Being an independent publisher in 2026 is just watching Google repeatedly make your life miserable, no matter how much you attempt to play by the rules they tell you to follow. Carscoops, one of the last remaining independent sites in the car media universe, has been sold off to mega publisher Static Media, which also owns Jalopnik.
Yes, this will end with me asking you to become a member, because membership is the best way we have to bring you the articles and writers you love without having to stuff the site with a miserable amount of ads, slop, and junk. But first, I’d like to explain what’s happening.
Just to give you a chart to set your hair on fire, here’s what website tracking software Similarweb* shows as the last three months at two major publishers (I will blur their names):

Yikes! This shows a massive decline in traffic, as measured indirectly by Similarweb over the last three months. One site produces a lot of original content, and the other has a mix of original reporting and some SEO-chasing, lower quality contributions. I think it’s meaningful that neither were spared. My sense is that October is only going to be worse, and that this might explain why Carscoops is just the latest site to sell to a conglomerate.
Enshittification On Steroids
Most of the news or enthusiast sites you read, whether inside or outside of the automotive universe, are probably funded primarily by display advertising, and most of that is likely programmatic advertising (90% according to most sources). This isn’t a carmaker doing an ad deal with a publisher, this is one set of servers selling to another set of servers, with publishers getting a cut.
In theory, this means that anyone can set up a website and start making money without having a huge sales team (or any sales team at all). In practice, what this means is that ethical publishers have to walk a tightrope: more ads means more money, but you don’t want so many ads that the site is unreadable.
Under this system, independent sites once flourished, and much of that had to do with a tacit agreement between massive platforms (Facebook, Google) and publishers. These platforms needed good content to make their products work, and rewarded good content with traffic, that was then served advertising. Facebook was one of the first major traffic sources to pop up, and helped popularize Buzzfeed-y style listicles and curiosity gap headlines (You’ll never believe how quickly contributors to that company got screwed when the Facebook traffic went away).
The Autopian is a post-Facebook-Apocalypse site, so we knew when we started that we’d never want to be reliant on any social network for traffic. Google was a slightly different story. Google doesn’t produce “content” in a practical way. It has, historically, connected valuable content with readers. This was initially Search, which led to some hacky SEO writing (What time is the Super Bowl?), but also products like Google News, which rewarded original work.
In fact, Google still tells publishers that when it ranks content it’s looking for “helpful, reliable, people-first” content. With Google leaning hard into AI summaries, search traffic suddenly became less valuable. Because most people on the web use some sort of Google product, the company seemed to try to make up this gap with a product called Google Discover. As a site, our great and original content was rewarded with traffic via Google Discover.
This all made some sort of sense to me, because even Google’s AI products rely on on our work to feed its AI models. Gemini doesn’t review cars. It doesn’t cover car news. Google needs us, like we need them. You’d think that would be enough to save publishers, but you’d be wrong.

I’ve written about this before, but secondary monitoring shows that what Google Discover has rewarded included our own original content, made-up hallucinated nonsense like the above, and crappy trending writing. So long as it was also rewarding us, I was fine with it. We did bend our headlines a bit towards what we knew worked on the platform when some genius came up with a good headline configuration, but we mostly just covered what we knew would serve our readership.
And then Google Discover traffic dramatically dropped. According to the latest report from Chartbeat, since July 2024, Google Search has dropped by 46% as a share of traffic, and Google Discover dropped by 28.4%. That’s across all the sites that are served by Chartbeat. For news publishers I’ve spoken with, the hit from Google Discover has been much larger. Over the last 18 months, we’ve seen a 63.8% drop in Google Organic traffic according to Google Analytics, though we’re in better shape than many other publishers.
What is Google thinking? I don’t know, but I think two things are happening. The first is a product issue, with Google using AI-fueled summaries to reduce the amount of traffic sent to websites. The second is a Google attempting to clean up bad actors in its ecosystem–the hardest hit sites seem to create a lot of slop content. Unfortunately, it’s never felt like Google has ever been that good at determining what is good content and what is bad content in any sort of consistent way, so a lot of original reporting gets hit with friendly fire.
