Being an independent publisher in 2026 is just watching Google repeatedly make your life miserable, no matter how much you attempt to play by the rules they tell you to follow. Carscoops, one of the last remaining independent sites in the car media universe, has been sold off to mega publisher Static Media, which also owns Jalopnik.
Yes, this will end with me asking you to become a member, because membership is the best way we have to bring you the articles and writers you love without having to stuff the site with a miserable amount of ads, slop, and junk. But first, I’d like to explain what’s happening.
Just to give you a chart to set your hair on fire, here’s what website tracking software Similarweb* shows as the last three months at two major publishers (I will blur their names):

Yikes! This shows a massive decline in traffic, as measured indirectly by Similarweb over the last three months. One site produces a lot of original content, and the other has a mix of original reporting and some SEO-chasing, lower quality contributions. I think it’s meaningful that neither were spared. My sense is that October is only going to be worse, and that this might explain why Carscoops is just the latest site to sell to a conglomerate.
Enshittification On Steroids
Most of the news or enthusiast sites you read, whether inside or outside of the automotive universe, are probably funded primarily by display advertising, and most of that is likely programmatic advertising (90% according to most sources). This isn’t a carmaker doing an ad deal with a publisher, this is one set of servers selling to another set of servers, with publishers getting a cut.
In theory, this means that anyone can set up a website and start making money without having a huge sales team (or any sales team at all). In practice, what this means is that ethical publishers have to walk a tightrope: more ads means more money, but you don’t want so many ads that the site is unreadable.
Under this system, independent sites once flourished, and much of that had to do with a tacit agreement between massive platforms (Facebook, Google) and publishers. These platforms needed good content to make their products work, and rewarded good content with traffic, that was then served advertising. Facebook was one of the first major traffic sources to pop up, and helped popularize Buzzfeed-y style listicles and curiosity gap headlines (You’ll never believe how quickly contributors to that company got screwed when the Facebook traffic went away).
The Autopian is a post-Facebook-Apocalypse site, so we knew when we started that we’d never want to be reliant on any social network for traffic. Google was a slightly different story. Google doesn’t produce “content” in a practical way. It has, historically, connected valuable content with readers. This was initially Search, which led to some hacky SEO writing (What time is the Super Bowl?), but also products like Google News, which rewarded original work.
In fact, Google still tells publishers that when it ranks content it’s looking for “helpful, reliable, people-first” content. With Google leaning hard into AI summaries, search traffic suddenly became less valuable. Because most people on the web use some sort of Google product, the company seemed to try to make up this gap with a product called Google Discover. As a site, our great and original content was rewarded with traffic via Google Discover.
This all made some sort of sense to me, because even Google’s AI products rely on on our work to feed its AI models. Gemini doesn’t review cars. It doesn’t cover car news. Google needs us, like we need them. You’d think that would be enough to save publishers, but you’d be wrong.

I’ve written about this before, but secondary monitoring shows that what Google Discover has rewarded included our own original content, made-up hallucinated nonsense like the above, and crappy trending writing. So long as it was also rewarding us, I was fine with it. We did bend our headlines a bit towards what we knew worked on the platform when some genius came up with a good headline configuration, but we mostly just covered what we knew would serve our readership.
And then Google Discover traffic dramatically dropped. According to the latest report from Chartbeat, since July 2024, Google Search has dropped by 46% as a share of traffic, and Google Discover dropped by 28.4%. That’s across all the sites that are served by Chartbeat. For news publishers I’ve spoken with, the hit from Google Discover has been much larger. Over the last 18 months, we’ve seen a 63.8% drop in Google Organic traffic according to Google Analytics, though we’re in better shape than many other publishers.
What is Google thinking? I don’t know, but I think two things are happening. The first is a product issue, with Google using AI-fueled summaries to reduce the amount of traffic sent to websites. The second is a Google attempting to clean up bad actors in its ecosystem–the hardest hit sites seem to create a lot of slop content. Unfortunately, it’s never felt like Google has ever been that good at determining what is good content and what is bad content in any sort of consistent way, so a lot of original reporting gets hit with friendly fire.
