Home » Our Commenters Are The Best In The Known Universe But Occasionally There Are Comments That Just Baffle Me

Our Commenters Are The Best In The Known Universe But Occasionally There Are Comments That Just Baffle Me

El 2cv Gearoil Commnter Top

If you’d like to read this two-fisted tale of a commenter angry about my choice of gear oil, please consider becoming an Autopian member. Thank you!

Follow us on:

Facebook
WhatsApp
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Subscribe
Notify of
207 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Buy Colorful Cars Again
Member
Buy Colorful Cars Again
23 days ago

That commentor is definitely a crank and a busy body who should absolutely consider some rest and relaxation this winter; however, the lines “You should at least disclaim to them that you’re an idiot” is admittedly very funny. Jason, I am very sorry you were on the receiving end of such a witty insult

Cars? I've owned a few
Member
Cars? I've owned a few
25 days ago

Yeah. Don’t swap out the gear oil you finally sourced for poo, sourced from Delmar (not his real name).

Hello #Editors Occasionally, I get emails and a notification in the ringy-dingy bell at the upper right in my browser saying a comment I made has been approved and allowed to be released into this wild. And I am always puzzled as to why it got flagged. By whom? An algorithm? And WHY?

I have never ad hominem attacked anyone in these comment sections. And I really do appreciate how I never see that here, and I further appreciate the intelligence and humor of my fellow commentors. I have actually made it to the COTD and Peter’s follow up posts about Autopian Asks responses. And the rare acknowledgements do make my day. The posts flagged haven’t even had one of George Carlin’s seven words I can’t say on a man on the street question. Why is that? Even CNN has a program (Have I Got News For You) that lets stuff through that gets bleeped on The Daily Show.

I kind of want that job who has to weed through all the comments that get flagged. Unless I’m the only one who does. In which case, I will try to be even more innocuous in the future.

Dave Larkman
Dave Larkman
25 days ago

Weird to get mad about the potential stupidity of using a particular grade of oil when your chainsawing lead acid batteries post is right there on the same internet.

I got a death threat once for disproving someone’s clearly impossible claim about suspension adjustment. It took some of the joy out of their eventual confession of having made it all up. Also I stopped going to car meets for a while.

In an unrelated event: I once had a car that was sponsored by a small company. I was at a show and a guy came up to me, clearly agitated, and asked if I was the guy who ran the company. It turned out that this guy posted one of his children’s drawings online, and the guy who owned the company had said something unflattering about it. So had I been the company owner his next move would have been to punch me in the face. For being mean about some random kid’s terrible scribble.

Cars? I've owned a few
Member
Cars? I've owned a few
25 days ago
Reply to  Dave Larkman

Who knows what gets posted on that other internet. Jason. On the dark web. Probably NSFW.

CR-V Oswald
Member
CR-V Oswald
25 days ago

I wonder if the commenter is Bob the Oil Guy. Or a frequent poster there.

https://bobistheoilguy.com/forums/

Torque
Torque
26 days ago

Any fluid for lubrication is there to prevent excessive heat build up, which leads to excessive wear and eventual damage

If baby shit can be kept cool enough, that will work too!

Cars? I've owned a few
Member
Cars? I've owned a few
25 days ago
Reply to  Torque

Might plug up the PCV in vehicles so equipped.

05LGT
Member
05LGT
27 days ago

When the Fabulous Furry Freak Brothers got the VW bus serviced with all natural avocados for gear oil the transmission exploded on the highway. It was ok though because it was delicious. So… GL4 should be fine.

JJ
Member
JJ
27 days ago

On a serious note . . .

I have a job where I not infrequently get rageful emails from strangers. It has helped me to remind myself that anyone who takes the time to insult someone they don’t know is not doing well. It helps me have some empathy and also some gratitude for my own circumstances.

JJ
Member
JJ
27 days ago

You should write a post saying this commenter inspired you to give peanut oil a try.

Last edited 27 days ago by JJ
Hugh Crawford
Member
Hugh Crawford
27 days ago

Not contentious or catastrophically?

