Home » Our Commenters Are The Best In The Known Universe But Occasionally There Are Comments That Just Baffle Me

Our Commenters Are The Best In The Known Universe But Occasionally There Are Comments That Just Baffle Me

El 2cv Gearoil Commnter Top

If you’d like to read this two-fisted tale of a commenter angry about my choice of gear oil, please consider becoming an Autopian member. Thank you!

Follow us on:

Facebook
WhatsApp
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Subscribe
Notify of
207 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Freddy Bartholomew
Member
Freddy Bartholomew
1 month ago

I needed a good laugh. I’m sitting here waiting for X-ray results because my right hip joint feels like someone forgot the lube.

David Tracy
Admin
David Tracy
1 month ago

I hope they, unlike JT, splurge for the multigrade!

Drive By Commenter
Member
Drive By Commenter
1 month ago

Ouch. Been there, done that. Start thinking of what shows you’ll want to binge while laying on your stomach high on opiates if they need to operate.

Freddy Bartholomew
Member
Freddy Bartholomew
1 month ago

They say it’s bursitis and it’s damn painful. They don’t prescribe opiates so I’m just on Aleve which could be a placebo as far as I can tell. It’s 4AM here and I’m making my way through a good bit of this website.

Argentine Utop
Member
Argentine Utop
1 month ago

All the best, good fella!

Argentine Utop
Member
Argentine Utop
1 month ago
Reply to  Argentine Utop

Also, if they give you opioids at some point, you’d be able to read Torch’s articles high as fuck, legally. A win, in my book.

CR-V Oswald
Member
CR-V Oswald
1 month ago

Opiates don’t work well with inflammation pain. Ask them if they’ll give you a Diclofenac rx.

Joregon
Member
Joregon
1 month ago

Are we talking specifically about lukewarm human baby shit? Would baby bird shit be too corrosive?

Kuruza
Member
Kuruza
1 month ago
Reply to  Joregon

The uric acid would probably be hell on the yellow metals. Reminds me of that meme with the blackbird or starling or whatever glaring at the camera in wide view and then in a choker shot:
“Nice car ya got there… it’d be a shame if someone LUBRICATED IT IMPROPERLY!”
https://share.google/8SRU5hxqRsgfII1yp

Rod Millington
Member
Rod Millington
1 month ago

Does he know that he is yelling on the internet at someone who cut batteries in half with a chainsaw?

SlowBrownWagon
Member
SlowBrownWagon
1 month ago
Reply to  Rod Millington

Came here to say this. If that guy had seen that video, Torch would have had to change the locks and hide Otto at a boarding school.

Tbird
Member
Tbird
1 month ago

Remember that the lube you make, is equal to the lube you take. Peace.

Cerberus
Member
Cerberus
1 month ago

Having spent an embarrassing amount of time on car forums since the wide adoption of the internet, I can say the number of car weirdos who get obsessed over oil brands, viscosities, etc. and generally based on purely anecdotal data is astounding. Asking “what oil should I use?” on any car site is like pouring gasoline over the floor of a dusty grain silo filled with airborne particles and tossing in a lit Molotov cocktail.

Along those lines, The Motor Oil Geek on youtube is the only guy I’d listen to.

Spikersaurusrex
Member
Spikersaurusrex
1 month ago
Reply to  Cerberus

A friend of mine used to be an engineer at a major oil company. I use what he says to use, which, of course is made by the company he worked for.

Jack Trade
Member
Jack Trade
1 month ago
Reply to  Cerberus

Having done the same, I’m always amazed at how on pretty much any forum, when the question comes up once again, you’ll find pretty much every possible oil brand and most weights strongly advocated for by someone. And according to them, they’re all serious drag racers, pro engine builders, OEM engineers, etc.; nobody’s just some guy who likes to fix his own car when he can or something.

Cerberus
Member
Cerberus
1 month ago
Reply to  Jack Trade

I just used the same synthetic for decades because I believe it was Porsche OEM a the time and I figured they were the other car boxer engine makers. Some wad would always go on about whatever overpriced difficult to source oil was somehow better, but I tore down a severely beat engine at 250k miles (burnt an exhaust valve) and it looked almost new, so who cares how much better some other oil might be? And I wouldn’t doubt other comparable brands would have had the same results. I recently changed brands. It’s a little better in testing, but I doubt it matters, I changed because it’s a bit cheaper.

