fire them all up with the steps required to make sure that they matched phase so they all put out the same timing of the 50 Hz sine waves I needed (The 50 Hz was a requirement because the equipment was bound for Europe. and it was cheaper to rent a pile of generators and run them at 50 Hz for a short test).
Just taking two Predator generators and daisy chaining them is a quick way to have one Predator generator and a small fire.
I don’t know if the Predator cloned the EU system.
I’ve never looked into the dual system, but they have been doing it for years.
They would have to sync up the frequency somehow.
Honda now makes a companion version that isn’t required.
It simply makes it easier.
I think a better way to handle too high a load for a generator would be to have a generator and a battery. Electrical devices have an inrush current and a steady draw current. You have to size the generators to take the inrush current and the steady draw current is typically 3-4 times lower. If you had a generator with a battery in parallel, then it could handle an inrush twice as high as the current it can generate and then have plenty of juice to recharge the battery quickly before the next inrush current hit. Shouldn’t have any problems with phase matching and the like.
Looking it up, Honda Generators can be paired with a special cable and an app. I expect this capability is another reason that Honda generators are more expensive than other brands.
This. Batteries are fairly cheap now and I think such a system could tie nicely with other home electricity generating systems (e.g. solar).
In my ideal world that whole house electricity and heat providing generator would be the backup family car/truck/motorcycle too :).
I have three plans. However, there is the right way to handle a storm.
I’ve been through the aftermath of a major tornado outbreak, including a long track EF5 passing within a couple miles of my house. The weather channel was hyping up TOR:CON 10 for days prior to the event and I was laughing that at least I would get the grass watered. Didn’t know I would have no power for 3 weeks and trauma for the entire family where all of us are still jumpy when we hear sirens.
2-3 years ago, my sister-in-law in Florida was in the cone for a major hurricane. We have a spare room and my wife and I put leverage on her to not to try to ride this out. She had been through dozens of Hurricane scares and she figured it was a waste of time to come visit, but we finally convinced her. She showed up a day before the storm hit her area. Her house was fine. However, major flooding had water right up to the door step.. for about a week and no power for about a month. She heard about it, but didn’t live thorugh it, because she was with my wife and I over 500 miles away.
So plan A is to leave. Not all bad weather can be predicted, but if it is, having a generator is still a lot less nice than being in a VRBO 500 miles away.
I dunno if you follow Kevin Rhodes here. He’s shared some of his experiences building his new home in rural Florida using prefab steel construction that I find very intriguing. R20 walls, R40 roof, raised foundation (per building code) hurricane resistant and steel framed so no termites or rot to worry about.
I asked him about his plans for a generator and he’s confident his solar and battery wall will handle everything even through post hurricane power losses, thanks to the insulation, reflective roof, LED lighting and energy-efficient appliances. And yes, he’s confident his solar setup will survive the hurricane.
I think if I lived in extreme weather country like you, your family and he do that’s the route I’d take.
I’ve moved since I was right on the path of Dixie Alley. I’ve been at my new to me house for about 10 years now and other than a power outage caused by a drunk driver, I’ve not had a blip in power that lasted over an hour.
My way of saying I’m fairly safe feeling is that not long after I moved in, I had to have three Bradford Pears removed. All were closing in in 75 feet. This house must not have gotten much more than a stiff breeze for 30+ years to get them that big.
There are a lot of copies of the Honda, but the known name brands aren’t that much cheaper. With resale often matching or exceeding retail, Honda seemed the choice.
Buying two I can pick up myself, and on a two wheeler shuttle around quickly, is an easy choice compared to a larger one.
I got mine at Northern tool at a discount.
Northern actually started by building their own generators using Honda engines.
I shop Northern Tool over Harbor Freight.
Both have house brands that are of unknown quality that sell for a similar price. The difference is that NT will have real brands right next to their house brands and it sometimes isn’t worth getting the house brand.
First time I went there I needed a big ass socket (something to do with a water heater I think). I was shocked to see I could get a Proto socket for $1 more than their house brand and I know Proto is a serious brand (the guys at work trust it more than Snap On for some reason).
Then when I have gotten a house brand, I’ve been impressed with NT. Never had a problem with a NT off-brand, have had problems with HF off-brands.
They carry Grey impact sockets, semi USA made and very reasonable.
I ended up needing a torque bar, but kept the 8mm swivel impact I ordered through northern.
I have northern torque multipliers, at a fraction of the proto cost.
Not as complex, but $$$ less.
I’ve only broken one of their lifetime klutch tools, and I was leaning on a one metre breaker bar when I snapped a half inch extension. Whoops!
They make flat wire for special purposes.
It’s intended for permanent use I think.
“I’ve had an open frame generator for several years, and it is louder than I would like”
There are aftermarket generator mufflers available that are supposed to be very effective at cutting down noise:
https://wsaparts.com/quiet-muffler-for-generator/
I will have a look – thank you!
Speedway motors often has a wild selection of low priced mufflers.
You might also think about enclosing it in a muffled box, I suggest rock wool as the insulator over fiberglass as it’s rigid, hydrophobic, non flammable and cheap .
I dunno how much airflow it needs and whether it can just inhale the heated air drawing in cool air that way or if it would need a fan.
Usually you need an open top.
Reflecting sound away is more successful when it’s an option.
I’ve thought about buying a dual fuel generator for emergenices at the house (there are conversion kits to plumb into a natural gas line available for many. Then I recall that in 16 yrs so far I have never been without power for more than an hour or so.
Ditto – I keep running into generators on sale at Costco and have plenty of “would be nice if” and “could be handy for” situations, but have never had a power outage in the 12 years I’ve lived in this neighborhood (not more than a couple of minutes, anyway).