How This Forces Publishers Like Carscoops Into The Hands Of Private Equity And Mega Publishers

I’ve been a Carscoops fan for a long time, and I’ve appreciated the way that they cover just about everything car-related, including more of the smaller European car news we don’t always post about. For many years, I’ve worked with the site’s publisher and founder John Halas to understand the larger web publishing ecosystem, and I’ve valued the insight he’s provided.
Carscoops, though, doesn’t have a membership model or any other obvious source of revenue other than display advertising. This means that it had nothing really to buffer itself against Google’s unpredictable behavior. Even sites that get value other ways (affiliate revenue, sales funnel) haven’t been able to stand on their own. This is why one company now owns MotorTrend, Autoweek, Car And Driver, and Road & Track.
Static Media, which bought Carscoops, was the buyer of last resort for Jalopnik. The details of the sale likely won’t ever be revealed, but I can guess what happens next. The website has already been converted to look like a Static Media site and it seems like the masthead has shrunk, with longtime editors gone. If it follows the path of other Static Media sites, full-timers will be slowly bled off and replaced with some mix of permalancers and poorly paid outside freelancers edited by other freelancers, leading to some bizarre outcomes.
I’m glad the site will exist in some form and that at least a few writers will continue to have jobs, but I fear for what will happen to a once-thriving site that wasn’t beholden to a massive corporate parent.
How To Stop This From Happening Again

We don’t do AI-wrtten stories. We don’t do slop. We pay people fairly. None of this is easy, but it’s our belief that the slow decline of other sites will eventually lead people to realize that a website like The Autopian is worth supporting. The way we get that support is via membership.
If you’re already a member, thank you so much for being a part of the community. If you haven’t become a member yet and have thought about doing so, now would be a key time. This hit we’re getting from Google is happening exactly at the worst time, as this is the time of year when ad rates are at the highest. Bleeding our traffic now is a huge blow to our bottom line. It’ll take about 2,000 new members to make up for the loss we’re projecting this year from losing Google traffic.
Given that Google relies on us to provide it insight, I’m not sure what the end goal is here. How does it benefit Google to drive publishers out of business? I don’t know, but I want to continue to build a model that doesn’t rely on them as a source.
And, as a perk, if you become a member the display ads and video pop-up goes away.
Please join if you can.
*There is no direct way to compare two websites, as most sites don’t release traffic data, so this is the best way to currently compare, and I’ve found it to be accurate enough to get close to an apples-to-apples comparison.
Top photo: Carscoops/Library of Congress via WikiCommons






I don’t have all day to vet automotive sources. I come here.
If auto enthusiasm becomes any more demanding, I will find another hobby. Consolidation and enshitification have already eaten decades of automotive knowledge by taking it down or drowning it in an ocean of useless search optimized results.
I have saved local digital or physical copies of the stuff I need to know. It sounds crazy to say that it’s easier to find something in my fie cabinet or a binder than it is to find it online. . . but here we are.
At some point this whole cycle of Google driving driving down traffic by employing AI summaries, causing the publishers to compress costs beyond what’s sustainable, thereby generating AI slop is going to eat itself like Ouroboros.
I just hope we don’t lose too many good publishers before that happens.
One can only hope against all evidence to the contrary that the pendulum swings back to people realizing that good content deserves payment, and we need to actively pay into communities and services that we want to use.
Magazines, newspapers, books.. people used to pay for this stuff. Then everyone stopped paying once ads began subsidizing it. Now we’re seeing the full effects of that going on for too long.
I punted Carscoops off my RSS feed a few years ago. It was a site I liked, but the quality of content …changed. Today I’d describe it as “AI slop”, but then it seemed more “low effort” or “wrong.” I remember questioning content there, and was rewarded with being banned.
So I’m not really surprised.
