Home » Which Nearly-New Old Truck Would You Pick Up? 1979 Dodge D150 vs Chevy C20

Which Nearly-New Old Truck Would You Pick Up? 1979 Dodge D150 vs Chevy C20

Sbsd 11 18 2026

Good morning! We’re stepping away from the shitboxes today, because I found these two amazing old pickups that I just had to show you. Yes, they’re expensive, but if you look at what you’re really getting, compared to what’s available now, they might actually be worth it.

The results of yesterday’s poll confirm it: Ain’t nothin’ like the real thing. The classic VW Super Beetle beat the 2000s upstart by almost two to one. The New Beetle was the choice of those of you who were looking for a daily driver, but most of you preferred the old orange Bug as a toy.

Vidframe Min Top
Vidframe Min Bottom

I’m torn on this one. My brief tenure as steward for a Super Beetle feels a little like unfinished business, but I’m not sure I want to go down the air-cooled VW path again. I could make a case for the New Beetle as a rallycross car, and I’m sure it would make a great one, but honestly, I’d rather have a Golf. And I’d much rather have an old Scirocco than either of these. I’ll toss my vote to the Super Beetle, I guess, just for old times’s sake.

Screenshot From 2026 11 17 18 18 23

We hear it a lot around here: “We want cheap simple trucks!” The modern Default Truck is just too big, too complicated, too overloaded with crap. In some cases you can still get a “work truck” spec, with a single cab and nice sturdy vinyl seats, but they’re still ungodly expensive. We keep seeing a few glimmers of hope, both from established brands and hopeful newcomers, but those aren’t a sure thing yet. As it stands, if you want a nice, basic truck, you have to look to the past. And you have to be lucky enough to find one that isn’t already mostly used up. These two would fit the bill; they’re both from the time when trucks were mostly made of metal and had few creature comforts. But condition-wise, they’re practically time capsules, and that might make their steep prices worth it. Let’s check them out.

1979 Dodge D150 Custom Prospector – $9,950

885547367 1742552686812127 2109192144466711870 N
Image: Facebook Marketplace seller

Engine/drivetrain: 225 cubic inch OHV inline 6, three-speed manual, RWD

Location: Seattle, WA

Odometer reading: 58,000 miles

Operational status: Runs and drives well

When it comes to domestic trucks, you hear a lot about “Ford guys” and “Chevy guys.” But you don’t run across many “Dodge guys.” (These days I guess they’d be “RAM guys,” which just sounds bad.) But Dodge trucks have always been just as capable as the other two, and arguably cooler. This era of Dodge truck produced some genuine classics, like the Li’l Red Express, the Warlock, and the rest of the “Adult Toys” line (which kinda sounds bad too, come to think of it). But even the more ordinary Dodge trucks from the late ’70s went about their business with more panache than a typical Ford or Chevy.

883722229 1151591277206092 492597340566339940 N
Image: Facebook Marketplace seller

This is a basic, bare-bones D150 Custom model, equipped with the lowest-tier drivetrain: a 225 cubic inch Slant Six and a three-speed manual transmission. Yes, it’s the fabled “three on the tree.” If you’ve never driven one, you should try it; it’s an experience every gearhead should have once. It starts, runs, and drives well, though the seller says the brakes pull slightly to the right. Might be a sticky caliper on the front, which should be easy enough to sort out.

878223772 1781662076470209 4204920206965205726 N
Image: Facebook Marketplace seller

Inside, it’s all classic truck greatest hits: a three-across bench seat with vinyl upholstery, rubber floors, and exposed steel on the inside of the doors. It’s in decent shape inside, though there are a couple cracks in the dash and the seller says the headliner is missing. But thinking about it, some old trucks didn’t even have a headliner. The radio doesn’t work, and neither does the passenger side windshield wiper. Hey, gotta have something to tinker with, right?

876208896 1460968039314178 7707489677770635037 N
Image: Facebook Marketplace seller

It has the “Prospector” package, which I believe is just some stripes and trim. It’s not perfect; there’s a dent in the tailgate and a wrinkle at the bottom corner of the driver’s door, but that just adds character. The bed is dented and scratched inside, as it should be. This truck has earned its keep over the years.