If I had Natural gas in my neighborhood (still waiting), I would put in a natural gas fired whole house generator. People have talked about having a propane fired one, but that sounds like too much work.
I’m also hoping that ISO 15118-20 becomes the norm soon. That is an international standard for V2H (Vehicle To Home) for EVs. GM, Ford, Tesla and Kia/Hyundai all have V2H systems, but they lock you in to their brand. If the ISO standard takes off, then you could use your EV as a battery back up to your house regardless of the manufacturer. I also expect that if there was an ISO standard, then the cost of the equipment to do V2H would be a ton cheaper than it is for GM, Ford, Tesa, etc. is today.
Keep in mind the efficiency of such small generators it absolutely, positively terrible. This one is only about 11.3% efficient at 25% load running on propane. That’s not even as good as a flathead v8 from the 1930s! And there is no practical way to harness the waste heat other than indirectly.
By comparison a modern Prius engine is 41% efficient and Chery has a car engine certified at a bit over 48%. They got that efficiency by taking the Atkinson cycle even further. I wish these generator manufacturers would put in some effort into making their products more efficient, especially since auto manufacturers have already done the hard work.
Yeah, they are basically lawnmower engines. Which makes me think V2H is a great solution. Especially if you have two EVs with a reasonable amount of range. Run Car 1 until it is 20% charged and go find a Fast charger while Car 2 runs the house. Rinse and repeat.
That’s basically my dream except replace “Fast charger” with “unguarded free EV chargers in the employee parking lot”.
I ain’t got time for dat, although having 2 EVs means that we could turn off the power, drive to a Level 2 charger and plug in the spent car and drive back the charged one.
Obviously my dream works best when it’s your own employer’s parking lot and your still seething over their draconian RTO policy.
Yeah, I’ve never needed to use a generator for emergency power, either. The only time my apartment has lost power in the 8 years I’ve lived here was when a drunk driver knocked over a power box, killing power to the whole neighborhood for a few hours.
I lost power for almost 3 weeks from a tornado and a week to a drunk driver hitting a pole. Lose power a couple hours each spring or fall from trees coming down in storms every year.
When something knocks out power to 1,000+ houses, it’s usually not for long (save tornados and such). But if it’s just your block….yeah, they’ll get to it when they get to it…
This is the key factor
My wife and I grew up 4 miles apart. We lived in a subdivision in the burbs and her family was a few miles farther out in a farming community. There were about 8 house on her street that was 3 miles long. Her father had a generator because when winter storms knocked out power and it would be out for a week or more. I can’t remember having power out for more than 24 hours.
My current house is in a subdivision with underground electrical service. In 10 years we have never been without power for more than 4 hours and those were scheduled outages.
The time I lost power from a drunk, the drunk hit a pole and snapped it off and killed power to two subdivisions. One was full of multi-million dollar homes, one was not. My backdoor neighbor is on the line for the multimillion dollar homes and had power restored within hours. It took almost a week to restore power to my house.
For the first, it wasn’t a tornado. It was 27. The linesmen that restored power to my area were French Canadians, we had people from all over North America putting in new Poles and wires. I saw trucks from Canada, Mexico, California, Washington, Maine, you name it.
The biggest problem wasn’t actually the local poles (which we lost hundreds). It was the high tension wires feeding the city.
Way back when, TVA went to put in high tension wires and found a nice path through the forest where a large tornado had touched down and ate the trees going into Huntsville in a perfectly straight line for miles. So, they didn’t have to clear trees to put in the towers. An EF5 followed that exact same path 60+ years later. Exact in that the center of the storm was right on top of the towers for miles. Some of the towers were screwed into the ground, some were just gone. All had to rebuilt to run the main feeder lines to town.
“An EF5 followed that exact same path 60+ years later. Exact in that the center of the storm was right on top of the towers for miles. Some of the towers were screwed into the ground, some were just gone.”
That must have been quite a sight to see.
Wasn’t there, but from my kid’s reports that were less than a mile away, the sky turned emerald green. Then the creek blocked up and the house started to flood and they had to wade out to some vehicles and flee.
In Twister, they describe EF5 destruction as “finger of god”. That’s not even close to true. The movie showed EF4 damage at best.
EF5 damage is Plowed field.
We helped some neighbors just up the road from where my kids were with some friends. Their all brick homes looked like they had taken Civil war cannon fire. Broken windows, blown in doors, cars in piles around the neighborhood. I was helping an older couple (simple stuff, just hanging out and talking with them as they charged their cell phones so they could call family) and the guy kept pointing at the field across the street where the news vans were setup and videoing the destruction. It took me a while to understand that that plowed field that was ready for Cotton to be planted was the center of the EF5 path. There had been homes over there. There was no sign of them. It took the trees, the grass, the pavement, everything. There were a couple slabs left of the cheaper slab homes and half a basement of the biggest home, but not a thing else.
One of the many reasons were I to find myself living in the Midwest my dream home would be a luxury refurbished missile silo.
I remember working at Canadian Tire (Canada’s hardware store) in the months leading up to the new Millennium.
There was a lot of speculation that all computers would stop working on January 1st, and massive power outages would result.
We cleared a whole aisle and filled it with generators.
Even with that level of power outage hysteria, we had very few takers.
My mother lives in a semi rural PG&E service area with no gas service. Her power has been off for nearly two weeks at a time as a PLANNED outage. This was in the hottest time of the year too. She had to make do with my camping gear and eating out a lot.
Cool story bro but what the point? It’s that I like to take every opportunity to remind the world that PG&E fucking SUCKS!
When, oh when will vehicle builders make a Sprinter-scale hybrid? Please!!! Then campers can use it to provide quiet power using a already-maintained power system instead of dragging around a separate generator (that needs maintenance). I know, I know, I whine about this every chance I get. Also we need a better term to replace “Sprinter-scale” to call out a vehicle of such size. I would daily a plug-in hybrid RV.
