Home » One Of The Last Independent Car Sites Loses Its Independence As Google Strangles Publishers

One Of The Last Independent Car Sites Loses Its Independence As Google Strangles Publishers

Carscoops Google Ts

Being an independent publisher in 2026 is just watching Google repeatedly make your life miserable, no matter how much you attempt to play by the rules they tell you to follow. Carscoops, one of the last remaining independent sites in the car media universe, has been sold off to mega publisher Static Media, which also owns Jalopnik.

Yes, this will end with me asking you to become a member, because membership is the best way we have to bring you the articles and writers you love without having to stuff the site with a miserable amount of ads, slop, and junk. But first, I’d like to explain what’s happening.

Vidframe Min Top
Vidframe Min Bottom

Just to give you a chart to set your hair on fire, here’s what website tracking software Similarweb* shows as the last three months at two major publishers (I will blur their names):

Visits Over Time 1
Source: SImilarweb

Yikes! This shows a massive decline in traffic, as measured indirectly by Similarweb over the last three months. One site produces a lot of original content, and the other has a mix of original reporting and some SEO-chasing, lower quality contributions. I think it’s meaningful that neither were spared. My sense is that October is only going to be worse, and that this might explain why Carscoops is just the latest site to sell to a conglomerate.

Enshittification On Steroids

Most of the news or enthusiast sites you read, whether inside or outside of the automotive universe, are probably funded primarily by display advertising, and most of that is likely programmatic advertising (90% according to most sources). This isn’t a carmaker doing an ad deal with a publisher, this is one set of servers selling to another set of servers, with publishers getting a cut.

In theory, this means that anyone can set up a website and start making money without having a huge sales team (or any sales team at all). In practice, what this means is that ethical publishers have to walk a tightrope: more ads means more money, but you don’t want so many ads that the site is unreadable.

Under this system, independent sites once flourished, and much of that had to do with a tacit agreement between massive platforms (Facebook, Google) and publishers. These platforms needed good content to make their products work, and rewarded good content with traffic, that was then served advertising. Facebook was one of the first major traffic sources to pop up, and helped popularize Buzzfeed-y style listicles and curiosity gap headlines (You’ll never believe how quickly contributors to that company got screwed when the Facebook traffic went away).

The Autopian is a post-Facebook-Apocalypse site, so we knew when we started that we’d never want to be reliant on any social network for traffic. Google was a slightly different story. Google doesn’t produce “content” in a practical way. It has, historically, connected valuable content with readers. This was initially Search, which led to some hacky SEO writing (What time is the Super Bowl?), but also products like Google News, which rewarded original work.

In fact, Google still tells publishers that when it ranks content it’s looking for “helpful, reliable, people-first” content. With Google leaning hard into AI summaries, search traffic suddenly became less valuable. Because most people on the web use some sort of Google product, the company seemed to try to make up this gap with a product called Google Discover. As a site, our great and original content was rewarded with traffic via Google Discover.

This all made some sort of sense to me, because even Google’s AI products rely on on our work to feed its AI models. Gemini doesn’t review cars. It doesn’t cover car news. Google needs us, like we need them. You’d think that would be enough to save publishers, but you’d be wrong.

Posts 1
Screenshot: Marfeel

I’ve written about this before, but secondary monitoring shows that what Google Discover has rewarded included our own original content, made-up hallucinated nonsense like the above, and crappy trending writing. So long as it was also rewarding us, I was fine with it. We did bend our headlines a bit towards what we knew worked on the platform when some genius came up with a good headline configuration, but we mostly just covered what we knew would serve our readership.

And then Google Discover traffic dramatically dropped. According to the latest report from Chartbeat, since July 2024, Google Search has dropped by 46% as a share of traffic, and Google Discover dropped by 28.4%. That’s across all the sites that are served by Chartbeat. For news publishers I’ve spoken with, the hit from Google Discover has been much larger. Over the last 18 months, we’ve seen a 63.8% drop in Google Organic traffic according to Google Analytics, though we’re in better shape than many other publishers.