Yeah, I was going to comment on the same thing. In recent years Carscoops was sometimes good, other times (maybe even most times) though, it seemed like the lowest effort was made to produce an article, seemingly with no fact-checking and minimal-if-any editing. I’m disappointed yet another independent site is gone, but at the same time I’m not the least bit surprised.
I too was banned there for pointing out they were stealing content from this site. Nothing grinds my gears like lazy writing (or plagiarism).
Hey look at my shiny new member badge
Looks great on you!
Wear it with pride!
Looking good!
Ooooooo shiny!!!
The obnoxiously colored shirts are even better!
Congrats!
So I guess I’ll start coming here then. I just hope yall stay away from all the bias and politics. That’s what drove me from jalopnik and now carscoops. TTAC was decent but I found their UI frustrating. Leftlanenews????
I just got a 99 solara v6 manual. How do I post pics?
For the most part, politics stay out of things. Unless it’s in direct relation to a story that is. But unfortunately no pictures can be posted
Don’t worry you can usually rely on me to crowbar my class-warrior bullshit in somewhere.
I did say for the most part, you’re the part that isn’t included ha
Not being included is the story of my fucking life.
We’re trying to sell memberships here! I know, I know. I still need to get mine but still
I don’t use the google anymore. duckduckgo no-ai for me. Works great.
Maybe it is just because I am an old, but I will always feel weird paying for a membership to read something I can read for free. Seeing the decline in quality of Ye Olde Site reminds me that nothing truly is free, though. I could stop paying and it wouldn’t matter, but if everyone did the same, this site would presumably start to suck. And that would suck. So as long as this site keeps making good content, I will keep paying.
Maybe I’ll buy another Autopian shirt to further support this site. That is assuming you actually want a mildly antisocial weirdo being a walking billboard for your company, though.
(Oh, and if you don’t want a mildly antisocial weirdo being a walking billboard for your company, remember I already own three Autopian shirts. So maybe y’all should be sending me money…)
The way I view it, what we’re actually paying for is the community. The internet has made information super cheap, but community relatively expensive.
When I was a teenager, I’d read the car mags (often in the library) and then discuss them with friends (“oh don’t worry, of course Pontiac will keep making the Fiero…this thing is the coolest!”). Then everything went online and all of sudden, car journalism everywhere. But what I missed was the talking about cars, complete with my half-asssed opininons therein, with my friends. And since I wasn’t the only kid in the library reading room perusing those tattered Car and Drivers, I’m completely willing to help build our own here so anyone who’s into cars can come talk.
“Mildly antisocial weirdo” is Autopian’s main reader/member demo. I know, cause I are one.
It’s funny, you think its I are one. I know its I is one.
Maybe we both are I one?
(raises hand somewhat ashamedly in solidarity)
*inserts “I’m Doing My Part” gif”
Would you like to know more?
I’ll die fighting for my pla….car blog as long as I am provided with some pocket rust and rusted knives made from rusted frames and body panels from Davids rust buckets to give our bug enemies tetanus. The only good bug is a dead bug.
My swag alone has attracted several mates. You get spotted, and then there’s a mating call – it could be a squealer on a brake pad, a hole in the exhaust, the rhythmic roar of a cupped tire endlessly jouncing on a bad shock, any number of things – and then, in a tender, beautiful dance of automotive marco polo, you find your way together like 10mm socket to 10mm nut.