Ford’s F-150 Hybrid has either a 2.4 kW AC output (two 120V/20A outlets) or a 7.2 kW system (four 120V/20A outlets and a 240V/30amp (NEMA 14-30))
It’s a great start. Now program the engine to run in generator mode *just* steadily enough so that each cylinder firing does so at peak fuel efficiency but firing those cylinders just often enough to match the draw with the battery cushioning the worst of the ebbs and surges.
Bonus points for an additional heat exchanger to allow the RV’s HVAC to utilize the engine’s waste heat.
I suspect it simply discharges from the battery and then at a set SOC the engine kicks on and charges the battery back up. At least that is how my Prius handled things.
Probably which is harder on both the battery and the engine. Better to run the engine constantly in a way that matches the load but also keeps the cylinder firing in its sweet spot while also keeping the battery as a buffer and a reserve.
If cylinder deactivation was both easier on the engine and cost effective hybrids would use that tech instead of turning on the engine and running it near peak efficiency.
One of the nice things about hybrids is you don’t need all that extra complexity to get excellent fuel economy.
The Lightning is AFAIK the first hybrid with V2X generator capability and it’s a party trick. Give it time. I think eventually manufacturers chasing gains will pull cylinder deactivation out of the corporate parts bin and into their hybrids too, especially if RV owners tell them they want to use their tow pig truck as a fuel efficient, low emissions generator.
The concept of using a hybrid as a generator is decades old. There have been aftermarket kits for Toyota hybrids for 20 years. This isn’t a new idea that manufacturers are just learning about. (When I had my 2005 Prius I got an inverter to use it as an emergency generator)
That said, generator use isn’t different than other loads. For example even my Prius had a mode that would let you turn on the A/C while the car was off and it would run off the battery and then cycle the engine on and off to charge the battery. People used it for pets or to sleep in the car on hot humid summer nights.
As to efficiency. Running one cylinder and spinning the rest of the rotating assembly continuously has to be pretty inefficient vs running the engine at peak efficiency for a short period of time and then cycling it off. I personally expect the hybrid future to be larger batteries, bigger motors, and smaller engines.
I see a few advantages to cylinder deactivation vs start and stop:
1) Fewer cold starts. Almost all engine wear happens when the engine starts cold. If the load is low enough the battery might not need a recharge till the engine is cold and the oil has gone back in the pan. Emissions are also highest at cold starts and engine efficiency is lowest. Use of an electric oil pump and block heater could mitigate this advantage though so since the ECU can plan several minutes ahead of time for a restart.
2) Constant *free* waste heat. Useful in cold weather, especially if its tapped for the RV. Even one cylinder firing occasionally should be enough to keep an RV toasty in mild weather.
3) Quieter operation. Probably not much of an issue except in a nighttime campground.
4) Higher efficiency (maybe). Cylinder deactivation allows output to closer match load.
You might be right, this may be a case of diminishing returns but until someone tries it we’ll never know.
Cold starts could be a problem with a large battery pack but like you said there are solutions.
The free waste heat would be rather limited with efficient engines and low loads. My 2003 Jetta TDI could not keep the cabin warm when idling in the winter time because it simply did not produce enough waste heat. I had to rev the engine to keep warm.
Yes, there are a lot of diminishing returns. When we look at hitting efficiency targets there are dozens of little things that get looked at and evaluated. Combined they add up to significant savings but most don’t make the cut because math doesn’t work.
Here’s the maths:
A small diesel engine like a 2.0L TDI consumes about 0.9L/h idling:
https://www.omnicalculator.com/everyday-life/idling-fuel-consumption
At idle that car is not moving. So 100% of the energy is going into heating the engine and the exhaust. Diesel fuel contains 10.65 kWh/L of energy.
https://afdc.energy.gov/fuels/properties
So at idle your TDI was effectively a 10kW heater. That’s at least DOUBLE what a home oven uses:
https://www.easylifeappliances.com/how-much-power-does-an-electric-oven-use-per-hour/
So that certainly enough to literally roast you in a space as small as a car’s cabin. The problem wasn’t that the engine wasn’t putting out enough idle heat. The problem is cars are designed to shed it that heat, not harness it effectively.
To capture that 10 kW of heat you not only have to capture all the heat that goes into the cooling system but also all the heat from the block and all the heat that goes out the exhaust. That simply will not happen.
You also need to collect the heat off the block and in the exhaust in a way that a small exhaust leak doesn’t kill the occupants of the RV. You also have to do it in a way that when it is hot outside the engine isn’t heating the RV. This is especially problematic as the electrical highest load by far in an RV is running A/C.
You have to do this all in a way that the extra cost of all this install and maintain this complex system is lower than the cost of simply heating the RV when it is cold. Don’t forget that the extra weight will reduce fuel economy and the extra bulk will cut into living space in the RV.
Again there is the reality of diminishing returns. There is a reason that Class 8s with sleeper cabs heat the sleeper with a small diesel heater instead of a trying to capture heat off the engine.
I doubt it’s as hard or as dangerous as you fear.
The engine bay can be insulated to put all the heat into the coolant and exhaust. The coolant heat alone is a lot and the engine radiator is already there, designed to keep the engine cool under the worst conditions which is overkill^overkill for generator duty. Use that radiator as a giant heater core, ducting the hot air inside the RV rather than dumping it outside when needed. That’s no less safe than how billions of cars have been keeping occupants warm for over a hundred years, just supersized.
Harnessing the exhaust heat (if even necessary) is done the same way, wrapping the exhaust with cooling lines (or blowing the exhaust across a heater core) to move that heat into a second core inside the cabin, the water heater or if you want to get fancy as floor heating would harness a lot of heat from the exhaust.