What is Google thinking? I don’t know, but I think two things are happening. The first is a product issue, with Google using AI-fueled summaries to reduce the amount of traffic sent to websites. The second is a Google attempting to clean up bad actors in its ecosystem–the hardest hit sites seem to create a lot of slop content. Unfortunately, it’s never felt like Google has ever been that good at determining what is good content and what is bad content in any sort of consistent way, so a lot of original reporting gets hit with friendly fire.

How This Forces Publishers Like Carscoops Into The Hands Of Private Equity And Mega Publishers

Carscoops Drop
Photo: Carscoops

I’ve been a Carscoops fan for a long time, and I’ve appreciated the way that they cover just about everything car-related, including more of the smaller European car news we don’t always post about. For many years, I’ve worked with the site’s publisher and founder John Halas to understand the larger web publishing ecosystem, and I’ve valued the insight he’s provided.

Carscoops, though, doesn’t have a membership model or any other obvious source of revenue other than display advertising. This means that it had nothing really to buffer itself against Google’s unpredictable behavior. Even sites that get value other ways (affiliate revenue, sales funnel) haven’t been able to stand on their own. This is why one company now owns MotorTrend, Autoweek, Car And Driver, and Road & Track.

Static Media, which bought Carscoops, was the buyer of last resort for Jalopnik. The details of the sale likely won’t ever be revealed, but I can guess what happens next. The website has already been converted to look like a Static Media site and it seems like the masthead has shrunk, with longtime editors gone. If it follows the path of other Static Media sites, full-timers will be slowly bled off and replaced with some mix of permalancers and poorly paid outside freelancers edited by other freelancers, leading to some bizarre outcomes.

I’m glad the site will exist in some form and that at least a few writers will continue to have jobs, but I fear for what will happen to a once-thriving site that wasn’t beholden to a massive corporate parent.

How To Stop This From Happening Again

Autopian Members Top
Photo: The Autopian

We don’t do AI-wrtten stories. We don’t do slop. We pay people fairly. None of this is easy, but it’s our belief that the slow decline of other sites will eventually lead people to realize that a website like The Autopian is worth supporting. The way we get that support is via membership.

If you’re already a member, thank you so much for being a part of the community. If you haven’t become a member yet and have thought about doing so, now would be a key time. This hit we’re getting from Google is happening exactly at the worst time, as this is the time of year when ad rates are at the highest. Bleeding our traffic now is a huge blow to our bottom line. It’ll take about 2,000 new members to make up for the loss we’re projecting this year from losing Google traffic.

Given that Google relies on us to provide it insight, I’m not sure what the end goal is here. How does it benefit Google to drive publishers out of business? I don’t know, but I want to continue to build a model that doesn’t rely on them as a source.

And, as a perk, if you become a member the display ads and video pop-up goes away.

Please join if you can.

*There is no direct way to compare two websites, as most sites don’t release traffic data, so this is the best way to currently compare, and I’ve found it to be accurate enough to get close to an apples-to-apples comparison.

Top photo: Carscoops/Library of Congress via WikiCommons

 

 

 

Follow us on:

Facebook
WhatsApp
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Subscribe
Notify of
215 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Logan
Member
Logan
1 month ago

Not for nothing but based on some of the “articles” I’ve seen in the past year or so whenever I stumble across orange blurred line graph that’s quite a few million too many.

Last edited 1 month ago by Logan
PlatinumZJ
Member
PlatinumZJ
1 month ago

Wow, it’s just turning into a bigger and bigger mess out there. I’m more than happy to keep paying for my Autopian subscription! I still have two print magazine subscriptions, one of which may be on its way out for me due to what I see as a creeping shift toward “gee isn’t A.I. great!” content.

Nick Adams
Nick Adams
1 month ago

Well, all the anti-government types are happy, no regulation means Google gets content for free and then makes all the money when people consume said content. Resource extraction for nothing, yay small government.