1983 Chevrolet C20 Scottsdale – $12,500

00707 39j1ccfvfjy 0nm0hw 1200x900
Image: Craigslist seller

Engine/drivetrain: 350 cubic inch OHV V8, four-speed manual, RWD

Location: Van Nuys, CA

Odometer reading: 83,000 miles

Operational status: Runs and drives well

But if a half-ton shortbed Dodge isn’t quite enough truck for you, I have something here a little heavier-duty. This is a three-quarter-ton Chevy, from the classic “squarebody” era, which ironically was officially called the Rounded Line in Chevy’s advertising. The seller has it listed as a K20, but it’s definitely not four-wheel drive; therefore it is a C20. Neither is it a Silverado. It’s the Scottsdale trim level, which I believe was the base model in 1983. I can’t tell you how often I find vehicles incorrectly labeled.

00x0x 88kkjl4epaq 0ci0t2 1200x900
Image: Craigslist seller

Only one engine could possibly power a truck like this: the classic 350 small-block V8. It wasn’t exactly a powerhouse in the early ’80s; this one is rated at 160 horsepower and 260 pound-feet of torque. But this truck has a secret weapon to help make the most of that power: the Muncie SM465 four-speed manual transmission. First gear is a super-low 6.55:1 ratio, commonly known as a “granny gear,” good for climbing steep inclines or getting heavy loads moving, and not much else. In normal driving, you ignore first gear and treat it as a three-speed. It runs and drives “amazing,” according to the seller.

00c0c Ep0hd48whs5 0ci0t2 1200x900
Image: Craigslist seller

We don’t get a good look at the interior except for this photo of the dash, which looks fine. The seat isn’t visible in any photos at all, which worries me a little. The driver’s side door panel is shown, and it’s scuffed and battered, but not really damaged. The seller does say the air conditioning is “ice cold,” which is a nice bonus.

00k0k Lscba3p7un9 0ci0t2 1200x900
Image: Craigslist seller

The outside looks good, but I have one concern: Some photos show the truck with the fender badges, and some without. So are they there, or not? As far as I know, those badges are riveted on, not glued, so if someone removed them, there should be holes. Did they Photoshop them out in some photos? The plastic bug deflector is there in all the photos. It’s so weird.

So how, you’re asking, can I claim that ten or twelve grand for these ancient beasts could actually be a good deal? Well, they’re half the price of a REO or a Slate, and neither one of those actually exists yet. They’re about a fifth the price of a brand-new truck. And you’ll never need a laptop to fix either one of them. Parts are cheap, and repairs are simple. Either one of them should last you indefinitely if you take care of it, especially if you’re not driving it daily and only using it when you need a truck. So which one would you take: the cool little six-cylinder Dodge, or the capable long-bed Chevy?

 

Follow us on:

Facebook
WhatsApp
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Subscribe
Notify of
97 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Forrest
Member
Forrest
1 day ago

In the book “Fall: or Dodge in Hell” there is a guy whose nickname is Dodge. His real name is Richard, and he has a relatively flat forehead and face. Growing up, his friends decided his face looks like the tailgate of a DODGE that they saw on the road, so his nickname became Dodge. Anyway, he ends up getting his mind uploaded into a computer program. He is a bit confused, and he thinks his name is Egdod (dodge backwards).

So, when I think of an old 3 on the tree Dodge pickup, I think the sound it makes idling must be “eg dod dod dod dod dod dod.” And accelerating through the gears, it goes “eg-dod-dod-dod-dod-dod crunch dod-dod-dod-dod-dod crunch dod-dod-dod-dod-dod (and that’s it).”

My brain is full of garbage like this. If you like this story, great! Otherwise… like… that’s just your opinion man.

Last edited 1 day ago by Forrest
It's Pronounced Porch-ah
Member
It's Pronounced Porch-ah
2 days ago

Square body is my least favorite, Ford would have been first choice, followed by the Dodge, but I prefer a V8 and an 8ft bed for truck stuff so the Chevy won today.

Big Matt
Big Matt
2 days ago

The squarebody Chevy all day.

I like that generation of Dodge, but they rust to pieces way too easily, even in Texas.

That Chevy has three places that like to rust and I’d be proactive about preventing that, and have a truck that would last the rest of my lifetime.

Horizontally Opposed
Member
Horizontally Opposed
2 days ago

I guess Dodge guys have the Mopar subset? I’d go for the Dodge all day long.

-67Mustang
-67Mustang
2 days ago

This is a tough one today.
Squarebody Chevies are pretty cool and a better truck, but as an owner of an old Ford 3/4ton truck, you want the ride quality of the 1/2 ton.
Voted for the Diodge

Dodsworth
Member
Dodsworth
2 days ago

Both, both, both, both, Dodge, both, both, both. Seriously, I’ll take the smoother ride and three on the ever-lovin’-tree.