You’d control temperature exactly as you do now, with thermostats. Only as much heat is harnessed as is needed, the rest is dumped just as it is now.
If you’re worried about exhaust fume buildup I think the natural pumping of the engine can be utilized to ensure fresh air is drawn into the engine bay and potentially contaminated air is simply burned, essentially a variation of EGR.
The heat is there for the taking. Use it.
“The heat is there for the taking. Use it.”
The problem is that taking it costs money. Taking the waste heat has to cost less than simply using a heater.
One thing to note- that seems to be an issue on virtually all of the cheaper inverter generators- the muffler outlet screens they use can and will clog up over time, resulting in them being hard to start, running rough, and lack of power. Buddy has the smaller (I think 3000w) version of the Predator generator for his RV. It’s just enough to run the AC, but not a ton more. Every like 10-15hrs the muffler screen has to be removed and cleared out with some brake cleaner or it starts running like crap. It almost plugs solid with carbon deposits. Despite HF slapping about 30 warning stickers and reminders all over everything (CHECK OIL EVERY HOUR OR WARRANTY VOID) and all sorts of other goofy stuff nobody will do, they neglected to mention that, and “clean the muffler” sounds like something you’d tell a rookie to do on his first day on the job.
Next in the boondocking experience…..full solar and lithium battery setup.
We still have our small 2000 watt (peak) quiet generator, but almost never use it.
Amazing what solar and lithium can do today. And, at surprisingly little cost if you buy things on sale and DIY the install.
We have 1600 watts roof mount and 400 watts ground deploy solar.
840 amp hours of battery bank.
Very important…..the new Chill Cube Air Con. It can run at different power consumption. 600, 900, & 1200 watts of draw…..much more efficient that the old style roof mount AC units.
Yes, Air Con with totally quiet solar power isn’t just possible, it is possible at a surprisingly cheap price.
The Victron inverter is also a neat bit of kit. It can boost a small generator to allow our 1600 watt continuous generator to run the air con, microwave and other items all simultaneously. It can boost a standard 110 volt 15 amp outlet to power our entire RV.
It opens up many possibilities for boondocking, sites like Harvest Host, and even if going to a site with full hookups, we run the air con on the road and arrive to a nice, cool RV. A great thing when it is near 100 degrees outside.
It would be a long post to describe our full setup, and there are folks with much larger systems that have spent much more $$$. We sized our system to allow solar to provide our needs 85-90% of the time with occasional use of the tiny inverter generator. That last 10% can get very expensive.Yes, this system is more expensive than just a generator, but it allows for supplement with a very small generator if needed, and a huge amount of flexibility.
PS, for those wondering, I was able to build our solar system by waiting for sales and deals for around $3,500……
I think for 90% of people, this is a great plan. But for 10% or so, it isn’t. It depends on where and when you use your RV.
I follow a couple narrowboaters in the UK. Narrowboating is basically a floating, extremely slow RV. For the narrowboaters that cruise in the summer and dock up with shore power in the winter, Solar is amazing. Some are able to not just power everything in the boat, but even the boat itself with nothing but solar panels. However, in the winter, with the short days and the low sun angles, they generate nearly nothing for power, so they have to park their boats. Admittedly, the UK is VERY north with very short winter days. But I would assume that an RVer in Arizona in summer would do much better with Solar than someone in Maine in Midwinter.
What is a chill cube?
It is basically a minisplit system that fits the standard RV roof opening. 14″X14″. It replaces the standard RV roof top AC unit and is 30-35% more efficient. The standard roof top unit pulls 1500 watts to produce 15,000 btu of cooling. At 1400 watts, the Chill Cube does 18,000 btu.
But, the beauty of the Chill Cube is that it is inverter driven and can run at variable speeds. You can manually select 50% (around 9000 btu – 600 watts) or 75% (12,000 btu – 900 watts). This makes it much better for solar. On all but the hottest days, 75% is plenty in our RV. 50% is plenty most nights. At its lowest power draw, I have seen 200ish watts from the Chill Cube. Suddenly, RV AC on solar is possible!
Interesting
Put this in Mercedes’s suggestion box to review next.
It is available on some of the supposedly “better” RV brands now. Brinkley, Alliance, etc.
It is Furrion……unfortunately another Lippert product for RVs, but this one seems to be decently made.
My wife and I both WFH. While we haven’t embraced the sell everything and live in an RV, we do live & often work from an RV often.
Do RVs make sense for the folks that pay to store them and use them at most 1-2 weeks a year? I don’t think so, but hey, you do you.
We store ours under a pole barn on our property and use it 45-60 nights most years. Couldn’t afford Vrbo and the like for that many nights. But, $30 a night for National, State, & Local parks or COE sites, sure!
The F-150 Hybrid with 7.2KW “Pro Power” system can completely replace these generators, and I’m sure it would be much much quieter. Also, the emissions are far fewer, I’m guessing the efficiency is higher, the fuel is already onboard, and the engine will only run when the on-board battery is depleted or when demand peaks. And, it doesn’t put “miles” on your truck.
This! But bump the output 2-3x to be able to run the whole (large) house. Maybe have a “Prepper” trim level with tri fuel capability, a more efficient generator mode and taps into the cooling system to transfer the waste heat to the home/RV/reenforced nuclear bunker HVAC system too.
I just bought one of these exact models last week to replace my old Troy-Bilt 5500W generator for emergency house backup in case of power outage.
I no longer needed 240V as I don’t live on a well anymore and I just needed 120V power for frigerators, freezer, lights, tv, internet, and a couple portable heaters for winter, and a portable room AC for summer. This has plenty of power for this.
This new one is amazingly quiet, I can’t even hear it inside my house. We are ready for hurricane season!