Steve L
Member
Steve L
1 month ago

I’ve also been a paying member since (pretty much) the beginning. I’m currently at the Cloth level and would consider upgrading, but it seems I’d lose my current paid time if I did that. Have you considered some sort of upgrade credit path, or is that more trouble than it’s worth? If nothing else, I can set myself a reminder to upgrade when it’s close to renewal time.

Spopepro
Member
Spopepro
1 month ago
Reply to  Steve L

I could be remembering incorrectly, but I believe when I bumped up I got pro-rated. But hopefully Matt or someone will swing through and see this.

Mr. Asa
Member
Mr. Asa
1 month ago
Reply to  Spopepro

I’ve been pro-rated before. Just email Matt when you do the upgrade and he should be able to help through the process.

Zags
Member
Zags
1 month ago

Happy to continue to support this site as it’s my most visited site and certainly where I spend a majority of my internet reading time. It’s the only site I pay for and I want it to continue! Keep up the good work!

Vadertime
Vadertime
1 month ago

I think it was back in 2010 or 2011 when Google offered itself up for sale to Yahoo! Yahoo! rejected the offer and chose it’s own search engine. So, here we are a decade and a half late when everyone hates Google, because it’s the 900lb Gorilla on the block.

I retired 2 years ago after a 40 year career in computers and software application development. When I was trained by the phone company and began my career as a computer programmer there was only “Big Iron” – IBM mainframes. Now, the Android phone I carry in my pocket is more powerful then those mainframes on which I worked 40 years ago.

For all you people who hate Google, please feel free to go over to Apple or Microsoft. Google dwarfs them both in services and products. In business we talk about a natural monopoly. Your electric company, gas company, utilities company and trash pickup fall into this category of natural monopolies. Google is rapidly becoming a natural monopoly. European governments are trying to legislate control of the internet away from Google. It’s an effort in futility.

I don’t pay for my news content. Over the past 25 years, even when I had my Yahoo! news pages, I did not pay for news and information. Please go ahead and put up your pay wall. It’s only a short-term solution. Good luck and thanks for all the fish. Cheers.

Rapgomi
Member
Rapgomi
1 month ago
Reply to  Vadertime

In 2010 Google was still a decent enough search engine. Now its worthless slop. How is something that does not require a physical presence like most utilities a natural monopoly? Was ATT a natural monopoly? Perhaps in its desperation to use AI for everything, and justify its monstrous cost, Google will go the way of Yahoo.

Some people are willing to pay for a good resource.
Some are willing to swallow slop.

CR-V Oswald
Member
CR-V Oswald
1 month ago
Reply to  Vadertime

It was in 2001-2002, not 2001-2011. Google was 3-4 years old then.

If a paywall is only a short-term solution, what do you suggest would be a good long-term solution?

Really No Regrets
Member
Really No Regrets
1 month ago
Reply to  Vadertime

Interesting you want free content, though highly unlikely you created ‘content’, or worked, for free.

Enjoy the socialization of members supplying you with ‘free’ content.

Hope you have the day you voted for!

Moonball96
Member
Moonball96
1 month ago

I’m not a big commenter cause I feel like my two cents doesn’t add up but I do so enjoy being a member and supporting this site (and reading everyone else’s fun comments cause some of y’all are just hilarious people and I would subscribe to your newsletter if you have one)

CR-V Oswald
Member
CR-V Oswald
1 month ago
Reply to  Matt Hardigree

The CMS mangled that link and inserted <span> in the middle.

Here’s a hopefully correct link:

https://substack.com/@TheAutopian

Last edited 1 month ago by CR-V Oswald
Thomas The Tank Engine
Member
Thomas The Tank Engine
1 month ago

Member here. Been visiting since the day you started, visit every day, read almost everything. Happy to pay for the privilege of your fine work.

Vetatur Fumare
Member
Vetatur Fumare
1 month ago

Google harms websites, but Google has also become almost entirely useless for searching. I am an avid car photographer and I also like to do a bit of research on the cars I photograph (as in the individual examples) – this used to be easy, but nowadays I cannot find anything useful whatsoever, even with chassis numbers in hand. Just last night I managed, after a good half hour, to find a Bonhams auction listing by following up links in other articles, but the auction description would not show up in Google. Only garbage sites and ones that demand money to share information about particular cars (looking at you, ECR/Exclusive Car Registry). Message boards and brand specific websites have disappeared entirely; Il Cavallino and Forum-Auto no longer appear.