How This Forces Publishers Like Carscoops Into The Hands Of Private Equity And Mega Publishers

I’ve been a Carscoops fan for a long time, and I’ve appreciated the way that they cover just about everything car-related, including more of the smaller European car news we don’t always post about. For many years, I’ve worked with the site’s publisher and founder John Halas to understand the larger web publishing ecosystem, and I’ve valued the insight he’s provided.
Carscoops, though, doesn’t have a membership model or any other obvious source of revenue other than display advertising. This means that it had nothing really to buffer itself against Google’s unpredictable behavior. Even sites that get value other ways (affiliate revenue, sales funnel) haven’t been able to stand on their own. This is why one company now owns MotorTrend, Autoweek, Car And Driver, and Road & Track.
Static Media, which bought Carscoops, was the buyer of last resort for Jalopnik. The details of the sale likely won’t ever be revealed, but I can guess what happens next. The website has already been converted to look like a Static Media site and it seems like the masthead has shrunk, with longtime editors gone. If it follows the path of other Static Media sites, full-timers will be slowly bled off and replaced with some mix of permalancers and poorly paid outside freelancers edited by other freelancers, leading to some bizarre outcomes.
I’m glad the site will exist in some form and that at least a few writers will continue to have jobs, but I fear for what will happen to a once-thriving site that wasn’t beholden to a massive corporate parent.
How To Stop This From Happening Again

We don’t do AI-wrtten stories. We don’t do slop. We pay people fairly. None of this is easy, but it’s our belief that the slow decline of other sites will eventually lead people to realize that a website like The Autopian is worth supporting. The way we get that support is via membership.
If you’re already a member, thank you so much for being a part of the community. If you haven’t become a member yet and have thought about doing so, now would be a key time. This hit we’re getting from Google is happening exactly at the worst time, as this is the time of year when ad rates are at the highest. Bleeding our traffic now is a huge blow to our bottom line. It’ll take about 2,000 new members to make up for the loss we’re projecting this year from losing Google traffic.
Given that Google relies on us to provide it insight, I’m not sure what the end goal is here. How does it benefit Google to drive publishers out of business? I don’t know, but I want to continue to build a model that doesn’t rely on them as a source.
And, as a perk, if you become a member the display ads and video pop-up goes away.
Please join if you can.
*There is no direct way to compare two websites, as most sites don’t release traffic data, so this is the best way to currently compare, and I’ve found it to be accurate enough to get close to an apples-to-apples comparison.
Top photo: Carscoops/Library of Congress via WikiCommons






It’s sad to realize that all of the great car magazines that I grew up reading are now under one owner.
It’s clear a new model is needed.
Paying for content one enjoys should be the norm. The trouble is there is still so much free quasi entertaining content that paying for better, real writing is counterintuitive.
I remember when the NYT started a paywall after a brief confusing period during which their newspaper was free. Everyone predicted their demise. Now all newspapers worth a damn are paywalled, plus lawsuits are ongoing against digital platforms for IP theft. Maybe a better future will come out of all this- all we can do is hope and pay for the stuff we love.
Looking at those sample articles from Jalopnik reminded me why I haven’t read anything from them for a few years. JFC that was sad to look at. I couldn’t get past the point where it went from saying manuals can give you better fuel economy to acknowledging that modern automatics are more efficient in the same paragraph.
It makes me even more grateful this site exists.
I went back for a NPOND yesterday as an e63 caught my attention. My computer couldn’t even load the comments section, and the dynamic content was so forced in there, it broke the article about 3/4 the way down. The content is generally terrible, their social strategy appears to be regurgitating year-old articles at random, and the site is so broken you can’t even read the garbage you don’t want to see.
Poor Rob Emslie (NPOND series) is the only writer worth a damn over there anymore, and the only thing I periodically check.
I share your respect for Mr Emslie but confess I found I had stopped going there some time ago.
NPOND was the last thing I kept going back for after The Autopian hit their stride. I haven’t looked at it for at least a year. I agree that Rob Emslie deserves better than having his fine work trapped on that sinking ship.