Hugh Crawford
Member
Hugh Crawford
27 days ago

Anyone who rears a child to use the word lugubrious in a note about how much they hate their parents is doing an excellent job.

Didn’t the Porsche design of synchronizers use brass friction rings? The were used on VW a Porsche gearboxes of course but the roots of the Porsche family fortune were the synchromesh transmission patents so presumably there were lots of others. It wasn’t until Borg Warner developed steel cone synchros (in the 70s ?) that brass fell out of favor.

This is all from the same memory that can’t remember why I walked into the kitchen ( because it was on the way to the shop idiot, but what is in the shop? Walk back and timber I need a posidrive screwdriver bit) so take it with a grain of salt. Or a sugar cube.

Brockstar
Member
Brockstar
28 days ago

Reminds me of a guy in traffic the other day yelling out of his window at the vehicle behind him for what I assume, based on his ramblings, amounted to an almost accident in a round about. It was comical to watch just how mad Frontier man was at the supposedly offending vehicle. My three-year-old gets big mad like this too sometimes. Generally a hug goes a long way to making her feel better. So Jason, maybe you need to set up a hugging booth. These are for platonic friendship hugs, nobody get any weird ideas okay!

Dirtywrencher
Member
Dirtywrencher
28 days ago

I’m sure no one will get this far down in the comments, but this reminds me of an aircraft engineering experience:
Back when oil companies were moving from clay-based aircraft wheel bearing grease to synthetic blends, one oil company made a long, detailed pitch to an old-time engineer about the longer bearing life, increased resistance to water corrosion, and higher heat range of the new greases. After the reps pitch, the old-time engineer looked at him and said “I sincerely believe that if you could keep it in the bearing, peanut butter would be perfectly acceptable.”
That engineer has long since retired and we’ve all moved on to the modern greases (which perform amazingly), but I’ve always thought there is some truth in his comment if the lube is religiously changed.

Ben
Member
Ben
28 days ago

occasional belligerent jackass, or malicious punk, or some other manner of shithead.

I feel called out here. 😛

Ben
Member
Ben
28 days ago
Reply to  Ben

Also, don’t tell that commenter I just put 00 grease in my snowblower gearbox instead of gear oil.

BB 2 wheels > 4
Member
BB 2 wheels > 4
28 days ago

Jason, you are a gem. This type of article brings me joy and LAUGHTER. Keep up the shitposts. Cause this IS a post about shit.

PlatinumZJ
Member
PlatinumZJ
28 days ago

I remember that post…that was weird (in a creepy sort of way).

People sure are passionate about automotive and industrial lubricants. I was working on a generator rebuild project and needed to create an inspection plan for everything, even the bearing greases being used. There are ASTM standards that detail various test methods that can be used to provide assurance that a particular grease meets the manufacturer’s specifications. Despite these being stardards, there are commenters on certain forums who hold fast to their belief that dropping point should never be used because it’s impossible to truly control the temperature, and there are others who insist that it’s four ball wear scar testing that should be discontinued as a standard, and the commenting just gets spectacularly nasty.

HondaDyne Systems T360
Member
HondaDyne Systems T360
28 days ago

Fun article but don’t feed the trolls Jason! It’s what they want.

Besides, that rant on oil viscosity is only MostlyRight at best… everyone knows SAE Grade 140 GL4 is more comparable to scalding hot baby shit when it’s up to temp in the gearbox. It should be fine!

Vetatur Fumare
Member
Vetatur Fumare
28 days ago

Good to know what is required to get some attention ’round here. Time to develop some anger issues.

SaabaruDude
Member
SaabaruDude
28 days ago

lugubrious. LUGUBRIOUS indeed!

MtnGeek
Member
MtnGeek
28 days ago

I hate to point this out, but the study Jason references is for body temperature baby shit. When it’s at a vehicle’s operating temperature, it’s a much better lubricant. Though it will eat through brass, so probably best to not test this in a 2CV.

207
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x