A suggestion, don’t skip on the 220V if you haven’t yet. Get an interlock on your main panel and plug it in. Don’t have to run extension cords all over, just power the house through the existing circuits. My dad did that after his first power outage from a storm.
I have a transfer switch and the 10 circuits I want tied into that. I just am not going to buy a generator large enough to run two 2.5 ton AC/Heat Pumps. That’s all I would ever need 220V for.
What I meant is that you run the 220V plug from the generator to the panel (through a transfer switch) and then have the panel split it to the 110V that you want. It’s a lot better than having a dozens extension cords running around.
Back when I did that for 2 weeks, I had 5700W. I figured that as long as we didn’t run the microwave and blowdriver and high end gaming computer, we could stay under 1200W on 120V circuits for the entire house (not a huge house). Since I had 5700W, I could pick the microwave (3kW), the Hot Water heater (4.5kW) or a single burner on the range (3kW) to run in addition to all the 120W.
A quiet generator is appreciated by all. The efficiency is truly awful though:
The spec sheet says this generator puts out a maximum of 3600W on propane. It will run for 14.6 hours @25% of that max power on 20# of propane.
Propane has an energy content of 5.8kWh/lb so a tank of propane contains 116kWh of energy. The generator running at 25% max power turns that 20# of propane into 13,140Wh of energy which is only 11.3% efficiency. To add insult the rest of that energy is thrown away as heat to the air, not even harnessed to cook food, boil water or just to heat the trailer.
We can do WAY better than this! Even a generator using 20 yo Prius technology would be three and a half times as efficient and be liquid cooled so at least some of the waste heat could be put to use too AND it would be way quieter too boot. Add in battery storage for quiet hours and as a buffer to keep the generator in its happy place.
what is the make and model of this generator you speak of?
The Predator that is the topic of this story.
Apparently, hybrid generators do exist, but they’re about the size of a generator trailer. It would be cool to see one in a smaller form factor!
It certainly would. Something to bug RV manufacturers about whenever you get the chance ;).
(I think a good starting point would be a surplus BMW i3 REX. Those are relatively compact, about 32% TE and I think would be relatively easy to modify)
technically there’s no such thing as an i3 REX engine since it’s just a drop-in scooter motor.
Technically it’s more than a drop in scooter motor since in the BMW it’s not ever driving the wheels but exclusively driving a generator. I imagine BMW also adjusted the cam profile and engine tuning as well to get that efficiency.
Thanks for answering the question but how does it run on propane? Maybe for a food truck where it is mostly just running the fans and there is large propane tank it does not matter.
You hook it up to a tank of propane. The carburetor is designed to work with propane. And of course it matters. It’s cheaper than gasoline energywise, cleaner burning too but even so propane isn’t free.
(I do wonder if the exhaust is hot enough to use as a source of heat for those fryers though.)
As long as the 100# tank on the truck lasts all day, it only matters if the generator itself is cheaper to buy and repair than another more expensive generator that has a slightly higher efficiency. Cheap can buy a lot of extra propane.
11.3% to 41% is quite a bit more than a “slightly higher efficiency”. That’s the difference between that tank lasting all day and lasting most of the week. If that generator is your main source of daily power that cost is going to add up fast, especially if you also use propane for heating. Even more so if you’re set up in a remote area and you have to travel far to get a refill.
So what would that cost be? Probably not as much as you think. Most of the parts would be off the shelf or adapted from existing motors. We are talking about tech that’s been mass produced for nearly 30 years after all.
I think the future is propane fuel cells with bigger batteries. Quieter and higher efficiency than even a Prius engine.
There are some propane conversion on the Prius forums. Seems it cost some dude $1000 to get it converted at a shop in Romania. Definitely possible, but efficiency will take a hit after inverter losses. Also the Prius engine seems big and heavy for how much electricity it can generate with the standard equipment.
You are certainly correct in that fuel cells are more efficient, simpler, quieter and vibration free. All else equal they’d be my choice too.
However despite the promise of such game changing there seems to be a conspicuous absence of small propane/natural gas fuel cells on the market. From what I have been able to gather there are still significant issues with generator startup times and costs. Odorants may also be a problem; catalysts tend to be easily poisoned and the ethyl mercaptan odorant in propane is a known fuel cell poison. These are less problematic for ICE based generators.
So rather than holding our collective breath until perfect finally comes along I propose we go with something much, much better than the abysmal we have now which would be more efficient ICE based generators.
“Also the Prius engine seems big and heavy for how much electricity it can generate with the standard equipment.”
A standard Prius engine is overkill for running an RV or a food truck. Mercedes seems happy with this generator for her giant RV which is limited to a max of 3600W or about 5 HP of engine output. This generator is a single cylinder with a displacement of 224cc.
I am thinking a single cylinder engine using Priuslike parts and tech using hit and miss firing should be plenty thanks to the dramatically higher efficiency. Since the smallest Prius engine that I know of was the original 1.5L that would mean about 375cc of displacement but there may be smaller engines from other manufacturers in other markets that will work even better.
Mind you an Atkinson cycle engine needs more displacement than an Otto cycle engine of the same power due to the smaller intake stroke. So I think a single Priuslike cylinder might still be overkill but it could also mean it’s very under stressed and longer lasting.
As to the inverter I think an inverter might not even be needed if the generator is an AC design and designed to maintain the correct frequency.
They make power backups for semi trucks already.
That might fit your purpose.
That is a good point as they are much more efficient. This one for example has a max efficiency of about 25%:
https://www.wincogen.com/product/ec6010ke-03-b/
The problems I see with it is:
1) it uses diesel, not gasoline/propane/NG
2) it is very expensive.
3) its still very inefficient for a diesel. 25% is comparable to a 1980s gasoline powered Otto cycle car engine.