I still get email updates from the Drive and if it’s one of two authors, I will sometimes click it and read. I will say that sometimes the short format is easier to get through. I love the long format here but don’t know that it needs to be every article. Unfortunately, I don’t have the time anymore to just sit and read everything so have had to become a little more selective
I don’t have a source for this, but it stuck with me, and seems to be proving true. It is estimated that 80% of AD traffic is just one bot talking to another. For instance The Google AI bots harvesting web content to feed their “search” algorithms, or now AI agents. In essence Google AD money was being paid to their own bots, which eventually turns out to be bad business. Rather than fix the problem, it’s better to just shoot everyone in the face and stop paying AD revenue that isn’t going to actual humans.
That’s been the case for a long time, and there’s also a lot of fraud involved (pumping views, etc). There’s a whole economy around ad verification — DoubleVerify and Integrated Ad Science are two biggies. DV is public and a quick check of their stock price puts their value around $1.5B. Everyone gets their cut except the people creating the content…
Yep, it’s a hidden bubble economy that will either burst, or burn the whole Internet to the ground.
I’ve worked designing web sites since around 2003. And all of that and what I’ve known is being turned on its head. The “problem” now is that whenever anyone does a search for anything the first results are of an Ai-generated summary. And that summary is getting longer and longer. Where this is heading is eventually nobody will go to the actual web sites: They will instead just look at their phone’s default screen.
I’ve already told a few people at work: Web sites are going extinct. None of them believe me but I truly think that is where this is eventually heading.
But would that then not wipe out Google’s business model too? If there are no more websites, where will the AI summary content come from?
I am not saying you are wrong; I am just wondering why Google is doing this when they are shooting themselves in the foot by doing it.
I could also be wrong. But I just-for example- observe my own behavior. As in- time to do XXX in the house or to the car or any number of pedestrian things. I don’t go to sites for this anymore. Instead its all neatly spelled out in a summary. Granted the data came from a bunch of web sites.
It’ll be gradual but the way we browse and read web sites will probably change pretty dramatically. At my job we’re already being told to make sure and load up the web sites with as much crap as possible so the Ai tools and pull the data.
Web sites could go away. Or they could just increasingly become places to park shit tons of data that will only be seen in a summary versus people going to the physical site.
Strange time to be in this business. It feels like most of us who’ve done this a long time are seriously considering different career paths. Almost all of the work I do is and will eventually be replaced with Ai and robots. Its sad. I really enjoyed making these things.
Why would publishers want their content to wind up in the AI summaries? Out of the vain hope that someone will go to the source website after all?
Tons of shit data…FTFY
Google is betting on behavioral capture via Gemini. Their war chest is big enough that they can let Anthropic and OpenAI fight to the death then pick off the loser.
It reminds me of the Scorpion and Frog fable, except that the scorpion is massive and the frog is getting tinier by the day.
I have noticed that as well in regards to the AI “summaries” getting longer and longer. Makes it seem like they are trying to make a short format article sometimes
Member here… will continue to be one and do membery things.
This is far and away the best automotive ‘home’ on the internet. I’ve been a member since the beginning and find the value to be incredible. I encourage others to do the same.
Same here!
The Autopian is not a website. It’s a lifestyle and an ethos. To me it’s like a digital owners club that transcends physical place. Compelling content keeps us coming in but what’s just as important is the vibe of being here. If the commenters were as miserable as they got on the lightning bolt site I would enjoy it here. so, I’m saying thanks to our authors and members for being stand up humans who bring some humor and lightheartedness to the world.
All my money goes to this, and of course, Calico Cut Pants.
For both, you gotta give!
The little dots!!
Fuck google.
I believe the best remedy for enshitification is to give a cold hard shoulder.
Here are some alternatives I have been using lately:
The list goes on.
None of these alternatives works as good as google. But then none of the honest cyclists could keep up with a cheating Lance Armstrong either.
It feels good to be somewhat free.
(And yes, I am considering membership.)
My thoughts exactly!
Please become a member if it fits in your budget.
This is the way forward.
I am sad to have lost Autoweek to Hurst.