I try different search engines but nope. Everything is limited to recent things, to items in American English, and results in my vicinity. It’s like living behind a great firewall. As it stands, I have to use a VPN before I am able to obtain results that are not US-centric, but even then, Google suspects me of being American and pushes American results.

DiscoPotato
DiscoPotato
1 month ago

Huh, I always avoided Carscoops because I was under the impression it was just a car tabloid, like Buzzfeed with cars. I couldn’t tell you why I thought that, maybe I read a clickbait headline and just wrote off the whole website as I tend to do that from time to time.

Now you’re telling me it was a legitimate website with real news?… Now I feel bad for not supporting them.

BB 2 wheels > 4
Member
BB 2 wheels > 4
1 month ago

How many members strong is TheAutopian. As someone who works a bit in the publisher space, this is very difficult to see happening to small indepndent publishers. The internet is not what it used to be. But car people still be car people.

EXL500
Member
EXL500
1 month ago

I miss magazines. I was just thinking earlier I haven’t been on motortrend.com recently.

RC
RC
1 month ago

That Jalopnik article on manual transmission may be the worst thing I’ve read today.

I’ll grief Gen Z for not knowing that it’s okay to capitalize letters and that you don’t need to end every sentence on a duplicated letter, but at least the thoughts they’re articulating are cogent.

That article, though. I wondered if whoever was involved in that drafting/editing/”click publish” pipeline has ever sat in a vehicle, taken a series of successive breaths, and/or consumed anything at “Dr. Seuss” level or higher.

Mike
Member
Mike
1 month ago
Reply to  RC

The most bizarre thing I’ve ever seen (although I’m sure it’s a feature, not a bug): that link changes! Half the time I click on it, I get the insanely stupid manual transmission article, the other half of the time, it’s an even more insanely stupid article about cold weather destroying spark plug.

twentyonePSI
Member
twentyonePSI
1 month ago
Reply to  Mike

It’s two separate links. The spark plug story is WILD, too lol

Melendez69
Melendez69
1 month ago

I noticed the different format yesterday… and thought how strangely it resembled Jalopnik’s format. I guess one less site to read.

Horizontally Opposed
Member
Horizontally Opposed
1 month ago
Reply to  Melendez69

Carscoops provides a good addition to my daily car fix. Autopians are precious and few so only so much they can cover. We need diversity and Carscoops provided it.

Javier Chavez
Member
Javier Chavez
1 month ago

Now you only need 1999 new members! Could not find the ‘Do not fulfill button’ but if you can see my new membership on your side, please save the cost and Do not fulfill. Best of luck on your membership drive!

Matthew Carroll
Member
Matthew Carroll
1 month ago

New member today! How do I change this profile pic though as I think this is what D.J. Byrnes was found guilty of sending his senator.

Richard Truett
Member
Richard Truett
1 month ago

I have become member recently. I really regret not joining sooner. After your visit to Detroit where we chatted in the Wal Mart parking lot, I knew your dedication to producing quality, original, fresh, fun and thought-provoking automotive journalism was not only real, but a passion of the Autopian team.
Also: fuck Google.

Scott Alan Finkeldei
Member
Scott Alan Finkeldei
1 month ago

Thanks for sharing some insider details and helping make this site an actual destination website, like sites of old, with writers and topics I want to read.

Fourmotioneer
Member
Fourmotioneer
1 month ago

I’d personally welcome a vinyl membership where you keep the tshirt and bumper sticker. Would prefer the modest cost of those plus mailing to stay with the site

MalibuVTX
Member
MalibuVTX
1 month ago
Reply to  Matt Hardigree

I agree, i don’t need more t-shirts either, so if that’s helpful i’ll set mine to Do Not Fulfill as well.