Of course, sometimes you then find out that was no 10mm, that was a 3/8″, and you come away feeling absolutely shredded and yet convinced you were right – how could it not have been a 10? Who would use standard after, honestly, after the 90s whatsoever? You stare at your hands, covered in – a quick taste! – brake fluid, yes, thank god it’s brake fluid, this time at least, the long bed can hold so much but only so many, only so many, the gross vehicle weight rating can mean more than one thing and there are only so many arms and shoes and knuckles that can fit, there must be some way to stop this, Harbor Freight is threatening to stop selling me tarps. No one can have that much to cover they said, no one has that much at risk of rust they said, so it’s collar up and ballcap down to go to Lowe’s, to Home Depot, just the six by nines so I can keep them all tidy, you see, tidy are my projects, all the pieces in bins, all the things that need the burning cleansing of … rust… remover to strip and not only strip but renew, restore, to purify what has been lost to New Jersey salt, to the wash of sea air, to the humid fester of the southern summer, churning, oxidizing, but I nearly have all the pieces, I must. It can’t be more than one more trip to Advance, fair, maybe to AutoZone, at a loss in a panic O’ Reilly’s, they’re closed but no matter I can get what I wantneed, no need to rent a tool I have a full body shop at home, all the clamps and bleeders and hoses you could I could ever need to get rid of all this brake fluid, always so full of it, they sell it by pint or quart but it comes in gallons, great hot gallons it seems like, more pig mats more pig mats. Starved pigs will eat up anything I bet that’s how that got that name you know one good lift by the pinch … welds… you know you can’t do that body on frame, you’ve got to support the carchassiscassproper, the skin is no such way to lift such a thing that you could order from RockAuto is selling my purchase history to the FBI, no one needs this many radiators it’s not just suspect it’s criminal, we don’t know how yet but it’s ungodly, unholy whatever is happening in that bodies shop check your hoses and fittings man because you are leaking leaking you’ve got pink milkshake but your name isn’t Toyota at all it’s this damn brake fluid DOT one two three four five six seven eight nine ten twelve eighteen thirty-one when do they DOT STOP
(Happy Halloween & subscribe to the Autopian if you’re able!)
Hey, everything ok man? Breathe, just breathe.
My my air intake is so tight, my air filter is it’s full of leaves and bugs and filth, I can’t naturally aspirate
And all the fluid. So much fluid, fluids everywhere! And…
Thank you
Hey! Are you the dude who wrote Ulysses? I thought that guy was dead! Wow! Amazing to meet you here!
I read all that. You remind me of my friend Steve.
Are…you Steve?????
This.,.this reminded me of the mental gymnastics of a certain character from “1984”.
I wish I could sub right now, but after two back to back four digit car repair bills and another four digit medical bill, I’m tapped out for the foreseeable future.
If we ever have to fight the machines, me and my GTI will go down in a blaze of glory.
I’ve use a Google phone for years, and have always replied on the discover feature. It used to be great, but right around the time you first started writing about the AI changes I noticed discover got worse. I used to get autopian recommendations, even though I likely read it hours before I would still click in. But now everything is twitter links, and threads. I have made you a trusted source, but it still doesn’t seem to help. Getting tired of being recommended crap I hardly seek out news through that channel anymore. Membership here is well worth it, and I appreciate being able to contribute to the greater good that is human thought and written word. You guys are absolutely fantastic people also, so it helps knowing my money is going to actually good people.
I’ve had an Android for over a decade. The only time I find myself in Discover, is when I’ve gone there accidentally. I’ve never found it useful.
It doesn’t help that the perverse incentives of AI slop mean that about 50% of digital ad spend is wasted on bots clicking ads to drive traffic to sites that serve ads that are owned by…the people who deployed the bots. This was happening long before now, AI just makes the scam far more efficient. So the slop feeds the scam, but Google doesn’t really have an incentive to stop the scam because they’re the biggest beneficiaries of it.
Don’t use the Google.
And Facebook can also eat shit.
Duck Duck is the way to search.
Regret that I can’t even afford the cheap membership here.
It’s all good! Thank you for reading.
Do what I do – I look at the ads and add to the site’s viewership stats for selling to the advertizers.
Second on Duck Duck been using it so long when I DO use Google I don’t recognize it.
Membership makes you more attractive to your preferred romantic interests, flowers smell better, the sun is brighter, the world is weirder, and your cars instantly get more attention from fellow car nerds when parked in certain Walmart parking lots. It’s worth it!