I do not subscribe to any of that crap.
About a year ago I switched to ProtonMail to get away from GMail. In the next few days I plan to move my phone over the GrapheneOS to distance myself a bit from Android.
Neither of these are perfect ways to cut Google out, but they are little steps.
I found a nice, albeit inflammatory alternative to Proton, hosted email from fuck.it
So I now have an incredibly childish @fuck.it email address. Their model is paid service, no data mining, encrypted at rest, and hosted in Germany so it has all the privacy laws baked into the service. They also offer alternative office solutions at higher paid tiers. It’s not a ton of money, and I get to snicker everytime I use my shiny new email address..
I switched to DuckDuckGo for search right about the time Google really leaned into AI summaries.
(Both on my desktops at home/work and on my Android.)
Only that Qwant now often provides something it calls “Flash Response” but which looks uncannily like an AI summary.
Thanks for the info on qwant. I’m going to give it a try.
I started moving my email to a paid provider (Fastmail – Proton gives me bad vibes, I won’t go into it all) last year. For messaging, I recommend Matrix/Element. Works kind of like Discord, but it’s an open protocol (like email) and offers encryption, etc.
Qwant seems good. They have a partnership with my browser of choice, Waterfox (Firefox fork with better privacy and customization). I’ve also looked into the paid search engine Kagi, which did good on some trial searches, but I don’t have the budget to take on another paid service right now.
I understand that cost cutting works, and getting rid of all your editors and contributors makes for a lean operation.
What I don’t understand is how the traffic doesn’t crash even harder after all these changes are made.
I stopped reading Autoblog when it shut down. I stopped reading Jalopnik when it was bought out. It wasn’t out of solidarity for the writers or some righteous indignation (although I obviously wish them well). As a casual reader, I didn’t necessarily know what was going on behind the scenes. It’s just that the content became absolute garbage, overnight.
The enshitification was immediate and far reaching. How have those websites maintained viewership at all? Is it just inertia from the brand?
I can’t imagine anyone reading Autoblog today being faced with the 300th “Here’s how studded tires can actually make your morning coffee more bitter” BS slop thinking it’s the same website as it always was.
Think of it in terms of 80’s TV.
It’s not what they choose to watch, it’s what’s on.
If the people taking over these sites took over a restaurant, they would simply stop buying ingredients and watch their operating costs plummet! Genius!
Kudos to Matt, very nice obituary. It’s an unfortunate end and I’m no longer with Carscoops after nearly a decade. At least there’s a few independent voices left.
Now that Google has hoovered up the entire Internet, it can afford to withhold traffic from the sites that fed into its corpus and let them die, because no new information will ever need to be published.
Thanks for the deep dive, Matt. For someone like me who knows nothing of online publishing, it’s interesting and highly dismaying to get an idea of what’s going on. I very much hope you and the rest of the Autopian group have this figured out and will continue putting out high quality articles as well as providing a space for all of us whacked out car junkies to get together for a long time to come.
Last of the independents?
https://youtu.be/TxaqjQWQVAk
Love that movie,
I just upped my membership to vinyl. We need places like this.
Less derangedly, I’d ask what the plan is for when AI-slop output is the primary source for AI-slop input, but there’s no plan and there never has been. It’s been a naked smash and grab since day one, an extraordinary theft of human creative endeavor the likes of which should make video game publishers bitching about piracy blush because it’s a strong, principled stand but oh wait they’re salivating, since they can now steal from the entirety of humanity without (immediate) consequence.
Round one of social media, Google, and Amazon made the internet a worse, more ruthlessly consolidated space. Round two may kill it altogether (sigh, yes, there will still technically and technologically be an “internet,” and you could hypothetically start a site, etc etc, but places like The Autopian will have died, but you’ll be able to read all about the recently leaked 2028 Corvette pickup with jump seats and a unique external 12V battery package on a Google AI summary soon enough).
Yeah, everyone is predicting the wrong danger. They think it’s a super-powerful general AI that will end humanity. But it’s actually going to be an ecosystem of inbred AI that has lost all truth, purpose, and meaning and a humanity that has forgotten how to think.