Echo Stellar
Member
Echo Stellar
1 month ago

I have to think some of these oddities are bots. Sewing discord is their design intent.

Cerberus
Member
Cerberus
1 month ago
Reply to  Echo Stellar

I agree. I’ve seen a few unrecognized names that show up with unreasonable and unprovoked hostility and I just assume that’s what they are.

Echo Stellar
Member
Echo Stellar
1 month ago
Reply to  Cerberus

I don’t want to get all tin foil hat, but the one that Jason writes about probably drives a digital Lada.

Cerberus
Member
Cerberus
1 month ago
Reply to  Echo Stellar

The war and sanctions doesn’t leave much for income options, I guess.

Framed
Member
Framed
1 month ago
Reply to  Echo Stellar

Bots that quote multi grade oil viscosity? What a world!

CR-V Oswald
Member
CR-V Oswald
1 month ago
Reply to  Echo Stellar

Sewing discord is the job of seamstresses and tailors who play video games.

Echo Stellar
Member
Echo Stellar
1 month ago
Reply to  CR-V Oswald

This is true. I meant what farmers do.

Nick
Nick
1 month ago

Viscosity of infant stool…. ok here, take your damn star for the day…

MostlyRedCars
Member
MostlyRedCars
1 month ago

Back on the other car site, there were a couple commenters (at least I think it was two different people) that were sort of like this. One would pop up on the car buying articles to insist that he would never buy a car from dealer that offered anything other than MSRP, because being willing to offer a number other than what was on the sticker was a sign of dishonesty. The other showed up on Hyundai/Kia articles, especially those that listed the warranty as a benefit to those brands, to insist that the 10 year warranty was a reason not to buy the car. Any brand that tried to lure you in with things like that was not to be supported. In both cases, especially the first one, it wasn’t just expressing an opinion but protracted exchanges to try and convince us all to their way of thinking. Point is, people choose some real weird hills to die on.

Jack Trade
Member
Jack Trade
1 month ago
Reply to  MostlyRedCars

I remember the Hyundai guy. Nothing would convince him otherwise. The first guy reminds me of the classic King of the Hill episode where it comes to light that Hank’s longstanding secret car buying deal that he’s so proud of is “sticker price, not a penny more.”

CR-V Oswald
Member
CR-V Oswald
1 month ago
Reply to  MostlyRedCars

A recent “Autopian asks” post about what makes an enthusiast car had a commenter who went off on people who didn’t follow his elaborate car enthusiast taxonomy. It was odd.

Jdoubledub
Member
Jdoubledub
1 month ago

Man this takes me back 25 years to a forum post where I had mentioned filling my Focus MTX75 transaxle with 75W-90 (instead of ATF) to quiet the woodpecker chatter after installing an 8.5lb aluminum flywheel in place of the stock 22.5lb one and I was assured by someone that it would be like shifting through cement…even though I was regularly driving the car and could attest it was just as smooth as the factory filled fluid.

Njd
Member
Njd
1 month ago

It’s not enough to think I’d choose a different approach. I have to be RIGHT and they have to be WRONG.

Tbird
Member
Tbird
1 month ago
Reply to  Njd

More than one way to skin a cat (not that I’m endorsing , nor have any experience with cat skinning).

I don't hate manual transmissions
Member
I don't hate manual transmissions
1 month ago
Reply to  Njd

I’m assuming this is satirical, but if not, are you the new guy we just hired?

4moremazdas
Member
4moremazdas
1 month ago

Harvey Firebirdman reminded me of this, but it’s such a great read I had to make a top level comment to share:

(tldr: Torch should have just put some Fluid in there… tick. tick. tick.)

https://www.reddit.com/r/AskAShittyMechanic/comments/1vsctn8/customer_said_engine_was_ticking_so_i_put_atf_in/

Last edited 1 month ago by 4moremazdas
Clark B
Member
Clark B
1 month ago
Reply to  4moremazdas

That was an amazing read, reminds me a bit of some of Stephen King’s short stories.