Completely unrelated: Matt, I expect a check in the mail…
Many people are saying this…
Many really great people, the best people, really. Some people say, “Sir, that Autopian is the best.” And I say, “Yes, it’s good, like me.” And I say that all the time.
lol
I’m proud to be a member here. At first I just wanted to support the people making something I like. Now, it feels like we are at a point where we are fighting the man and the rise of our future robot overlords!*
*I, for one, welcome our future robot overlords. Please don’t send me to the mines, I can be useful to you in other (non-sexual) ways!
Damn the man, save the empire!
SHOPLIFTERRRRRRrrrrrRRRRRrrrRRRRR!!!!
So… road trip to Atlantic City?
I want to reiterate this: Membership here is literally going to these things:
That is to say: The Autopian is very responsible with how it spends. We are a machine that turns dollars into car-content, cool merch, meetups, and geekery.
>buying LaForza
>responsible spending
Can’t be any worse than a CrossCab that doesn’t like to be driven during the peak of summer! …Right?
It definitely can. But that’s Content!
Can’t be any dumber than things I’ve bought lately.
Can confirm
This Rodius erasure will not stand, man.
I fucking suffered and I’m not letting anyone forget it.
LOL!
I’m happy to have been a member since early on. I don’t comment too often, but I read multiple articles daily and love the comment sections.
Thank you, Matthew! It means a lot.
Go LeSharo over LaForza. Buy the RV!
I think this is useful from a board member perspective, but less on the bone from more of a crowdfunding perspective potentially worth exploring
Is there an opportunity to expose the irrational side of your community by soliciting funds for specific projects in addition to the actual membership?
Wedding registry style parts donation?
This week I made The Autopian™ one of my preferred sources.
I still visit Jalopnik once a day to vote for the NPOCP vehicles. Then I come to The Autopian to vote for the Shitbox Showdown.
I go to Jalopnik first because it opens in like a nanosecond, while The Autopian takes 5-8 seconds for the page to open, even if I click on The Autopian first.
That helps a lot, thank you! We are working on some ways to speed up the page. Hopefully, that’s Q1 of 2027.
Lol I got laid off again so I’ma get back to working on that, sigh.
Make sure you are using hamsters, not guinea pigs, to power the Sinclair 2000 servers. They have 37% more energy than hamsters, according to Gemini.
Ugh, so that’s why I’ve been gaining weight.
They have to be careful with hamsters, they have history with one named Nibbles.
Is there an easy way to add Autopian as a preferred source? A button I’m missing? It seems like I have to see a story via Google to add it easily on my own?
I see a lot of sites promoting adding themselves now via on-page icons, on the Discover-based stories I open. (And I never see Autopian there anymore grr, RSS is still my friend fortunately)
This link.
From Let Me Google That For You.
It should be the first image that shows up after the snarky page. 🙂
Cheers and done – when I did Google it, the AI crap claimed it was a whole rigamarole…
To stop your browser’s search box (omnibox) or Google search from using A.I., you can disable hidden Chrome flags or set up a custom default search engine that forces traditional web-only results.
Set a Web-Only Default Search Engine:
If A.I. overviews or features appear when searching, you can create a custom search shortcut that bypasses them entirely:
Apparently the way to avoid Google A.I. while searching on Google is to type what you’re looking for directly into the top address bar in Chrome – Who knew that was even a thing? – This bypasses Google’s A.I. overview results to asked questions.
Now I just have to see if I can get used to typing stuff into the address bar rather than the Google search bar on Google’s homepage.
https://tenbluelinks.org/#chrome-windows
Hope this helps somebody.
This strategy has never worked for me. 100 percent of my searches are through the address bar, and Google happily serves me AI slop. Also, searching using the address bar has been a thing since Google Chrome beta in 2008.
What I have found effective is placing a swear word into the search query.
If you use the above steps and change your sight search to ‘Google Web’ and change the URL to %s&udm=14 and save changes then Google should only show you web links. When I highlight text in an article or comment and right-click it, the search option I get is “Search Google Web for… (whatever I highlighted).