Well said
If you ask high school teachers and college professors, humanity is well on its way to your suggested endpoint.
AI is going to end up being our society’s version of all the Romans eating off of lead plates for a few generations.*
*Okay, they didn’t actually use lead tableware, but they did use it for plumbing and in cookware, and had a lot of heavy metal pollution from smelting operations. They may have suffered an average IQ drop of 2 to 3 points; we’ll be lucky if it’s only that much.
Considering my day job is in public ed administration (former HS math teacher) and my other job is teaching undergrads…
Romans were broadly adding lead acetate to crappy wine to improve the flavor. Maybe an even better parallel to our nicotine crewing, testosterone injecting, destroy all regulatory rule making society.
Adding lead to wine seems a bit like our current transition from nicotine-delivered-as-lung-clogging-smoke-particles to nicotine-delivered-as-lung-burning-steam. Sort of a “you know, this vice ain’t bad enough – let’s see if we can make it worse” kind of deal.
Owned operated and lorded over by the techbros and their bought and paid for pols.
I am a member (see badge) and hope to be one for as long as I can (age-wise, as I am an old person with sufficient resources for membership). Even though I would get dumped from most car ‘enthusiast’ sites, I feel at home and welcome here. The community is so good, that I’ve been known to sneak down and read comments first. I promise that I go back and read the articles. Thanks to all the The Autopians and hope to see many people in Alameda later this month.
Aww man…
When I was starting out back then all those years ago, Carscoops was one of my go-to websites for automotive news (along with the usual suspects like Autoblog, Jalopnik etc). They were always reliable and consistent, and I remain a fan to this day even if I’ve not been a regular visitor for some time now.
For shame. It’s sad how automotive content (and actually just content in general) has descended to this state.
Cheers Ben.
It’s bad enough that I’ve lost most of my actual paper paged car magazines I looked forward to getting in the mail every month, (Had 12 subscriptions, now 4 as they slowly die off) now these corporate whores are going after digital, too???? Enough is enough car fellow car lovers! We must revolt!!!!
I just renewed here for the (I think) 2nd time, and I’ll say y’all are the 2nd place to get my sub, but the only one to get to keep it. Keep up the quirks!
I’m reminded of Frostpunk – the last of humanity huddled around a generator with dwindling resources as the world around us goes cold.
The Generator is powered by memberships, and this AI-excused collapse in traffic is the storm. The city must survive!
Perhaps someday, this winter will end. I can’t imagine how it could.
(Unfortunately, my member badge will be taking a vacation soon unless I can find my own source of funding…I imagine if the times weren’t otherwise difficult, the surge of support for independent media would have been even greater.)
What sets The Autopian apart is the community and how the writers care, engage, and each have their own distinct quirky personality. Proud to be a member for life!
This is a big part of my professional life right now, although slightly different. I work for a large company that’s both a publisher and a straight-ahead B2B biz. Our organic traffic (of which I’m responsible for maximizing) is down 66% this year. It’s brutal, we’re (organic traffic) the largest source of revenue loss, and nobody understands how Google AI Overviews and LLM chat-based search saps organic traffic that will never come back. Not fun. And Google’s own advice blows.
I give more than half of my personal media budget to independent producers. This site, a handful of indie podcasts, and PBS (MPT – home of Motorweek) after the removal of federal funding. I’m willing to pay more for authentic and interesting content. Not everyone can. What really sucks is the pool of choice is just evaporating so fast. I love this site and will cheer all the things that make it great, but I’ve kicked three sites’ RSS feeds to the curb just this month that I’ve been reading for more than a decade — one for almost 20 years. It deeply depresses me. When Autoblog lobotomized itself, then Jalopnik, now Carscoops and that’s just on the car side (C/D is hanging on for dear life — keeping that just for the retro reviews). Similar stories for me in tech, sports, and even local news. The limitation of points of view with these sites disappearing is approaching a dangerous low level of diversity.
How much does/could merch contribute to your bottom line?
Asking both because I’m curious and because I missed my stainoflauge mk 1 chance apparently forever :'(