There’s so much more to making a car that drives itself than just following the basic rules of the road and understanding the physics of driving. I mean, that’s pretty important, sure, and you’re not going anywhere without that, but there’s so much more to driving that requires a greater understanding of not just the objects moving along the road, but what those objects are, how they may behave, and even cultural and societal behaviors and expectations. It’s a big deal.
A lot of automated driving (AV) companies may chalk this stuff up to “edge cases,” but the truth is the whole world is made of edge cases. Edge cases are just life, and sometimes it gets complicated. Complicated like when there’s some debris on a highway, and the highway patrol is trying to block traffic to clear the road; most people understand that when there’s a bunch of cop cars forming a barrier on the highway, flashing their blue lights and generally looking serious and busy, the best plan is to, you know, keep back.
Waymo’s automated robotaxis seemed to have an issue with this sort of thing, as just recently seen in a video that went viral of a Waymo that attempted to get around a California Highway Patrol traffic break on the I-280 freeway. As expected, the attempt by the robotaxi to drive around the traffic break wasn’t appreciated by anyone, and while the robotaxi eventually agreed to play ball and remain behind the blockade, California’s Department of Motor Vehicles has decided to ban Waymo’s vehicles from the state’s highways, calling the cars an “imminent hazard.”
Here’s video of the misbehaving Waymos, taken by someone who was on the highway at the time of the incident:
“Safety is at the foundation of everything we do. Following recent freeway construction zone encounters on U.S. 101 in California that did not involve any injuries or collisions, the California DMV has implemented an operating restriction on freeway operations in the state. In alignment with our safety-first principles, we have also temporarily restricted freeway operations across our other operating markets to evaluate our performance. Our ride-hailing service continues to operate safely on surface streets, serving over half a million trips each week. We are working with the California DMV and other state officials diligently and responsibly to resume freeway operations.”
Waymo
I think Waymo has done the right thing here by ceasing highway operations. What I find puzzling is that I would have thought highway driving would actually be easier than city driving, despite the higher speeds used on freeways. Generally, highway driving is more orderly and usually has fewer outside elements (like pedestrians, complicated intersections, cool dogs in sunglasses and backwards ballcaps on skateboards) to potentially cause issues, but that’s clearly not always the case, and when combined with higher speeds and the greater danger that could be caused by coming to a stop, highway driving is absolutely as demanding as city driving.
I’ve reached out to Waymo for comment, and will update the article when or if I hear back.
I'm a co-founder/Chief Creative Officer of the Autopian, the site you're on right now! I'm here to talk to you about taillights until you cry and beg me to stop, which I absolutely will not. Sorry. Hug? Also, David's friend.
You can find me on Twitter and Insta
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Current Fleet (running or close enough): 1990 Nissan Pao, 1983 Citroën 2CV, 1989 Ford F-150; (not so running): 2020 Changli, 1977 Dodge Tioga RV, 1973 VW Beetle
Sounds like after one incident they decided they didn’t need any (more) of that Tesla FSD negative press