Mechjaz
Member
Mechjaz
1 month ago
Reply to  4moremazdas

Thank you for sharing that, that was incredible.

CR-V Oswald
Member
CR-V Oswald
1 month ago
Reply to  4moremazdas

Thanks for that. I’d never seen it and now I’m rotflmao.

Mechjaz
Member
Mechjaz
1 month ago

Man, who lukewarm baby-shat in that commenter’s Cheerios?

Last edited 1 month ago by Mechjaz
Tbird
Member
Tbird
1 month ago

Good on Torch for getting the 2CV up and running. A dead car is an ignored car… and as stated, winter drivability is a tomorrow problem. Any no/low sulphur oil should work. IIRC I sent over few compatible specs in the original comments.

Last edited 1 month ago by Tbird
Cerberus
Member
Cerberus
1 month ago
Reply to  Tbird

Yeah, he has multiple cars. If it shifts poorly, oh well, grab a different car in the winter.

Totally not a robot
Member
Totally not a robot
1 month ago
Reply to  Cerberus

Joke’s on Torch when he inadvertently applies that thinking to all of his cars.

Tong Thrower
Member
Tong Thrower
1 month ago

This being my day off I was able to consult with some experts on this.

Johnny Carson weighed in on the overall quality of Autopians, comparing them to a live studio audience, “They can’t all be gems.”

Elwood Blues had this to say about the relationship between an artist and their audience, “Don’t try to understand ’em; just rope and throw and brand ’em.”

Dr. Ruth Westheimer had a bit of insight into the mental composition of this particular commentator, “Bad people are a result of bad sex.”

MondialMatt
Member
MondialMatt
1 month ago

As one such “occasional belligerent jackass,” I’m very grateful that my shitheadery hasn’t yet needed to be weeded out.

My handle even used to have “Ass” right in there, so everybody would see the BS coming before becoming incensed, but people just thought I like butts, so I ditched it and now I have to choose more carefully my words. #adult

Cerberus
Member
Cerberus
1 month ago
Reply to  MondialMatt

It can be both. I’m an ass and I like big butts (I cannot lie).

i Pete in the woods
Member
i Pete in the woods
1 month ago
Reply to  MondialMatt

Cosmo Kramer, the ASS MAN

Jb996
Member
Jb996
1 month ago

It’s a really formulaic response too.

– You did something I don’t understand or don’t like.
– Technobabble that usually, either subtlety or blatantly doesn’t really matter. Usually misses the overall point. But see how much smarter than you I am?
– Personal insult/attack.

Spopepro
Member
Spopepro
1 month ago

There does seem to be a portion of the commentariat that really has issue with the shade tree, just keep it running, low cost style of wrenching that many of the writers here practice. And not just “I wouldn’t do it that way” but something that seems to really make them deeply upset. I see it on a lot of DT’s articles, especially the challenge articles. It started elsewhere and seems to have followed to here. I’ve often found it puzzling too.

Jack Trade
Member
Jack Trade
1 month ago
Reply to  Spopepro

At least we’re not at epidemic levels here yet. I used to frequent stangnet when I first got my Mustang, but eventually left b/c I couldn’t stand yet another flame war over the “correct” rear end gears and people insisting that no, drag race spec ones are not only perfectly fine but actually damn preferable for your mom’s everyday driving you complete moron…

Jb996
Member
Jb996
1 month ago
Reply to  Spopepro

I think because it’s an easy stance to take, and people like being “right”.

For example, if you didn’t torque to spec:
I get to be right by citing the manual, the engineers that designed it, references to bolt design and thread pitch angle, materials analysis, etc.
There’s so many wonderful ways to tell you how smart I am and how wrong you are.
You have to try to prove that it’s “close enough”, and will be “fine”.

/even though anyone not a crotchety ass will know that it’s close enough and will be fine.

Cerberus
Member
Cerberus
1 month ago
Reply to  Jb996

Or what about when the specs are wrong? I’ve seen that too many times. Almost lost an engine to a published low spec on a crank pulley. i think that’s the difference between the people who have only read about things and those who have actually done them and sometimes had to do them under non-ideal conditions and with a lack of money for a “proper” fix. Don’t tell anyone, but I over-torque my wheels by 10 pounds. Done that for nearly a million miles and never had to re-torque alloy wheels after a change nor broke a stud, not even ones on high mileage Subarus with notoriously weak wheel studs.