I think a generator intended for RVs and emergency backup needs to primarily run on propane or natural gas with gasoline as an option. Propane and natural gas have an indefinite storage life so they will not gum up even after sitting for a decade. It’s also very convenient to just feed an emergency generator piped natural gas with a tank of propane on hand if the gas cuts out.
I also think a generator like this has to be cheap, compact and relatively lightweight as well as quiet. At this point I don’t think a Prius like small engine needs to be that much more expensive to manufacture than a shitty engine since the auto industry has already done the lions share of development and CNC manufacturing is a thing. Use as many off the shelf parts as possible and adapt from existing designs for the parts that need to be made. China excels at doing exactly this.
“there seems to be a conspicuous absence of small propane/natural gas fuel cells on the market.”
It looks like there is a company now called Redwire that has sold thousands, mostly for backup power at railroad crossings. There is also the Watt Nomad where they have a picture of it already installed in an RV. I do not like how you have to contact them for the price, but I do not think we are going to have to wait that many years for the price to be reasonable.
I was not aware of those, thank you.
Looking at the spec sheets I can see some potential issues.
Redwire Endurance: “Zero Routine MaintenanceRun continuously for up to 15,000 hours or 15 cycles with no routine maintenance required”
But will need maintenance after 15 cycles which depending on what that means may be a deal breaker for domestic and RV use
The Predator: “Low-maintenance: only at 3,000-hour intervals” and “Can cycle at least 250 times for 3000 hours”
That’s a bit tricky to understand. Does it mean unlimited starts and stops are OK as long as it’s maintained every 3000 hours? Or must it be in continuous operation for that 3000 hours to reach that interval?
Power Output: Provides constant 250W or 1kW output with no degradation at end of life.
Runtime: Runs up to 80hr on 20lbs of propane
They don’t specify which that applies to but I’m assuming they mean the 250W model. If so that 20# of propane contains 126kWh of energy 250W over 80 hours is 20kWh of power for an efficiency of 16%, which is truly horrific for a fuel cell, not much better than the Predator. If however they mean the 1kW model then the efficiency is 63% which would be excellent and much more in line with other commercial fuel cells.
Now how about the Watt Nomad?
From their spec sheet:
Max Gas (propane) Consumption:
500W – 0.36 lbs/hr -> 22% efficiency
1250W – 0.68lbs/hr -> 29% efficiency
https://wattfuelcell.com/wp-content/uploads/WATT-NOMAD-specifications-sheet.pdf
Which is much better than the Predator but IMHO not the slam dunk needed to take the idea of a Priuslike Atkinson cycle generator off the table, especially since a Prius engine is well documented to run 500k miles on gasoline even in a taxi with nothing more than spark plugs and fluid changes. On much cleaner burning propane I expect a generator could do much better.
The word from when propane cars were common in Europe was that it shortened the lifespan.
Ussr made some very simple radiation heat powered generators around one to two kilowatts.
There seems to be some issue with ordering on eBay as the import paperwork never finalizes.
I heard differently:
“Experts estimate that Auto LPG use doubles the lifespan of the engine as opposed to using gasoline. According to a study, Auto LPG “increases engine life by about 50-percent, where cylinder bore wear is reduced; prolongs the exhaust life system as compared to gasoline.” (Source: Journal of Physics/IOP Publishing).”
https://www.cleanfuel.ph/auto-lpg-vs-gasoline-which-one-should-you-use/
” In general, propane generators have a longer lifespan than gasoline or diesel generators because propane is a clean-burning fuel that doesn’t leave behind carbon deposits in the engine, which can shorten the generator’s lifespan.”
https://toolingideas.com/how-long-is-the-life-expectancy-of-a-propane-generator/
I don’t know why propane would shorten the lifespan of an internal combustion engine. It burns cleaner, vaporizes more efficiently, yadda yadda yadda. If you have the answer please do share it.
Dry fuel is the complaint I hear, like the military insisting on using JP8 instead of diesel.
I would expect inverter generators to last longer just because they aren’t on a fixed rpm.
Dry fuel? Do you mean the problem is the fuel does not contain water or the drying agents like icing inhibitor in JP8?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dry_gas
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JP-8
AFAIK such additives are not needed with propane. Propane is deccicated before storage by necessity because the Joule Thompson (JT) expansion of the fuel flash boiling with the pressure drop of exiting the tank would freeze any water to ice blocking the flow. There is no way for water to get into the tank either because to keep propane liquid at ambient temperatures it naturally maintains a pressure of 12 atmospheres or so Any leaks go out, not in.
“I would expect inverter generators to last longer just because they aren’t on a fixed rpm.”
I guess it depends on the cleverness of the design.
I believe this is a lubrication issue because gaseous fuels provide no lubrication. Shorten the oil change interval and use a high mileage full synthetic and it will be fine.
Gasoline as a solvent is even worse for engine oil so like you I expect this is a long ago solved problem. Even Honda figured it out.
I will inquire further, but I took it as a lack of lubrication or corrosive by products.
This gets into areas above my direct experience.
Hoping for a clever design is why I got the Hondas.
There is better equipment, but not at that price. I’ve run my Honda for months so far without issues.
By the way, big industrial diesel generators can exploit their heavy build to be relatively quiet, and seem to thump along at low rpm.
They aren’t all loud.
I slept next to a 100 kilowatt diesel in the desert, and slept very well.
It powered a large camp with some being high loads.
It wasn’t silent, but wasn’t harsh.
I would appreciate that.
I wouldn’t expect lubrication or corrosion to be the issues, at least any more so than other fuels. Gasoline I think is not a particularly good lubricant and a known solvent of engine oils. Honda found this out the hard way. Propane may also dissolve oil but propane is only a liquid at relatively high pressures and low temperatures never seen in an engine crankcase so I don’t see how that could happen in an engine. It’s combustion products are the same as other hydrocarbons but cleaner so less soot is generated. Maybe NOx from higher compression ratios but I wouldn’t think any moreso than gasoline.