Fourmotioneer
Member
Fourmotioneer
1 month ago
Reply to  Matt Hardigree

To be clear was I just missing this to begin with? Or are you proposing the DO NOT FULFILL moving forward?

Regardless nice!

Jdoubledub
Member
Jdoubledub
1 month ago
Reply to  Matt Hardigree

I recently upgraded from Cloth to Vinyl and was getting curious about when I’d see the T-shirt. Just checked and I never entered an address! Got that fixed so hopefully it triggers fulfillment.

Dan1101
Dan1101
1 month ago
Reply to  Matt Hardigree

I’d also appreciate PayPal and/or Ko-Fi payment options, my wallet is never nearby when I’m reading.

Last edited 1 month ago by Dan1101
Really No Regrets
Member
Really No Regrets
1 month ago
Reply to  Matt Hardigree

Please add this option on the left side of the memberful (whatever it’s called) webpage, which includes “Account”, “Subscriptions”, etc.

“DO NOT FULFILL” tick box choice, and something that succinctly explains what ticking the box means.

Thanks!

The Clutch Rider
Member
The Clutch Rider
1 month ago
Reply to  Fourmotioneer

i think those are fun and promoting the site as well. I know the lego t-shirts are a real conversation starter.

Pusher9000
Member
Pusher9000
1 month ago

RIP Autoblog.

Goblin
Member
Goblin
1 month ago

A non-event in my book. Never cared for carscoops much.
There are two types of automotive/powersports outlets – the ones who do long-term reviews with their own money at least from time to time, and the ones to idle chat on.

Car&Driver, Edmunds, are still out there. Motorcycle ones we are losing most of them, but then again this represents the motorcycle market as a whole.

From the idle chat ones – I discovered The Autopian when I finally gave up on trying to get ANY comment past approval on Jalopnik – they were all stuck in approval hell forever, from different accounts I created. Good thing it happened.

PS: Well now. Welcome me to Cloth. I slipped.

Last edited 1 month ago by Goblin
David Tracy
Admin
David Tracy
1 month ago
Reply to  Goblin

Goblin! Thank you! And if there’s any more specific content you want, we’re always listening.

Goblin
Member
Goblin
1 month ago
Reply to  David Tracy

Well David, now that I pay all of five bucks a month, I own you all, and you are to service all my whims, so let’s start with:

_ As a side quest for the taillight secret society – lobby Congress to mandate amber turn signals, or if they are to be red – have them be mandatorily separated from the stop lights by some distance. Abduct the ones that vote against, and have them follow a 2000 Lincoln Town Car in the rain, by night, on the FDR in Manhattan, and have them guess whether the car is stopping, signaling, or both.

_ Dive into the beautiful, and about to die, science of gauge cluster design. How could the early 2000s Lexus IS300 cluster, the moving cluster of the LC500, the 1st gen NSX, the 4th Gen Supra gauge clusters coexist in the same astral plane as all-on-single screen systems without the Universe exploding from outrage?

_ Dig into the dark sides of car cabin ergonomics, specifically driver-oriented. Are there actually design teams with real people working on this nowadays?

_ Will the comment section ever get image embedding, a non-crazy carriage return & bulletpont handling (see my underscores to mark a bulletpoint? Yes, they are there in the hope my post doesn’t get compressed into one unformatted sentence), font color ?

That’s it for now. Next time we’ll discuss why EDM CRX is better than JDM CRX.

EXL500
Member
EXL500
1 month ago
Reply to  Goblin

I would love image embedding here

RataTejas
RataTejas
1 month ago
Reply to  EXL500

That’s a lot of server space. Especially if people hotlink.

Thx1138
Member
Thx1138
1 month ago

I had to drop down a level due to life changes but this is still worth the money for a place to come and flush my brain when things are tough to handle.

Church
Member
Church
1 month ago

(I will blur their names):

But did you, though?

Rockchops
Member
Rockchops
1 month ago

In this economy, things are tough. I’m going to have to choose between winter spark plugs and Autopian membership.

215
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x