If I phrase a question on Google’s search page as a question, then I still get A.I. suggestions sometimes. If I paste the same question in the top address bar, I no longer get any A.I. results.
It’s refreshing.
Been doing this forever. Cuts down a bit on the verts too.
Being the Old I am, I was unaware of that functionality.
And, thanks to you, that is no longer the case. I hope selecting this site as a preferred source helps them somehow!
I just remembered that they asked us to do that a few months back so I searched for the article, found it, and added the link.
Glad it helped.
RSS is your friend.
I go to Jalopnik too, partly out of habit, mostly just to glance at what they’re up to, very occasionally reading what they write (because they hardly have anything interesting now). I spend more time on here to be honest.
Rob is a treasure and NPoND was what kept me at Jalopnik when this site started. Then I was skimming Jalopnik as a lot of posts seemed lower quality (even from some writers I liked, it just seemed like they weren’t given the opportunity to spend time on real reviews) and coming here for more content. Then I was stopping by Jalopnik just for NPorND and not even glancing at anything else. Finally Rob must have been on vacation, but after a couple of days without my morning ritual I stopped going to Jalopnik entirely.
It will always be NPOCP in my mind.
Membership here is worth it. The quality of the content here is unsupassed. If you think it can continue indefinitely without your contribution, please think again. Nobody can work for free, even if Google seems to think they should. The only way we can preserve this website we all love is to pay for the content according to our abilty. From $50 per year to whatever Rich Corinthian Leather costs, there is a level for almost everyone.
Thank you!
Well as a victim of the newspaper wars I can tell you that it is a losing game. Google conned real journalism by saying hey we will help set up your websites and all we want to do is be able to share your content outside your market. What a deal. Then Google set up Google news and cut traffic to the original content provider and sold ads based on traffic other people created. We sacrificed ourselves instead of creating our own website. From day one I saw what would happen and said we need to set up a web zone with audited media that would control our content. Nope newspapers destroyed and now it is doing the same thing to websites
Seen it in so many different sectors, it always starts out how great it will be, then once there are enough fingers around it, it gets snatched away.
Becoming an Autopian member brought back the feeling of picking up my black ’77 Firebird back in ’86. Sure, my 16-year-old self was running on raw testosterone and synth-pop, but my 56-year-old self hasn’t felt this right about a financial decision in a long time. Should’ve done it sooner. Keep killing it!
Thank you!
Man, it’s such a shame to see once highly regarded websites like ammameaend.com and juanlizpnk.com in such a state.
Gosh, I haven’t been to Jalopnik for years. Went back to see that spark plug article linked here and it’s very…interesting… I didn’t know Static Media owned so many sites. Planning to become a member here soon!
Appreciate it!
“How does it benefit Google to drive publishers out of business?”
Not at all if you think long or even medium term. But if you think like a major corporation it boosts the closing stock price. This is the same reason some of America’s once greatest corporations, the tentpoles of industry, have cut themselves into shadows of their former selves, mere names licensed to generic crap .
Long-term? Google gets to become one of very few major sources of information. Their long-term game is becoming the internet. This isn’t about stock prices, it’s about power.
Oh! Fantômas is on staff now? cool.
Is joining the Apple News ecosystem viable for independent publishers? Currently, the auto news available there is mostly slop (depending on one’s opinions of Jalopnik and The Drive + the remaining husks of the legacy magazines).
Defector, another independent, member based setup, is also available there, but I have no idea if it helps pull in new readers/subscribers for them. One disadvantage though is that one of its best features – the amazing commentate, just like the Autopian, does not feature on Apple News.
I was wondering what happened to the site! I tried to check it just after my shift and the servers were down. I just saw the update and I immediately caught bad vibes.
So sad, I’ve been perusing that site for over 10 years now. I won’t be going back
TBF Jalopnik was dead before this happened
I gave up on Jalopnik somewhere pre COVID. But I was a near-religious viewer of Carscoops.
Cheers. Appreciate that.