Jack Trade
Member
Jack Trade
1 month ago
Reply to  Cerberus

You make a great point. There’s a huge difference between knowing mechanical data and being a mechanic; one comes from knowledge (which is good), but the other comes from knowledge plus actually doing the thing. Which in itself generates more knowledge that can’t be acquired any other way.

Who Knows
Member
Who Knows
1 month ago

I never thought I’d see graphs of the viscosity of baby poop. And actually relevant to something. Since laughing is supposed to be healthy, thanks for the continued personal health boosts.

JJ
Member
JJ
1 month ago
Reply to  Who Knows

Just imagine the folks tasked with this research (which I am sure is of value) are real people. Who go to parties and get asked “so what do you do for work?”

Jack Trade
Member
Jack Trade
1 month ago

I feel this could be next year’s member’s t-shirt, basically combining the post and Otto’s fictional retort.

“How dare you put that viscosity of oil in your 2CV?? Have you no scruples at all?! I bid you good day. GOOD DAY SIR.”

John Burkhart
Member
John Burkhart
1 month ago

I dunno, I think there are organisms roving the net who thrive on becoming outraged and actively seek source material to fuel that feeling. Granted some who exhibit this behavior have financial motivations and are just looking for clicks. TBH I love Autopian for it’s innocent love of cars, it’s like a bunch of 9 year olds geeking out on cars with no concern for looking cool.

BigMike2k3
Member
BigMike2k3
1 month ago

I happily went no contact when I caught my dad using a JIS screwdriver on what was clearly a Phillips screw. Sometimes, I still feel like I wasn’t harsh enough…

Last edited 1 month ago by BigMike2k3
Totally not a robot
Member
Totally not a robot
1 month ago
Reply to  BigMike2k3

You wouldn’t believe the shitstorm when I got caught using a security Torx bit on a regular Torx screw.

JJ
Member
JJ
1 month ago

sometimes with hex bits, I use metric even when I know it’s SAE. Man it feels good to finally be able to get that off my chest.

ESO
Member
ESO
1 month ago

Was that ROOTWYRM using a different handle?

Last edited 1 month ago by ESO
Manwich Sandwich
Member
Manwich Sandwich
1 month ago
Reply to  ESO

That guy did know quite a bit… but MAN he had a lot of pent up rage.

ESO
Member
ESO
1 month ago

I really enjoyed his comments, all except for his anger at fellow commenters.

Tbird
Member
Tbird
1 month ago
Reply to  ESO

Ditto.

Rommi
Member
Rommi
1 month ago

One time I witnessed my father using an unapproved container for gasoline. The disgust and anger that coursed through my body was nearly overwhelming. It’s been nearly 20 years since that day and I’ve not spoken to him once.

Tbird
Member
Tbird
1 month ago
Reply to  Rommi

I once watched my dad smoking a cig while dropping a fuel tank out of a station wagon…

Last edited 1 month ago by Tbird
JJ
Member
JJ
1 month ago
Reply to  Rommi

you did the right thing. Stay the course.

A. Barth
A. Barth
1 month ago

I want people to be free and happy to say whatever they want.

Appreciated, but if they’re combative jackasses like that loser they should get the banhammer immediately. That was not an off-the-cuff comment; there was intent.

Arguably they should further be held captive in metaphorical stocks in the town square so we can fling rotten vegetables and/or eggs at them.

Pinto Panopticon
Member
Pinto Panopticon
1 month ago

I’m from South America (formerly South Park), so I like to hit RECIRC and smell my own farts! I’m joking…

…but the viscosity of that air is slightly closer to the consistency of baby shit than just fresh air, and I’m not talking about the long-running NPR show.

Cerberus
Member
Cerberus
1 month ago

That must be brutal. My car often chooses recirc at start up on warmer days because programmers are dicks and I don’t usually think about it because the button is largely hidden by the shifter, but I remember it when I suddenly realize that the air has turned to cotton candy.

207
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x