“By the way, big industrial diesel generators can exploit their heavy build to be relatively quiet, and seem to thump along at low rpm.
They aren’t all loud.”
I agree, big diesels if designed to be so can be remarkably quiet.
Google “tell me about lubricant issues in engines powered by gaseous fuels” for an interesting read. Higher temperatures and increased nitration, making thicker oil and viscosity spikes a primary failure mode. The ash level being so low can actually lead to excessive exhaust valve seat wear and recession. Pretty interesting that there is a whole natural gas engine oil category with formulations to overcome these issues.
Well it appears to be a solved problem. Which you’d expect given propane is the third most common vehicle fuel in the world after gasoline and diesel.
Well if you want the Toyota (with a Lexus price) you should check out “ene farm fuel cell type s”. Make the AI read Japanese for you because there is very little in English about it. It is for a house but can run on LP gas or methane, has the hot water output built in, electrical efficiency 55%. Puts out 700 watts for $13k.
“The Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry’s Strategic Energy Plan (decided by the Cabinet in October 2021) aims to introduce 3.0 million Ene-Farm units by 2030. To help reduce society’s overall environmental impact, it is necessary to further popularize Ene-Farm.”
That’s the right idea. Now mass produce billions of these things at 1/10th the price and size.
They have sold over a million units already, but I am not sure if that many are type S which is solid oxide. Previous versions had a chamber before the fuel cell where the fuel was reformed into hydrogen. Reformation happens internally in a solid oxide type.
I think it is funny when people (usually obsessed with EVs) try to dunk on Toyota for spending their governments money on fuel cell research like nothing practical came out of it. They pivoted into stationary residential units pretty successfully.
I imagine they consume the city gas directly. The efficiency they claim I think would not be possible with hydrogen reforming.
Engineer: Our new line of Generators is ready for testing, but we haven’t come up with a name yet.
Boss: Not now. I’m busy watching Predator.
Engineer: We’ve got production approval but still haven’t come up with a name…
Boss: Not now. I’m watching To Catch a Predator.
Engineer: Marketing is going to kill me if we don’t have a name for the packaging.
Boss: Y’know, my date last night was an absolute disaster. If there was only someone who could go on a date in advance for you to make sure the other person isn’t crazy. You know? Some kind of Pre-dater.
Engineer: I’ll just come up with something.
I imagine the naming process at HF is handled by one person working 3 minutes per day.
If the Predator employs active camouflage you will never find it, then you are out $1000
I regularly work with a Honda water pump and it’s loud as shit. I’ve always wanted to weld on another muffler that’s sticking straight up in the air. Hive mind: have you ever rednecked up something like a generator or water pump with two mufflers? Is is quieter? Will it even run?
I’ve never done that, but generator enclosures are a pretty common way to reduce noise. You build a box out of plywood lined with foam, leave a couple of holes for fresh air and exhaust, and it can knock down the noise substantially. If you’re moving around a lot it might be too much hassle, but it’s something to consider.
You generally want to direct the sound up or in some other direction.
High mass works better for isolation, but convenience often matters more.
Plywood and carpet are common.
I used a paneling thick piece of plywood to shroud most of my eu.
If there is a generator version of your engine, it may offer the quietest option.
But yes, altered exhaust systems can be better.
Predator engines are the stuff of legends.
So that’s 1250w for 18 hours, or 22.5 kWh from 3.7 gal or 14L of petrol. I know small carbed engines are going to be less efficient, but you’re getting only 1.6 kWh from one litre of petrol. I believe that the average EREV can do 3 kWh per litre (my own car does 3.3 kWh/L, tank to battery)
If (or when) EREVs hit North America they could be great for campsite power, switch it to generator mode and power the camper with V2L. Maybe deflect the exhaust with some cardboard so you dont swamp your living quarters with fumes
Ford already does this with the hybrid F-150. I don’t know what the efficiency is, but it has a bank of plugs in the bed that provide 7kW-ish of power (IIRC) and it will only cycle the engine on long enough to recharge the hybrid battery. It was honestly a big temptation back when I was looking for a new tow vehicle, but at the time the hybrid was new enough that it wasn’t clear if they’d worked out all the kinks yet and I wasn’t willing to risk it. I suspect this functionality will be a mandatory feature next time I’m shopping trucks though.
I lose power enough that I finally started looking at generators, and have promptly forgotten all the recommendations. I also really considered a Jackery battery unit, or even both together.
Maybe this generator is the answer.
Wouldn’t it make more sense to use one of the new solar generator/battery packs – especially now that the simple “Balcony Solar” systems are coming available?
Quiet operation, infinite/free fuel, simple setup = Better camping experience.
Most solar set ups I’ve seen like that don’t produce near the amount of power as a generator. This Predator is spitting out 3,900 watts. To get that in solar you’d need ~10 400W panels, which costs hundreds of dollars each (if not coming close to $1,000 each, but more realistically around $400-600 each). They’d also be roughly 65 inches by 39 inches each in size. And you’d only be getting 400 watts in the most ideal situation, so you better hope you’ve got a big battery.
I actually looked into this recently because although my 100W suitcase solar panel and 100Ah lithium battery are more than capable of handling my 12V loads, I thought it would be cool to be able to run air conditioning off one of those. The ones that are rated for enough wattage only have enough capacity to run an AC unit for about an hour before they’d be depleted. And the solar panels required to recharge it in one day’s worth of sun would cover your entire campsite.
However Solar can run a lot of fans –
Just roll open the awnings, open those windows and let the breezes flow…
Not helpful when it’s 95 and 80% humidity (that’s not hypothetical, those were the actual conditions for one of my camping trips this summer).
