Home » When Your Expensive Scratch-Built Jeep Is Technically Cheaper Than Its Spiritual Successor: COTD

When Your Expensive Scratch-Built Jeep Is Technically Cheaper Than Its Spiritual Successor: COTD

Joopcomment

David Tracy pulled off what seemed like the impossible. He took hundreds of parts scattered across his house and yard, then somehow turned them into a working World War II Jeep. I’ve said it before, but David was one of my inspirations when I was a young adult, as was Jason. Crazy projects like the Jeep build are why. Anyway, as it turns out, it was crazy expensive, but somehow cheaper than a 2026 Jeep Wrangler Willys Edition.

David wrote about how much his hand-built WWII Jeep cost him to build. James McHenry:

Vidframe Min Top
Vidframe Min Bottom

Your 2026 Willys MB still snuck under the MSRP of a 2-door 2026 Jeep Wrangler Willys Edition. In fact, the only cheaper Wranglers are the Sport and Sport S. So in 2026 terms, still a pretty Cheap Jeep.

Hoser68:

Thank you, David.

I’ve done and seen enough projects to know that this is a realistic price for something like this. It sounds shocking because it seems like it shouldn’t be that expensive, but everything adds up QUICKLY. I’m actually shocked you didn’t exceed $50k when the dust settles.

There will be many outside of here that think “For $42,500 plus all that labor, David could have bought a brand new Wrangler that was much more capable, faster and had a better warranty.” Which is completely true, but completely missing the point.

We live in a world that all our hobbies seem to have to be monetarized. “If you can’t sell it on Etsy for a profit, you shouldn’t do it.” I call BS

David made his own jeep with tons of sleepless nights and busted knuckles and, if he is like me, about 5 pirate ships worth of cuss words. Oh and for a LOT more money than it would have cost to go to a dealership and just picked out the red one.

AND he’s thrilled with it. Which is the ultimate point.

Jeep says that a 1945 CJ-2A was $1,090 new. That means that David didn’t even beat inflation, as that 1945 Jeep’s price would be $20,521 today. Apparently, the government paid even less for the military versions. But, David also built it with his own two hands, which he couldn’t say about a new Wrangler.

Antti wrote about James Bond’s Saab. Dogisbadob had me giggling with:

James Bønd. :-p

Matt wrote a Morning Dump about Porsche 911 sales, and finished by asking you about your favorite 911. Taargus Taargus:

Probably Reno 911.

DKW

Finally, Jason wrote about a weird Brazilian car again. Y2Keith:

Munga only pawn in game of life.

Have a great evening, everyone!

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on whatsapp
WhatsApp
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on reddit
Reddit
Subscribe
Notify of
14 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
RustyJunkyardClassicFanatic
Member
RustyJunkyardClassicFanatic
1 month ago

“didn’t even beat inflation”
The tires looked full to me…
I’ll see myself out…

1978fiatspyderfan
1978fiatspyderfan
1 month ago

Jeep says $1,090? Well That was based on stealing the design and a quite a large volume discount. Let’s ask Jeep to release a similar model today for their $20,521 price they will sell a ton

Manwich Sandwich
Member
Manwich Sandwich
1 month ago

Jeep says that a 1945 CJ-2A was $1,090 new. That means that David didn’t even beat inflation, as that 1945 Jeep’s price would be $20,521 today. Apparently, the government paid even less for the military versions. “

Yeah… that’s the magic of mass production.

Samurai87
Samurai87
1 month ago

“We live in a world that all our hobbies seem to have to be monetarized. “If you can’t sell it on Etsy for a profit, you shouldn’t do it.” I call BS”
I like to fly fish and tie flies, been doing it since the late ’60’s. Don’t want to let the other half know the, err, monetarized cost is, lol.

DialMforMiata
Member
DialMforMiata
1 month ago
Reply to  Samurai87

Yeah, that comment really hit home for me as a model car builder. I’ll often have hundreds of hours and several hundred dollars invested in a build and the questions “how much would you sell that for” and “how much would it cost you to build me one” come up once in a while. Non-hobby people don’t understand that a fully-detailed 1/12 scale model could come in at 5 figures if I put any value on my time at all.

The Stig's Misanthropic Cousin
Member
The Stig's Misanthropic Cousin
1 month ago

David also built it with his own two hands, which he couldn’t say about a new Wrangler.

Didn’t DT design part of the current Wrangler’s cooling system? That’s gotta count for something.

Last edited 1 month ago by The Stig's Misanthropic Cousin
James McHenry
Member
James McHenry
1 month ago

That whole comment started for two reasons:

1: I remember going to IMTS, a big manufacturing trade show, a few years ago. There was a then-new Renegade on the show floor as an example of something made with the various products, and I commented to a coworker how it’d be neat to have. Said coworker noticed the window sticker was present and told me to go have a look.

I retracted my comment.

2: I just wanted to use the words “Cheap Jeep.” It’s a fun phrase. It rhymes.

So, to justify using it, it was off to the Jeep website…

Last edited 1 month ago by James McHenry
CR-V Oswald
Member
CR-V Oswald
1 month ago

> David was one of my inspirations when I was a teenager

I’m sure that made David feel young and sprightly.

Data
Data
1 month ago
Reply to  CR-V Oswald

This feeling only gets worse the older you get. You’ll remember when babies were born and be appalled they are in high school, college, or have a child of their own now.

Shop-Teacher
Member
Shop-Teacher
1 month ago
Reply to  Data

I teach middle school, and have multiple coworkers who I taught in middle school now.

Phuzz
Member
Phuzz
1 month ago
Reply to  Shop-Teacher

One of my parent’s friends used to be a head teacher, so he’s used to bumping into former pupils, but said it felt a bit odd when he was sat in hospital, just dressed in a gown, waiting for a test, and the doctor walked in and said, “Oh, hello Mr K!”

Shop-Teacher
Member
Shop-Teacher
1 month ago

I was wondering about that. I know you were young when I met you, but I was fairly certain you were not a teenager.

Dogisbadob
Dogisbadob
1 month ago

Yay I made it 😀

Last edited 1 month ago by Dogisbadob
14
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x