Christopher Derrick
Member
Christopher Derrick
2 days ago

Gonna go with Dodge because I don’t trust photoshopped car ads.

T. Ferguson
T. Ferguson
2 days ago

Gonna pass – both are overpriced for 2wd stripper models. Growing up a buddy had a similar Scottsdale with the Flintstones option (cab floor rusted through due to Iowa road salt). At least that one was 4WD.

Baja_Engineer
Baja_Engineer
2 days ago

I’m on a losing streak this week and that ain’t changing today.
Give me the red underdog truck.

Jay Mcleod
Jay Mcleod
2 days ago

Chebby of course.

My wasted youth was spent around countless versions of the squarebody.

They are junk. They were junk when they were new and they are uber junk now.

But I’d love to have one. Nostalgia.

Dear God that carb! Those pieces of crap dieseled so bad in the hot Bakersfield sun. Turn it off. Walk away. Sit on the patio with a cold soda and see how long the damnable thing would diesel.

We had an 85′ that would never stop. Never. Not kidding.

And this 83′ is sus. I have a deep hunch it’s a parts truck cobbled up. Lots of small details are wrong as the author notes with just the fender badges.

Fishy.

Pure junk those trucks. Garbage.

I want one though.

Scoutdude
Scoutdude
2 days ago

The Scotsdale was the mid level trim with such fancy options such as a dome light, cigarette lighter and a light in the ashtray, which weren’t standard on the lesser Custom Deluxe. The badges were not riveted on but they did mount with studs and nuts on the back side. Meaning there would be holes since even the Custom Deluxe had a version of those fender badges. I’m guessing that the seller put Silverado in the title since that is what the current model name for Chevy pickups.

As far as which truck I’d pick the Chevy for so many reasons, not the least of which is the fact that I wouldn’t cringe every time I started it. The fact that it is a 3/4 ton V8 4sp long bed also makes it far more useful for doing truck stuff is very close behind.

Jay Mcleod
Jay Mcleod
2 days ago
Reply to  Scoutdude

Yes, Custom was the base model. Then Custom Deluxe. Scottsdale. Silverado.

Curtis Loew
Curtis Loew
2 days ago

squarebody

Gen3 Volt
Member
Gen3 Volt
2 days ago

I’ve fond three on the tree memories, so Dodge for me.

Harvey Firebirdman
Member
Harvey Firebirdman
2 days ago

Ohhh this is a great one today. I have had both a square body at one point (K5 Jimmy) and currently has my D250. So this one was a toss up but I went with the Dodge just because I currently have my truck and red is my favorite color.

Widgetsltd
Member
Widgetsltd
2 days ago

It pained me to vote for the Chevy, as I’m more of a Dodge guy, but I just could handle the slant 6 in a pickup. I just can’t drive such a sluggish unit. A V8 with a 4-speed is more my style. Plus, it appears to be the same light camel tan as the 1978 Cutlass Salon 2-soor that my mom bought brand new!

Shop-Teacher
Member
Shop-Teacher
2 days ago

These are both really nice trucks, but they are overpriced. Squarebodies are hot right now, and I love them, but that’s way too much for a 3/4 ton 2wd long bed. Here’s a really nice one in my neighborhood for 1/3 less. Even that’s pretty strong money for a C20.

I voted for the tin grill Dodge, because it’s cheaper, it’s a 1/2 ton, and it’s a short bed. That’s where the money is in old street trucks. Turbo the slant-6 until it blows up, and then swap in a magnum 360.

But really, I’d wave $7 grand cash in front of my neighbor, and I bet that V8 manual trans C20 would come home with me. That truck hasn’t moved often or far in the last 15 years.

Burt Curry
Member
Burt Curry
2 days ago

I’ve had a few 3-on-the-tree’s, and though it’s not my favorite, it’s okay and honest and easy to fix. The other one sounds compromised

Azrael
Azrael
2 days ago

That’s a clean slant. I’d probably go for it just because it’s a bit different and is a fair bit cheaper (and will run forever if the body doesn’t rot out). Wouldn’t turn down the Chevy either, but those are significantly more common, albeit lacking the proper transmission.

M SV
M SV
2 days ago

I just like dodges more it being cheaper slant 6 lower miles just seals the deal.

Anonymous Person
Anonymous Person
2 days ago

While I like the idea of the slant-six and the three-on-the-tree, I’ve already owned a ’67 C10 with the 250 straight-six and a three-on-the-tree.

The square-body with the four-on-the-floor sounds like the better truck today, even if it is slightly overpriced.

97
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x