Yeah, Oshkosh in late July is often a humid oven without a whole lot of wind. It was better this year, with temperatures that usually fluctuated in the high 70s and low 80s, but in previous years, I’d be out on the flightline in temps above 90.
I think you’re actually better off using your ears than a dB meter. The meter will give you the total energy in sound being emitted, but our hearing isn’t a flat response. Some frequencies and patterns will be more irritating than others, so perception is probably a better way, even if it’s not calibrated.
Hence the dBA scale.
NVH matters a lot!
Blows my mind that people run loud ass generators all day long at campsites. Completely ruins the experience for everyone around them. I wish I could bumble through life with that level of ignorance; it has to be nice.
Same sort of thing as people going to a nighttime event like fireworks or a drive-in and running their engine and headlights the entire time.
I live near one of the handful of surviving drive-ins, and the headlights thing is a real problem, especially with today’s crazy bright LEDs. The drive-in tends to show two movies, so you’re there for four hours at a minimum. Starting your engine is expected, but nobody does anything about their lights, so the screen gets washed out.
I already fixed the issue back in 2013. If I can’t turn off the DRLs, I just bring an extra-thick blanket (or multiple blankets) and put it over the headlights. Boom, simple solution.
My Toyota s all thankfully allow me to turn DRL’s off for exactly these situations. I’ll usually just run the engine during the intermission and have no issues.
why are people starting their engines at a drive in movie other than at the end to leave?
It can get cold after the sun goes down, even sitting in a vehicle. Also, my truck would shut off every 10 or 15 minutes if it wasn’t running. Normally a good thing to preserve the battery, but a problem when you’re using the stereo to get movie audio.
I learned all this when they set up a temporary outdoor theatre here during covid. I still didn’t run my engine because idling is terrible for modern cars, but for some of the Fall showings if I hadn’t brought serious blankets with me I might have had no choice.
Some people go to the theater in cars that have crappy batteries, or run a huge sound system, or want to run their heater during cold spring/fall showings, or whatever. Some also might not understand that their battery could last the length of a movie without dying.
My Smarts have a battery power-save function that shuts down the stereo after 45 minutes if you have not started the engine. So I’ll wait until the radio shuts down, run the engine for about 15 minutes, shut it off again, and let the auxiliary power run for another 45 minutes. My bigger cars can usually last the length of one movie, so I’ll just wait until the intermission to pump the battery back up.
The last time I was at a drive-in they had those metal boxes you’d clip onto your half-open window. I guess those days must be over.
Way over. I have a drive-in movie speaker box in my den, never did see if it still produces sound.
They could just turn the bass down.
I swear they must not hear them. I regularly see people sitting at their campfire with no one in the trailer at all and the generator roaring away right next to them.
Of course, there are also the people who will run the full length of their electrical cord to get the generator away from their campsite, so they know damn well what they’re doing and there’s a special circle of hell reserved for them.
Its kids man……the people that aren’t bothered by noise have kids. Having kids makes one deaf apparently.
I have kids.
Went camping and had to move our tent campsite at 9pm because we (kids included) couldn’t stand the noise of the campsite next door running their monstrosity all day and night.
This is why I stopped camping in “Campgrounds”. If I can see you I am not going to be camping there.
Your not camping if you have a Sat TV, AC, and sit inside a plywood box all day….
Amen. Sometimes I hate my parents for burdening me with the need to show consideration for the people around me, and I unfortunately have passed that same burden on to my own kids.
I tried to balance things out for them by not passing on my dad’s love of fishing in freezing cold weather. Or golf.
When I was a kid, my parents travel trailer had a Sears generator. Dang thing was LOUD. Years and Years later, my Dad bought a little Honda that put out the same watts, but that little Honda was whisper quiet.
I had a Coleman one that could wake the dead, gave it away and bought a small Honda- world of difference, just wish it was lighter
I too, used a Coleman like that last year.
But it was our only option, AND we were camping at a race track. So it was already loud.
My dad borrowed it one winter and took it out to some old military base to camp in AZ and said people thought it was loud
Which Honda did you get?
2200I
In addition to limits on noise (whether it’s the radio, loud party, or your generator): the baseline for all new RVs should be a nominal amount of solar panels that’ll let you run the majority of your trailer in peace-and-quiet.
There’s not enough space or insulation between most RV parts to have any sense of noise abatement – let alone within the RV/Trailer itself, and the whole point of RVing is to “get away”, so why bring the noise with you?
Largely because the whole point of RVing, as opposed to tent camping or the like, is to also bring the AC with you, and enough solar to run an AC all day is usually not feasible.
So many people don’t make good use of the 12V systems at all. My last camping trip got cooooold overnight, and the first morning after it got cold a bunch of people got up and fired up their generators, instead of just using the 12V/propane furnace that is definitely installed in their trailer.
I’m also about 95% certain I’ve camped next to people who fired up the generator every morning just to make coffee in their electric coffee maker, despite the existence of numerous options that don’t require 120V. Special shout out to the a-holes who did this at 5:30 AM (well before quiet hours in the campground were over) the day they were leaving.
I mean, I get using your trailer as a mobile hotel room with all the comforts of home (I do some trips like this too), but at some point the generator is actually a worse option than just using the built-in systems.
And not only are 12v camping gizmos always advancing (12v fridges, for example, being much more efficient and prices have come down), the explosion of usb charged/powered options has been exponential. Fans, lights, speakers – all that will last days and you can bring in and out with you.
Propane heat is always going to be your most efficient option and a full 20# tank should cover you for heating, cooking, and water for a long weekend unless it’s close to freezing temps.
But I guess “just run the generator” is simpler than thinking about things when you’re 11 natty-lights deep.